Article thumbnail

Art and the unconscious : a semiotic case study of the painting process

By Asta Sutton

Abstract

This dissertation is an attempt to design an interpretation model for the comprehension of unconscious content in artworks, as well as to find painting techniques to free the unconscious mind, allowing it to be expressed through artwork. The interpretation model, still in its infancy, is ripe for further development. The unconscious mind is a fascinating subject—in art production as well as in many scientific fields. This hidden part of the mind, being the source of creativity, constitutes an important foundation for many possible and valuable inquiries in multiple areas of knowledge. In the present study, the unconscious is approached from an art-educational perspective. The nature of the unconscious is addressed through the theories of Carl Gustav Jung and Charles Sanders Peirce, as well as through the information gained from data the author produced herself during the experimental painting process she devised for this study. For psychological distinctions not addressed by Jung, the theories of Sigmund Freud are used to forward this inquiry into the unconscious mind. A research method was created to bring Peirce’s theories into consonance with Jung’s amplification method. Since Peirce’s theories are challenging to read, to avoid misinterpretation, the author used Phyllis Chiasson’s 2001 book Peirce’s Pragmatism: The Design for Thinking as a secondary source. Peirce’s three modes of reality—firstness, secondness, and thirdness—were utilized to interpret artworks. This three-mode reality allows interpreters to reflect on their subjective feelings and then to compare them to collected data. The interpreters’ intuitive self-interpretations often correlate well with the more objective data. In this approach to interpretation, the work of art is seen as a sign, in the Jungian as well as in the Peircean sense, and interpretation seeks to discover a sign’s objects—icon, index, and symbol. Additionally, the objects are studied in combination with Peirce’s designation of the sign’s character elements—sinsign, qualisign, and legisign. Peirce’s theory offers a logical and productive structure for approaching a variety of signs and reaching a multiplicity of interpretations. Jungian theories inculcated a combined psychological and artistic perspective for the interpretation of artworks. Jung’s method of amplification is an effort to bring a symbol to life, and it is used as a technique to discover—through the seeking of parallels—a possible context for any unconscious content that an image might have. In amplification, a word or element—from a fantasy, dream, or, in this study, artwork—is associated, through use of what Jung called the active imagination, with another context where it also occurs. It must be remembered that unconscious images in artworks do not easily open themselves up for interpretation. One way to interpret possibly unconscious images is for the interpreter to become vulnerable by employing his or her own unconscious mind to interpret an artwork; such use of the active imagination can enable a subjective experience of the artwork on the part of the interpreter, who might thereby uncover unconscious content. Moreover, in this study, Jung’s theory of archetypes is employed, in parallel with Peirce’s and Jung’s theories of the sign, to illuminate an artwork’s images by connecting them with collective unconscious archetypes. The author relied upon The Book of Symbols: Reflections on Archetypal Images (Ronnberg and Martin 2010) as the main source for interpreting possibly unconscious elements in the artworks. This approach is especially powerful when artists interpret their own artwork—possibly leading to a galvanizing self-discovery as they revisit past encounters, personal highlights, and other pieces of unconscious content that might reveal previously unknown meaning important to their life. By comparing archetypes to the unconscious content in their own lives, people can discover themselves. Unconscious phenomena were approached on both the theoretical and empirical levels. Different methods and ideas were used to stimulate the author’s unconscious thinking while performing artwork analyses of three paintings: surrealist Salvador Dalí’s (1904–1989) Assumpta Corpuscularia Lapislazulina; abstract expressionist Jackson Pollock’s (1912-1956) The Deep; and one painting by the author herself, and for which the process of painting is videorecorded (www.astagallery.com/academic.html). With regard to the third painting interpreted, the author is the study subject, and her artistic production is used as an opportunity to explore the unconscious mind. During the act of painting, an attempt is made to free unconscious thinking by fusing Dalí’s and Pollock’s methods as well as by testing multiple other methods. The author’s artistic production was conjoined with use of a technique that is called the verbal protocol method, which generates additional data not necessarily visible in the final artwork. This method unseals the artist’s tacit knowledge, which in normal circumstances remains silent. In the verbal protocol method, the author, while engaged in the act of painting, speaks aloud the stream of consciousness that accompanies and guides the art-making activity; the recorded and transcribed monologue from the artistic production is supplied, in both Finnish and English, in appendices. This thinking-aloud technique allows a person to become more self-aware and to create more solutions while struggling with emergent artistic problems. Such narratives can reveal more about the painting than the completed artwork alone can convey. Along with the artist’s finished painting and the videorecorded material, narratives produced during the painting activity were interpreted. Moreover, the discoveries arising from the author’s interpretation of her own artwork are correlated with some of the latest research on the unconscious. This study allows the reader-viewer an intimate glimpse into the author’s subjective painting experience and demonstrates the participation of the unconscious in an artwork’s creation. The interpretations methodology constitutes an interpretation model suitable for other artists and art educators to follow. Keywords: unconscious, art, archetype, mandal

Publisher: fi=Lapin yliopisto|en=University of Lapland|
Year: 2014
OAI identifier: oai:lauda.ulapland.fi:10024/61720
Provided by: Lauda
Journal:

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. 19, 1956–57.” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by
  2. (1948). 50 Secrets of Magic Craftsmanship. Translated by Haakon
  3. (1943). A General Introduction to Psychoanalysis. Translated by Joan Riviere.
