Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The child witness and the criminal justice process : a case study in law reform

By Amanda Elizabeth Wade

Abstract

The 1988 and 1991 Criminal Justice Acts transformed the position of the child witness within the criminal justice system. Rules of evidence which had discriminated\ud against children's testimony were progressively abolished, and new procedures were introduced to accommodate children's needs within the trial process. This thesis\ud offers a socio-legal critique of the reforms, analysing the way in which their development and implementation have been ideologically structured.\ud \ud Part Two provides an historical overview of the way in which the legal system has regarded children's testimony. Contrasts are drawn between the relative failure of the\ud 1925 Inter-Departmental Committee on Sexual Offences against Young People to secure changes in the treatment of child witnesses, and the comparative success, some\ud sixty years later, of the Pigot Committee. The links between child witness reform and dominant conceptions of child sexual abuse are investigated.\ud \ud Part Three turns to the implementation of the reforms and reports the findings of a qualitative and ethnographic study conducted for this thesis at one Crown Court\ud Centre. Sixteen contested piosecutions, between them involving evidence from 53 child witnesses, were identified. The final hearing of each case was observed in full, and the attitudes towards the reforms of the barristers and child witnesses concerned were sought by way of interviews and questionnaires.\ud \ud Part Four notes the mixed effects of the reforms, and the categorical distinctions observable at the study Crown Court in the treatment of child complainants and child\ud by-stander witnesses. It is suggested that the reconceptualisation of child sexual abuse as a criminal justice, rather than a welfare, problem, played a significant role in achieving child witness reform, but that the moral rhetoric involved silenced alternative perspectives and has led to the marginalisation of some child witnesses. What these conclusions suggest about the law reform process more generally is briefly\ud discussed

Publisher: Centre for Criminal Justice Studies (Leeds)
Year: 1997
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:422

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1988). A reply to King.' The Psychologist
  2. (1991). Achieving Power. Practice and Policy in Social Welfare.
  3. (1996). All Fall Down. BBC television programme transmitted 20.2.1996.
  4. (1986). All snakes and no ladders. Child sexual abuse: corroboration.'
  5. (1993). An Education in Interviewing: Placing the Researcher and the Researched.'
  6. (1991). An Evaluation of the Live Link for Child Witnesses. Home Office:
  7. (1979). An experimental study of the effectiveness of different techniques of questioning child witnesses.' doi
  8. (1988). Barrister among six men accused of child sex abuse: Court video screens will shield alleged victims.' The Times 12.11.1988.
  9. (1990). Beyond a Reasonable Doubt: Factors That Influence the Legal Disposition of Child Sexual Abuse Cases.' Crime and Delinquency doi
  10. (1991). Blackstock 's Guide to the Criminal Justice Act
  11. (1989). Changes urged to spare child sex victims.' The Times 2.10.1989.
  12. (1987). Child abuse: the first steps to justice.' The Times 3.10.1987.
  13. (1988). Child Evidence: More Proposals for Reform.' Criminal Law Review pp.
  14. (1993). Child protection in Europe: convergence or divergence?' doi
  15. (1986). Child sex abuse: 1. Lawyers and doctors reeling over growing use of video tapes.'
  16. (1986). Child sex abuse: 2. Lawyers oppose video questioning.' The Times 17.6.1986.
  17. (1988). Child sex evidence banned.' The Times 2.3.1988.
  18. (1990). Child sexual abuse -2.' NewLawJournal23.3.1990,
  19. (1988). Child Sexual Abuse and the Law.' doi
  20. (1992). Child sexual abuse and the regulation of women: variations on a theme.' In:
  21. (1987). Child Sexual Abuse Cases a Worry.' Social Work Today 29.6.1987,
  22. (1986). Child sexual abuse cases doubled last year, NSPCC survey shows.' The Times 22.3.1986.
  23. (1963). Child Victims of Sex Offences. Institute for the Study and Treatment of Delinquency: London.
  24. (1992). Child Victims: Crime, Impact and Criminal Justice. doi
  25. (1987). Child Witnesses - A Further Skirmish.'
