Location of Repository

History in the Turkish elementary school : perceptions and pedagogy

By Dursun Dilek

Abstract

This study investigates teachers' and pupils' roles in the teaching and learning of\ud elementary history in relation to the social studies curriculum in Turkish schools. The\ud methodological design of the study embraces both quantitative and qualitative research\ud methods. Questionnaires were completed by 219 elementary teachers in Istanbul and\ud Samsun in Turkey. Seven class teachers and three head teachers took part in the interview\ud process based in the study's three case schools in the Bafra district of Samsun.\ud Observations took place in three fourth and three fifth grade elementary classrooms of the\ud same schools and lasted three weeks.\ud The study argues that children must be given a sense of the discipline of history by\ud introducing historical enquiry as the basis of the school history teaching in order that pupils\ud will develop the skills which make significant contributions to their cognitive development\ud (see Chapter three).\ud From the analysis of the data the study found that:\ud - There were gaps between teachers' espoused child-centred curriculum theories and their\ud classroom practices. Teachers preferred whole class teaching techniques (i. e. lecturing and\ud questioning) as the means of delivering the curriculum. The curriculum itself was too\ud broad and too knowledge-based.\ud - History was seen as a vehicle in citizenship education based on the political events of\ud national history. The subject's classroom activities were dominated by textbooks and the\ud practice of 'pupil's recitation' which was limited to the memorisation of factual\ud information.\ud - Teachers mostly used a style of questioning which checked pupils' historical knowledge\ud rather than their historical understanding.\ud - From the analysis of interview data and Turkish curriculum documents, the study argued\ud that the teachers could be classified as 'national utopians' and 'utilitarian/instrumentalists'\ud in their perceptions of elementary education. This affected their teaching styles.\ud - The analysis of video-tape data showed that teachers used three main teaching styles. On\ud the basis of a further classification teachers were grouped as 'lecturers', 'controllers of\ud proxy teaching' and 'questioners'. The relationship between teaching styles and teachers'\ud perceptions of elementary education is discussed in chapters five and six.\ud - The teachers thought that they were experts in the teaching of literacy and numeracy and\ud argued that subject specialism was only to be considered in other areas of the curriculum.\ud - This study also confirmed that the social studies textbooks used in the classrooms\ud involved in the study were not appropriate to pupils' understanding and reading levels (see\ud chapters five and six). During the observations, it was recorded that below average pupils\ud used their textbooks less than the above average and average pupils. The textbooks were\ud less likely to promote the task related behaviour category 'working' than other materials.\ud The study has implications for the process of educational change beyond the teaching of\ud history. It focuses on issues of curriculum and practice in Turkish elementary schools by\ud analysing the factors affecting teachers' perceptions of curriculum policy and their own\ud practices. It investigates each of these areas and presents the implications for policy,\ud theory, practice and research in Chapter seven by concluding that the starting point for a\ud rational educational policy should be partnership with teachers. Therefore, the study argues\ud that teachers must be included in research projects and that such projects need to use a\ud variety of techniques based on classroom practice, (e. g. interview analysis, observation\ud techniques, questionnaires, document analysis, case studies and action research) explored\ud and evaluated throughout this study

