Location of Repository

Attempts to link organisational strategy and training strategy in the new Civil Service : an evaluation

By Julia Marilyn Hockey


The literature on strategic human resource management (HRM) includes much\ud discussion about the importance of linking organisational strategy and HRM strategy\ud and little agreement about how the integration of these strategies should be achieved.\ud As an integral part of HRM, training strategy is an important element in this on-going\ud debate. This thesis seeks to add to the existing body of knowledge in the research\ud area by focusing on a large decentralised public sector organisation that has\ud experienced fundamental change over two decades and has tried to link its\ud organisational strategy and its training strategy. The evaluation of the attempt by the\ud Civil Service to make these links in strategy forms the basis of the case study\ud research.\ud Middle managers working in Civil Service departments and agencies have been\ud selected as the primary source of information that has been collected by using a\ud combination of focus groups, a survey questionnaire and one-to-one follow-up\ud interviews with a selection of survey respondents. In addition, documentary evidence\ud has been used to help explain the organisational strategy and the training strategy of\ud the Civil Service, and to corroborate evidence from other sources.\ud The research findings confirm the difficulties experienced by decentralised\ud organisations when trying to link their organisational strategy and their training\ud strategy, and the need for the corporate centre to understand how strategies will\ud translate into action on the ground. The thesis argues that unless the linking\ud mechanisms selected in the training strategy are compatible with the organisational\ud strategy and complementary and compatible with one another, linkages will be\ud incomplete. The conflicting pressures on line managers to achieve business and\ud people objectives have been identified from the research. Their crucial managerial\ud responsibilities for linking organisational strategy and training strategy is emphasised\ud together with recommendations for strengthening this role in the future

Topics: HF, JN101
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3611

Suggested articles



  1. (1989). 1\ lanaging the Skills Gap: Report on Skills Training Survey London Confederation of British Industry. '
  2. (1999). 10.30 a.m. doi
  3. (1999). 10.30 a.m. HEO ./ Cockspur Street, London Government Office for East Midlands,
  4. (1995). 111 the Field: An Introduction to Field Research London '-' ,
  5. (1993). 1Vhat is strategy - and does it matter?,
  6. (1997). 330 If Attendance Training & Development Needs of Middle Managers in the New Civil Service Focus Group 22
  7. 998d), Next Steps Briefing Note,
  8. (1999). A 21 st-century service',
  9. (1984). A Framework for Strategic Human Resource Management', doi
  10. (1996). A Handbook of Personnel Management Practice (6th edn),
  11. (1991). A Public Management for All Seasons?' doi
  12. (1998). A reason for learning? A survey of experiences of and attitudes to learning in the Civil and Public Services, London, Cabinet Office.
  13. (1998). A slice of the action',
  14. (1999). About tum for Whitehall?', Public Finance,
  15. (1995). Accountingfor Taxpayer's Money: The Government's Proposals - Resource Accounting and Budgeting in Government, Cm 2929,
  16. (1997). An Evaluation of Investors doi
  17. (1997). An Evaluation of the Investors in People Standard', doi
  18. (1991). b)' Developing People for Results Through the Line: Part 1, London, Cabinet Office.
  19. (1999). Beat the retreat',
  20. (1999). Beyond the Tony and John Show', Public Finance,
  21. (1999). Bonding Training to Strategy: Part One', Training Journal,
  22. (1999). Bonding Training to Strategy: Part Three', Training Journal,
  23. (1999). Bonding Training to Strategy: Part Two', Training Journal, doi
  24. (1999). Bringing in and Bringing on Talent, Recommendation by the Civil Service Management Committee Sub-Group,
  25. (1999). Building, London National Savings,
  26. (1996). Business Drircn Human Resource Management,
  27. Cabinet Office (1991a), A Forcefor Improvement in the UK Civil Service, London, Cabinet Office.
  28. Cabinet Office (1994a), Review of Fast Stream Recruitment,
  29. Cabinet Office (1997a), Your Right to Know: Freedom of Information , Cm 3818, London, The Stationery Office.
  30. (1998). Cabinet Office (1998a), Civil Service Statistics
  31. Cabinet Office (1999a), A Civil Service for the 2Ft Century: Meeting the Challenge of Change, London, Cabinet Office.
  32. (1996). Career Anchors Revisited: Implications for Career Development in the 21 st Century', Society for Organisational Learning: Hall Career Paper, doi
  33. (1995). Career Development in Flatter Structures: Organisational Practices,
  34. (1978). Career dynamics: matching individual and organizational needs, doi
  35. (1993). Career Management and Succession Planning Study, doi
  36. (1997). Career management competences - the individual perspective', doi
  37. (1995). Career Survival: Strategic Job and Role Planning,
  38. (1995). Careers in Organisations: Issues for the Future, Brighton, The Institute for Employment Studies.
