A real-time iterative machine learning approach for temperature profile prediction in additive manufacturing processes

Additive Manufacturing (AM) is a manufacturing paradigm that builds three-dimensional objects from a computer-aided design model by successively adding material layer by layer. AM has become very popular in the past decade due to its utility for fast prototyping such as 3D printing as well as manufacturing functional parts with complex geometries using processes such as laser metal deposition that would be difficult to create using traditional machining. As the process for creating an intricate part for an expensive metal such as Titanium is prohibitive with respect to cost, computational models are used to simulate the behavior of AM processes before the experimental run. However, as the simulations are computationally costly and time-consuming for predicting multiscale multi-physics phenomena in AM, physics-informed data-driven machine-learning systems for predicting the behavior of AM processes are immensely beneficial. Such models accelerate not only multiscale simulation tools but also empower real-time control systems using in-situ data. In this paper, we design and develop essential components of a scientific framework for developing a data-driven model-based real-time control system. Finite element methods are employed for solving time-dependent heat equations and developing the database. The proposed framework uses extremely randomized trees - an ensemble of bagged decision trees as the regression algorithm iteratively using temperatures of prior voxels and laser information as inputs to predict temperatures of subsequent voxels. The models achieve mean absolute percentage errors below 1% for predicting temperature profiles for AM processes. The code is made available for the research community at https://github.com/paularindam/ml-iter-additive.Comment: 10 pages, 8 figure

Improving precision of material extrusion 3D printing by in-situ monitoring and predicting 3D geometric deviation using Conditional Adversarial Networks

The field of additive manufacturing, especially 3D printing, has gained growing attention in the research and commercial sectors in recent years. Notwithstanding that the capabilities of 3D printing have moved on to enhanced resolution, higher deposition rate, and a wide variety of materials, the crucial challenge of verifying that the component manufactured is within the dimensional tolerance as designed continues to exist. Material extrusion 3D printing has long been established for rapid prototyping and functional testing in many research and industry fields. However, its inconsistency and intrinsic defects (surface roughness and geometric inaccuracies) hinder its application in several areas, most notably “certify-as-you- build” small-batch prototyping and large-batch production.In this study, we present an approach to reduce both inconsistency and the 3D geometric inaccuracies of products fabricated by material extrusion.1. This work developed and demonstrated an approach for layer-by-layer mapping of 3D printed parts, which can be used for validation of printed models and in situ adjustment of print parameters. This in situ metrology system scans each layer at the time of printing, providing a 3D model of the as-printed part. A high-speed optical scanning system was integrated with a Material Extrusion type 3D printer to achieve in situ monitoring of dimensional inaccuracies during printing, which leaves the door open to implement a closed-loop feedback system to compensate geometric errors during printing in the future and fabricate “certify-as-you-build” products.2. This work trained machine learning algorithms with data from this scanning system and predicted 3D geometric inaccuracies in new designs. Eight Conditional Adversarial Networks (CAN) machine learning models were trained on a limited number of scanned profile images of different layers, consisting of less than 50 actual images and 50 generated images, to predict the 3D geometric deviations of freeform shapes. The generated images were produced by randomly combining and cropping the actual images without any distortion. These CAN models produced predictions where at least 44.4%, 87.6%, 99.2% of data were within �0.05 mm, �0.10 mm, �0.15 mm of the actual measured value, respectively.3. This work developed an Iterative Forward approach to redesign the Computer-Aided- Design model by reverse engineering using the trained machine learning models, allowing for compensation of print imperfection at the design stage, in advance of the first printing. The compensation algorithms with eight different sets of different parameters were evaluated. It has been proven that the Iterative Forward approach improved the geometric deviation of the predicted profiles by making compensation to the CAD model

Online Two-stage Thermal History Prediction Method for Metal Additive Manufacturing of Thin Walls

This paper aims to propose an online two-stage thermal history prediction method, which could be integrated into a metal AM process for performance control. Based on the similarity of temperature curves (curve segments of a temperature profile of one point) between any two successive layers, the first stage of the proposed method designs a layer-to-layer prediction model to estimate the temperature curves of the yet-to-print layer from measured temperatures of certain points on the previously printed layer. With measured/predicted temperature profiles of several points on the same layer, the second stage proposes a reduced order model (ROM) (intra-layer prediction model) to decompose and construct the temperature profiles of all points on the same layer, which could be used to build the temperature field of the entire layer. The training of ROM is performed with an extreme learning machine (ELM) for computational efficiency. Fifteen wire arc AM experiments and nine simulations are designed for thin walls with a fixed length and unidirectional printing of each layer. The test results indicate that the proposed prediction method could construct the thermal history of a yet-to-print layer within 0.1 seconds on a low-cost desktop computer. Meanwhile, the method has acceptable generalization capability in most cases from lower layers to higher layers in the same simulation, as well as from one simulation to a new simulation on different AM process parameters. More importantly, after fine-tuning the proposed method with limited experimental data, the relative errors of all predicted temperature profiles on a new experiment are smaller than 0.09, which demonstrates the applicability and generalization of the proposed two-stage thermal history prediction method in online applications for metal AM.Comment: 30 pages, 21 figures, 2 table

Real-Time 2D Temperature Field Prediction in Metal Additive Manufacturing Using Physics-Informed Neural Networks

