Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Junior doctors : morale, job satisfaction, stress and their interrelationships

By Caron Grainger

Abstract

Research and anecdote suggest that . the morale of doctors is low. Consequences of this in medicine include poor communication, faulty decision making, and poor interpersonal relationships.\ud \ud This works assesses the morale of pre-registration house officers (PRHOs), using the proxy measures of job satisfaction and mental and physical ill-health\ud manifestations of stress, and follows one group over a period of eighteen months to determine whether morale improves over this time.\ud \ud Data collections was by modified postal questionnaire and consisted of self reported job satisfaction and mental and physical ill-health, life style data and career information. Data was obtained in three separate studies,\ud comprising\ud \ud : 234 eligible PRHOs working within the West Midlands in 1993 (response rate of 83.6%)\ud \ud : A follow up study of the respondents to the original west Midlands survey (response rate 80.4%)\ud \ud : 828 eligible PRHOs working in the West Midlands, Bristol, Nottingham, Oxford and Sheffield (response rate of 58.9%)\ud \ud PRHOs and SHOs had significantly lower scores for job satisfaction and significantly higher scores for mental and physical ill-health than comparative groups. Female PRHOs and SHOs had significantly higher scores for ill-health\ud than male PRHOs. Some improvement in job satisfaction was seen in the 18 month period from PRHO to SHO, but there was no significant change in well being during this time.\ud \ud As a result of this work, a stress counselling and management service has been made available in the West Midlands, an "Introduction to being a House Officer" course begun in the final year at Birmingham Medical School, and a\ud "Stress Survival Guide" book published

Publisher: School of Medicine (Leeds)
Year: 1997
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:656

