Location of Repository

Understanding benefit fraud : a qualitative analysis

By Keleigh Ann Groves


The concern to understand why people act in the way they do has preoccupied the social sciences since their very inception. At the heart of this concern is the question of how we might best theorise the relationship between individual action (agency) and social context (structure). This relationship is the focus of this thesis and it has been explored theoretically and empirically through a qualitative study of benefit fraud.\ud \ud Theoretically, four sociological concepts - discourses, resources, normative guidelines and identity - are argued to be central to the relationship between structure and agency. Taken together, these concepts offer a valuable template to explore social action in general and, in\ud particular, why people engage in fraudulent action.\ud \ud The research involved in-depth interviews with a socially diverse snowball sample of 16 people engaged in benefit fraud. Three key points emerged from the analysis of the\ud interview narratives. First, benefit fraud (and social action more generally) can be understood through acknowledging the resource-configurations within which individuals exist. Resources are conceptualised as financial, social and/or ontological and their contingent nature is highlighted. The research demonstrates how the availability, accessibility and acceptability of resources changes with time and place, as well as being influenced by discourses, normative guidelines and self-identity. Second, discourses are shown to have a shaping influence upon the normative guidelines underpinning individual action. However, this does not occur in a straightforward way, since actors critically negotiate with the discursive matrix within which they are embedded. Third, it is argued\ud that individual accounts of fraudulent action are about much more than motivation - their primary purpose for the individual is the (re)construction of moral adequacy in the context of lives lived at the margins - socially, materially and normatively.\ud \ud This research aims to present a more robust theorisation of benefit fraud than much previous work in this field and, in addition, to contribute new empirical insights on the\ud complex and contingent nature of resources and moral accounts. The thesis ends with an exploration of the theoretical, methodological and policy implications of the research

Publisher: School of Sociology and Social Policy (Leeds)
Year: 2002
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:475

Suggested articles



  1. (1997). (eds.) Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood:
  2. (1990). A Matter of Record: Documentary Sources in Social Research.
  3. (1999). A New Political Economy For New Labour -
  4. (2002). A Proper Place To Live: Health Inequalities, Agency and the Normative Dimensions of Space. Social Science and Medicine,
  5. (1992). A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency and Transformation.
  6. (2001). Accessing Hidden and Hard-to-Reach Populations: Snowball Research Strategies.
  7. (1999). Agency, Modernity and Social Policy.
  8. (2001). Agency, Rationality and Social Policy.
  9. (1992). An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology.
  10. (2002). Analysing Families:
  11. (2001). Anthony Giddens: A Global Social Theorist. In
  12. (1998). Anthony Giddens: The Last Modernist. Routledge, London and
  13. (1985). Applied Qualitative Analysis.
  14. (1999). Ask Not What Your Community Can Do For You': Obligations, New Labour and Welfare Reform.
  15. (1999). Balancing Polarities: Developing a New Framework for Welfare Research. In
  16. (2002). Benefits Ad Girl Is Secret Dole Cheat: Shame of Actress Who Claimed as She Worked. News of the World,
  17. (1994). Beyond Left and Right.
  18. (2001). Blair In Row As Whitehall Adverts Soar By 157%.
  19. (2000). Bourdieu, Social Suffering and Working-Class Life.
  20. (1993). Breaking Out Again: Feminist Ontology and Epistemology. Routledge and Kegan,
  21. (1971). Capitalism and Modern Social Theory.
  22. (1979). Central Problems in Social Theory.
  23. (1999). Changing Paradigms of Welfare. In
  24. (2002). Changing Views on Benefit Rights and Abuse: On the Modernisation of the Culture of Social Assistance. Paper presented to the European Social Policy Research Network Annual Conference, 'Social Values, Social Policies', 29th _ 31S` August,
  25. (1998). Choice and Public Policy: The Limits to Welfare Markets.
  26. (2002). Complex Cultures: Rereading The Story About Health and Social Capital. Critical Social Policy, Volume 72,
  27. (1998). Conceptualising Constraint: Mouzelis, Archer and the Concept of Social Structure.
