Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Transmission errors in precision worm gear drives

By Michael Anderson Fish


Transmission error is a measure of the positioning accuracy of a gear system. This\ud has been widely documented in gearing for many years as the source of problems in\ud noise and vibration. It is a result of errors in the contact conditions which affect the\ud driven gear with respect to the rotation of the driver gear. This research aims to\ud present a better understanding of the basic kinematics of worm gear systems by\ud identifying the significant influences which determine the contact conditions.\ud \ud \ud A literature review of existing theory is described which determines the major areas\ud considered in worm gear contact analysis. Formulae are derived which quantify the\ud effect of component parameter variation on contact. An investigation of the design,\ud manufacture, and operating processes is recorded which identifies error sources\ud relative to the theoretical contact condition. A computer program is developed which\ud calculates contact characteristics such as worm and wheel component form,\ud transmission error and contact marking pattern for a given design including any\ud contact error sources. Computer calculations are validated by comparing direct\ud measurements of these characteristics from several manufactured gear sets with\ud synthesised results produced using the design information, machine settings and error\ud sources detected during production. The behaviour of these gear sets during operation\ud under a torque load has been investigated experimentally. Measured transmission\ud error data from a test rig is used to develop a basic model of worm gear deformation\ud under load. This model has been added to the computer program to improve and\ud extend the analysis capability. The test rig has also been used to investigate the effect\ud of initial wear on contact characteristics.\ud \ud \ud The good correlation between calculated and experimental results shows that the\ud characteristics of a worm gear set can be predicted once all elements of the design and\ud manufacture are known. The results also validate the software as a useful design tool\ud for academic and industrial applications. Important conclusions are drawn on design\ud techniques, the manufacturing process, and the effects of operating under load.\ud Further areas of investigation are identified which offer future research an opportunity\ud to expand upon these conclusions