  4. (1986). A Life of One’s Own. London: Anchor Brendon Ltd.
  5. (1971). A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. doi
  6. (2004). A Short Introduction to Psychoanalysis. doi
  7. (2000). A Shy and Turbulent Man Who Became a Myth. November 9, 1959.” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by Harrison Helen A.
  8. (1991). A Weekend with Picasso.
  9. (1970). Abstract Art. Translated by Jonathan Griffin. doi
  10. (1975). Aha! Insides Into the Creative Behavior. doi
  11. (1978). An Illustrated Encyclopaedia of Traditional Symbols. London: Thames and Hudson.
  12. (2000). An Inquiry into Paul Cézanne: The Role of the Artist in Studies of Perception and Consciousness.” In
  13. (2000). An Interview with
  14. (2000). An Interview with Clement Greenberg,
  15. (1999). An interview with Lee Krasner Pollock, in Jackson Pollock: Black and White.
  16. (2004). An Introduction to Zen Buddhism. With a Foreword by Carl Jung.
  17. (1968). Analytical Psychology: Its Theory and Practice. The Tavistock Lectures. doi
  18. (1989). Analytical Psychology. Notes of the Seminar given in 1925 by doi
  19. (1965). Art and Illusion. A Study in the Psychology of Pictorial Representation. doi
  20. (1959). Art and the Creative Unconscious: Four Essays. Translated by Ralph Manheim. doi
  21. (2001). Art and the Unconscious: A Psychological Approach to a Problem of Philosophy. doi
  22. (2001). Art History’s History. New Jersey: Upper Saddle River.
  23. (2000). Artificial Magic.” In Dalí’s Optical Illusions, edited by Ades Dawn. London: Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art in association with
  24. (1999). Artist’s Statements and Interviews. Pollock’s first solo exhibition at Peggy Guggenheim’s gallery, Art of this Century,
  25. (2005). Artistic Research: Theories, Methods and Practices. Espoo: Cosmoprint Oy.
  26. (1960). Basic Principles of Psychoanalysis.
  27. Catalogue.” In Dalí’s Optical Illusions, edited by Dawn Ades. Hartford: Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art in association with
  28. (1998). Chagall: The Art of Dreams.
  29. (2012). Charles S. Peircen semiotiikan mahdollisuudet taidehistoriassa ja kuvataiteen tutkimuksessa.” In the book Taidetta tutkimaan, menetelmiä ja näkökulmia, edited by Annika Waenerberg Satu Kähkönen. Jyväskylä: Kampus Paino,
  30. Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce: Volume VII Science and Philosophy. Edited by Arthur W. Burks. Cambridge: doi
  31. Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce: Volume VIII Reviews, Correspondence, and Bibliography. Edited by Arthur W. Burks. Cambridge: doi
  32. (1960). Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce. Volume V Pragmatism and Pragmatism and Volume VI Scientific Metaphysics. Edited by doi
  33. (1974). Concepts of Modern Art: From Fauvism to Post-Modernism.” In Dada and Surrealism. Edited by Stangos Nikos. London: Thames and Hudson.
