Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Exploring the pattern of Islamic social movements : four case studies

By Seyed Saaid Zahed Zahedani

Abstract

This thesis is a study of Iranian-Islamic social movements. Iran has witnessed four major social movements in the late nineteenth and twentieth century. Except for the\ud Islamic Revolution of 1978-79 which attracted a great deal of sociological attention, and the Constitutional Revolution which has received some specialist study, the other two, regardless of their importance and influence in the Iranian history, have been grossly neglected. In order to have a better sociological understanding and a more\ud general model of this type of social movements there is need to review all of them according to the same theory and with an identical method. These cases which are\ud explored in this study are: the Tobacco Movement (1892) - an 'anti colonialism' movement, the Constitutional Revolution (1905-1906) - a 'justice' movement, the 15th\ud of Khordad movement (1963) - an 'anti modernisation' movement, and the last in chain, the Islamic Revolution of 1978-79 - an 'anti imperialism' movement.\ud \ud This thesis also attempts to provide a contribution to the theory of social movements with a review and synthesis of the existing major theories of the area. Ten key social\ud movement theories are reviewed and a new synthetic one is developed. The models under review belong to Smelser (1962), Davies (1962), Toch (1966), Blumer (1969),\ud Wilson (1973), Tilly (1978), Touraine (1981), McCarthy and Zald (1987), Melucci (1989) and Scott (1990). These theories identify quite different 'engines' of the social\ud movement and thus can be classified according to whether they regard the individual, society, or their relations as the main cause or initiator of the social movements.\ud Following the discussions of the relationship between the individual and society, this thesis recognises the need for an approach to social explanation which looks at the fine\ud texture of the interrelationship of the structure, agency, and their relations, and so proposes a 'synthetic' theory of social movements which recognises the importance of\ud the conjunction of the three elements of the individualist, the structural and the relationalist models. In this theory of social movements, social context provides the ground for the underlying mechanism of the movement to be released. Ideology plays the part of the relational factor between the individual and the society. It is the main mobilisational factor of social movements. Actors then 'perform' the movements at three levels of social actions: leadership, distribution, and enactment of the outburst.\ud \ud The synthetic theory provides a framework for a more comprehensive study of the four cases. Each of the movements is explained using it as a 'conceptual grid' and it is shown on each occasion to be useful tool in identifying the main agents, antagonisms, ideologies, social opportunities and constraints, and the accomplishment of the movements. So whilst the movements vary by 'focus' and by 'success' it is shown that it is Islamic ideology which shapes the goals of 'justice', 'freedom', 'independence' and 'democracy'. In all of the reviewed movements the authority of the shah came into dispute with the command of the ulama, and it was religious rituals and organisations which mobilised the people.\ud \ud Whilst the synthetic theory proposed here can provide an analytic framework with which to compare the movements, the history of the analysed movements reveals the significance of the 'political sociology' of Iran's last hundred years. This dimention provides an understanding of some of the 'initial conditins' which underpin the Iranian\ud social movements. The thesis attempts to outline some crucial elements in this sociopolitical history, and attest their importance by examination of one further Iranian\ud social movement, the National Movement of Iran (195 1-1953). This was a predominantly non-Islamic movement which failed because it declined to take the advantage of the authority of the ulama as one of the major sways at the socio-political setting of Iranian society.\ud \ud The adequacy of the resultant knowledge from the proposed model of Iranian-Islamic social movements is further tested against the some writings of nine scholars on Iranian\ud social movements: Fischer (1980), Milani (1988), Parsa (1989), Amuzegar (1991), Ray (1993), Zubaida (1993), Moaddel (1993), Foran (1994) and Keddie (1995)

Publisher: School of Sociology and Social Policy (Leeds)
Year: 1997
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:540