Topics: TJ, TL
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1994). A Code of Practice for Checking the Reproducibility of Gear Measuring Machines',
  2. (1994). A Code Of Practice For Interpretation Of Measurements',
  3. (1994). A Code of Practice for Verifying the Accuracy of Gear Measuring Machines',
  4. (1960). A Critical Look At The Novikov Gear' The Engineer,
  5. (1954). A New Look At Worm Gear Robbing',
  6. (1996). A New Method of Measuring Involute Profile Deviations of Gear Teeth', doi
  7. (1987). A New Theory For The Design of Helical Gears For Surface Fatigue Using Hertzian Point Contact Stress.',
  8. (1994). A Practical Method Of Measuring The Worm Wheels Of Cylindrical Worm
  9. (1979). A Review Of The Single Flank Method Of Testing Gears,' Annals C.I.R.P., doi
  10. Accurate Method For Calculation Of Stress And Deformations In Elliptical Hertzian Contacts', doi
  11. (1962). American Gear Manufacturers Association, paper 87FTM14,
  12. (1979). An Engineering Data doi
  13. (1989). An Improved Kinematic Method', doi
  14. (1996). An Investigation Of Globoidal Wormgear Drives.',
  15. (1995). Analysis Of Marking Patterns And Transmission Errors In Worm Gears', B.G.A.
  16. (1963). Analytical Mechanics Of Gears.',
  17. Application Of Finite Element Analysis For Deformation Of Load Share, Real Contact Ratio, Precision of Motion, and Stress Analysis', doi
  18. (1949). C.,'The Deformation Of Loaded Gears And The Effects On Load Carrying Capacity', doi
  19. (1994). Computed Contact Surface Topology Of Worm Gears (New Approach) And Cutting Parameter Influences',
  20. (1992). Computerized Simulation Of Meshing And Bearing Contact For Single Enveloping Worm Gear Drives', doi
  21. (1980). Concepts And Parameters Associated With Cylindrical Gear Pairs With Involute Teeth', doi
  22. (1987). Contact Surface Topology Of Worm Gear Teeth',
  23. (1994). Deformation Numerical Analysis Of Meshing Gears And Tooth Profile Modification',
  24. (1996). Design Features Increase The Load Capacity Of Worm Gears',
  25. (1993). Design Manual For Cylindrical Worm Gearing.'
  26. (1963). Dynamic Behaviour Of Spur Gears.', doi
  27. (1958). Dynamic Loads On The Teeth Of Spur Gears.', doi
  28. (1970). Dynamics And Noise Of Parallel Axis Gearing', doi
  29. (1986). Effects Of Pressure Angle On Tooth Deflection and Root Stress', doi
  30. (1995). Encyclopedic Dictionary Of Gearing.',
  31. Estimation Of The Static Load Distribution Factor For Helical Gears.', doi
  32. (1992). Etude De La Geometrie Des Roues Et Vis Tangentes',
  33. (1971). Gear Engineering',
  34. (1962). Gear Handbook.', 1st Ed.,
  35. (1945). H.,'Worm Gear Deflection (A Consideration Of Distortion Effects And Correcting Measures)', Automobile Engineer,
  36. (1994). Helical Gear Vibration Excitation With Misalignment.' doi
  37. (1985). Identification of Gear Noise with Single Flank Composite Measurement',
  38. (1962). Involute Gear Geometry', doi
  39. (1997). Kinematic Errors In Precision Worm Gears',
  40. (1994). Loaded Transmission Error Prediction Using A Computer Model And Its Verification'
  41. (1995). Measurements Of Transmission Error, Vibration And Noise
  42. Mechanical Engineering Design.', First Edition,
  43. Mechanical Engineers Data Handbook', doi
  44. (1988). Nouvelle Methode De Dimensionnement Des Engrenges A Roue Et Vis Tangentes',
  45. Numerical Recipes In Pascal.', doi
  46. On Cutting And Hobbing Gears And Worms', Applied Mechanics,
  47. Roark's Formulas For Stress And Strain', 6th Ed.,
  48. (1986). Root Stresses Of Helical Gears With Higher Pressure Angle', doi
  49. Simplified Mechanics And Strength Of Materials', 4th Ed,
  50. Simulation Of Meshing And Bearing Contact For Single Enveloping Worm Gear Drives', doi
  51. (1991). Simulation On Rotational Vibration Of A Helical Gear Pair Transmitting Light Load', doi
  52. (1994). Some Measurements Of Static And Dynamic Transmission Error Of Spur Gears'
  53. (1983). Specification For Worm Gearing, Part 2', doi
  54. (1993). Statistics', 2nd Ed, Wm C
  55. (1995). Study Of The Effect Of Machining Parameters On Performance Of Worm Gears.',
  56. (1994). Study On Hour Glass Worm Gearings With Good Contact State And Insensitivity To Manufacturing Errors',
  57. (1980). Technical Aspects Of Double Enveloping Worm Gear Drives.', Ex-Cell-0 Corporation, Cone Drive Operation,
  58. (1975). Terms And Definitions For Cylindrical Worm Gears With Shaft Angle 90°,
  59. (1989). The DC Component of Gear Transmission Error',
  60. (1996). The Differences Between 3-Axis And 4-Axis Gear Measuring Machines',
  61. (1978). The Fast Fourier Transform And Its Applications.' doi
  62. (1985). The FFT Fundamentals And Concepts.'
  63. (1987). The Geometry Of Involute Gears', doi
  64. (1991). The Hertzian Load Capacity And Lubrication Of A Double Enveloping Worm Gearing With Planar Generating Surface.',
  65. (1991). The Mathematical Model For Helicoid Double Enveloping Worms With An Improved Kinematic Method',
  66. (1989). The Use Of Oversize Hobs To Cut Worm Gears',
  67. (1989). Theory Of Gearing', NASA Reference Publication 1212, AVSCOM.
  68. (1994). Tolerance For Spur and Helical Gears', doi
  69. (1997). Verifying The Accuracy Of Involute Gear Measuring Machines.',
  70. (1952). Worm Gear Design', The Engineer,
  71. (1935). Worm Gear Performance', doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.