Location of Repository

The internet and the politics and processes of trade unionism

By John Michael Christopher Hogan


This thesis explores the implications of the internet for the politics and processes of trade unionism. Michels' classic formulation on the "iron law of oligarchy" and its grounding in a communications based theory of leadership domination is presented as a heuristic devise for uncovering the significance of Information Communication Technologies for trade unionism. The present relationship of\ud trade unionism and the internet in the United Kingdom is characterized and the potentialities for union democratization are presented. A set of concrete case\ud studies of rank and file union internet activism are investigated. This thesis seeks to extend analysis beyond formal decision making processes and to situate communicative pathways, structures and protocols, so that the task of grasping the full significance of Information Communication Technologies for trade unionism can begin. Arising from the presentation of case study materials, new\ud institutional patterning, politics and processes are revealed and uncovered. Established is a communicative network model of union communication, one that challenges traditional bureaucratic top down information models of union communication. With the supplementary powers revealed by the availability of distributed communication technologies leadership practices are challenged\ud within the new context of a distributed discourse. The thesis looks forward to a collective solidarity which may be beyond the structure and shape of the present institutional form of trade unions and draws out the perils, opportunities and dilemmas that the future may bring

Publisher: Leeds University Business School
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:664

Suggested articles



  1. (2000b) `Third tribunal payout gags MSF allegations: Union official drops victimisation case for £200,000 retirement deal. ' The Guardian,
  2. (2000c) 'Lavish spending union told to make £3m savings', The Guardian,
  3. (2000d) `No 10 tries to bar Lyons', The Guardian,
  4. (2000e) `MSF chief in No 10 talks',
  5. (2001). 16 Propositions on Internationalist Labour Networking (and Others)', (Hosted at http: //www.
  6. A History of Trade Unionism doi
  7. (2003). A., `Surveillance, electronic communications technologies and regulation', doi
  8. (2004). Achieving a new equilibrium? The stability of cooperative employer-union relationships, industrial Relations Journal, doi
  9. (2001). Calling up culture: information spaces and information flows as the virtual dynamics of inclusion and exclusion' doi
  10. (2002). Challenges and Opportunities: Unions confront the New Information Technologies', doi
  11. (1995). Challenging Transition Theory: The Labour Movement, Radical Reform, and Transition to Democracy in South Africa', doi
  12. (2003). COMMENTARY: ECollectivism and Distributed Discourse: New Opportunities for Trade Union Democracy', doi
  13. (2002). Computer Power and Union Prospects: CyberUnions or Faux Unions? ', Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Fall doi
  14. (2004). Computers in Union Education: A Feasibility Study for Ditsela' (available at http: //link.
  15. (1989). Cultures of Solidarity: Consciousness, Action, doi
  16. (1999). CyberUnion: Empowering Labor Through Computer Terchnology', doi
  17. (2002). Danger Lurks for the Passive', Workers Online: Official Organ of LaborNet, November Issue.
  18. (2002). Distributed globalization: identity, virtuality and adjacency, in
  19. (1994). Don't mourn, Organise', New Statesman and Society, September 2,1994 New Statesman and Society
  20. (2001). E-collectivism and Distributed Discourse: New Opportunities for Trade Union Democracy' doi
  21. (2000). E-Collectivism: Emergent Opportunities for Renewal',
  22. (2002). E-collectivism: On-line action and online mobilisation', in
  23. (2002). E-Learning and Union Mobilization', doi
  24. (1997). E-mail as a weapon in an industrial dispute', doi
  25. (2001). From a dinosaur to a dotcom? ' Computer Weekly,
  26. (1972). From the Webbs to the Web: The contribution of the Internet to Reviving Union Fortunes, ' in Sue Fernie and David Metcalf (eds) Trade Unions: Resurgence or Demise? Leverhulme Series Volume 3 on The Future of Trade Unions
  27. (2000). Geographical scale and grass roots internationalism: the Liverpool Dock Dispute, doi
  28. (2002). Geographies of Power: Placing Scale. doi
  29. (2003). Geography and industrial relations'
  30. (2000). Globalisation and Identity in the Network Society: A Rejoinder to Calhoun, Lyon and Touraine',
  31. (2002). History in the making III: the electricity workers strike' (http: //www. kctu. orq/action%20alert/strike2002-06-publicutilities. htm captured on 05.10.04) Kelber, H, `LaborTalk: Who Killed LaborNET? ' (captured on 28.04.03
  32. (1996). How the Web industry is working its way out of a Golden Age',
  33. (1999). Imagined Solidarities: Can Trade Unions Resist Globalisation? ',
  34. (1920). Industrial Democracy (Longman,
  35. (2007). Industrial Relations"
  36. (2005). Information and communications technology use in British unions', doi
  37. (2002). Information technology, US union organizing and union effectiveness', doi
  38. (1998). International Transport Workers' Federation, Solidarity: The First Hundred Years of the ITF. ' The Journal of Transport History,
  39. (1999). Internet or Intranet? Putting your union on the Web'. www. ilr. cornell. edu/library/reference/quides/lui/inter intra. htm now http: //www.
  40. (2000). Is MSF a corrupt Organisation? ' Available at http: //www. londondefencecampaign. freeserve. co. uk/msfcorrupt. htm