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. Books and articles doi
  2. (1982). IRAN Between Two Revolutions (New Jersey, doi
  3. (1985). Iran. A Revolution in Turmoil
  4. (1980). Religion and Politics doi
  5. (1983). Shariati's Social Thought, Nikkie
  6. (1969). imp.: Religion and State
  7. (1985). Islam and Revolution: Writings and Declarations of Imam Khomeini (London, doi
  8. (1991). Religious Forces In Twentieth Century Iran, The Cambridge History doi
  9. (1982). A la recherche de la conscience collective: Durkheim's Ideological Impact in Turky and Iran,
  10. (1991). The Dynamics of the Iranian Revolution. The Pahlavis' Triumph and Tragedy doi
  11. (1995). Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). 11 . doi
  12. (1994). The uses of history in sociology: a reply. doi
  13. (1992). History and Social Theory, doi
  14. (1962). The Psychology of Social Movements (N. doi
  15. (1983). The City and The Grassroots: A Cross-Cultural Theory Of Urban Social Movements (London, doi
  16. (1990). Iranian Politics and Religious Modernism, The Liberation Mmovement
  17. (1992). Modern Social Theory, From Parsons to Habermas (London Harvester, doi
  18. (1962). Toward A Theory Of Revolution, doi
  19. (1971). When Men Revolt-and Why (N. Y., Free Press).336
  20. (1992). The Concept of Social Movement, doi
  21. (1980). From Religious Dispute to Revolution (Massachusetts, doi
  22. (1994). A Century of Revolution, Social Movements in Iran (London, doi
  23. (1968). Power and Discontent doi
  24. (1975). The Strategy of Social Protest doi
  25. (1984). The Constitution of Society (Cambridge, doi
  26. (1991). The uses of history in sociology: reflections on some recent tendencies, doi
  27. (1995). Current Issues In Comparative Methodology (Printout of a lecture held in
  28. (1970). Why Men Rebel (Princeton, doi
  29. (1979). IRAN: Dictatorship and Development (Middlesex, doi
  30. (1991). The Pahlavi Autocracy: Muhamad Reza Shah, The Cambridge doi
  31. (1992). What's Wrong With Ethnography?, doi
  32. (1994). John Goldthorpe and relics of sociology, doi
  33. (1994). The Nationalist Movements in Azarbaijan and Kurdistan, 1941-46,
  34. (1991). The Pahiavi Autocracy: Muhamad Reza Shah, The Cambridge doi
  35. (1973). The Use of Official Statistics in Sociology: A Critique of Positivism and Ethnomethodology
  36. (1985). Alain Touraine, Manuel Castells and Social Movement Theory: a critical sppraisal, doi
  37. (1991). Islamic Propagation Organization,
  38. (1966). Revolutionary Change doi
  39. (1984). Social Science Concepts, A Systemic Analysis (Sage Pub.,
  40. (1981). The Political Economy of Modern Iran, doi
  41. (1966). Religion and Rebellion in Iran: The Tobacco Protest of 1891-1892, doi
  42. (1968). An Islamic Response to Imperialism: Political and Religious Writings of Sayyid Jamal ad-Din "a! Afghani", (Berkeley and Los Angeles: doi
  43. (1983). Religion and Politics In iran: Shiism from Quietism to Revolution (Mass., doi
  44. (1995). Iran and the Muslim World, Resistance and Revolution doi
  45. (1985). 2nd ed.: The Practical Laws of Islam (Tehran: Islamic Propagation Organisation).
  46. (1969). Collective Search for Identity doi
  47. (1964). A Reconsideration of the position of the Marja'al-taqlid and the Religious Institution',
  48. (1970). The Persian Land Reform (London: doi
  49. (1972). The Concept of Ideology (Hampshire, doi
  50. (1990). The Realist Image In Social Science, doi
  51. (1993). New Strategies In doi
  52. Robert
  53. Lin,
  54. Cambridge doi
  55. of doi
  56. Karl,
  57. McCarthy, John D. & Zald, Mayer N., 1973: doi
  58. 1977: doi
  59. Ten Hypotheses for the doi
  60. 1985:
  61. S.
  62. Milani, Mohsen M., 1988: doi
  63. A doi
  64. Populism, Class, and Gender in Postrevolutionary Iran, John Foran
  65. and doi
  66. Morteza,
  67. Kohn,
  68. Oberschall,
  69. C., 1985: Disorganized Capitalism (Cambrige, Polity Press). doi
  70. Movements, doi
  71. Social doi
  72. Measures: doi
  73. Pinault, David, 1992: The Shiites, doi
  74. Przeworski, doi
  75. Charles,
  76. L. doi
  77. Ragin, Charles C. & Howard S. Becker (e.d.), doi
  78. Rahnema, Au & Farhad Nomani, 1990: doi
  79. Robertson,
  80. (1991). Research on Social Movements (Colorado, Westview Press).
  81. Giovanni,
  82. 1990:
  83. Skocpoi, Theda, 1979: Srates and Social Revolution (Cambridge, Cambridge
  84. 1984: doi
  85. Smelser, Nil
  86. Neil
  87. Smith Anthony D., 1973: doi
  88. Swanson, Guy, 1971: Frameworks for comparative
  89. 1978: From doi
  90. 1986: Contentious French (Cambridge, Belknap Press). doi
  91. Toch,
  92. Touraine, Alain, 1981: doi
  93. Capitalism
  94. Weber, Max, 1930: The Protestant Ethic and The Spirit doi
  95. Wilson, John, 1973: doi
  96. Society (New Brunswich, New Jersey, Transaction Books).
  97. Michael P.: The Rise of Reza Khan, John Foran
  98. Adamiyyat,
  99. Alizadeh, Mohammad, Kazem Kazerooni, 1363
  100. 1354
  101. AHS
  102. (1983):
  103. Rowhaniyoon-e Iran, Vol. 2 (Tehran).
  104. Pahiavi,
  105. Golpayegani, Mohammad Reza, n.d.: doi
  106. Isfahani: Tarikh-e Dokhaniye, Mosa Najafi & Rasool Jaafarian,
  107. Kasravi, Ahmad, 1357
  108. Kermani, Nazem-ol-Islam, 1371
  109. Khosrowshahi, Seyed Hadi: Moqaddame, Moheet Tabatabaii, Mohammad, 1350 ABS (1971?): Naghsh-e
  110. Madani, Seyed Jalal-ed Din, 1361
  111. Az Asr-e Tanbacco:
  112. Malekzadeh, Mehdi,
  113. Moheet Tabatabaii, Seyed Mohammad, 1350 ABS (1972): Naqsh-e Seyed
  114. Motahhari,
  115. Abbas
  116. Nahavandian, Mohammad, nd.: Paykar-e Pirooz-e Tanbacco (Tehran, Partow).343
  117. Najafi, Mosa:
  118. Andishehay-e Mirzay-e Shirazi:
  119. (1977):
  120. Imam
  121. (1334). Taleqani,
  122. Teymoori, Ibrahim, 1363 AHS (1984), 4th imp.:
  123. Zahed Zahedani, Seyed Saaid, 1365
  124. (1995). Zargarnezhad,
  125. (1996). Askarowladi,
  126. Lah,
  127. (1101). AHS,
  128. 1341 AHS, No. 11042.
  129. Ettelaat, June 4 1962, No. 11106.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.