  34. (2000). Concerning the Science of Art.” In the book
  35. (1977). Concerning the Spiritual in Art. doi
  36. (1991). Consciousness Explained.
  37. (1969). Conversation with Dalí. Translated by Joachim Neugroschel.
  38. (1996). Creativity, Flow and the Psychology of Discovery and Invention. doi
  39. (1986). Creativity: Genius and other Myths. doi
  40. (2011). Curators’ Preface.” In Salvador Dalí: The Late Work, edited by
  41. (1957). Dalí on Modern Art. The Cuckolds of Antiquated Modern Art. Translated by Haakon
  42. (1999). Dalí: Genius, Obsession and Lust.
  43. Dalí’s Optical Illusions.” In Dalí’s Optical Illusions, edited by Dawn Ades. Hartford: Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art in association with doi
  44. (2000). Dalí’s Permanent Provocation.” In Dalí’s Optical Illusions, edited by Dawn Ades. doi
  45. (1965). Diary of a Genius by Salvador Dalí.
  46. (1987). Dictionary of Analytical Psychology. doi
  47. (1989). Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain. A Course in Enhancing Creativity and Artistic Confidence. doi
  48. Dream Analysis. Notes of the Seminar given in 1928–1930 by doi
  49. (2000). Editorial Introduction.” In
  50. (1970). Education Through Art. doi
  51. (1997). Ensor and his Environment: Landscapes, Interiors, Still Lifes, 1880–1998.” In James Ensor 1860–1949: Theatre of Masks. Edited by Carol Brown. Bryssels: Snoeck Ducaju & Zoon.
  52. (1976). Essays in Freudian Psychoanalysis.
  53. (2000). Excerpt from an Interview with Patsy Southgate.” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by Harrison Helen A.
  54. (1972). Expressionism and Fauvism.
  55. (1969). Freud: Dictionary of Psychoanalysis. Edited by Nador Fodor and Frank Gaynor. doi
  56. (1949). from his own notes by Jeffrey Potter
  57. (1973). Fuseli: The Nightmare. Edited by John Fleming
  58. (1999). Gala Dalí: The Eternal Feminine.” In Salvador Dalí. A Mythology, edited by Dawn Ades and Fiona Bradley.
  59. (2002). Hidden Minds: A History of the Unconscious.
  60. (2005). Holy Toledo! Saint John of the Cross, Paranoiac-Critical Mysticism, and the Life and Work of Saint Dalí.” In The Dalí Renaissance: New Perspectives on His Life and Art after 1940, edited by
  61. (1991). How to Look at Modern Art.
  62. (1998). How to Think Like Leonardo da Vinci: Seven Steps to Genius Every Day.
  63. (1989). Hugo Simberg – unien maalari. Keuruu: Kustannusosakeyhtiö Otava.
  64. (1981). Image and Code: Scope and Limits of Conventionalism in Pictorial Representation.” In Image and Code, edited by Steiner Wendy. Ann Arbor:
  65. (1977). Image, Music, Text. Translated by Stephen Heath. doi
  66. (1999). Inner Vision. doi
  67. (1999). Interpreting Pollock.
  68. (1999). Interview with Lee Krasner: Who was Jackson Pollock? Art in America.” In Jackson Pollock, edited by Karmel Pepe.
  69. (1973). Introducing Abstract Picture Making. doi
  70. (2000). Jackson Pollock
  71. (2000). Jackson Pollock and Relationships.” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by Harrison Helen A.
  72. (1999). Jackson Pollock at Work: An Interview with Lee Kasner, Partisan Review,
  73. (1951). Jackson Pollock Motion Picture. One film reel 11 min. Directed by Hans Namuth.
  74. (1972). Jackson Pollock; Energy Made Visible.
  75. (1987). Jackson Pollock: A Biography.
  76. (2000). Jackson Pollock: An Appreciation.
  77. (2000). Jackson Pollock: Fragments of conversations and statements.
  78. (2000). Jackson Pollock: Notes concerning the nature of his drawings and his art psychotherapy. December 27, 1982” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by Harrison Helen A.
  79. (1999). Jackson Pollock: The Infinite Labyrinth, Magazine of Art,
  80. (1969). Jackson Pollock: Works on Paper.
