Location of Repository

The cost of bus travel time variability

By Yaron Hollander


The reliability of bus systems is a vital issue on the transport agenda, since urban areas are yearning for high quality alternatives for the private car. A key indicator of\ud reliability is a low level of day-to-day travel time variability (TTV). To obtain funds for reducing TTV, it is necessary to give evidence for the benefits from such improvement, but current tools for estimating the cost of TTV are insufficient. This thesis covers issues that arise when analysts need to show that improved bus infrastructure brings benefits from reduced TTV.\ud \ud The first part of the thesis aims at understanding how the attitudes of travellers to TTV can be converted into monetary terms. The design of a survey is described, where\ud respondents trade-off between TTV and other attributes. A modelling experiment, based on the survey responses, finds that the effect of TTV is best explained using variables\ud that represent trip scheduling considerations. Following is a series of experiments that seek to estimate the willingness-to-pay for reduced TTV in a way that is sensitive to taste variation between travellers. Several Mixed Logit models are estimated, but some doubts about their credibility are raised, and hence the same willingness-to-pay estimates are also computed using nonparametric techniques. Some conclusions are drawn regarding the process of estimating heterogeneous willingness-to-pay and the ability to recognise the willingness-to-pay from survey data.\ud \ud The starting point for the second part of the thesis is the lack of tools for estimating the level of TTV in hypothetical scenarios. We, consider the case for using traffic microsimulation to estimate TTV by running a microsimulation model multiple times, and looking at the variation between runs as an estimate of the variation between different days. Such concept of estimation requires a special calibration methodology, which sets the level of simulated inter-run variability at a similar level to inter-day variability in the real network. A full calibration methodology is developed, tackling methodological, computational and statistical issues.\ud \ud Finally, the demand and supply methodologies are combined, and it is illustrated how the savings from improved bus infrastructure can be examined. The contribution of the\ud entire study includes methodological and technical insights into modelling the attitudes to TTV, estimating the distribution of the willingness-to-pay and calibrating traffic microsimulation models; but it also brings up policy issues concerning the role of TTV in transport appraisal.\u

Publisher: Institute for Transport Studies (Leeds)
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:306