  28. (1998). Criteria for Assessing Interpretive Validity in Qualitative Research.
  29. (1994). Dangerous Classes: The Underclass and Social Citizenship.
  30. (1998). Data Management and Analysis Methods.
  31. (1995). de France, Paris. Quoted by
  32. (1992). Dependency Culture: The Explosion of a Myth.
  33. (1998). Designing Funded Qualitative Research.
  34. (1999). Detecting, Prosecuting and Punishing Benefit Fraud: The Social Security Administration (Fraud) Act
  35. (1989). Differential Responses to Tax and Supplementary Benefit Fraud.
  36. (2000). Disabled People, New Labour, Benefits and Work.
  37. (1995). Discourse and Social Change.
  38. (1993). Discourse, Ideology, Discourse, Ideology, Discourse, Ideology...
  39. (1998). Do Housing Tenure and Car Access Predict Health Because They Are Simply Markers of Income or Self-Esteem?
  40. (2000). Doing Qualitative Research Differently: Free Association, Narrative and the Interview Method.
  41. (1993). Doing Research on Sensitive Topics.
  42. (1988). Doing the Business: Entrepreneurship, the Working Class, and Detectives in the East End of London.
  43. (1999). Doing the Right Thing: Labour's Attempt to Forge a New Welfare Deal Between the Individual and the State. Social Policy and Administration, Volume 33,
  44. (1994). Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonapate.
  45. (1996). Ethics and Social Policy Research. University of Luton in conjunction with
  46. (1995). Eurodrugs. Routledge, London. Quoted
  47. (1999). Exploring Links Between Old and New Paradigms: A Critical Review. In
  48. (1998). Exploring Self and Society.
  49. (1989). Family Obligations and Social Change.
  50. (1977). Fiddlers On The Hoof Moral Panics and Social Security Scroungers.
  51. (1994). Fiddly Jobs, Undeclared Working and the Something for Nothing Society. Work, Employment and Society,
  52. (1973). Folk Devils and Moral Panics.
  53. (2001). Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Discourse. In
  54. (1995). Friday Night, Saturday Night: Youth Cultural Identification in the Post-Industrial City. University of Newcastle upon Tyne,
  55. (2001). Getting the Measure of Fraud.
  56. (1997). Good Enough Morality? Divorce and Postmodernity.
  57. (1999). Good-Enough Principles for Welfare.
  58. (1993). Greenhorn Revisited: Researching Myself and My Sisters.
  59. (1994). Hard Times? How Poor Families Make Ends Meet. Policy Studies Institute,
  60. (1981). Hemel Hempstead.236 Department of Employment/Department of Health and Social Security
  61. (2000). Housing Tenure and Health Inequalities: A Three-Dimensional Perspective on People, Homes and Neighbourhoods.
  62. (1902). Human Nature and Social Order Charles Scribner's Sons,
  63. (1986). Human Territoriality: Its Theory and History.
  64. (1936). Ideology and Utopia: An Introduction to the Sociology of Knowledge. Harcourt, Brace and Co,
  65. (2001). Illness Narratives: Fact or Fiction? Sociology of Health and Illness,
  66. (1982). Images of Welfare: Press and Public Attitudes to Poverty.
  67. (1976). In Search of the Scrounger: The Administration of Unemployment Insurance
  68. (2000). Incestuous Fields: Management Research, Emotion and Data Analysis'.
  69. (2000). Inequality and Social Environment - A Reply to Lynch et al.
  70. (2000). Information. Available at: http://www.targetingfraud.gov.uk/pages/info.html
  71. (2002). Insecure Families and Low-Paying Labour Markets: Comments on the British Experience.
  72. (1983). Inside the Inner City.
  73. (1996). Insider Perspectives or Stealing the Words out of Women's Mouths: Interpretation in the Research Process. Feminist Review,
  74. (1972). Insiders and Outsiders: A Chapter in the Sociology of Knowledge.
  75. (1996). Inter Views: An Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing.
  76. (1996). Introduction: In Search of the Underclass.
  77. (1999). Introduction: Misleading Messages: The Media and Social Policy.
