Location of Repository

Primary teachers' conceptions of giftedness amongst schoolchildren

By George Victor Ilsley


The new National Curriculum for schools in England & Wales\ud stresses the need for 'differentiation' in educational provision to cater for all children by attending to the needs of the individual. Special provision is made for slow learners and the physically handicapped. but despite a growing awareness, the needs of the 'gifted' have by\ud comparison been neglected. Academic researchers have for decades concentrated on the identification problem often based on standardized intelligence and creativity tests, whilst teacher support organisations in this country have concentrated on provision. Notwithstanding the activity of these interest groups the efficiency with which any\ud provision is made for such children in the primary classroom is almost entirely dependent on the classteacher.\ud \ud The present study sampled two class teachers, teaching nine and ten year old children, from each of 24 schools in the County of Northamptonshire. The schools chosen were large, small, rural and urban. Teachers were invited to respond to an unstructured, tape recorded interview which included flash cards of similar terms used to describe the different groups of able children, the results of which were analysed using cluster analysis (CLUSTAN 2 computer software) to\ud identify similarities and differences between the respondents.\ud \ud The results of the study reveal that most of the primary\ud classteachers were able to recognise children in the classroom who they considered to be 'gifted' in their terms. However there was an apparent lack of certainty with which they conveyed their understanding of such terms as gifted, talented, exceptional, highly able and bright.\ud Inasmuch as a 'core' attribute can be ascribed to their concept of giftedness, specific outstandingness in relation to peers usually in such fields as mathematics and music was most frequently mentioned in their responses. The nature of that outstandingness is a matter of some debate.\ud \u

Publisher: School of Education (Leeds)
Year: 1989
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:1060