  81. (1999). Jackson Pollock.
  82. (1999). Jackson Pollock. Interview with William Wright. The Springs,
  83. (1999). Jackson Pollock’s ‘The Moon Woman cuts the Circle.’
  84. (1983). Jung: Selected Writings, edited by Anthony Storr.
  85. (1989). Kätketty avain. Translated by Mirja Rutanen.
  86. (2012). Kuvastojen tutkimus metodologisena haasteena – esimerkkinä maisemakuvaston visuaalinen analyysi.” In Taidetta tutkimaan, menetelmiä ja näkökulmia, edited by Annika Waenerberg, Satu Kähkönen. Jyväskylä: Kampus Paino,
  87. (1985). Kuvataiteen toisinajattelija. Translated by Marjut Kumela. Jyväskylä: Gummerus Oy.
  88. (1990). Kuvien edessä. Helsinki: Painokaari Oy.
  89. (2012). Kuvien tulkinta.
  90. (2002). Letters of Desire.” In Surrealism: Desire Unbound, edited by Mundy Jennifer and Ades Dawn. doi
  91. (2002). Lumikuningattaren valtakunta H.C. Andersenin satu sisäisen kasvun kuvauksena.”
  92. (1964). Man and His Symbols, edited by
  93. (2010). Manifestoes of Surrealism. Translated by Richard Seaver doi
  94. (1997). Marcel Duchamp: Identiteetti ja teos tuotteena. Tampere: Tammerpaino Oy.
  95. (1993). Minnesota Celebrates Matisse. Edited by Susan Jones. Minneapolis: The Minneapolis Institute of Arts.
  96. (1995). Modern Man in Search of a Soul. Translated by doi
  97. (1987). Modernista taiteesta. Translated by Kimmo Pasanen. Helsinki: Kirjapaino Hakapaino Oy.
  98. (1999). Month in Review: Fifteen Years of Jackson Pollock.
  99. (2004). Musta Neliö. Helsinki: Kustannus Oy Taide.
  100. (1987). Myytit kuvina Marc Chagallin I Pariisinkauden
  101. (1978). Narration Spoken by Jackson Pollock in Film by Hans Namuth and Paul Falkenberg
  102. (2004). Neron päiväkirja. Translated by Kimmo Pasanen. Helsinki: Werner Söderström Osakeyhtiö.
  103. (1933). New Introductory Lectures on Psycho-analysis. Translated by doi
  104. (1960). Observations on the Feeling of the Beautiful and Sublime. doi
  105. (2010). On Not Being Able to Paint. Padstow: doi
  106. (2005). On the Road with Salvador Dalí: The 1952 Nuclear Mysticism Lecture Tour.” In The Dalí Renaissance: New Perspectives on His Life and Art after 1940, edited by doi
  107. (1988). Optimal Experience: Psychological Studies of Flow in Consciousness. Edited by Isabella Selega Csikszentmihalyi. Cambridge: doi
  108. (1998). OUI Paranoid – Critical Revolution Writings 1927–1933. Edited by Robert Decharnes and translated
  109. (1997). Pedagoginen luonnoskirja Modernista taiteesta. Translated by Björne Lönroos and Kimmo Pasanen. Jyväskylä: Gummerus Oy.
  110. (1989). Peirce’s Approach to the Self: A Semiotic Perspective on Human Subjectivity. doi
  111. (1972). Peirce’s Epistemology. The Hague: doi
  112. (2001). Peirce’s Pragmatism: The Design for Thinking. doi
  113. (1966). Peirce’s Theory of Signs as Foundation for Pragmatism. The Hague: doi
  114. (1978). Photographing Pollock by Hans Namuth. In the book Pollock Painting, edited by Barbara Rose. New York: Agrinde Publication,
  115. (2000). Photographing Pollock. November 17, 1979” In Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock, edited by Harrison Helen A.
  116. (1989). Pinta ja Syvyys, esseitä. Forssa: Forssan kirjapaino Oy.
  117. (1999). Pollock and Krasner: Script and Postscript, RES.” In Jackson Pollock. Interviews, Articles, and Reviews, edited by Karmel Pepe.