  78. (1996). Introduction: Who Needs 'Identity'? In
  79. (1987). Introductory Sociology.
  80. (1998). Is There a Place for Geography in the Analysis of Health Inequality? Sociology of Health and Illness, Volume 20,
  81. (1996). It's Time To Shop Lilley The Stink. Daily Mirror,
  82. (1997). Knights, Knaves or Pawns? Human Behaviour and Social Policy.
  83. (1990). Know me as I am':
  84. (1998). Labour Plays Safe On Welfare: Purge On Benefit Fraud.
  85. (1991). Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought.
  86. (1958). Les Structures Sociales.
  87. (1995). Life In Fragments.
  88. (1996). Life On A Low Income. Joseph Rowtree Foundation,
  89. (1989). Living On The Edge: A Study of the Living Standards of Families on Benefit in Tyne and Wear. Tyneside Child Poverty Action Group,
  90. (1993). Locality and Community: Coming To Terms With Place Sociological Review, Volume 41,
  91. (1997). Lone Mothers and Paid Work - Rational Economic Man or Gendered Moral Rationalities? Feminist Economics,
  92. (1999). Lone Mothers, Paid Work and Gendered Moral Rationalities.
  93. (1993). Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy.
  94. (1995). Making Welfare Work: Reconstructing Welfare for the Millennium. Institute for Community Studies,
  95. (1997). Manageable Discord: Fraud & Resistance in the Social Security System.
  96. (1992). Managing Threats to Welfare: The Search for a New Paradigm of Welfare.
  97. (2002). Mapping Health Inequalities in Social Space.
  98. (1976). Methods and Issues in Social Research.
  99. (1967). Mind, Self and Society.
  100. (1991). Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age.
  101. (2000). Moral Tales of the Child and the Adult: Narratives of Contemporary Family Lives under Changing Circumstances. Sociology,
  102. (1981). Moral Tales: Parents' Stories of Encounters With The Health Professionals.
  103. (1993). Negotiating Family Responsibilities. Tavistock and Routledge,
  104. (1998). Negotiating Selves: Reflections on 'Unstructured' Interviewing.
  105. (1998). New Ambitions for our Country: A New Contract For Welfare.
  106. (2000). New Labour and The Third Way in the British Welfare State: A New and Distinctive Approach? Critical Social Policy,
  107. (1999). New Labour, New Welfare State? The 'Third Way'
  108. (1998). New Labour: Politics After Thatcherism:
  109. (1976). New Rules of Sociological Method.
  110. (2000). Organised Benefit Fraud - A Report. DSS, London. Available at http://www.dss.gov.uldpublications/dss/2000/scampion/index.htm Silverman,
  111. (1977). Part-Time Crime.
  112. (2002). Perspectives on Welfare: Ideas, Ideologies and Policy Debates.
  113. (1997). Pierre Bourdieu and Cultural Theory.
  114. (2002). Placing Social Capital. Progress in Human Geography,
  115. (1994). Polarisation, underclass and the welfare state.
  116. (1996). Postmodernism, Feminism and the Question of Difference.
  117. (1999). Poverty First Hand: Poor People Speak for Themselves.
  118. (1979). Poverty in the United Kingdom.
  119. (1995). Poverty, Deregulation of the Labour Market and Benefit Fraud. Social Policy and Administration.
  120. (1999). Poverty, Welfare and the Disciplinary State.
  121. (1995). Practical Sociology: Post-Empiricism and the Reconstruction of Theory and Application.
  122. (1994). Preface. In
  123. (1986). Prescribed Drug Use and the Management of Everyday Life: The Experiences of Black and White Working-Class Women. Sociological Review,
  124. (1998). Putting Fraud Into Perspective.
  125. (1994). Putting the Family First: Identities, Decisions, Citizenship.
  126. (1993). Qualitative Interviewing.
  127. (1996). Qualitative Research: The Emotional Dimension. Avebury,
  128. (2002). Qualitative Researching: 2' Edition.
  129. (1998). Qualitative Researching.
  130. (2000). Questioning Identity: Gender,
  131. (1992). Rare Populations, Hidden Populations and Link-Tracing Designs: What and Why?