Suggested articles



  1. (1925). (Ed) Genetic studies of genius Vol I: Mental & physical traits of a thousand gifted children. '
  2. (1956). A
  3. (1986). A conception of giftedness. In
  4. (1977). A manual for repertory grid technique.
  5. (1982). A model for intelligence.
  6. (1932). A new technique for the measurement of attitudes.
  7. (1985). Able children: Identifying them in the classroom
  8. (1987). An exploration of some definitions of giftedness.
  9. (1981). Attitudes and opinions on Rifted children and their education. In
  10. (1980). Car ceptions of giftedness. London:
  11. (1980). Characteristics and identification of gifted and talented students. Washington DC:
  12. (1961). Characteristics of the creative person: implications for the teaching-learning process.
  13. (1967). Children and their primary schools.
  14. (1978). Clustan user manual.
  15. (1987). Concepts and schemata.
  16. (1962). Creativity and intelligence: explorations with gifted students.
  17. (1969). Curiosity of gifted children: Performance on timed and untimed tests of creativity.
  18. (1986). D307: Exploring personal worlds: The Kelly project. Milton Keynes: The Open University.
  19. (1982). de Bono's thinking course.
  20. (1980). Educating the gifted child. London-
  21. (1972). Education of the gifted and talented: Report to the Congress of the United States by the U.
  22. (1978). Effects of training on teachers' accuracy in the indentification of gifted children.
  23. (1983). Environment and high IQ -a consideration of fluid and crystallised intelligence. In Personality and individual differences.
  24. (1973). Experinent design & statistics.
  25. (1980). Exploring teachers' thinking. London:
  26. (1959). Genetic studies of genius:
  27. (1980). Gifted and talented. In Every child is special.
  28. (1965). Gifted child in the classroom.
  29. (1981). Gifted children A research study, their relative levels of scholastic achievement and interests. Teachers views on their educational needs.
  30. (1984). Gifted children and teachers in the primary school 5-12.
  31. (1969). Gifted children and the Brentwood experiment.
  32. (1975). Gifted children and the Millfield experiment.
  33. (1980). Gifted children and their education.
  34. (1973). Gifted children in primary schools London:
  35. (1957). Gifted children: A handbook for the classroom teacher.
  36. (1980). Gifted children: Their identification and development in a social context. Lancaster:
  37. (1986). Gifted education policy in Australia.
  38. (1988). Gifted teachers: Realities and myths.
  39. (1986). Giftedness: A psychological approach.
  40. (1986). Giftedness: coalescence, context, conflict and commitment. In
  41. (1974). Government Printing Office.
  42. (1977). Grid techniques for children.
  43. (1986). Guidelines for curriculum enrich t: with special reference to able children in secondary years 1-3. Bristol: Avon County Council.
  44. (1968). Human intelligence; its nature and assessment.
  45. (1980). Identification of the gifted.
  46. (1979). Identifying gifted children: A case study - some theoretical considerations.
  47. (1973). In search of promise.
  48. (1971). Inquiring man: The theory of personal constructs. Harmondsworth:
  49. (1967). Intelligence assessment.
  50. (1979). Intelligence: Heredity and environment.
  51. (1968). Interviewing. In
  52. (1988). Issues in the definition and measurement of the giftedness construct.
  53. (1987). Knots' in teachers' thinking.
  54. (1959). Locating gifted children in high schools: A comparison of methods.
  55. (1977). Matters for discussion No. 4: Gifted children in middle and comprehensive secondary schools.
  56. (1965). Modes of thinking in young children.
  57. (1985). New challenges to common identification practices. In
  58. (1977). New perspectives in personal construct theory.
  59. (1956). Nonparaaetric statistics.
  60. (1975). Nursery teachers' perceptions of their pupils: An exploratory study. In
  61. (1978). Personal construct Psychology.
  62. (1985). Personal constructs in the context of Inset.
  63. (1976). Personality: Theraries, basic assumptions, research and applications.
  64. (1949). Personnel selection.
  65. (1979). Presenting research results
  66. (1984). Primary Teaching.
  67. (1966). Questionnaire design and attitude measurement.
  68. (1982). Reaction time and psychometric sr, In
  69. (1980). Recognizing the gifted child. In
  70. (1986). Research methods in education.
  71. (1985). Science 5-16: A statement of policy.
  72. (1983). Selection and training of teachers of the gifted in the United States.
  73. (1985). Self-organised learning London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  74. (1967). Some aspects of the study of the gifted.
  75. (1985). Some considerations regarding the use of teacher ludgment measures in the identification of Rifted pupils.
  76. (1978). Special Educational Needs. Report of Committee of Enquiry into the education of handicapped children and vounsR people.
  77. (1985). SPSSX Advanced statistics guide.
  78. (1957). Symposium: contributions to intelligence testing and the theory of intelligence. Reported
  79. (1976). Teacher expectations and pupil learning.
  80. (1985). Teacher identification of gifted children in primarv schools. In Cropley.
  81. (1985). Teacher ratings of task commitment: An operationalization of Renzulli's definition of giftedness.
  82. (1974). Teacher-student relationships: Causes and consequences
  83. (1982). Teachers' effectiveness in identifying gifted children.
  84. (1982). Teaching able and gifted children: A study of initial and in-service teacher training in England,
  85. (1988). Teaching able children.
  86. (1981). Teaching bright pupils in mixed ability classes.
  87. (1974). Teaching clever children 7-11.
  88. (1976). Teaching styles and Pupil progress. London: Open Books
  89. (1926). The art of thought.
  90. (1976). The creative vision: A longitudinal vision in problem finding in art.
  91. (1974). The education of gifted children.
  92. (1986). The educational definitions of giftedness and its policy implications. In
  93. (1983). The GAB computer program for the analysis of repertory grid data.
  94. (1973). The gifted child.
  95. (1982). The gifted student at university.
  96. (1958). The meaning of giftedness.
  97. (1957). The measurement of meaning.
  98. (1985). The nature and mea=surement of intelligence. In
  99. (1967). The nature of human intelligence.
  100. (1977). The psychology and education of gifted children.
  101. (1985). The Psychology of gifted children.
  102. (1955). The psychology of personal constructs. Vols. I & II.
  103. (1962). The relation between teacher-. judged giftedness, a group intelligence test and an individual test with possible kindergarten pupils. In The Gifted Child Quarterly.
  104. (1980). The role of the local education authority. In
  105. (1986). The three-ring conception of giftedness: A developmental model for creative oroductivity.
  106. (1981). Understanding teaching: Interactive educational psychology.
  107. (1974). Wechsler intelligence scale for children.
  108. (1981). What is educational research?
  109. (1978). What makes giftedness ? Re-examining a definition.
  110. (1980). Who are the gifted ?: Definition and Identification.
  111. (1982). Who are the gifted? In Looking to their future November. London: National Association for Gifted Children. -

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.