43,304 research outputs found
Using conceptual metaphor and functional grammar to explore how language used in physics affects student learning
This paper introduces a theory about the role of language in learning
physics. The theory is developed in the context of physics students' and
physicists' talking and writing about the subject of quantum mechanics. We
found that physicists' language encodes different varieties of analogical
models through the use of grammar and conceptual metaphor. We hypothesize that
students categorize concepts into ontological categories based on the
grammatical structure of physicists' language. We also hypothesize that
students over-extend and misapply conceptual metaphors in physicists' speech
and writing. Using our theory, we will show how, in some cases, we can explain
student difficulties in quantum mechanics as difficulties with language.Comment: Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. ST:PE
Uses and Abuses of Effective Lagrangians
Motivated by past and recent analyses we critically re-examine the use of
effective lagrangians in the literature to constrain new physics and to
determine the `physics reach' of future experiments. We demonstrate that many
calculations, such as those involving anomalous trilinear gauge-boson
couplings, either considerably overestimate loop-induced effects, or give
ambiguous answers. The source of these problems is the use of cutoffs to
evaluate the size of such operators in loop diagrams. In contrast to other
critics of these loop estimates, we prove that the inclusion of
nonlinearly-realized gauge invariance into the low-energy lagrangian is
irrelevant to this conclusion. We use an explicit example using known
multi-Higgs physics above the weak scale to underline these points. We show how
to draw conclusions regarding the nature of the unknown high-energy physics
without making reference to low-energy cutoffs.Comment: 36 page
From General Relativity to Quantum Gravity
In general relativity (GR), spacetime geometry is no longer just a background
arena but a physical and dynamical entity with its own degrees of freedom. We
present an overview of approaches to quantum gravity in which this central
feature of GR is at the forefront. However, the short distance dynamics in the
quantum theory are quite different from those of GR and classical spacetimes
and gravitons emerge only in a suitable limit. Our emphasis is on communicating
the key strategies, the main results and open issues. In the spirit of this
volume, we focus on a few avenues that have led to the most significant
advances over the past 2-3 decades.Comment: To appear in \emph{General Relativity and Gravitation: A Centennial
Survey}, commissioned by the International Society for General Relativity and
Gravitation and to be published by Cambridge University Press. Abhay Ashtekar
served as the `coordinating author' and combined the three contribution
Learning with multiple representations: An example of a revision lesson in mechanics
We describe an example of learning with multiple representations in an
A-level revision lesson on mechanics. The context of the problem involved the
motion of a ball thrown vertically upwards in air and studying how the
associated physical quantities changed during its flight. Different groups of
students were assigned to look at the ball's motion using various
representations: motion diagrams, vector diagrams, free-body diagrams, verbal
description, equations and graphs, drawn against time as well as against
displacement. Overall, feedback from students about the lesson was positive. We
further discuss the benefits of using computer simulation to support and extend
student learning.Comment: 10 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables http://iopscience.iop.org/0031-912
- …