  26. (1987). Child Witnesses and the Criminal Justice Bill.'
  27. (1990). Child witnesses in Scottish criminal proceedings.
  28. (1988). Child Witnesses: A case for legal refonn?.' In:
  29. (1990). Child Witnesses: Developments in Australia and New Zealand.' In:
  30. (1988). Child Witnesses: The Psychological Evidence.'
  31. (1996). Children as Research Subjects: a Risky Enterprise.' doi
  32. (1990). Children as victims of crime: Procedure at court.' In:
  33. (1937). Children in the Courts.'
  34. (1991). Children on Trial? Psychology, Videotechnology and the Law.' doi
  35. (1986). Children will give video evidence in trial changes.'
  36. (1987). Children's Evidence by Video.'
  37. (1990). Children's Evidence in Legal Proceedings: An International Perspective. Papers from an international conference, Selwyn College Cambridge,
  38. (1987). Children's Evidence. The Needfor Corroboration, Home Office Research and Planning Unit, Paper No. 41. Home Office:
  39. (1989). Children's Knowledge of Coui-t Proceedings.' doi
  40. (1987). Children's Reactions to Sex Abuse Investigation and Litigation.' doi
  41. (1984). Children's Testimony in Historical Perspective.' doi
  42. (1988). columns 272-278.344
  43. (1991). columns 32-67,
  44. (1990). Commission doi
  45. (1925). Committee on Sexual Offences against Young Persons doi
  46. (1981). Conviction: The State and the Construction of Justice.
  47. (1943). Crime andPsychology.
  48. (1988). Criminal checks on child care workers to counter abuse.'
  49. (1992). Developmental Changes in Research Risk and Benefit: A Changing Calculus of Concerns.' In:
  50. (1993). Digest 2: Information on the Criminal Justice System in England and Wales. Home Office Research and Statistics Department:
  51. (1973). Director of Public Prosecutions v Hester
  52. (1991). Doing justice to children.'
  53. (1983). Ethnography: Principles in Practice. doi
  54. (1987). Family Law Reports: Special Issue.'
  55. (1995). Feminism and Law: Some Problems of Analysis and Strategy.' In:
  56. (1992). Feminist Vigilantes of Late-Victorian England.' doi
  57. (1973). Folk Devils and Moral Panics. doi
  58. (1988). Health and Social Security doi
  59. (1988). Health and Social Security and the Welsh Office doi
  60. (1992). Home Office in conjunction with Department of Health
  61. (1991). How Children Tell:
  62. (1988). How not to reform the law.'
  63. (1987). Hurd plans wider video use.' The Times 11.4.1987.
  64. (1987). Hurd to lift bar on child evidence.' The Times 3.10.1987.
  65. (1976). Identity: The Wrong Face of the Law.
  66. (1988). Ideologies, political parties, and victims of crime.'
  67. (1995). Improving Children's Testimony: The Question, the Answer and the Environment.' In:
  68. (1990). In the Box or on the Box? The Pigot Report and Child Witnesses.'
  69. (1988). Inquiry into video tape plan.' The Times 20.6.1988.
  70. (1993). Interpreting.' In:
  71. (1988). Interviewing children.' doi
  72. (1981). Interviewing women: a contradiction in terms.'
  73. (1995). Introductory comments for Children
  74. (1984). It's great to have someone to talk to": The ethics and politics of interviewing women.'
  75. Journal 8.12.1989 'NSPCC calls for legal reforms.'
  76. (1987). Judicial Discourse in Father-Daughter Incest Appeal Cases.'
  77. (1987). Lawyers split over court video links.' The Times 6.3.87.
  78. (1988). Legal Lessons from Cleveland.'
  79. (1986). Legal plea for abused children.' The Times 9.5.1986.
  80. (1986). Live video link for child evidence. Witnesses of violence spared courtroom trauma.' The Times 4.11.1986.
  81. (1990). Loopholes 'allow abusers to go free'.'
  82. (1993). Lord Justice doi
  83. (1992). Making a Case in Child Protection.
