Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Civil society and democratisation theory : an inter-regional comparison

By Gideon B. Baker


This thesis constitutes an inquiry into the relationship between civil society theory and democratic theory. It revolves around an investigation into, and comparison between, recent discourses on civil society originating from within diverse political contexts. This is in order to uncover what the central claims - both normative and programmatic - of civil society theory are in the contemporary era, how these relate to the political contexts\ud within which they have originated, and why they reemerged when they did. The findings from this investigation then provided the material for a substantive critique of the overall coherence of recent civil society theory, and of the contribution of the idea of civil society to democratic theory and practice; they also enable a comparison of current ideas about civil society with classical civil society theory.\ud \ud The thesis presents a number of new arguments. Firstly, that all models of civil society,since their revival in the 1970s, make assumptions - though often hidden or unconscious\ud - about what democracy is and of where it should take place. Secondly, recent notions of civil society are divided most clearly into radical and liberal-democratic models, with crucial implications for how civil society is conceived. Thirdly, civil society theory illustrates the close linkages between political ideas and the political base within which they are articulated; political discourse, despite its power to shape the political context,\ud must itself evolve in accordance with the exigencies of the political base if it is to survive. Fourthly, contemporary civil society theory has shifted in a crucial aspect from classical civil society theory: while the latter was tied closely to liberalism, today's civil society theory is connected almost exclusively to democratic theory. Finally, it is argued that recent civil society theory adds little that is original to the lexicon of political theory. For\ud despite the novelty of radical models of civil society from the 1970s and early 1980s (which, it is argued, have not retained their initial force), the idea of civil society figures increasingly as a rubric for already established liberal democratic orthodoxies about the desired relationship between the state and society.\ud \u

Publisher: School of Politics & International Studies (POLIS) (Leeds)
Year: 1998
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1982), doi
  2. (1985), doi
  3. (1985), Letters From Prison and doi
  4. (1987), Interview with Helen
  5. (1990), doi
  6. (1990), 'Chance Wanderings: Reflections
  7. (1990), 'Democracy and Socialism in South America', Latin doi
  8. (1991), doi
  9. (1991), 'The Presence of Liberal Values', East European Reporter,
  10. (1992), doi
  11. (1992), 'Consolidation in Post-Transitional Settings', in
  12. (1993),
  13. (1995), doi
  14. (1996) doi
  15. (1996), doi
  16. (1997), doi
  17. (1997), 'Democratic Opposition and Democratization Theory', Government doi
  18. (1997), 'Happy Ever After in the Marketplace: NGOs and Uncivil doi
  19. (1997), 'Learning to be a Citizen: Cognitive and Ethical Aspects of Postcommunist Society Transformation', doi
  20. (ed.), doi
  21. (ed.), (1994), The Women's Movement in Latin America, doi
  22. (ed.), Civil Society: History, Theory, Comparison, Cambridge,
  23. (ed.), Democracy and Civil Society in Eastern Europe,
  24. (ed.), Democracy and Civil Society in Eastern Europe, London,
  25. (ed.), Issues in doi
  26. (eds.), The Latin American Left, London,
  27. (eds.), The Latin American Left, London, Latin America Bureau. doi
  28. (1979). A Democracia Como Valor Universal', Encontros com a Civilazacao Brasileira, 9,
  29. (1994). A Reconsideration of the Realities of "Civil Society" in the Light of Postcommunist Society'
  30. A.
  31. A. (1992), 'The Games of Transition', in Mainwaring,
  32. A. (1995), 'Interview With Adam Michnik', Constellations, 2(1), pp. 5-11. doi
  33. A. L. doi
  34. (1966). An Essay on the History of Civil Society (1767), edited by Forbes, doi
  35. (1991). An Unlikely Utopia: State and Civil Society doi
  36. and doi
  37. (1986). and Democracy, doi
  38. and the State in Latin America, Amsterdam, CEDLA. Laclau, doi
  39. (1989). Associated-Dependent Development and Democratic Theory',
  40. B.
  41. (1985). Base Communities and Urban Social
  42. (1997). Between Fear and Disappointment: Critical, Empirical and Political Uses of Habermas', doi
  43. (1994). Between Liberalism and Statism: African Political Cultures and Democracy',
  44. (1994). Beyond Left and Right, doi
  45. Bibic
  46. (1991). Brazil: The long March to the New Republic',
  47. (1996). Bringing Civil Society to an Uncivilised Place',
  48. (1985). Bringing the State Back In, doi
  49. C.
  50. C. (1985), The doi
  51. C. (1986), The Political Forms of Modern Society, Cambridge,
  52. Carpathian
  53. Case for
  54. (1985). Catholicism and Politics',
  55. (1998). Caught Between Facts and Norms: The Concept of Civil Society in African Studies", Coventry University African Studies Unit, Occasional Paper Series, Paper No.7.