  39. (1995). Changing Work Roles',
  40. (1999). Ciri / Scrrice Reform: Report to the Prime Minister from Sir Richard lVi/son, Head of the Home Civil Service, www.cabinetoffice.gov.uklcivilservice-reform, 16112/99. (l999b)' . A civil service committed to change', Financial Times,
  41. (1998). Civil Service College Review
  42. (1999). Civil service PRP to be scrutinised', Public Finance,
  43. (1987). Civil Service Statistics
  44. (1999). Clone-Free Zone',
  45. (1991). Competing for Quality; Buying Better Public Services, Cm 1730,
  46. (1989). Corporate training strategies: the vital component?',
  47. (1999). Courses of action',
  48. (1998). Cycling proficiency',
  49. (1999). Demand and supply', doi
  50. (1992). Dere/opments in the Management of Human Resources,
  51. (1999). Design of the times',
  52. (1991). Developing People - the Line Manager's Job, London, Cabinet Office.
  53. (1996). Development and Trainingfor Civil Servants: A Frameworkfor Action, Cm 3321,
  54. (1994). Devolving HR in the Civil Service', Personnel Management.
  55. (1999). DiversiIJ', Recommendation by the Civil Service Management Comnlittee Sub-Group,
  56. (1997). Do high-flyer programmes facilitate organisational learning? From individual skills building to development of organisational competence', doi
  57. (1996). Don't write off the traditional career',
  58. (1999). Down to Business',
  59. (1999). Education and Employment doi
  60. (1982). Efficiency and Effectiveness in the Civil Service, doi
  61. (1988). Employee Relations Strategy in the MultiDivisional Company', doi
  62. (1998). Empower steering',
  63. (1998). Enlployee Attitude Surveys',
  64. (1997). Evaluating the 'New Public Management' Refornls in the UK: A Constitutional Possibility?" Public Administration, doi
  65. (1994). Evaluation of IllYestors
  66. (1999). Expect expertise',
  67. (1989). Exploring Corporate Strategy: Text and Cases, Hemel Hempstead,
  68. (1999). f .r:; doi
  69. (1997). Facilitating new deals' doi
  70. (1999). Falling demand hits soft landing',
  71. (1999). Fast Stream: So what did you do today?,
  72. (1999). Faster-track learning',
  73. (1997). Firms face leadership skills gap',
  74. (1995). Focusing on the changing face of career management',
  75. (1994). From Manpower Planning to Strategic Human Resource Management?',
  76. (1994). From Old Public Administration to New Public doi
  77. (1992). Guide to In-Company Training Methods,
  78. (1999). Guiding blight',
  79. (1994). H M Customs and Excise Glasgow Collection: Becoming an Investor in People, A Case Study, London, Cabinet Office.
  80. (1999). High Involvement Work Systems and Peljhr/}]ance Outcomes: the Strength of Variable, Contingent and Contextbound Relationships,
  81. (1995). Hllll1an Resource and Business Strategy',
  82. (1990). HRM Practices and Employee Commitment: Possibilities, Pitfalls and Paradoxes', doi
  83. (1992). HRM: A Map, Model or Theory?',
  84. (1995). Human Resourc£! Al([}wg£!l11£!llt: Rhetorics and Realities,
  85. (1995). Human Resource Bundles and Manufacturing Performance: Organisational Logic and Flexible Production Systems in the World Auto Industry'. Industrial and Labour Relations Review, doi
  86. (1984). Human Resource Development and Organisational Effectiveness',
  87. (1999). Human Resource Management in the Public and Private Sectors: An Empirical Comparison', doi
  88. (1989). Human resource management: a critical analysis', in 1. Storey (ed), New Perspectives on Human Resource Management, doi
  89. (1995). Human resource management: still marching on, or marching OutT,
  90. (1994). Human Resource Management: The Views of Personnel Directors', doi
  91. (1995). Idcnt{fj'ing Targeted Training Needs,
  92. (1985). Identifying the Needfor Financial Skills, London, Treasury and Cabinet Office.