Accurately predicting the temperature field in metal additive manufacturing (AM) processes is critical to preventing overheating, adjusting process parameters, and ensuring process stability. While physics-based computational models offer precision, they are often time-consuming and unsuitable for real-time predictions and online control in iterative design scenarios. Conversely, machine learning models rely heavily on high-quality datasets, which can be costly and challenging to obtain within the metal AM domain. Our work addresses this by introducing a physics-informed neural network framework specifically designed for temperature field prediction in metal AM. This framework incorporates a physics-informed input, physics-informed loss function, and a Convolutional Long Short-Term Memory (ConvLSTM) architecture. Utilizing real-time temperature data from the process, our model predicts 2D temperature fields for future timestamps across diverse geometries, deposition patterns, and process parameters. We validate the proposed framework in two scenarios: full-field temperature prediction for a thin wall and 2D temperature field prediction for cylinder and cubic parts, demonstrating errors below 3% and 1%, respectively. Our proposed framework exhibits the flexibility to be applied across diverse scenarios with varying process parameters, geometries, and deposition patterns.Comment: 42 pages, 13 Figure

Capturing Local Temperature Evolution during Additive Manufacturing through Fourier Neural Operators

High-fidelity, data-driven models that can quickly simulate thermal behavior during additive manufacturing (AM) are crucial for improving the performance of AM technologies in multiple areas, such as part design, process planning, monitoring, and control. However, the complexities of part geometries make it challenging for current models to maintain high accuracy across a wide range of geometries. Additionally, many models report a low mean square error (MSE) across the entire domain (part). However, in each time step, most areas of the domain do not experience significant changes in temperature, except for the heat-affected zones near recent depositions. Therefore, the MSE-based fidelity measurement of the models may be overestimated. This paper presents a data-driven model that uses Fourier Neural Operator to capture the local temperature evolution during the additive manufacturing process. In addition, the authors propose to evaluate the model using the $R^2$ metric, which provides a relative measure of the model's performance compared to using mean temperature as a prediction. The model was tested on numerical simulations based on the Discontinuous Galerkin Finite Element Method for the Direct Energy Deposition process, and the results demonstrate that the model achieves high fidelity as measured by $R^2$ and maintains generalizability to geometries that were not included in the training process

Towards a Digital Twin Framework in Additive Manufacturing: Machine Learning and Bayesian Optimization for Time Series Process Optimization

Laser-directed-energy deposition (DED) offers advantages in additive manufacturing (AM) for creating intricate geometries and material grading. Yet, challenges like material inconsistency and part variability remain, mainly due to its layer-wise fabrication. A key issue is heat accumulation during DED, which affects the material microstructure and properties. While closed-loop control methods for heat management are common in DED research, few integrate real-time monitoring, physics-based modeling, and control in a unified framework. Our work presents a digital twin (DT) framework for real-time predictive control of DED process parameters to meet specific design objectives. We develop a surrogate model using Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM)-based machine learning with Bayesian Inference to predict temperatures in DED parts. This model predicts future temperature states in real time. We also introduce Bayesian Optimization (BO) for Time Series Process Optimization (BOTSPO), based on traditional BO but featuring a unique time series process profile generator with reduced dimensions. BOTSPO dynamically optimizes processes, identifying optimal laser power profiles to attain desired mechanical properties. The established process trajectory guides online optimizations, aiming to enhance performance. This paper outlines the digital twin framework's components, promoting its integration into a comprehensive system for AM.Comment: 12 Pages, 10 Figures, 1 Table, NAMRC Conferenc

Energy management system for biological 3D printing by the refinement of manifold model morphing in flexible grasping space

The use of 3D printing, or additive manufacturing, has gained significant attention in recent years due to its potential for revolutionizing traditional manufacturing processes. One key challenge in 3D printing is managing energy consumption, as it directly impacts the cost, efficiency, and sustainability of the process. In this paper, we propose an energy management system that leverages the refinement of manifold model morphing in a flexible grasping space, to reduce costs for biological 3D printing. The manifold model is a mathematical representation of the 3D object to be printed, and the refinement process involves optimizing the morphing parameters of the manifold model to achieve desired printing outcomes. To enable flexibility in the grasping space, we incorporate data-driven approaches, such as machine learning and data augmentation techniques, to enhance the accuracy and robustness of the energy management system. Our proposed system addresses the challenges of limited sample data and complex morphologies of manifold models in layered additive manufacturing. Our method is more applicable for soft robotics and biomechanisms. We evaluate the performance of our system through extensive experiments and demonstrate its effectiveness in predicting and managing energy consumption in 3D printing processes. The results highlight the importance of refining manifold model morphing in the flexible grasping space for achieving energy-efficient 3D printing, contributing to the advancement of green and sustainable manufacturing practices.Comment: 33 pages, 10 figures, Journa

Layer-to-Layer Feedback Control for Direct Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing

Additive manufacturing (AM) has garnered much attention in recent years, some calling it the fourth industrial revolution. It was first used to create rapid prototypes, although recent efforts have been made to advance the technology towards production of functional parts. This requires advancement in the materials used in AM, as well as the ability to produce quality parts repeatably. More specifically, direct energy deposition (DED) of metal powders is a process capable of producing and repairing parts with complex geometries; however, it is not widely used in industry due to challenges with quality control. In this process, metal powder is dispensed from a nozzle and a laser beam melts the incident powder particles and a portion of the underlying surface. The melt pool is translated along the desired toolpath and parts are constructed in a layer-by-layer fashion. Several process inputs determine the deposition quality, including powder feed rate, laser power and nozzle speed. These inputs, as well as the environmental conditions, are subject to random fluctuations that can cause geometric defects during deposition. Such defects often propagate through to subsequent layers and are amplified, rendering the final part unusable. The objective of this work is to improve the geometric accuracy of parts produced by metal powder DED by designing and implementing process feedback control. The strategy involves measuring the part height after each layer and adjusting the nozzle speed trajectory for the next layer according to a designed control law. The major contributions of this work are 1. the construction of an open-architecture metal powder DED system that is capable of implementing layer-to-layer control and 2. the development of controllers to improve part morphology accuracy in metal powder DED --Abstract, p. i