  41. (2003). Is the Future of unionism in cyberspace? ' doi
  42. (2000). Island histories, open cultures?: the electronic transformation of adjacency',
  43. (2005). Labour and the Internet in the Balkans:
  44. (1997). LabourNet: Networking for Unionists', Talk held at the Congress, 'Questions of Power in the information society',
  45. (2000). Materials for an exploratory theory of the network society', doi
  46. (2000). Networks and Neighbourhoods: Household, Community and Sovereignty in the Global Economy', doi
  47. (2001). On-line learning: opportunities to overcome temporal and spatial barriers for women trade unionists', paper presented at the conference on Spacing and Timing,
  48. (2003). Place, Space and the Reinvention of Social Emancipation on a Global Scale' (hosted at http: //www.
  49. (1997). Private Profit, Public Loss: The Financial and Economic Performance of UK Ports', doi
  50. (2001). Re-inventing the South African labour Movement: Making the desirable possible', Hosted at LabourNet Germany Waterman, P(2001 b) `Trade Union Internationalism in the Age of Seattle',
  51. (2005). Recovering Experience, Confirming Identity, Voicing Resistance: the Braceros, the Internet and Counter-coordination', doi
  52. (1998). Rethinking industrial relations doi
  53. (1999). Science, Technology and Society in East Asia: Frameworks for the challenges of the next century' doi
  54. (1996). Sending a strike message in a bottle',
  55. (1993). Social Movement Unionism: A New Union Model for a New World Order? ', Review e Fernand Braudel Center
  56. (2006). Space, Communication and the Daily Exercise of Solidarity: An Exploration of
  57. (1971). Strike at Pilkingtons (Bungay, William Collins Sons and Co).
  58. (2001). The Brazilian Labour Movement on the Internet', Paper prepared for presentation at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association,
  59. (1979). The Changing System of Industrial Relations in Great Britain (Basil
  60. (1996). The continental classroom: teaching labour studies online', Labor Studies Journal (captured on 5.11.03 @ http: //www. athabascau. ca/html/staff/academic/4efft/laboured/conroom/conroo m. htm) Taylor,
  61. (2003). The creation of the E-Union: The use of ICT by British unions', available at http: //www. rogerdarlington. co. uk/E-union. html (captured on 12.02.03) Davies_S.
  62. (2002). The CyberUnion Handbook: Transforming Labor Through doi
  63. The CyberUnion Handbook: Transforming Labor Through Computer Technology' (hosted at httiD: //www. doi
  64. (1976). The Dockers: Class and Tradition in London doi
  65. (1994). The dynamics of workplace unionism: shop stewards organization in three Merseyside plants
  66. (1981). The Forward March of Labour Halted? ",
  67. (2002). The Labour Market in the New Information Economy', Oxford Review of Economic Policy, doi
  68. (1997). The Labour movement and the Internet: the new internationalism
  69. (2000). The Labour movement and the internet', Asia labour Update, Issue 34,
  70. (1989). The Political Economy of Industrial Relations: Theory and Practice in a Cold Climate (Macmillan,
  71. (1978). The Social Organization of Strikes (Basil Blackwell). doi
  72. (1974). The Union makes us strong doi
  73. (2002). Today's Unions As Tomorrow's Cyber Unions: Labor's Newest Hope', doi
  74. (1997). Towards a global labournet', speech for LaborMedia conference,
  75. (1962). Trade Union Growth, Structure and Policy doi
  76. (2006). Trade Unions and ICTs: A Review of Theory and Practice' Paper presented at the Institute of Advanced Studies, University of Lancaster, workshop on Trade Unions in the "Information Age". (see http: //www.
  77. (2003). Trade unions and the ambiguities of social Europe' @ http: //www. fu-berlin. de/iira2003/papers/track_5/Plenary_Track_5_Hyman. pdf (captured 24/10/2003) ICEM
  78. (2006). Trade Unions and the Internet: Present and Future Prospects', Paper presented to the Industrial Relations in Europe Conference on The Future of Social Models,
  79. (2000). Trade unions at the crossroads (Mansell: London and
  80. (2000). Trade unions on line: technology, transparency and bargaining power',
  81. (1999). Trade unions on line: technology.
  82. (1977). Trade unions under capitalism doi
  83. (2001). Transaction cost and the social costs of on line privacy', in First Monday: Journal on the Internet (captured on 29.11.2004 at http: //www. firstmonday. dk/issues/issue6 5/sholtz/(captured) doi
  84. (1999). transparency and bargaining power', Paper presented at a workshop on Cyber Ontology at the
  85. (2003). Union "dot orgs" come of age', ILO (captured on 11.11.03 @ http: //www. ilo. org/public/english/bureau/inf/magazine/49/unions. htm)
  86. (2006). Union Democracy: Processes, Difficulties and Prospects', paper presented to the Conference:
  87. (2001). Unions Urged to find Web recruits',
  88. (2006). Unions, technologies of coordination, and the changing contours of globally distributed power', paper presented at the Conference, `Networked Labor: The Future of Unions and the Internet', doi
  89. (1997). Using the Internet to promote international labour solidaritybridging the gap between vision and reality' (Hosted at http:
  90. (2002). Volume 57, numero 4, Automne / Fall doi
  91. (1970). What About People in Regional Science? ' Papers of the Regional Science Association, doi
  92. (1997). Workers in a Lean World: Unions doi
  93. (1999). Workers Online', The Sunday Morning Herald,
  94. (1989). Workplace trade unionism in the 1980s: a process of renewal: Studies for Trade Unionists (London:
  95. (2003). Workplaces: A Study Of Union Resilience In The Restructured Workplace (London, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.