  93. (1999). IIP's credibility questioned despite satisfaction poll',
  94. (1988). Improving Management in Government: The Next Steps. Report to the Prime Afinister,
  95. (1998). In the Eye of the Beholder: Ethnography in the Study of Work',
  96. (1994). Information Systems and New Public Management - A View from The Centre', Public Administration, doi
  97. (1999). Innovate to educate',
  98. (1999). Interaction learning',
  99. (1998). Introduction to Social Research, London, Sage Publications. doi
  100. Introductions APPENDIX II - FOCUS GROUPS: Programme
  101. (1993). Investing in People: Towards Corporate Capability,
  102. (1999). Investors in People - the road to success', in S. Hoare and A. Jolly (eds). The eBl: Skills and Training Handbook,
  103. (1996). Investors in People' , Management Factsheets: Key Facts and guidance for managers, London, The Industrial Society.
  104. (1999). Joined-up thinking',
  105. (1998). Learning Alliances; Tapping into Talent, London, Institute of Personnel and Development. doi
  106. (1998). Linking job security and career developn1ent in a new psychological contract', Human Resource Management Journal. doi
  107. Managenlent Comlnittee Sub-Group (1999a), Vision and Common Principles, Recomlnendation by the Civil Service Management Committee Sub-Group,
  108. (1998). Managing Horizontal Government: The Politics of Co-ordination', doi
  109. (1999). Managing Learningfor Added Value, London, Institute of Personnel and Development.
  110. (1996). Managing the changing psychological contract', Employee Relations. doi
  111. (1988). Managing Two Fits of Strategic Human Resource Management', Academy of Management Review, doi
  112. (1999). Mandarin ducks the issue',
  113. (1999). Message to the Civil Service from the Civil Service Management Committee, London, Cabinet Office.
  114. (1999). Missing links',
  115. (1999). More privatisation is a racing certainty', Public Finance,
  116. (1996). New Modes of Control in the Public Service', doi
  117. (1998). Next Steps Report 1997, Cm 3889, London, The Stationery Office.
  118. (1999). No Room for Sir Humphrey', Public Finance,
  119. (1999). NTOs: their role in developing UK education, training and qualifications to meet the needs of employment',
  120. (1993). Open Government, Cm 2290,
  121. (1970). Organisational Psychology (2 nd edn), Englewood Cliffs,
  122. (1995). Organisational Structure',
  123. (1999). Past Abuses and Future Uses of Private Finance and Public Private Partnership in Transport', doi
  124. (1992). Pathways to Progress: Some Considerations on the Role of Intervention in Achieving Better Training Practice', doi
  125. (1999). PClj()rmonce Management, Recommendation by the Civil Service Managenlent Committee Sub-Group,
  126. (1999). Perfofl11ance and Innovation Unit
  127. (1998). Perfonnance Infonnation, Accountability and Executive Agencies',
  128. (1994). Performance Measurement: When Performance can Never be Finally Defined', doi
  129. (1998). Peripheral revision',
  130. (1989). Personnel and HRM: can you tell the difference?', Personnel Management,
  131. (2000). Personnel Management in Perspective' doi
  132. (1991). Personnel Management: A New Approach (2 nd edn), Hemel Hempstead,
  133. (1994). Personnel Management: Paradigms, Practice and Prospect',
  134. (1998). Planning your Future in the DT!:
  135. (1998). Pliblic Scrricesfor the Future: Modernisation, Reform, Accountabiliry, Cn1 4181, London, The Stationery Office.
  136. (1998). Pock£!t A/onog£!l11L Jnt Standards: Management Level 3,
  137. (1994). Principles of Human Resource Management, doi
  138. Private Opportunity, Public Benefit: Progressing the Private Finance Initiative,
  139. (1997). Public Management: Raising Our Game', doi
  140. (1994). Public Service Reform: Reinventing or Abandoning Government?' doi
  141. (1998). Public Services Under New Labour: Back to Bureaucracy?', doi
  142. (1998). Qualitative Methods: Techniques or Size?',
  143. (1989). Quantitative Approaches
  144. (1999). Realising our assets',
  145. (1998). Regulation Inside Goven1l11ent: Where New Public Management Meets the Audit Explosion', Public 1'[0I1C.1' doi
  146. (1994). Reinventing British Government', Public Administration, doi
  147. (1994). Reinventing Government in the Information Age', doi
  148. (1992). Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector, Reading, doi
  149. (1994). Reinventing Government": but will it work?',
  150. (1997). Report on Implementation Action Plans Produced by Departments and Agencies, London, Cabinet Office.
  151. (1995). Resource Accounting and Budgeting: Rationale and Background'. Public Administration, doi
  152. (1999). Return to centre',
  153. (1995). Review of 100 NVQs and SVQs: A Report Submitted to the Department for Education and Employment,
  154. (1999). rJl Health and Safety Executive 2nJ I\brch 1 <)(j<) - 10.30 a.m.