  56. (1994). Citizenship and Civil Society in Central Europe, doi
  57. (1981). Civil Society Against the State: Poland 1980-81', doi
  58. (1989). Civil Society and Associational Life in Africa', World Politics, doi
  59. (1993). Civil Society and Democracy in the Third World: Ambiguities and Historical Possibilities', doi
  60. (1993). Civil Society and Democratic Transition in East Central Europe', doi
  61. (1994). Civil Society and Disengagement in Africa',
  62. (1992). Civil Society and Political Theory, doi
  63. (1993). Civil Society and Populism in the Eastern European Transitions',
  64. Civil Society and The State in Africa, London, Lynne doi
  65. (1996). Civil Society in Africa, doi
  66. (1986). Civil Society in Africa', doi
  67. (1981). Civil Society in the Emerging Democracies: Poland and Hungary', doi
  68. (1992). Civil Society Theory and the Politics of Transition in South Africa', doi
  69. (1997). Civil Society Theory, Enlightenment and Critique', doi
  70. (1994). Civil Society, Democracy and Economic Change in Africa: A Dissenting Opinion About Resurgent Societies',
  71. (1989). Civil Society, History and Socialism: Reply to John Keane',
  72. (1983). Class and Civil Society,
  73. (1992). Conclusion: Theoretical and Political Horizons of Change in Contemporary Latin American Social Movements',
  74. (1994). Conditions of Liberty: Civil Society and its Rivals, doi
  75. (1992). Culture, Economics, and Politics in Latin American Social Movements',
  76. D.
  77. D. (1996), Models of Democracy (2nd
  78. (1994). Defining and Measuring Democracy, doi
  79. Democracy
  80. (1994). Democracy and Civil Society', in Bibic and Graziano (eds).,
  81. (1989). Democracy and its Critics, doi
  82. (1992). Democracy and the Lessons of Dictatorship', doi
  83. (1986). Democracy in Latin America', doi
  84. (1992). Democratization and the Decline of Urban Social Movements in Uruguay',
  85. (1991). Democratization Processes in East Central Europe: A Theoretical Reconsideration', doi
  86. (1988). Discourse Ethics and Civil Society', doi
  87. (1994). Discussions on Civil Society in Slovenia',
  88. Disintegration doi
  89. E.
  90. E. (1996), Civil Society: Challenging Western Models, doi
  91. (1983). El Socialismo Chileno Rescate y Renovacion, Barcelona, Ediciones del Instituto Para el Nuevo Chile.
  92. (1994). Engaging the State: Associational Life in Sub-Saharan Africa', doi
  93. F.
  94. F. (1993), 'After Regime Change', World Politics, doi
  95. (1994). Feminism, Revolution, and Democratic Transitions in Nicaragua',
  96. (1987). Fire in the America's: Forging a Radical Agenda, doi
  97. (1994). From Dictatorship to Democracy: The Women's Movement in Chile',
  98. (1993). From Post-Communism to Civil Society: The reemergence of History and the Decline of the Western Model', doi
  99. (1992). Further Reflections on the Public Sphere' doi
  100. G.
  101. G. (1992), 'What is the Charter?', East European Reporter,
  102. G. (ed.), Democracy and Civil Society in Eastern Europe, London, Macmillan.230 Mayekiso,
  103. Glorious
  104. (1988). Gramsci and the Concept of Civil Society',
  105. Grassroots Popular
  106. (1992). Habermas and the Public Sphere, doi
  107. Hankiss, E. (1990), East doi
  108. Havel, V. (1988), 'Anti-Political
  109. Heller, A. doi
  110. Hellman, J. A. (1992),
  111. Hite, K. doi
  112. (1996). How Useful is "Civil Society" as a Conceptualisation of
  113. (1983). How Will Majority Rule Come About in Azania/South Africa?', doi
  114. Hungarian
  115. Hungary', doi
  116. (1985). Identity: the Hidden Side of New Social Movements in Latin America',
  117. in doi
  118. (1989). Interclass Alliances in the Opposition to the Military in Brazil: Consequences for the Transition Period',
  119. (1989). Introduction: Politics, Society, and Democratization in Latin America',
  120. (1992). Introduction: Theory and Protest in Latin America Today',
  121. (1995). Introduction', in African Studies in Social Movements and Democracy, Dakar, CODESRIA Mamdani,
