Location of Repository

The effectiveness of Brazilian competition law

By Laura Cristhina Fiore Ferreira

Abstract

Attempts to regulate competition in Brazil have been made since the early 1960s without much success. However, with the adoption of trade liberalisation measures in the early 1990s, competition has gradually been regarded as an essential element of the process of liberalisation of the economy, and thus efforts have been made to develop and enforce competition law and policy. This thesis describes and evaluates competition law in Brazil during this last period. It critically analyses the legislation, the practices of enforcement agencies and the relevant case law. Emphasis is given to the study of cases which involve restrictive business practices as well as mergers, and which have been decided at the administrative level.\ud \ud This thesis highlights four main points: 1) developing countries should try to develop their own approach to competition law, and avoid adopting models created in other countries that reflect another reality; 2) competition legislation must define the approach to be adopted in the implementation of competition law in order to avoid uncertainty in the market; 3) a well structured institutional framework is necessary for the enforcement of competition law and policy; and 4) competition policy should be part of a coherent set of economic policies adopted by the government.\ud \ud The conclusion of this thesis is that competition policy in Brazil has not yet produced significant results. Factors that undermine competition policy in Brazil are the system for the enforcement of the law, the lack of coherence in case law, and changes in economic policy. On the other hand, there has been some progress: the legislation covers the main aspects of competition; the performance of enforcement agencies is improving; these agencies are co-ordinating their enforcement practices; and there is growing awareness among economic actors in Brazil that competition is desirable and should be protected