  132. (1996). Rational Economic Man or Lone Mother in Context? The Uptake of Paid Work.
  133. (1997). Reflexivity: The Dilemmas of Researching from the Inside.
  134. (1997). Reforming Welfare. Social Market Foundation/Profile Books,
  135. (2000). Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General -Appropriation Accounts
  136. (1973). Report, amid 5228.
  137. (1994). Researching Women's Lives From a Feminist Perspective.
  138. (1995). Review Article: The Transformations of Anthony Giddens -The Continuing Story of Structuration Theory.
  139. (1989). Rich Law, Poor Law: Differential Responses to Tax and Supplementary Benefit Fraud Open
  140. (1993). Richard Titmuss: 20 Years On.
  141. (1997). Sampling Hard to Reach Populations.
  142. (1986). Scientific Realism and Human Emancipation.
  143. (1979). Scroungers: Crushing The Invisible.
  144. (1998). Securing The System: A Report By The Benefit Fraud Inspectorate. Available at: hftp://www.dss.gov.uldhq/pubs/bflar98/index.htm
  145. (2000). Sensitive Issues in Life Story Research.
  146. (1994). Service and Security: The Benefits Agency's Fight Against Fraud in 1993-1994. The Stationary Office,
  147. (2000). Short Stories About Stroke: Interviews and Narrative Production.
  148. (2001). Sick or disabled: a basic guide to benefits and tax credits for people of all ages with a physical or mental illness or disability - and for people who look after them.
  149. (2000). Social Capital - Is It A Good Investment Strategy For Public Health?
  150. (1998). Social Capital and Economic Development: Towards a Theoretical Synthesis and Policy Framework.
  151. (1998). Social Capital in Rural and Urban Communities. Rural Sociology, Volume 63,
  152. (2000). Social Capital, Economic Capital and Power: Further Issues for a Public Health Agenda.
  153. (1997). Social Divisions of Welfare: Tax and Social Security Fraud. In
  154. (1996). Social Identity.
  155. (1993). Social Research: Issues, Methods and Process.
  156. (1997). Social Security Fraud: The Role of Penalties.
  157. (1988). Social Structures and Human Lives: A Sociological Theme.
  158. (1968). Social Theory and Social Structure.
  159. (1927). Society and National Union of Ratepayers' Associations
  160. (1999). Soft-Soaping The Public? The Government and Media Promotion of Social Policy.
  161. (1975). Space, Time, and Human Conditions.
  162. (1987). Structuration Theory and Social Praxis.
  163. (1967). Studies In Ethnornethodology Prentice-Hall,
  164. (1996). Studying One's Own in the Middle East: Negotiating Gender and SelfOther Dynamics in the Field. Qualitative Sociology, Volume 19,
  165. (1970). Suicide: A Study in Sociology. Routledge and Kegan Paul,
  166. (1997). Supporting the Family: Lone Mothers, Paid Work and the Underclass Debate. Critical Social Policy,
  167. (1984). Surveying Through Stories.
  168. (1991). Surviving the Welfare System: How AFDC Recipients Make Ends Meet in Chicago. Social Problems, Volume 38,
  169. (1995). Target The Real Cheats and We Will All Benefit. Daily Mirror,
  170. (1998). Thatcherism, New Labour and the Welfare State. Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion (CASE), London School of Economic (LSE),
  171. (2000). The Academic Contribution to Social Reform. Social Policy and Administration,
  172. (2000). The Black Economy. Guardian Unlimited, Thursday 9th March. Available at: http://www.guardianunlimited.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,3972099,00.html TUC (Trades Union Congress)
  173. (1981). The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies.
  174. (1995). The Coming of Age of Feminist Sociology: Some Issues of Practice and Theory for the Next Twenty Years.
  175. (1995). The Complete Stories. The Women's Press,
  176. (1984). The Constitution of Society: Outline of The Theory of Structuration.
  177. (1977). The Difficulties of a Minority Researcher in Minority Communities.
  178. (1990). The Emerging British Underclass. rEA Health and Welfare Unit,
  179. (1991). The Ethics of Social Research. Longman,
  180. (1999). The Ethnographic Self: Fieldwork and the Representation of Identity.