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1992). 1291-95 ISO Royal College of Physicians. Medical aspects of exercise: benefits and risks. London, Royal College of Physicians of London
  2. 1545-1548 s General Medical Services Committee. Your choices for the future. London BMA
  3. (1987). 1651-3 its Cartwright L. Occupational Stress in women physicians.
  4. (1979). A cybernetic framework for the study of occupational stress. Human relations doi
  5. (1988). A meta analysis of selected techniques for inducing response. Public Opinion Quarterly doi
  6. A predictive study of CND.
  7. (1990). A profile of doctors who recently deregistered Final report to the
  8. ABC of sports medicine: benefits of exercise in health and disease. doi
  9. (1991). Alcohol use and abuse in random samples of physicians and medical students. doi
  10. Alcoholism in house staff physicians : an occupational hazard. doi
  11. All change? doi
  12. (1994). and depression in hospital consultants, general practitioners and senior health service managers. BMJ doi
  13. (1988). Any room at the top? London Policy Studies Institute,
  14. (1975). Applied psychology: adjustments in living and work. 2nd edition.
  15. (1997). BMA stresses role of counsel service.
  16. Career destinations in 1994 of United Kingdom medical graduates of 1983: results of a questionnaire survey. doi
  17. (1993). Career preferences of doctors who qualified in the United Kingdom in doi
  18. Cited in Stress and the medical profession. BMA Scientific Division. London
  19. (1995). cohort of medical graduates. Part I- background and initial career aspirations. BMA Health Policy and Economic Research Unit. London
  20. (1995). cohort study of 1995 medical graduates. First report, part 2-professional values.
  21. (1996). Committee of Postgraduate Medical Deans. Conference on the education and training ofpre-registration house officers.
  22. (1991). Committee. Junior Doctors - the New Deal. London BMA doi
  23. (1991). Coping with stress in the health professionals. A practical guide. Chapman and Hall London
  24. (1987). coronary disease and coronary death Ann Clin Res
  25. (1993). Council - Tomorrow's Doctors, Recommendations on Undergraduate Medical Education,
  26. Counselling needs and experience of junior hospital doctors. doi
  27. (1991). Critical thinking : the future of undergraduate medical education.
  28. (1990). Demoralised doctors. BMJ 1990; 300: 56-7 - 23 Dudley HAF. Stress in junior doctors I -stress and support. BMJ doi
  29. (1985). Depressive symptoms in medical house officers - effects of training and work rotation. Arch Intern Med doi
  30. (1987). Determinants of mood in general practitioners. doi
  31. (1992). Division. Stress and the medical profession. BMA London
  32. Doctors and their careers -a new generation. doi
  33. (1988). Doctors and their careers. London Policy Studies Institute
  34. (1991). Doctors careers. Aims and experiences of medical graduates. doi
  35. (1988). Doctors drinking habits and consumption of alcohol. BMJ doi
  36. (1996). Doctors health and needs for services. Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.
  37. (1991). Doctors in the making. - the experience of the pre-registration year. University of Bristol: School for Advances Urban Studies.
  38. (1996). Doctors under stress.
  39. (1989). Drinking amongst medical students: a questionnaire survey. BMJ doi
  40. (1987). Emotional distress in house officers. doi
  41. (1989). Emotional distress in junior doctors. BMJ 1990; 295: 926 's Spurgeon A, Harrington JM. Work performance and health of junior hospital doctors -a review of the literature. Work and stress doi
  42. (1978). Executive Stress.
  43. (1993). Facing the future. doi
  44. (1987). Factors affecting response rates to mailed questionnaires: a comprehensive literature review. doi
  45. (1992). Feeling overloaded. Student BMJ
  46. (1996). for the provision of careers services for doctors.
  47. (1979). foundation and practices.
  48. (1966). Generalised expectations for internal versus external control of reinforcement.
  49. (1996). Guidelines for the provision of career services for doctors London
  50. (1978). Happy Health Staff? Health Services Journal
  51. (1988). Health Education Authority. Action on stress at work. HEA London
  52. Health in the medical and other learned professions. doi
  53. (1991). Health status, job satisfaction, job stress and life satisfaction among academic and clinical faculty. JAMA 1985; 254: 2775-82 as doi
  54. (1992). Health. The Health of the Nation: a strategy for England and Wales. London
  55. (1995). Hospital doctors work. BMJ doi
  56. (1987). Hospital Medical Staffing: Achieving a Balance: plan for action. London DHSS doi
  57. (1990). Hours, volume and type of work of pre-registration house officers. BMJ doi
  58. (1992). Household Survey
  59. Improving response rates to mailed questionnaires. doi
  60. (1989). Inequalities in health within the health sector. BMJ doi
  61. Introduction to behavioural science for business.
  62. (1981). Job decision latitude, job demands and coronary heart disease: a prospective study of Swedish men. doi
  63. (1991). Leading for health: a BMA agenda for health. London doi
  64. (1986). Levels and sources of stress in medical students. BMJ doi
  65. (1988). Living with stress. London Penguin doi
  66. (1979). Mail questionnaires in survey research: a review of response inducement techniques. doi
  67. (1981). Married to medicine: an intimate portrait of doctors wives. doi
  68. (1993). Medical education. BMJ, doi
  69. (1980). Medicine: half our future doctors? In Careers of professional women. Croom Helm