Suggested articles



  1. (I 997b), Journey Time Variability in the London Area - 2. Factors Affecting Journey Time Variability,
  2. (2005). A
  3. (2005). A Calibration and Validation Procedure for Microscopic Simulation Model: A Case Study of SimTrafflic Arterial Streets,
  4. (2004). A Calibration Procedure for Microscopic Traffic Simulation, doi
  5. (2001). A Comparison of Hierarchical Bayes and Maximum Simulated Likelihood for Mixed Logit, //ýlsa.
  6. (1987). A Discrete Choice Model for Ordered Alternatives, doi
  7. (2004). A Genetic Algorithm Based Approach to Traffic Micro-simulation Calibrating Using doi
  8. (1996). A Microscopic Traffic Simulator for Evaluation of Dynamic Traffic Management Systems, doi
  9. (1978). A Model For Investigating the Effects of Service Frequency and Reliability on Bus Passenger Waiting Times,
  10. (2004). A Model for Time of Day and Mode Choice using Error Components Logit, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in doi
  11. (1987). A More General Model of Individual Departure Time Choice, Transportation Planning Methods,
  12. (1986). A New Dispersion Model for Traffic Flows, Road Traffic Control,
  13. (2005). A New Methodology for Estimating Travel Time Reliability in a Freeway Corridor, doi
  14. (1979). A Study of Travel Time and doi
  15. (1987). An Analysis of the Severity and Incident Duration of Truck Involved Freeway Accidents, doi
  16. (1974). An Approach to the Evaluation of Changes in Travel Unreliability: A "Safety Margin" doi
  17. (1982). An Empirical Study of Travel Time Variability and travel doi
  18. (1979). Analysis and Simulation of an Urban Bus Route, doi
  19. (1996). Are There Quantifiable Benefits from Reducing the Variability of Travel Times?, Transportation Plannin Methods,
  20. (2000). Assessing the Impacts of Local Trans-port Policy Instruments, ITS Working Paper 549,
  21. (2004). Basic Statistics - Interval Estimation, Virtual Laboratories
  22. (1995). Bus Joumey Time Reliability Study -
  23. (1997). Bus Reliability Study - Stated Preference Research,
  24. (2001). Calibration and Path Dynamics Issues in Microscopic Simulation for Advanced Traffic Management and Information Systems, doi
  25. (2004). Calibration and Validation of CORSIM for Swedish Road Traffic Conditions,
  26. (2003). Calibration and Validation of Microscopic Traffic Simulation Tools - Stockholm Case Study, doi
  27. (2005). Calibration of Micro-Simulation Models using Non-Parametric Statistical Techniques, doi
  28. (2004). Calibration of Microscopic Traffic Simulation Models with Aggregate Data, doi
  29. (1997). Commuter Responses to Travel Time Uncertainty under Congested Conditions: Expected Costs and the Provision of Information, doi
  30. (2003). Confidence Intervals, Data Analysis for Enviromnental Science and Management,
  31. (1969). Congestion Theory and Transport Investment,
  32. (2001). Cost-Benefit Analysis
  33. (1973). Cost-Benefit Analysis and Public Investment in Trans-port: A Survey, Butterworths,
  34. (1993). Cost-Benefit Analysis of Transport Projects, doi
  35. (1977). Cost-Benefit Analysis, Hensher,
  36. (1999). Cost/Benefit Analysis for Transit ITS: Using Available Data to Yield Credible Results,
  37. (2004). Data Analysis Methods in Weather and Climate Research,
  38. (1997). Day-to-Day Evolution of Network Flows Under Real-Time Information and Reactive Signal Control, doi
  39. (2003). Demand Choice Models - Estimation of Passenger Traffic,
  40. (1993). Demand Effects of Travel Time Reliabilit , Centre for Logistics and Transportation,
  41. (2005). Development and Evaluation of Simulation Model Calibration Procedure, doi
  42. (1979). Direct Analysis of the Perceived Importance of Attributes of doi
  43. (1985). Discrete Choice Analyis: TheoKy and Application to Travel Demand,
  44. (2005). Discrete Choice Models in Preference Space and Willingness-to-Pay doi
  45. (1999). Downhill Sim-plex Method for Many (-20) Dimensions,
  46. (2006). DRACULA Microscopic Traffic Simulator, Version 2.3, Working paper,
  47. (2001). Economic Appraisal of European Transport Projects: the State-of-the-art Revisited, doi
  48. (1971). Economic Appraisal of Transport Projects: A Manual with Case Studies, doi
  49. (1981). Economic Evaluation, Investment Criteria and Public Enterprise Objectives,
  50. (2000). Eliminating Bias Due To the Repeated Measurements Problem doi
  51. (2005). Estimating of Value of TravelTime Savings using Mixed Logit Models, doi
  52. Evaluating the Regularity and Reliability Benefits of Bus Priority Schemes: the London Experience, Transportation Planning Methods,
  53. (2004). Evidence on the Distribution of Values of Travel Time Savings from a Six-Week Diary, Arbeitsbericht Verkehrs und Raumplanun ,
  54. (1984). Factors Affecting Travel Times on Urban Radial Routes, ITS working paper 177,
  55. (2004). Flexible Substitution Patterns in Models of Mode and Time of Day Choice: New Evidence from the UK and the Netherlands, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in doi
  56. (2002). Genetic Algorithm-Based Optimization Approach and Generic Tool for Calibrating Traffic Microscopic Simulation Parameters, doi
  57. (2004). Guidelines for Calibration of Microsimulation Models: Framework and Application, doi
  58. (1968). Headstart Strategies for Combating Congestion, Trans, doi
  59. (2004). Identifying the Influence of State Choice Design Dimensionality on Willingness to Pay for Travel Time Savings,
  60. (1999). Impacts of Traffic Control Tools in 'Daccord',
  61. (1999). Improved Methods of Representing Travel Time Reliability in SP Experiments, 254 Transportation Planning Methods,
  62. (1989). Incident Characteristics, Frequency, and Duration on a High Volume Urban Freeway, doi
  63. (2003). Internet-Based Stated Preference Surveys -Studies in Traffic Information and Public Transport, Paper presented at the 4"h
  64. (2004). Introductory Statistics, School of computing,
  65. (1995). Investigating Effect of Travel Time Variability on Route Choice Using Repeated-Measurement Stated Preference Data,
  66. (2006). Investigating the Distribution of the Value of Travel Time Savings, doi
  67. (1997). Journey Time Variability in the London Area - 1.
  68. (1993). Lognormal Distribution for High Traffic flows,
  69. (2004). Methodological Notes on the Calibration and Validation of Microscopic Traffic Simulation Models,
  70. (2003). Microscopic Simulation Model Calibration and Validation - Case Study of VISSIM Simulation Model for a Coordinated Signal System, doi