Topics: HF, K1
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2578

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1984). 0 'discurso intervencionista' nas Constit*6es brasileiras",
  2. (1991). 0 programa brasüeiro de privatizagäo de empresas estatais"',
  3. 1), "The modemization of antitrust a new equflibriurn",
  4. (1983). 298 A World Bank doi
  5. (1972). 7he Myths qfA ntitrust,
  6. (1989). A expenencia brasileira de Constituiýdo Economica",
  7. (1996). A fivre concorrencia e sua defesa", paper given at IBMEC -Brazilian Institute of Market Shares, Rio de Janeiro.
  8. (1985). A lei antitruste brasielira eo Conselho Administrativo de Defesa Economica - CADE: a1guns aspectos",
  9. (1992). A nova lei antitruste brasileira: criticas e sugest6es", Revista ano g.
  10. (1990). A Ordem Economica na ConstituiVäo de
  11. (1997). A privatizagdo eo direito concorrencial",
  12. (1982). Abuso do poder economico e defesa do consumidor".
  13. (1966). Abusos do poder economico, Editora Revista dos Tribunais, Silo Paulo.
  14. (1990). Activities relating to Specific Provisions of the Set of Principles and Rules,
  15. (1994). An Introductory Guide to EC Competition Law doi
  16. (1998). and others
  17. (1967). Antitrust Analysis, Little Brown and Co.,
  18. (1973). Antitrust and Economic Efficiency,
  19. (1990). Antitrust and Monopoly - Anatomy of a Policy Failure, Hohnes and Meier,
  20. (1988). Antitrust dialogue on social science, cultural values, and merger laW',
  21. (1994). Antitrust enforcement in Mexico",
  22. (1992). Antitrust in Latin America: regulating goverment and business",
  23. (1988). Antitrust in New Zeland - The Case for Reform, New Zeland Business Roundtable. doi
  24. (1977). Antitrust jurisprudence: a symposium on the economic, political and social goals of antitrust policy - introduction", doi
  25. (1976). Antitrust Law - An Economic Perspeciive,
  26. (1980). Antitrust, inicroeconomics, and politics: reflections on some recent relationships", doi
  27. (1996). Areeda, Chicago, and antitrust injury: economic efficiency and legal process",
  28. (1994). Barriers to Entry and Exit in Competition Policy, Office of Fair Trading,
  29. (1967). Brazilian Planning - Development, Politics and Administration, The University of North Caroline Press, Chapel Hill.
  30. (1992). Comentärios a LegislaVäo Antitruste, Editora Atlas,
  31. (1989). Compeation Law, 2nd edition, doi
  32. (1994). Competition and efficiency", Fordham Corporate Law Institute, Antitrust in a Global Economy:
  33. (1984). Competition and Trade Policies - Their Interaction, doi
  34. (1994). Competition Policies for an Integrated World Economy, The Brookings Institution, Washington. SECOFI - Deregulation Unity (nd. ), Economic and legal background for Mexico "s new competition law,
  35. (1993). Competition policy in developing countries pursuing structural adjustment",
  36. (1997). Competition policy in Latin America",
  37. (1967). Competition Policy in the European Community,
  38. (1991). Competition policy, merger control and the European Community's
  39. (1990). Conceito de 'underseffing' ('dumping") dentro do Anteprojeto da nova Lei Antitruste",
  40. (1993). Concentration of Market Power, through Mergers, Take-overs,
  41. (1976). Control of restrictive business practice in Latin Amenca",
  42. (1997). Cormnent",
  43. (1990). Direito Administrativo Brasileiro, 22 nd edition, Malheiros Editores, Silo Paulo.
  44. (1991). Direito do Planeiamento Economico, e Social, dissertation submitted for the degree of Master in Law, Universidade de Sdo Paulo,
  45. Dmilnio do Congresso Nacional (Seqdo 1), 13.05.93, p. 9628/9629 Didrio do Congresso Nacional (Segdo 1), 08.06.94, p. 8990/9006 "FHC quer supýerpoder com lei antitruste",
  46. (1987). Does antitrust make economic senseT, European Competition Law Review,
  47. (1995). Donn'mo de mercado, acordos restritivos da concorreneia e ^i concentraQao de empresas,
  48. Draft Commentaries to Possible Elementsfor Articles of a Model Law or Laws, TD/B/RBP/8 I /Rev. 3 LTNCTAD (1994b), The Role of Competition Policy
  49. (1996). Economia Brasileira Contemporanea,
  50. (1988). Economical and Political Development,
  51. (1977). Economics and more humanistic disciplines: what are the sources of wisdom for antitrust? ",
  52. (1991). Efficient industrialization in a technologically dependent economy: the current Brazilian debate", Competition and economic development,
  53. (1986). Entrevista com Paulo Germano MagalhAes", Direito Economico - Revista do CADE, nova fase, rL 1,
  54. (1967). EXAMINED Administrative Rule n. 105/92 Decree 99244/90 Federal Constitution of 1934 Federal Constitution of 1937 Federal Constitution of 1946 Federal Constitution of
  55. (1995). Framing competition law in an emergmg economy: the case of Brazil".
  56. (1987). Freedom and regulation: an anthropological critique of the market ideology",
  57. (1996). Governo quer »tabelar' margem de posto'*, Fotha de Säo Paulo,
  58. (1986). Ideological cycles and unstable antitrust nýdes",
  59. (1992). Institutional sources of corruption in Brazil", doi
  60. (1994). Institutions and policy change in the European Communities: the case of merger control", doi
  61. (1995). Integragito de empresas: concentragAo, eficiencia e controle",
  62. (1988). Law as policy instrument: comparative perspective",
  63. (1992). Lei de defesa da concorrencla,
  64. (1994). Marco legal para la promocion de la competencia en derecho comparada y en Colombia",
  65. (1992). Mergers and developing countries - trends, effects and policies",
  66. (1994). Mexico's new economic competition law: toward the development of a Mexican law of antitrust",
  67. (1995). Mexico's new institutional frwnework for antitrust enforcement"',
  68. (1978). Modern Political Economy: An Introduction to .
  69. (1992). Monopoly, Competition and the Law, 2" ed., Harvester Wheatsheaf,
  70. Novo titular da SDE vai avaliar risco da nova Vale virar truste", Folho de Sao Paulo, 11.06.1997. "Produzir pode dar cadeia",
  71. (1985). Parecer", in
  72. (1978). Planejamento Economico e Regra Juridica, Ed. Revista dos Tribunais, Sdo Paulo.
  73. (1990). Planejamento, Estado e Crescimento, doi
  74. (1995). Politica da concorrencia: tendencias recentes eo estado da arte no Brasir', Texto Para Discussdo n.
  75. (1993). Politicas de competencia ýen la integracion en America Latina7, Integracion Latinoamericana (Revista mensual del Instituto para la Integracion Latina),
  76. (1994). Prdticas verticais restritivas da concorrencia",
  77. (1994). Privatization in Latin America", The World Economy, doi
  78. (1991). Propriedade Industrial -
  79. (1989). Recent, developments in economics that challenge Chicago School views",
  80. (1994). Report, Comision de Libre Competencia,
  81. SDE quer explicagdo dos planos de safide", Folha de Sdo Paulo,
  82. (1994). Soberania e aplicagao do direito da concorrencia na CE e no Mercosur',
  83. (1986). Sugest6es para a nova lei de abuso economico", Direito Economico - Revista do CADE, nova fase,
  84. (1978). The Antitrust Paradox,, Basic Books, doi
  85. (1994). The Bene ts of Free Trade: East Asia and Latin America.
  86. (1979). The Chicago school of antitrust analysis", doi
  87. (1971). The Economic Growth of Brazil -A Survey from Colonial to Modern Times, doi
  88. (1990). The economic order in the Brazilian Constitution of 1988", doi
  89. (1983). The Effects of Corruption on Administration Performance - Illustrations from Developing Countries, World Bank Staff Working Papers, n. 580, Management and development subseries,
  90. (1977). The goals of antitrust: other than competition and efficiency, what else counts? ", doi
  91. (1995). The instruments of competition policy and their relevance for economic development", in Frischtak, C., Regulatory Policies and Reform in Industrializing Countries, The World Bank.
  92. (1992). The Legal Foundations of the Single European Market, doi
  93. (1983). The new Argentine antitrust law - competition as an economic policy instrument 9ý ý
  94. (1972). The paradox of planning",
  95. (1979). The political content of antitrust", doi
  96. (1992). The relevance of antisnonopoly policy for developing countries",
  97. (1988). The rise and (coming) fall of efficiency as the ruler of antitrust",
  98. (1994). The transformation of European Community Competition LawT,
  99. (1986). The unreasonableness of coerced cooperation: a comment upon NCAA decision's rejection of the Chicago school",
  100. (1980). The Zero-sum Society: Distribution and Possibilities for Economic Change, Basic Books, doi
  101. (1988). Three 'efficiency school' hypotheses about market power",
  102. (1992). Untwisting the strands of Chicago antitrust",
  103. (1990). Valores de Säo Paulo doi
  104. (1998). ýxn gov. hr cadc CADE

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.