  70. (1996). Mental health of hospital consultants: the effects of stress and satisfaction at work. Lancet doi
  71. (1989). Mental health, job satisfaction and job stress among general practitioners. BMJ doi
  72. (1985). Mentally ill doctors.
  73. (1984). Mortality study of British pathologists 1974-80. doi
  74. (1975). Mortality study of pathologists and medical laboratory technicians. BMJ doi
  75. (1996). New Deal has reduced hours but increased workload.
  76. (1996). Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust. Taking care of doctors health. doi
  77. (1990). Occupational stress in health service employees. Health Service Man Res
  78. (1992). Occupational stress in health service workers in the UK. Stress Medicine doi
  79. (1987). Occupational stress in women physicians. In Payne RL Firth-Cozens I (Eds), Stress in health professionals.
  80. (1989). Occupational Stress Indicator Data Supplement. NFER-Nelson
  81. (1988). Occupational Stress Indicator Management Guide. NFER-Nelson
  82. (1988). Olkinuora eta! Doctors drinking habits and consumption of alcohol. BW doi
  83. (1976). Patterns of adjustment.
  84. (1979). Pg 268,2nd edition. Survey methods in Social Investigation. Heinman Educational Books London
  85. (1984). Physicians at risk. Occupational Medicine
  86. (1992). Planning the medical workforce. Afedical Manpower Standing Advisory Committee: first report. London DoH
  87. (1990). Possible factors affecting response to postal questionnaires from a study of general practitioner services. JPub Hlth Med
  88. (1994). Postgraduate Dean, University of Birmingham "
  89. Pre registration house officers in the four Thames regions: I Survey of education and workload. doi
  90. Predisposition to emotional distress and psychiatric illness amongst doctors: The role of the unconscious and experiential factors. doi
  91. (1987). Prevalence of depression and distress in a large sample of Canadian Residents, Interns and Fellows.
  92. Psychiatric disorder in the medical profession.
  93. Psychological determinants of a medical career.
  94. (1992). Psychological factors in coronary artery disease: epidemiologic evidence. Circulation 1987; 76: 1117-23. Cited in Stress and the medical profession. BMA Scientific Division. London
  95. (1995). Psychological stress in nursing and medical staff on bone marrow transplant units.
  96. (1979). Psychology applied to life and work. doi
  97. Reasons for doctors' career choice and change of choice. doi
  98. Review Debt problems make students sick. London BMA
  99. (1991). Review. Juniors living conditions. London BMA
  100. (1987). Royal College of Physicians. A great and growing evil.
  101. (1979). satisfaction, absenteeism and turnover. doi
  102. (1991). Seeing for themselves. BMJ doi
  103. (1997). Senior House Officer Training: is it getting better? A questionnaire survey. BMJ doi
  104. (1997). Senior house Officers work related stressors, psychological distress and confidence in performing clinical tasks in accident and emergency: a questionnaire study. BMJ doi
  105. Sex differences in work stress. doi
  106. (1990). Sources of stress in women junior house officers. BMJ doi
  107. (1990). Stress and stress counselling. doi
  108. (1994). Stress case paves the way for damages claims. BMJ doi
  109. Stress in doctors: not so simple solutions. doi
  110. (1987). Stress In health professionals. doi
  111. (1990). Stress in junior doctors. doi
  112. Stress in medical undergraduates and House Officers. doi
  113. (1987). Stress in physicians. In Stress in health professionals.
  114. (1991). Stress in women doctors. BMJ 1990; 301: 76 Is BMA. Report of the survey into morale of hospital consultants. BMA Economic Research Unit. London
  115. (1992). Stress in women doctors. Br J Hosp Med 1994; 51(6); 267-8 B0 Hale R, Hudson L. The Tavistock study of young doctors: report of the pilot phase.
  116. stress, satisfaction and mental health among general practitioners before and after the introduction of the new contract. doi
  117. (1993). Substance abuse and addiction among medical students, Residents, and physicians. Psychiatr Clin North Am
  118. (1967). Suicide by psychiatrists: a study of medical specialists among 18730 consecutive physician deaths during a five year period,
  119. (1992). The costs of stress and the costs and benefits of stress management. National Association for Staff Support
  120. (1995). The doctors tale; the work of hospital doctors in England and Wales. London HMSO
  121. (1987). The effects of fatigue on the health and performance of junior hospital doctors. University of Birmingham Institute of Occupational Health, undated Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. Proportion of gross domestic product spent on health.
  122. (1946). The general adaptation syndrome and the diseases of adaptation. doi
  123. (1981). The health and health care of doctors.
  124. (1959). The motivation to work. 2nd ed.
  125. (1991). The people - oriented professionals :a cognitive perspective. Paper given at the Society of Public Health Conference "Stress and the Health Services" London: Royal Society of Medicine.
  126. The pre-registration house year: a critical incident study. doi
  127. (1996). The provision of medical services to sick doctors. A conspiracy of friendliness. Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.
  128. The stress of residency. a review of the literature. doi
  129. (1994). Trends in alcoholism among male doctors in Scotland. Addiction doi
  130. Undergraduate medical education: present state and future needs. doi
  131. (1994). Unified training grade. Report of the working party on the unified training grade. London

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.