Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Qualitative Reasoning Methodology for the Generation of Process Plant Operating Procedures

By Regina Ferreira Vianna


The analysis of operating procedures in the early stages of design can lead to safer and higher performance plants. Qualitative reasoning techniques hold considerable promise in supporting generations of operating procedures, since they are able to describe possible trajectories of a system based on non-quantitative information and provide explanation about process behaviour in a way which gives insight into the underlying physical processes. Despite this potential, existing techniques still present\ud limitations related to the tendency for generating non-real behaviour patterns and the inability to describe distributed parameter systems.\ud \ud \ud This study presents a qualitative reasoning methodology, weighted digraph (WDG) approach, for describing the dynamics of complex chemical processes, and in particular of distributed parameter systems, with a considerable reduction in the generation of spurious solutions. It is based on a generalisation of the signed digraph approach and retains its main advantages, such as the ability to easily represent intuitive and causal knowledge and a graph structure which makes apparent the flow of information between variables. In addition, it incorporates several new features, making use of functional weighting, differential nodes and temporal edges, which enable the procedure to qualitatively describe complex patterns of behaviour.\ud \ud \ud The effectiveness of the approach is demonstrated by considering the qualitative modelling and simulation of the dynamic behaviour of several chemical processes: heat-exchanger, CSTR with and without temperature control and distillation column.\ud \ud \ud The proposed weighted digraph approach is used to support generation of start-up procedures with reference to two case studies: a network of heat-exchangers and an integrated system composed of a CSTR and a feed/effluent heat-exchanger. It is shown that the digraph based strategy has the ability to generate feasible operating procedures in the presence of operational constraints and identify the need for modifications of the process topology in order to allow the start-up of the system.\ud \ud \ud Results also indicate that work is still needed in order to further improve the methodology and create an interactive computer based interface to help with reasoning about complex patterns of behaviour