Topics: LB
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3669

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. ( 1985)'Modem Education in Turkey' in Surve ofMuslim y Education, Cambridge: The Islamic Academy.
  2. (1995). (Tiirkiye'de) Etnosantrik tarlhgiligin pratik sonuglan'
  3. (1995). 11kokul ders kitaplarinda tarih bilgileri ve tarih yazimina katkilari'
  4. (1983). 7-he Pupils as Scientist?,
  5. (1989). 7he Curriculum: 7heory andPractice (3d edition),
  6. 85) 'John Dewey Raporu'ndan esintiler' Eaitim ve Bilim, Ocak
  7. (1998). A Comparison between Turkish and English History Textbook& Design, Construction and Usability Issues', Unpublished Ed. D Thesis.
  8. (1989). A Guide to Teaching Practice (3 edition), doi
  9. (1993). a) The National Curriculum and Its Assessment: Interim Report,
  10. (1986). Actual Minds, Possible Words, doi
  11. (1994). An introduction to Classroom Observation,
  12. (1975). An Introduction to Curriculum Research and Development,
  13. (1995). An Introduction To Teaching: Psychological Perspectives,
  14. (1970). Analyzing Teaching Behavior, doi
  15. (1996). at is History Teaching?: Language, Ideas and Meaning
  16. (1994). Changing English Primary Schools?: The Impact of the Education Reform Act at Key Stage One,
  17. (1994). Changing Teachers, Changing Time; Teachers' doi
  18. (1967). Children and their Primary Schools (Plowden Report), doi
  19. (1996). Children making sense of history' doi
  20. (1988). Children's grasp of controversial issues'
  21. (1978). Children's Minds, doi
  22. (1992). Cognitive Development Today: Piaget and his Critics, doi
  23. (1987). Common Knowledge: The Development of Understanding in the Classroom,
  24. (1981). Communication in the Classroom: A Guide for Subject Teachers on the more Effective Use of Reading, Writing and Talk, London: Hodder and Stoughton.
  25. (1995). Creative Teachers in Primary Schools,
  26. (1996). Cumhuriyet d6nemi egitim politikalarinin temel 6zellikleri'
  27. (1977). Curriculum 11-16,
  28. (1996). Curriculum and Assessment Authority doi
  29. (1992). Curriculum Organization and Classroom Practice in Primary Schools: A Discussion
  30. (1980). Data presentation, analysis and statistical methods'
  31. (1986). Dealing with controversy in the school curriculum: a philosophical perspective'
  32. (1916). Democracy and Education, doi
  33. (1987). Direct instruction' in
  34. (1995). Direct teaching' in C. Desforges (ed) An Introduction To Teaching: Psychological Perspectives,
  35. (1987). Discussion methods' doi
  36. (1982). Education 5-9, doi
  37. (1998). Education after Auschwitz: a task for human rights education' in C. Holden and N. Clough (eds) Children as Citizens: Educationfor Participation,
  38. (1995). Education at a Glance, doi
  39. (1996). Education at a Glance: OECD Indicators. doi
  40. (1997). Education: Culture, Economy and Society, doi
  41. (1978). Educational Psychology: A Cognitive View,
  42. (1970). Educational Research Methods,
  43. (1987). Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Application (Pedition),
  44. (1996). Effective Teaching and Learning: Teachers' and Students' Perspectives,
  45. (1986). Effective Teaching in Schools, Hemel Hemstead,
  46. (1996). Egitimde Program Gelistirme, doi
  47. (1996). Ekitim Psikolo/isinin Temelleri: Ekitim Psiko/o/isi, AnkaraGiA Yayinevi.
  48. (1980). Empirical research and educational theory'
  49. (1984). Englishftom 5 to 16, Curriculum Matters Series,
  50. (1991). Essential Teaching Skills, Hemel Hemstead-,
  51. (1978). Evidence in history and the classroom'
  52. (1994). Evidence: the basis of the discipline'
  53. (1982). Facing History and Ourselves: Holocaust and Human Behaviour,
  54. (1990). Final Report of the National Curriculum History Working Group, doi
  55. (1976). From Communication to Curriculum, Harmondsworth: Penguin
  56. (1997). G. 'Introduction: teachers and the National Curriculum'
  57. (1988). Garden or jungle? Teacher development and informal primary education',
  58. (1980). History 13-16 Evaluation Study,
  59. (1994). History 5 to I], London: Hodder and Stoughton. doi
  60. (1997). History 7-11: Developing Primary Teaching Skills, doi
  61. (1969). History Betrayed,
  62. (1989). History in Primary Schools, doi
  63. (1991). History in the National Curriculum,
  64. (1988). Historyftom 5 to 16, Curriculum Matters Series,
  65. (1988). How Children 7-hink and Learn,
  66. (1993). Identifying progression in children's understanding: the use of visual materials to assess primary school children's learning in history', doi
  67. (1963). Ihe Process ofEducation,
  68. (1997). Ilkbg'retim Okulu Haftalik Ders Qizelgesi',
  69. (1995). Ilkokul tarih programlari ve ders kitaplarl'
  70. (1971). Imagination in teaching history',
  71. (1986). Individual Development and the Curriculum, doi
  72. (1980). Inside the Primary Classroom, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. 325 Gammage, P. 'Primary school practice beyond Plowden'
  73. (1994). Introduction' in The Review of the National Curriculum: a Report on the 1994 Consultation, London. School Curriculum and Assessment Authority (SCAA).
  74. (1998). Jlk6kretim okulu sosyal bilgiler dersi bAretim programimin kabulii' Ankara: Ministry of Education. Karar sayisi:
  75. (1995). Kredili sistem ve lise tarih kitaplari'
  76. (1985). Language and learning: history', doi
  77. (1971). Language in the secondary classroom' in doi