  122. (1994). Introductory Remarks', in Bibic and Graziano (eds).,
  123. its doi
  124. J.
  125. J. (1981), 'What Next doi
  126. J. (1995), 'Interview doi
  127. Jorgensen,
  128. (1988). Keane, doi
  129. Keane, J. (1988b), Democracy and Civil Society,
  130. Kolakowski, L. (1971), 'Hope and Hopelessness', Survey 17, pp. 42-48.
  131. Kolakowski, L. (1974),
  132. Konrad, G. (1984), doi
  133. Kowarick,
  134. Kuron, J. (1981), doi
  135. L. doi
  136. (1962). L'Ancien Regime, doi
  137. (1981). La cultura autoritaria en Chile,
  138. (1979). La Viabilidad de Capitalismo Dependiente y la Democracia', America Latina: Estudios y Perspectivas,
  139. (1996). Laying the Groundwork: The Struggle for Civil Society in El Salvador', doi
  140. Linz, Juan, and Stepan, doi
  141. London,
  142. Lunga, G. F. (1986), 'The Church, Labour and
  143. M.
  144. M. (1987), 'Labour Movements doi
  145. M. E. doi
  146. Macdonell, D. (1986), Theories of Discourse, doi
  147. Mamdani, doi
  148. (1997). Market Economy and Democratic Polity', doi
  149. Markus, M. (1985), 'Formation
  150. (1992). Marxism, Feminism, and the Struggle for Democracy in Latin America', doi
  151. (1993). Mexico: The Perils of Unity and the Challenge of Modernization',
  152. Michnik,
  153. Millard, F. doi
  154. Milosz, C. (1985), Forward, in Michnik, Letters from Prison.
  155. Mislivetz, F.
  156. Morawski,
  157. Movements,
  158. (1997). Myths of Moderation: Confrontation and Conflict During Democratic Transitions', doi
  159. N.
  160. (1994). Neopatrimonial Regimes and Political Transitions in Africa', doi
  161. (1984). New Theories of State and Civil Society: Recent Developments in Post-Marxist
  162. NG0s,
  163. (1993). Non-Governmental Organisations as Agents of Democratization: An African Perspective', doi