  118. (1999). Pollock as Jungian Illustrator: The Limits of Psychological Criticism. Art in
  119. (1984). Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data. London: doi
  120. (1958). Psyche and Symbol: A Selection from the Writings of C.
  121. (1992). Psychoanalytic Drawings. doi
  122. (1952). Psychoanalytic Explorations in Art. doi
  123. (1963). Psychology of the Unconscious. doi
  124. (2005). Reminiscences of Dalí: A Conversation with Amanda Lear and Ultra Violet.” In The Dalí Renaissance. New Perspectives on His Life and Art after 1940, edited by
  125. (2004). Salvador Dalí 1904–1989.
  126. (1988). Salvador Dalí Eksenterisyys ja nerous. Translated by Lea Teittinen-Walter.
  127. (2008). Salvador Dalí House – Museum Portlligat-Cadaques. Igo: SA Imma Planas.
  128. (2007). Salvador Dalí.
  129. (2004). Salvador Dalí. Grafiikkaa ja pienoisveistoksia Erkki Paanansen yksityiskokoelmasta.
  130. (2003). Saveen piirtyviä muistoja. Subjektiivisen luomisprosessin ja sukupuolen representaatioita.” Hollola: Salpausselän Kirjapaino.
  131. (1990). Seeing through the Visible World: Jung, Gnosis, and Chaos. doi
  132. (1909). Selected Letters of
  133. (2010). Self Comes to Mind: Constructing the Conscious Brain. doi
  134. (1975). Semiology. Translated by George Gross. doi
  135. (1987). Semiotics and Fieldwork. Qualitative Research Methods. London: Sage Publication.
  136. (1999). Shades of Darkness: Mythology and Surrealism.” In Salvador Dalí: A Mythology, edited by Dawn Ades & Fiona Bradley.
  137. (1959). Sigmund Freud Collected Papers Volume 5. Edited by James Strachey. doi
  138. (2000). Such Desperate Joy: Imaging Jackson Pollock.
  139. (1964). Symbolism in the Visual Arts.” In Man and His Symbols, edited by
  140. (1985). Symbolism, the Sacred, and the Arts. Edited by Diane ApostolosCappadona.
  141. (1964). Symbols in an individual analysis.” In Man and His Symbols, edited by
  142. (2007). Taidot tulevaisuuden onnen perustana.” Tulevaisuudentutkimuksen seuran kesäseminaari Lepaalla 23–24.8.
  143. (1988). Tapaustutkimus kasvatustieteessä. Oulu: Monistus- ja kuvakeskus.
  144. (1966). Tapestries in Sand: The Spirit of Indian Sandpainting. doi
  145. (1999). Telling Bodies Performing Birth everyday narratives of childbirth.
  146. (2010). Teoksen synty. Kuvataiteellista prosessia sanallistamassa.” Jyväskylä: Bookwell Oy.
  147. (1959). The Basic Writings of doi
  148. (1938). The Basic Writings of Sigmund Freud. Edited and translated by A.
  149. (1959). The Case of Salvador Dalí.
  150. (1973). The Child & Reality: Problems of Genetic Psychology.
  151. (2000). The Cognitive Neuroscience of Art: A Preliminary fMRI Observation.” In
  152. (1980). The Collected Works of C.G. Jung Volume 9, part 1. Edited by doi
  153. (1966). The Complete Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis. Edited and translated by James Strachey.
  154. (1962). The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Volume XI doi
  155. (1975). The Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Volume XIII doi
  156. (1992). The Creative Spirit.
  157. (1951). The Creative Unconscious Studies in the Psychoanalysis of Art. doi
  158. (1970). The Eclipse of Symbolism. Columbia: doi
  159. (1989). The Ego and the Id. doi
  160. (2003). The Endless Enigma Dalí and the Magicians of multiple meaning. Ostfildern: Hatje Cantz Publishers.
  161. (1946). The Essence of Buddhism. doi
  162. (1998). The Essential Jackson Pollock.
  163. (1972). The Essential Writings. Edited by Edward C.
  164. (1978). The I Ching or Book of Changes. doi
  165. (1991). The Impressionists and Their Art.
  166. (1957). The Journey to the East. Translated by Hilda Rosner.