  84. (1991). Media reporting of social work: a framework for analysis.'
  85. (1987). Metropolitan Police and Bexley Social Services
  86. (1986). More humanity, Mr Hurd.' The Times 25,11.1986.
  87. (1987). New concern over child sex evidence.' The Times 25.9.1987.
  88. (1986). No action against sex-case doctor.'
  89. (1997). No easy answers: children's perspectives on investigative interviews.' In
  90. (1993). NSPCC Launches Justice for Children Campaign. Press release,
  91. (1987). NSPCC records 137% increase.'
  92. (1988). NSPCC Submission to the Home Office Advisory Group on the Admissibility of Video Recorded Interviews.
  93. (1990). Opening Speech to the Conference.' In:
  94. (1989). Papers from an international conference, Selwyn College Cambridge,
  95. (1987). Parliamentary Papers 1884-1885 vol.3 0 Sapsted,
  96. (1987). Peers press for video evidence in child cases'
  97. (1986). Picture book plan in child abuse cases.' The Times 14.12.86.
  98. (1990). Plea for children's evidence on video as case collapses.' The Times 22.6.1990.
  99. (1993). Pressure, Power, and Policy: State Autonomy and Policy Networks in Britain and the United States. Harvester Wheatsheaf Hemel Hempstead. doi
  100. (1991). Problems in view for videos.' The Times 13.10.1991.
  101. (1988). Prosecuting child sexual abuse: a challenge to the status quo.'
  102. (1995). Prosecuting ChildAbuse. An Evaluation of the Government 's Speedy Progress Policy.
  103. (1992). Protecting the Child Witness in the Courtroom.' doi
  104. (1993). Questioning Young Children in Court: A Linguistic Case Study.' doi
  105. (1981). Reconstructing Social Reality in the courtroom. doi
  106. (1991). Reducing the System-induced Trauma for Child Sexual Abuse Victims through preparation, Assessment andFoiow-up. The London Family Court Clinic:
  107. (1993). Reflecting on Research Practice. doi
  108. (1991). Reformers despair.'
  109. (1988). Reforming the Competency Requirement.'
  110. (1989). Report of the Advisory Group on Video Evidence. (Chairman Judge Thomas Pigot QC.) Home Office:
  111. (1986). Research as Praxis.'
  112. (1993). Researching Sensitive Topics. doi
  113. (1984). Revision Committee doi
  114. (1913). RoundAbout aPounda Week. Re-published by Virago: London,
  115. (1973). Routledge and Kegan Paul: doi
  116. (1991). Running a campaign: appropriate stategies for changing times.' In:
  117. (1979). SelectedLetters of Oscar Wilde.
  118. (1961). Sexual Assault on Children.' doi
  119. (1978). Sibling and Parent-Child Incest Offenders.'
  120. (1994). Social Services Inspectorate
  121. (1996). Specialist Police Units and the Joint Investigation of Child Abuse.' doi
  122. (1993). Speech for the Lord Chancellor: The launch of the Child Witness Information Packs.
  123. (1995). Statistics: Annual Report doi
  124. (1995). Steering Group on Child Evidence.' Unpublished information sheet distributed to participants at the Children in the Crossfire conference held by the Michael Sieff Foundation,
  125. (1992). Steps towards forensically relevant research.' In:
  126. (1995). Strange Dislocations: Childhood and the Idea of Human Interiorily, doi
  127. (1989). Strange Language: Child Victims under Crossexamination. Riverina Murray Institute: Australia.339 Burgess,
  128. (1990). Striving for justice in court.'
  129. (1992). Testifying in Criminal Court: Emotional Effects on Child Sexual Assault Victims.' doi
  130. (1992). The Barrister's World and the Nature of Law. doi
  131. (1995). The Child Witness in the Courtroom: Empowerment or Protection?' In:
  132. (1988). The Child Witness. Final Report to the Criminological Research Branch, Central Research Unit, The Scottish Office Home and Health Department,
  133. (1986). The Child Witness.' doi
  134. (1991). The Children Act doi
  135. (1994). The Code for Crown Prosecutors. CPS:
  136. (1978). The Criminal Trial before the Lawyers.' doi
  137. (1990). The dilemmas of the criminal and civil law approaches to child protection.'