  71. (2002). Microsimulation in Travel Demand Modeling - Lessons Learned from the New York Best Practice Model, doi
  72. (2006). Microsimulation Models Incorporating Both Demand and Supply Dynamics, doi
  73. (1992). Minimization or maximization of function, Numerical Recipes in C (second edition), doi
  74. (2002). Mixed Logit (or Logit Kernel) Model - doi
  75. (1999). Mixed Logit Estimation Routine for Panel Data, //ýlsa. berkeley. edu/S`oftware/ýbstracts/train0296html>, downloaded I"
  76. (2003). Mixed Logit with Bounded Distributions of Partworths, Alberini, doi
  77. (1998). Mixed Logit with Repeated Choices: Households' doi
  78. (2000). Mixed MNL Models for Discrete Response, doi
  79. (1978). Modeling and Measurements of Bus Service Reliability, doi
  80. (2004). Modelling Public Trans-port Reliability - Case
  81. (2005). Modelling Safety-Related Driving Behaviour - doi
  82. (2005). Modelling time Period Choice: Experience from the UK and the Netherlands, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in
  83. (2001). Models for Choice of Departure Time, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference, Homerton College,
  84. (2005). Monitoring and Predicting Freeway Travel Time Reliability, doi
  85. (2003). MSL for Mixed Logit Model Estimation - On Shape of Distributions, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in
  86. (1998). Nonparametric Regression Techniques in Economics, doi
  87. (1991). Novel Approaches to forecasting the Demand for New Local Rail Services, doi
  88. (2005). On Examining the Impact of Stop-Making and Travel Time Reliability on Commute Mode Choice: An Application to Predict Commuter Rail Transit Mode for Austin, doi
  89. (1987). On-time Performance and the Exponential Probability Distribution,
  90. (2005). Optimal Design for Mi'Xed Logit Models, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in
  91. (2005). Parameter Estimation and Analysis of Car-Following Models, doi
  92. (1996). Particle Hopping Model and Traffic Flow Theory, doi
  93. (2003). Practial Procedure for Calibrating Microscopic Traffic Simulation Models, doi
  94. (1970). Practical Solutions of the Behrens-Fisher Problem, doi
  95. (2004). Public Transport Values of Time, doi
  96. (2001). Quasi-Random Maximum Simulated Likelihood Estimation of the Mixed Multinomial Logit Model, doi
  97. (2000). Route and Scheduling Choice under Travel Time Uncertainty, doi
  98. (1989). Sample Size Detennination to Evaluate the Impact of Highway Improvement,
  99. (2004). Self and Others' Willingness to Pay for Improvements to the Paved Road Surface, doi
  100. (2002). Sensitivity to Travel Time Variability: Travellers' Learning Perspective, paper presented at the 13 th mini-EURO conference Handling Uncertainty in the Analysis of Traffic and Transportation Systems held in
  101. (2003). Simplex-Based Calibration of Traffic Microsimulation Models with Intelligent Transportation Systems Data, doi
  102. (2005). Specification of a Model to Measure the Value of Travel Time Savings from Binomial Data, Paper presented at the European Transport Conference held in
  103. (1994). Stated Preference Analysis of Travel Choices: doi
  104. (1975). Statistical Distributions, Butterworths, doi
  105. (1987). Statistical Tools for Simulation Practitioners, doi
  106. (2004). Statistical Validation of Traffic Simulation Models, doi
  107. (2004). Systematic Investigation of Variability due to Random Simulation Error in an Activity-Based Microsimulation Forecasting Model, doi
  108. (1949). Systems of Frequency Curves Generated by doi
  109. The Demand for Public Transport: a Practical Guide,
  110. (1988). The Design of Stated Preference Travel Choice Experiments with Special Reference to Interpersonal Taste Variations,
  111. (1974). The Economics of Transport Appraisal, doi
  112. (1987). The Evaluation of Reductions in Travel Time Variability,
  113. (1984). The Flexibitity of Departure Times for Work Trips, doi
  114. (1995). The Importance of Punctuality and Reliability: A Review of Evidence and Recommendations for Future Work, Research report,
  115. (1994). The influence of Travel Time Variability on the Value of Time, doi
  116. (2003). The Mixed Logit Model: The State of Practice, doi
  117. (1982). The Scheduling of Consumer Activities: Work Trips,
  118. (2001). The Valuation of Reliability for Personal Travel, doi
  119. (2001). The value of Time and Reliability: Measurement from a Value Pricing Experiment, doi
  120. (1983). Travel Outcome and Performance: The Effect of Uncertainty and Accesibility,
  121. (1995). Travel Time Uncertainty, Departure Time Choice,
  122. (1982). Travel Time Variability - the Case of Two Public modes, doi
  123. (1987). Travel Time Variability and Departure Time Choice: A Utility Theoretic Approach,
  124. (1987). Travel Time Variability and its Effect on Time of Day Choice for the Journey to Work, Transportation Plannin Methods,
  125. (1989). Travel Time Variability of a Group Of Car Commuters in North London, ITS Working Papers 277 to 279,
  126. (2002). Travel Time Variability: A Review of Theoretical and Empirical Issues, doi
  127. (1974). Trip Time Characteristics of Journeys To and From Work, Transportation and Traffic Theor ,
  128. (2004). Uncovering the Contribution of Travel Time Reliability to Dynamic Route Choice using Real-Time Loop Data, doi
  129. (2005). Uncovering the Distribution of Motorists' Preferences for Travel Time and Reliability, doi
  130. (1994). User Response to Travel Time Variabilit
  131. (2000). Validation of High-Fidelity Traffic Simulation Models, doi
  132. (1999). Valuation of Travel-Time Savings and Predictability in Congested Conditions for Highway User-Cost Estimation,
  133. (2003). Values of Travel Time Savings
  134. (2005). Valuing Noise Level Reduction in a Residential Location Context, doi
  135. (2005). Valuing Time and Reliability: Assessing the Evidence from Road Pricing Demonstrations, doi
  136. (1984). Variability of Car Journey Times on a Particular Route in Central London,
  137. (1985). Vehicle Scheduling at a Transportation Terminal with Random Delay En Route, doi
  138. (1995). Verification and Validation of Simulation Models, doi
  139. (2004). Witlingness to Pay for Reducing Fatal Accident Risk in Urban Areas: an Internet-Based Web Page Stated 257 Preference Survey, Accident Analysis and Prevention, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.