  167. (1999). The Legacy of Jackson Pollock Art News,
  168. (1926). The Migration of Symbols and their Relations to Beliefs and Customs. doi
  169. The Museum of Modern Art. doi
  170. (1999). The Nation 157, NO.22 November 27, 1943: Reprinted by Permission of University of Chicago Press.” In Jackson Pollock: Interviews, Articles, and Reviews, edited by Karmel Pepe.
  171. (1968). The Origins of Pragmatism: Studies in the Philosophy of Charles Sanders Peirce and William James. doi
  172. (1991). The Painter’s Eye, Learning to look at Contemporary American Art.
  173. (1951). The Philosophy of Modern Art. doi
  174. (1978). The Philosophy of Peirce: Selected Writings. Edited by Justus Buchler. doi
  175. (1969). The Psychology of Art. Translated by
  176. (1977). The Psychology of Consciousness. doi
  177. (1996). The Psychology of Kundalini Yoga. Notes of the Seminar given in 1932 by doi
  178. (2009). The Red Book (Liber Novus). Edited by Sony Shamdasani. doi
  179. (1976). The Secret Life of Salvador Dalí. Translated by Haakon
  180. (1970). The Sounding Cosmos: A Study in the Spiritualism of Kandinsky and the Genesis of Abstract Painting. Turku: Åbo Akademi.
  181. (1966). The Spirit in Man, Art, and Literature. doi
  182. (1982). The Spirit of Zen: A Way of Life, Work and Art in the Far East.
  183. (1997). The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migrations: With Observations on the Migration of Certain Industries in Prehistoric Times. doi
  184. (1966). The Tacit Dimension. doi
  185. (1979). The Tao of Psychology: Synchronicity and the Self. doi
  186. (2010). The Undiscovered Self with Symbols and the Interpretation of Dreams. Translated by doi
  187. (1967). Therapy and Technique. Edited Philip Rieff.
  188. (1995). Tiede, tutkimus ja tutkielma.
  189. (1997). Tietoinen toiminta kuvataiteellisessa prosessissa.”
  190. (1966). Toward a Psychology of Art. Collected Essays. Los Angeles: doi
  191. (2006). Tutkiva Toiminta ja ilmaisu, teos, tekeminen. Hamina: Akatiimi Oy.
  192. (2004). Un chien andalou. Black-and-white film, 1929, length 17 min. Los Angeles: Transflux Films.
  193. (1999). Unframed Space. The New Yorker 26, NO.24 August 5, 1950: 16.” In Jackson Pollock. Interviews, Articles, and Reviews, edited by Karmel Pepe.
  194. (1995). Uni ja isänmurha. Kuusi esseetä taiteesta. Translated by Mirja Rutanen. Jyväskylä: Gummerus kirjapaino Oy.
  195. (2001). Unia, ajatuksia, muistikuvia. Translated by Mirja Rutanen.
  196. (2001). Unien tulkinta. Translated by Erkki Puranen. Jyväskylä: Gummerus Kustannus Oy.
  197. (2000). Using Science to Investigate Jackson Pollock’s Drip Paintings.” In doi
  198. (1970). Van Gogh, Gauguin and the Impressionist Circle. doi
  199. (2002). Violation and Veiling in Surrealist Photography: Woman as Fetish, as Shattered Object, as Phallus.” In Surrealism: Desire Unbound, edited by Mundy Jennifer and Ades Dawn.
  200. (1987). Visual Dynamics in Jackson Pollock’s Abstractions. Ann Arbor:
  201. (2001). Visual Methodologies. An Introduction to the Interpretation of Visual Materials. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publication. doi
  202. (1971). What Is Zen?
  203. (1999). What Painting Is: How to Think about Oil painting. Using the Language of Alchemy. doi
  204. (2005). Who Says a Woman Can’t be Einstein?” Time,
  205. (1986). Writings of Charles S. Peirce: A Chronological Edition doi
  206. (1971). Zen and the Fine Arts. Translated by Gishin Tokiwa. doi
  207. (1987). Zen in the Art of Painting. Translated by George Campbell. London: Arkana Paperbacks.
  208. (1996). Zen in the Fifties: Interactions in Art between East and West.
  209. (1970). Zen Painting. Translated by John Bester.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.