  155. (1995). Scottish and National Vocational Qualifications: Annual Report 1994-1995,
  156. (1999). Seize the day', doi
  157. (1998). Service First: The New Charter Programme,
  158. (1991). Setting Up Next Steps, doi
  159. (1997). Steering but not Rowing?',
  160. (1987). Strategies and Styles: The Role of the Centre In l\Janaging Diversified Corporations,
  161. (1996). Strategies for Career Development: Promise, Practice and Pretence, Brighton, The Institute for Employment Studies.
  162. (1999). Study finds that PRP fuels jealousy in the workplace', Public Finance,
  163. (1997). Supporting the Individual to Manage and Develop a Career: Consortium Project Main Report, London, Cabinet Office.
  164. (1995). The ~lanagelllent of Careers',
  165. (1999). The Challenge of Accountability', Public Finance,
  166. (1994). The Changing Role of the Training Function: A Test for the Integration of Human Resource and Business Strategies?', doi
  167. (1994). The Citizen's Charter: A Preliminary Analysis', doi
  168. (1991). The Citizen's Charter: Raising the Standard, Cm 1599,
  169. (1968). The Civil Service Vo!'l Report of the Committee 1966-68,
  170. (1994). The Civil Service White Paper: A Job Half Finished' doi
  171. (1995). The Civil Service: Taking Forward Continuity and Change, Cm 2748,
  172. (1994). The Civil Sevice: Continuity and Change, Cm 2627,
  173. (1997). The Conservatives and the Civil Service: 'One Step Forward, Two Steps Back'?'. Public Administration, doi
  174. (1994). The Empty Raincoat, doi
  175. (1992). The Future of Whitehall,
  176. (1998). The Guide to the Executive Agencies, Pinner, Carlton Publishing and Printing Ltd. doi
  177. (1996). The Impact of Human Resource Management On Organisational Performance: Progress and Prospects', doi
  178. (1995). The In1pact of Human Resource Management Practices on Turnover. Productivity and Corporate Financial Perfonnance', doi
  179. The Institute for Employment Studies (1997a), Supporting the Individual to Manage and Develop a Career: Consortium Project Executive Summary, London, Cabinet Office.
  180. (1998). The Learning Age: a renaissance for a new Britain, Cm 3790, London, The Stationery Office.
  181. (1997). The Learning Company: A Strategy For Sustainable Development (2 od edn),
  182. (1995). The Manager as Coach and
  183. (1999). The new network National Training Organisations - Leading the driye for \vorld class skills',
  184. (1998). The New Public Management and a New Accountability', Public Administration, doi
  185. (1994). The Next Steps Agencies, Political Salience and the Arm'sLength Principle: Barbara Castle at the Ministry of Transport 1965-68', doi
  186. (1987). The Politics of Privati sat ion: Contracting Out Public Services,
  187. (1997). The Public Sector MBA, London, Cabinet Office.
  188. (1998). The Role and Challenge of Case Study Design in Industrial Relations Research',
  189. (1998). The Scottish Office
  190. (1996). The Shape of Ideology: Structure, doi
  191. (1999). The Stationery Office doi
  192. (1996). The Strategic HRM Debate and the Resource-Based View of the Firm', doi
  193. (1997). Tomorrow People',
  194. (1999). Too close to home',
  195. (1999). Top jobs to go in big Whitehall shake-up',
  196. (1995). Training and Development' doi
  197. (1994). Training Needs Analysis and Evaluation, London, Institute of Personnel Management.
  198. (1997). Trajectories of Reform: Public Management Change in Four Countries', doi
  199. (1996). Up is Not the Only Way', Training & Development,
  200. (1998). Update on Key White Paper Statistics, London, Cabinet Office.
  201. (1999). Upskill task',
  202. (1999). Wanted: helpers not heroes',
  203. (1999). What Drives Machinery of Government Change? doi
  204. (1996). What Makes Training Pay?', Issues in People Management,
  205. (1999). Whitehall reforms require 'seismic' behavioural shift',
  206. (1999). Who is listening to HR?',
  207. (1995). Will variety spice civil service life?',
  208. (1987). Working Pattern, London, Cabinet Office (Management and Personnel Office).
  209. (1998). YOllr Development Directory 199912000, Sunningdale Civil Service College. ' Civil Service College
  210. (1999). You've got e-mai1.
  211. (2000). Your Development Directory: year 2000-2001, Sunningdale, Civil Service College.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.