  164. Nzimande, B. and Sikhosana,
  165. O'Donnell,
  166. O'Donnell, G. (1973), Modernization and Bureaucratic Authoritarianism, Berkeley, UCLA.
  167. of doi
  168. On doi
  169. (1977). On Revolution,
  170. (1981). On the Maturation of Socialism', doi
  171. (1985). On the Question of Chartism', doi
  172. Orden doi
  173. OUP.
  174. Oxhorn, P.
  175. Oxhorn, P. (1994), 'Where Did All the Protesters doi
  176. P.
  177. Pakenham, R.
  178. (1988). Parallel Polis, or an Independent Society in Central and Eastern Europe: An Inquiry',
  179. Pateman, C. (1988), The Sexual Contract, Cambridge, Polity. doi
  180. Pateman, C. (1988b), 'The
  181. (1992). Patterns of Transition from a One-Party State to Democracy in Poland and Hungary',
  182. Polanyi, K. (1944),
  183. (1980). Political doi
  184. Pomian, K. (1981), 'Miracle doi
  185. Popular
  186. (1990). Popular Incorporation and Prospects for Democracy', doi
  187. (1993). Popular Liberalism, Radical democracy, and Marxism: Leftist Politics in Contemporary Colombia, 1974-1991',
  188. (1989). Popular Mobilization and the Military Regime in Chile: The Complexities of the Invisible Transition',
  189. (1992). Popular Movements and the Consolidation of Democracy in Brazil',
  190. Post-Communism's
  191. (1992). Power in Africa: An Essay in Political Interpretation, doi
  192. (1992). Predatory Rule: State and Civil Society in Africa, doi
  193. R. doi
  194. R. (1988), 'The New Right in Central doi
  195. (1990). Reflections on the Revolution in doi
  196. (1994). Rethinking Civil Society: Towards Democratic Consolidation',
  197. (1992). Rethinking the Public Sphere', doi
  198. (1990). Revolution, Civil Society and Democracy', Praxis International, 10 Arato, A_
  199. (1990). Roads to Freedom: Democratization and its Problems in East Central Europe',
  200. Robinson, M. (1995), 'Strengthening doi
  201. Rothchild, D. and Lawson,
  202. Rupnik,
  203. Sachikonye, L. (1995), 'Democracy, Civil Society and doi
  204. Schwarzmantel, J. (1994), The State in Contemporary Society, New York, doi
  205. Science or the Art of Democratisation', in Tulchin, J. S. (ed.), The Consolidation of Democracy in Latin America, London, Lynne Rienner. doi
  206. (1971). Selections from the Prison Notebooks, doi
  207. Seligman, A. (1992), The Idea of Civil Society, Princeton, Princeton University Press. doi
  208. Smith,
  209. Social doi
  210. (1992). Social Movements and Political Power in Latin America', doi
  211. (1985). Social Movements and Revolution: the case of Nicaragua',
  212. (1984). Social Movements, Civil Society, and the Problem of Sovereignty',
  213. (1992). Social Movements: Actors, Theories, Expectations',
  214. (1997). Social Power and the Inflation of Discourse: The Failure of Popular Hegemony in Nicaragua', doi
  215. Society
  216. Society, doi
  217. (1985). Spiritual Values, Independent Initiatives and Politics',
  218. Splichal, S. (1994), 'Civil Society
  219. State, doi
  220. (1995). State, Capitalism and Democracy doi
  221. Stepan,
  222. Strength', in Smith,
  223. Swidlicki, A. (1981), 'The doi
  224. Taylor, doi
  225. Tester,
  226. the doi
  227. (1994). The (Trans)formation of Feminism(s) and Gender Politics in Democratizing Brazil',
  228. (1993). The Actors and Mechanisms of Systemic Changes in the Economy',
  229. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge, translated by Sheriden Smith,
  230. (1993). The Changing Status of the Latin American Left in the Recent Past',
  231. (1995). The Civic Limitations of Civil Society', doi
  232. (1997). The Condition of Citizenship, doi
  233. (1989). The Consolidation of Fragile Democracies', in Pastor, R. A.
  234. (1992). The Constitution of Civil Society in African History and Politics',
  235. (1993). The Crisis of Bolivian Radicalism'
  236. (1992). The Decline of Civil Society Theory in Postcommunist Eastern Europe: A Response to John Keane', Times Literary Supplement,
  237. (1986). The Failure of Dictatorships in the Southern Cone', doi
  238. (1995). The Importance of Being Modular',
  239. (1986). The Left and Democracy: Recent Debates in Latin America', doi
  240. (1991). The Legitimation of Power, doi
  241. (1993). The Liberation of Civil Society: Neo-Liberal Ideology and Political Theory', doi
  242. (1982). The New Politics of Participation in Tropical Africa', doi
  243. (1958). The Origins of Totalitarianism, doi
  244. (1986). The Political Transition in Brazil: A Reappraisal of the Dynamics of the Political Opening', doi
  245. (1992). The Politics of Civil Society', doi
  246. (1981). The Reconstruction of Society', in Telos, 47. doi
  247. (1989). The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, doi
  248. (1994). Three Normative Models of Democracy', doi
  249. Tidskrift, vol. 94(1), pp.1-11.
  250. (1995). to doi
  251. (1954). Totalitarianism,
  252. Touraine, A.
  253. Tulchin, doi
  254. University
  255. (1994). Urban Social Movements in Brazil: A Debate and its Dynamics', doi
  256. (1994). Utopia Unarmed, doi
  257. V. doi
  258. Vergara,
  259. Villas, C. M. (1993), 'Between Scepticism
  260. Vohryzek, J. (1985), 'Thoughts Inside a Tightly-Corked
  261. Von
  262. Weffort, F. (1989),
  263. Weyland, K. (1995), 'Latin America's Four doi
  264. Wine or Old Bottlenecks?', Comparative Politics, 23, pp. 479-492. doi
  265. Wood, E. M. (1990), 'The doi
  266. Zverina, J. (1985), 'On Not Living in Hatred', in Havel, V. et al., The Power of the Powerless: Citizens Against the State in Central-Eastern Europe, London, Hutchinson.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.