Agent-Based Modeling of Consensus Group Formation with Complex Webs of Beliefs

Formation of consensus groups with shared opinions or views is a common feature of human social life and also a well-known phenomenon in cases when views are complex, as in the case of the formation of scholarly disciplines. In such cases, shared views are not simple sets of opinions but rather complex webs of beliefs (WoBs). Here, we approach such consensus group formation through the agent-based model (ABM). Agents’ views are described as complex, extensive web-like structures resembling semantic networks, i.e., webs of beliefs. In the ABM introduced here, the agents’ interactions and participation in sharing their views are dependent on the similarity of the agents’ webs of beliefs; the greater the similarity, the more likely the interaction and sharing of elements of WoBs. In interactions, the WoBs are altered when agents seek consensus and consensus groups are formed. The consensus group formation depends on the agents’ sensitivity to the similarity of their WoBs. If their sensitivity is low, only one large and diffuse group is formed, while with high sensitivity, many separated and segregated consensus groups emerge. To conclude, we discuss how such results resemble the formation of disciplinary, scholarly consensus groups

Analyzing the extremization of opinions in a general framework of bounded confidence and repulsion

In the bounded confidence framework, agents’ opinions evolve as a result of interactions with other agents having similar opinions. Thus, consensus or fragmentation of opinions can be reached, but not extremization (the evolution of opinions towards an extreme value). In contrast, when repulsion mechanisms are at work, agents with distant opinions interact and repel each other, leading to extremization. This work proposes a general opinion dynamics framework of bounded confidence and repulsion, which includes social network interactions and agent-independent time-varying rationality. We extensively analyze the performance of our model to show that the degree of extremization among a population can be controlled by the repulsion rule, and social networks promote extreme opinions. Agent-based rationality and time-varying adaptation also bear a strong impact on opinion dynamics. The high accuracy of our model is determined in a real-world social network well referenced in the literature, the Zachary Karate Club (with a known ground truth). Finally, we use our model to analyze the extremization of opinions in a real-world scenario, in Spain: a marketing action for the Netflix series “Narcos”