  78. (1993). Learning in primary school' doi
  79. (1987). Letting them get on with it: A study of unsupervised group talk in an infant school'
  80. (1967). Logical thinking in history', doi
  81. (1995). Managing the Learning offfistory,
  82. (1997). Monitoring the School Curriculum: Reporting the Schools,
  83. (1989). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) doi
  84. (1992). Organizing for Learning in the Primary Classroom: A Balanced Approach to Classroom Management, Buckingham-Philadelphia:
  85. (1992). Osmanli Ekitim Tarihi Istanbul.
  86. (1996). Other Primary Schools and Ours: Hazards
  87. (1974). Perception and Understanding in Young Children: An Experimental Approach,
  88. (1979). Piaget's Theory: A Psychological Critique, London- Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  89. (1975). Place, Time and Society 8-13. - Curriculum Planning in History, Geography and Social Science, Bristol: Collins. ESL for the School Council.
  90. (1992). Policy and Practice in Primary Education, doi
  91. (1997). Policy into practice and practice into policy: creative Mediation in the primary classroom'
  92. (1997). Practitioners or policy- makers? Models of teachers and educational change'
  93. (1978). Primary Education in England: A Survey by HMI,
  94. (1993). Primary Geography Primary History, doi
  95. (1981). Primary school children's perception of authenticity and time in historical narrative pictures'
  96. (1993). Primary Teaching Skills, doi
  97. (1984). Primary Teaching,
  98. (1988). Psychologyfor Teachers,
  99. (1997). Qualitative research in developing countriesissues and experience'
  100. (1993). Questioning, doi
  101. (1992). Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement, doi
  102. (1994). Reciprocal teaching: A review of the Research', doi
  103. (1987). Reflective Teaching in the Primary School: A Handbookfor the Classroom,
  104. (1995). Research and the Teacher (2' edition),
  105. (1989). Research in Education: A Conceptual Introduction (2 d edition), London: Scott and Foresman.
  106. (1988). School Matters: The Junior Years, London.
  107. (1987). Small group methods I
  108. (1993). Sociology (2 nd edition), doi
  109. (1987). Some benefits of egocentrism'
  110. (1993). Sosyal Bilgiler 11kokul 5, doi
  111. (1993). Sosyal Bilgiler 11kokul 5, Istanbul: Genda* A. _
  112. (1985). Stationary Office, doi
  113. (1995). Strategies for Effective Teaching (2nd edition),
  114. (1991). Tarih ogretimi, Esk*ehir: Anadolu ffniversitesi.
  115. (1996). Tarih programlari nasil diizenlenmelidir? ' Gazi Ekitim Fakidiesi Dergisi,
  116. (1992). Tarih ve 6gretimi, Istanbul: Cem Yayinevi.
  117. (1994). Teaching and Learning in the Primary School, London-New York: Routledge and The open University. doi
  118. (1993). Teaching History ftom Primary Evidence,
  119. (1995). Teaching History in the New Europe, London, Cassell and Council of Europe.
  120. (1994). Teaching History, doi
  121. (1997). Teaching Primary History, doi
  122. (1973). Teaching Strategies for the Social Studies, doi
  123. (1996). Teaching students to generate questions: A review of the intervention studies, doi
  124. (1976). Teaching Styles and Pupil progress, London- Open Books. doi
  125. (1992). Teaching talk' doi
  126. (1995). Teaching through discussion'
  127. (1990). Tfirkiye'de Egitim,
  128. (1996). The Culture of Education, doi
  129. (1989). The Curriculum: A Comparative Perspective, doi
  130. (1977). The development of children's construction of historical duration', doi
  131. (1988). The development of children's historical thinking', doi
  132. (1984). The development of thinking and reasoning' doi
  133. (1976). The Dissemination of Curriculum Development, doi
  134. (1960). The John Dewey Report, Ankara: Research and Measurement Bureau.
  135. (1959). The Language and Thought of the Child, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  136. (1993). The National Curriculum in primary schools- A dream at conception, a nightmare at delivery' in C. Chitty and B. Simon (eds) Education Answers Back: Critical Responses to Government Policy, LondonLawrence and Wishart.
  137. (1988). The National Curriculum- an historical perspective' in D. Lawton and C. Chitty (eds) The National Curriculum, doi
  138. (1993). The review of the National Curriculum and assessment'
  139. (1973). The Sociology ofEducational Ideas, London- Routledge and Row.
  140. (1995). The teaching of History in Primary Schools: Implementing the Revised National Curriculum, doi
  141. (1992). The Teaching of History:
  142. (1928). The Turkish Tragedy' 7-he New Republic,
  143. (1984). The Use andAbuse of History: How the Past is Taught, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  144. (1994). Thinking Through Primary Practice,
  145. (1962). Thought and Language (I Ith edition), doi
  146. (1997). Tiirk Egitim Tarihi: Baslangictan 199 7: ye (6th edition),
  147. (1998). Tiirkiye'de Dfinden Bugiine Oftetmen Yetiýtiren Kurumlar, Istanbul: Marmara'Gniversitesi Eg-itim Fakflltesi Yayinlari.
  148. (1988). Time in History, doi
  149. (1966). Towards a Theory of Instruction,
  150. (1982). Understanding of the concept of change among children and young adolescents' doi
  151. (1981). Values and ideologies'
  152. (1993). Vygotsky's contribution to the development of psychology' doi
  153. (1995). What is involved in learning? '
  154. (1984). Why learn history'

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.