  181. (1984). The Evolution of The British Welfare State.
  182. (1986). The Forms of Capital. In
  183. (2000). The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: The Different Faces of Agency in Social Security Fraud. Paper presented to Social Policy Association Annual Conference - Futures of Social Policy and Practice?
  184. (2000). The Informal Economy - A Report.
  185. (1998). The Interpretation of Documents and Material Culture.
  186. (1990). The Logic of Practice.
  187. (1950). The Lonely Crowd.
  188. (1998). The Long-term Unemployed, Informal Economic Activity and the 'Underclass' in Belfast.
  189. (1986). The Making of a Claiming Class - The Neglect of Agency in
  190. (1992). The Making of an English 'Underclass'? The Social Divisions of Welfare and Labour.
  191. (1994). The Narrative Constitution of Identity: A Relational and Network Approach.
  192. (1970). The Order of Things.
  193. (1984). The Penguin Dictionary of Sociology.
  194. (1985). The Penguin Guide to Supplementary Benefits.
  195. (1972). The Phenomenology of the Social World.
  196. (1979). The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. Translation by
  197. (1994). The Power To Know One Thing Is Never The Power To Know All Things: Methodological Notes On Two Studies of Black American Teachers.
  198. (1993). The Problems of Researching Sensitive Topics: An Overview and Introduction.
  199. (1995). The Proximate Contexts of Workfare and Work: A Framework for Studying Poor Women's Economic Choices. The Sociological Quarterly,
  200. (2002). The Results of the Area Benefit Review and the Quality Support Team from
  201. (1998). The Right Amount to the Right People?' Reducing Fraud, Error and Non-Take-Up of Benefit.
  202. (2001). The Rise and Fall of the UK's First Tax Credit: The Working Families Tax Credit 1998-2000. Social Policy and Administration, Volume 35,
  203. (1978). The Scrounging Controversy: Public Attitudes Towards the Unemployed in Contemporary Britain.
  204. (1957). The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.
  205. (1951). The Social System.
  206. (1978). The Sociological Imagination.
  207. (1921). The Sociological Significance of the 'Stranger'.
  208. (1986). The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume 1: Reason and the Rationalisation of Society.
  209. (1987). The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume 2: The Critique of Functionalist Reason.
  210. (1998). The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy.
  211. (1998). Theorising Childhood.
  212. (1998). Theorising Inequalities in Health: The Place of Lay Knowledge.
  213. (1999). Thinking the Unthinkable: Welfare Reform and the Media.
  214. (1992). Trapped in Poverty? Labour-Market Decisions in Low-Income Households.
  215. (2002). Understanding Social Exclusion.
  216. (1994). Understanding Social Theory.
  217. (1977). Varieties of Opportunistic Research. Urban Life,
  218. (2000). Victims or Villains? Exploring Structure and Agency in Accounts of Social Security Fraud.
  219. (1998). Volume 5, Number 3. Available at: http://www.socresonline.org.uk/5/3/perriton.html Plows,
  220. (1993). Weaving Stories: Personal Auto/Biography in Feminist Research.
  221. (2000). Welfare: From Security to Responsibility?
  222. (1960). Werke Volume 8. Dietz Verlag,
  223. (1992). What's Wrong With Ethnography? Methodological Explorations.
  224. (1994). When Black Is Not Enough: Doing Field Research Among Gullah Women.
  225. (1985). Who's Fiddling? Fraud and Abuse.
  226. (1996). Whom Can You Trust? The Politics of 'Grassing' on an Inner-City Housing Estate. Sociological Review, Volume 44,
  227. (1989). Work and Welfare Benefits.
  228. (2001). Work For Those Who Can, Security For Those Who Cannot': A Third Way in Social Security Reform or Fractured Social Citizenship? In
  229. (1997). Work, Welfare and Single Mothers' Economic Survival Strategies. American Sociological Review,
  230. (1999). Working in the Hidden Economy: The Experience of Unemployed Men
  231. (1998). Writing the Voices of the Less Powerful: Research on Lone Mothers.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.