  138. (1988). The Emotional Effects of Criminal Court Testimony on Child Sexual Assault Victims: A Preliminary Report.'
  139. (1996). The Ethics of Social Research with Children: An Overview.' doi
  140. (1987). The Evidence of Absent Children.'
  141. (1988). The Evidence of Children and Other Potentially Vulnerable Witnesses.
  142. (1990). The Evidence of Children: The Law and the Psychology. Blackstone Press: London.350
  143. (1964). The Evidence of Children.'
  144. (1983). The Family and the Market: A Study of Ideology and Legal Reform.' doi
  145. (1986). The Guardian 29.9.1987 'A louder voice for the child in abuse cases.' The Guardian 29.9.1987 'Keep on cuddling, parents advised.' The Guardian 29.9.1987 'Mother had sex with her three sons.'
  146. (1988). The Investigation of ChildSexualAbuse. Home Office Circular 52/1988,
  147. The Law Journal 30.1.1926 'Sexual Offences Against Young Persons.' doi
  148. The Law Journal 6.3.1926 'Sexual Offences Against Young Persons.' doi
  149. (1990). The Law Society (unpublished, doi
  150. (1978). The Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon Re-examined: Child Prostitution and the Idea of Childhood in Late Victorian England.'
  151. (1989). The Paedophile and the Court Room Drama: a Distortion of Reality.'
  152. (1993). The Preparation of Child Witnesses.'
  153. (1963). The Proof of Guilt: A Study of the English Criminal Trial. Stevens and Sons: London, 3rd edition.
  154. (1969). The Protection of the Child Victim of a Sexual Assault in the Criminal Justice System.'
  155. (1993). The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice doi
  156. (1885). The Royal Commission on the Housing of the Working Classes doi
  157. (1990). The Scandinavian Countries,' In:
  158. (1992). The Sexual Abuse of Male Children and Adolescents: A Review of Current Research.' doi
  159. (1984). The Testimony of the Child Victim of Sexual Assault.' doi
  160. (1992). The Use of Closed Circuit Television for Child Witnesses in the ACT. A Report for the Australian Law Reform Commission and the Australian Capital Territory Magistrates'
  161. (1987). The Use of Video Technology at Trials of Alleged Child Abusers. Consultation paper issued 8.5.1987. Home Office:
  162. (1994). Thinking through fieldwork.' doi
  163. (1993). Three Years After the Verdict: A Longitudinal Study of the Social and341 Psychological Adjustment of Child Witnesses Referred to the Child Witness Project. London Family Court Clinic Inc.:
  164. (1988). TV evidence speed-up in cases of child abuse.' The Times 19.12.1988.
  165. (1989). TV link-up fails to calm child witness.' The Times 23.2.1989.
  166. (1994). Under Fire: Lawyers questioning children in criminal courts.'
  167. (1995). Unquestionably a Moral Issue: Rhetorical Devices and Regulatory Imperatives.' In:
  168. (1988). Use of Video in Child Abuse Trials: A Reply to the Professional Affairs Board of the Society.' The Psychologist
  169. (1989). Video evidence of child sex victims backed in report.' The Times 20.12.1989.
  170. (1990). Video shows up victims.'
  171. (1987). Video study to assist children in abuse cases.' The Times 9.5.1987.
  172. (1988). Videos allowed in child abuse cases.' The Times 4.8.1988.
  173. (1986). Videotaped interviews in child abuse cases criticised by judge.' The Times 16.7.1986.
  174. (1995). Videotaping Children's Evidence: An Evaluation. Home Office Publications Unit:
  175. (1987). Videotaping Children's Evidence.'
  176. (1990). Violence against women: feminism and the law.' doi
  177. (1988). What is the age of reason?'
  178. (1990). When the victim is a child: past hope, current reality and future promise of legal reform in the United States.' In:
  179. (1987). Women 's Silence, Men 's Violence: Sexual Assault in England 1770-1845. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.