21 research outputs found
Towards a Definition of Role-related Concepts for Business Modeling
Abstract—While several role-related concepts play an\ud
important role in business modeling, their definitions,\ud
relations, and use differ greatly between languages, papers,\ud
and reports. Due to this, the knowledge captured by models is\ud
not transferred correctly, and models are incomparable. In this\ud
paper, we provide a meta-model and definitions for several\ud
role-related concepts based on the practice of existing modeling\ud
languages and ontological analysis. This forms a basis for\ud
creating comparable, formal business models, which enable\ud
further enterprise engineering, in a repeatable wa
BFO and DOLCE: So Far, So Close…
A survey of the similarities and differences between BFO and DOLCE, and of the mutual interactions between Nicola Guarino and Barry Smit
Unintended consequences of existential quantifications in biomedical ontologies
<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The Open Biomedical Ontologies (OBO) Foundry is a collection of freely available ontologically structured controlled vocabularies in the biomedical domain. Most of them are disseminated via both the OBO Flatfile Format and the semantic web format Web Ontology Language (OWL), which draws upon formal logic. Based on the interpretations underlying OWL description logics (OWL-DL) semantics, we scrutinize the OWL-DL releases of OBO ontologies to assess whether their logical axioms correspond to the meaning intended by their authors.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>We analyzed ontologies and ontology cross products available via the OBO Foundry site <url>http://www.obofoundry.org</url> for existential restrictions (<it>someValuesFrom</it>), from which we examined a random sample of 2,836 clauses.</p> <p>According to a rating done by four experts, 23% of all existential restrictions in OBO Foundry candidate ontologies are suspicious (Cohens' <it>κ </it>= 0.78). We found a smaller proportion of existential restrictions in OBO Foundry cross products are suspicious, but in this case an accurate quantitative judgment is not possible due to a low inter-rater agreement (<it>κ </it>= 0.07). We identified several typical modeling problems, for which satisfactory ontology design patterns based on OWL-DL were proposed. We further describe several usability issues with OBO ontologies, including the lack of ontological commitment for several common terms, and the proliferation of domain-specific relations.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>The current OWL releases of OBO Foundry (and Foundry candidate) ontologies contain numerous assertions which do not properly describe the underlying biological reality, or are ambiguous and difficult to interpret. The solution is a better anchoring in upper ontologies and a restriction to relatively few, well defined relation types with given domain and range constraints.</p
Applying the functional abnormality ontology pattern to anatomical functions.
BACKGROUND: Several biomedical ontologies cover the domain of biological functions, including molecular and cellular functions. However, there is currently no publicly available ontology of anatomical functions. Consequently, no explicit relation between anatomical structures and their functions is expressed in the anatomy ontologies that are available for various species. Such an explicit relation between anatomical structures and their functions would be useful both for defining the classes of the anatomy and the phenotype ontologies accurately. RESULTS: We provide an ontological analysis of functions and functional abnormalities. From this analysis, we derive an approach to the automatic extraction of anatomical functions from existing ontologies which uses a combination of natural language processing, graph-based analysis of the ontologies and formal inferences. Additionally, we introduce a new relation to link material objects to processes that realize the function of these objects. This relation is introduced to avoid a needless duplication of processes already covered by the Gene Ontology in a new ontology of anatomical functions. CONCLUSIONS: Ontological considerations on the nature of functional abnormalities and their representation in current phenotype ontologies show that we can extract a skeleton for an ontology of anatomical functions by using a combination of process, phenotype and anatomy ontologies automatically. We identify several limitations of the current ontologies that still need to be addressed to ensure a consistent and complete representation of anatomical functions and their abnormalities. AVAILABILITY: The source code and results of our analysis are available at http://bioonto.de
Towards Improving Phenotype Representation in OWL
BACKGROUND: Phenotype ontologies are used in species-specific databases for the annotation of mutagenesis experiments and to characterize human diseases. The Entity-Quality (EQ) formalism is a means to describe complex phenotypes based on one or more affected entities and a quality. EQ-based definitions have been developed for many phenotype ontologies, including the Human and Mammalian Phenotype ontologies. METHODS: We analyze formalizations of complex phenotype descriptions in the Web Ontology Language (OWL) that are based on the EQ model, identify several representational challenges and analyze potential solutions to address these challenges. RESULTS: In particular, we suggest a novel, role-based approach to represent relational qualities such as concentration of iron in spleen, discuss its ontological foundation in the General Formal Ontology (GFO) and evaluate its representation in OWL and the benefits it can bring to the representation of phenotype annotations. CONCLUSION: Our analysis of OWL-based representations of phenotypes can contribute to improving consistency and expressiveness of formal phenotype descriptions
Two Approaches to the Identity of Processes in BFO
This paper aims to explore processes and their identity with a focus on the
upper ontology Basic Formal Ontology (BFO). We begin with a classification
based on two basic classes of changes of independent continuants: changes with
respect to a single specifically dependent continuant thereof or with respect
to the spatial region that its parts occupy. We accordingly distinguish two
kinds of simple processes: specifically dependent continuant changes and
spatial changes. Next, we investigate a compositional approach to the identity
of processes: the identity of any process is determined by the identity of the
simple processes that compose them. Then, we consider a causal approach to the
identity of processes with recourse to a dispositional view of processes
according to which any process is a realization of some disposition. We also
examine assumptions on which these two approaches to the identity of processes
are based
An ontologically founded architecture for information systems in clinical and epidemiological research
This paper presents an ontologically founded basic architecture for information systems, which are intended to capture, represent, and maintain metadata for various domains of clinical and epidemiological research. Clinical trials exhibit an important basis for clinical research, and the accurate specification of metadata and their documentation and application in clinical and epidemiological study projects represents a significant expense in the project preparation and has a relevant impact on the value and quality of these studies