Publisher: School of Chemistry (Leeds)
Year: 1995
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1994). A Computer Integrated Concurrent Process Engineering Environment,
  2. (1993). A Distributed Fault Diagnosis Method Based on Digraph Models: Steady-State Analysis, doi
  3. (1990). A First Principles Approach to Automated Troubleshooting of Chemical Plants, doi
  4. (1992). A Framework for Qualitative Simulation
  5. (1993). A Fuzzy-Logic-Based Approach to Building Efficient Fuzzy Rule-Based Expert Systems,
  6. (1986). A Generalized Model for Distillation Columns - I: Model Description and Applications, doi
  7. (1980). A Graphical Approach to Cause and Effect Analysis of Chemical Processing Systems, doi
  8. (1980). A Graphical Approach to the Problem of Locating the Origin of the System Failure,
  9. (1991). A Methodology for Common-sense Model Development, Comp. doi
  10. (1991). A Qualitative Model for Simulation of the Start-up of a Distillation Column with Energy Feedback. In:
  11. (1994). A Qualitative Physics Compiler,
  12. (1992). A Qualitative Process-Oriented Approach for Chemical Plant Operations - doi
  13. (1992). A Review of Qualitative Reasoning Including Applications to Process Engineering and Plant Design,
  14. (1987). A Synthesis Method for Chemical Plant Operating doi
  15. (1992). A Tool for doi
  16. (1979). An Algorithm for Diagnosis of System Failures doi
  17. (1994). An Application of Automated Operating doi
  18. (1982). An Approach for Determination
  19. (1992). Artificial Neural Networks for Chemical Process Characterisation,
  20. (1990). Automated Reasoning about Chemical Plants from First Principles: Application to Troubleshooting and Design, PhD Thesis,
  21. (1992). Automatic Abduction of Qualitative Models,
  22. (1989). Automatic Synthesizer of Operating Procedures for Chemical Plant by Use of Fragmentary Knowledge, doi
  23. (1989). CEF'87, The Use of Computers in Chemical Engineering,
  24. (1984). Chemical Process Control - An Introduction to Theory and Practice, doi
  25. (1984). Commonsense Reasoning about Causality: Deriving Behavior from Structure, doi
  26. (1991). Concurrency in Process Engineering Design, PhD Thesis,
  27. (1994). Concurrent Engineering Application in Fluid Catalytic Cracking Process Design, doi
  28. (1972). Depth-first Search and Linear Graph Algorithms, doi
  29. (1991). Fault Diagnosis Based on Qualitative/Quantitative Process Knowledge, doi
  30. (1991). Fault Diagnosis Utilizing a Three-Layer Directed Graph, doi
  31. (1985). Feasibility Study of a Fault-Diagnosis System for Chemical Plants,
  32. (1988). Formal Order-of-Magnitude Reasoning doi
  33. (1990). Graphs and Digraphs. In: doi
  34. Himmelblau (1994a). The Possible Cause and Effect Graphs (PCEG) Model for Fault Diagnosis - doi
  35. Himmelblau (1994b). The Possible Cause and Effect Graphs (PCEG) Model for Fault Diagnosis - doi
  36. (1989). Interactive Design of Multicomponent Distillation Columns, PhD Thesis,
  37. (1994). Interactive Design of Non-Ideal Multicomponent Distillation Columns, PhD Thesis,
  38. (1994). Interactive Graphics-Based Design of Multistage Multicomponent Distillation Processes, PhD Thesis,
  39. (1991). Large Qualitative Models of Complex Chemical and Bioengineering Processes, doi
  40. (1987). Malfunction Diagnosis Using Quantitative Models with Non-Boolean Reasoning in Expert Systems, doi
  41. (1993). Model Simplification by Asymptotic Order of Magnitude Reasoning, doi
  42. (1989). Model-Based Monitoring of Dynamic Systems, doi
  43. (1994). Modular Approach for Start-up Operational Procedures of Chemical Plant,
  44. (1992). Multiple Models Based on Fuzzy Qualitative Modelling, IFAC-Artif. Intell. in Real-Time Control,
  45. (1987). Naive Models doi
  46. (1993). Numeric Reasoning with Relative Orders of Magnitude,
  47. O'Shima (1985a). Fault Diagnosis Algorithms Based on the Signed Directed Graph and Its Modifications, doi
  48. (1990). On-line Fault Diagnosis Using the Signed Directed Graph, doi
  49. (1988). Operating Procedure Synthesis Using Local Models and Distributed Goals, doi
  50. (1991). Order of Magnitude Reasoning,
  51. Perkins (1978a). On the Dynamics of Distillation Processes - I: The Simple Distillation of Multicomponent Non-reacting, Homogeneous Liquid Mixtures,
  52. Perkins (1978b). On the Dynamics of Distillation Processes - II: The Simple Distillation of Model Solutions, doi
  53. (1975). Process Computer Alarm Analysis: Outline of a Method Based on List Processing,
  54. (1985). Prospects for Computer Aided Process Engineers,
  55. (1990). QPC: A Compiler from Physical Models into Qualitative Differential Equations,
  56. (1992). QSIM and Partial Differential Equations, personal communication.
  57. (1995). Qualitative Modeling and Simulation of a
  58. (1988). Qualitative Modeling and Simulation of Dynamic Systems, doi
  59. (1990). Qualitative Modeling of Chemical Reaction Systems. In: doi
  60. (1991). Qualitative Modelling of Distillation Columns, doi
  61. (1990). Qualitative Physics. In: Encyclopedia of Artificial Intelligence, doi
  62. (1991). Qualitative Process Modelling. In: doi
  63. (1992). Qualitative Reasoning Methodology for Chemical Processes,
  64. (1989). Qualitative Reasoning: Modelling and Simulation with Incomplete Knowledge, doi
  65. (1989). Qualitative Simulation for Process Modeling and Control, doi
  66. (1991). Qualitative Simulation for Start-up a Distillation Column,
  67. (1988). Qualitative Simulation of Chemical Process Systems: Steady-State Analysis, doi
  68. (1986). Qualitative Simulation, doi
  69. (1980). Reznichenko
  70. (1978). Safety Supervision of Valve Operations,
  71. (1990). Self-Explanatory Simulations: An Integration of Qualitative and Quantitative Knowledge,
  72. (1992). Start up and Shut down of a Plant. In:
  73. (1983). Synthesis of Control Systems for Chemical Plants -A Chalenge for Creativity, doi
  74. (1988). Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Complete Chemical Plants - I. Hierarchical, Structured Modelling for Nonlinear Planning, doi
  75. (1988). Synthesis of Operating Procedures for Complete Chemical Plants - II. A Nonlinear Planning Methodology, doi
  76. (1987). Taming Intractable Branching in Qualitative Simulation, doi
  77. Tano and E. O'Shima (1985b). Fault Diagnosis of Chemical Processes by the Use of Signed, Directed Graphs. Extension to FiveRange Patterns of Abnormality,
  78. (1992). The Curious Behavior of Homogeneous Azeotropic Distillation - Implications for Entrainer Selection, doi
  79. (1990). The Qualitative Process Engine. In: Readings in Qualitative Reasoning About Physical Systems, doi
  80. (1987). The Scope of Artificial Intelligence in Plant-wide Operations. In:
  81. (1992). Towards a Qualitative Lagrangian Theory of Fluid Flow,
  82. (1988). Using Incomplete Quantitative Knowledge in Qualitative Reasoning,
  83. (1994). Using Qualitative Physics to Build Articulate Software for Thermodynamics Education, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.