Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Modelling in the evaluation of a manufacturing strategy

By Tim S. Baines


This thesis describes research that has developed the principles of a modelling tool for the analytical evaluation of a manufacturing strategy. The appropriate process of manufacturing strategy formulation is based on mental synthesis with formal planning processes supporting this role. Inherent to such processes is a stage where the effects of alternative strategies on the performance of a manufacturing system must be evaluated so that a choice of preferred strategy can be made. Invariably this evaluation is carried out by practitioners applying mechanisms of judgement, bargaining and analysis. Ibis thesis makes a significant and original contribution to the provision of analytical support for practitioners in this role. The research programme commences by defining the requirements of analytical strategy evaluation from the perspective of practitioners. A broad taxonomy of models has been used to identify a set of potentially suitable techniques for the strategy evaluation task. Then, where possible, unsuitable modelling techniques have been identified on the basis of evidence in the literature and discarded from this set. The remaining modelling techniques have been critically appraised by testing representative contemporary modelling tools in an industrially based experimentation programme. The results show that individual modelling techniques exhibit various limitations in the strategy evaluation role, though some combinations do appear to provide the necessary functionality. On the basis of this comprehensive and in-depth knowledge a modelling tool ' has been specifically designed for this task. Further experimental testing has then been conducted to verify the principles of this modelling tool. Ibis research has bridged the fields of manufacturing strategy formulation and manufacturing systems modelling and makes two contributions to knowledge. Firstly, a comprehensive and in-depth platform of knowledge has been established about modelling techniques in manufacturing strategy evaluation. Secondly, the principles of a tool that supports this role have been formed and verified

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 1994
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1988). A Business Plan. doi
  2. (1987). A Combined Approach for the Study of Industrial Dynamic Systems. In:
  3. (1987). A Combined Feedforward/Feedback To Make! Model for a-
  4. (1990). A decision 'analysis based system for formulating manufacturing strategy. doi
  5. (1991). A Framework for Modem Manufacturing Economics. '
  6. (1991). A Generative IDEFO Model of Process Planning. ' doi
  7. (1982). A Guidebookfor Technology Assessment and Impact Analysis.
  8. (1971). A Language for Organization Design: Part I. doi
  9. (1993). A Manufacturing Strategy Design Scheme which makes Optimum Use of Marketing, Production and Financial Criteria. In:
  10. (1986). A Mathematical Programming Model for Manufacturing Strategy. '17he Carbide and
  11. (1992). A Metamodel-Based Decision Support System for Shop Floor Production Control! doi
  12. (1985). A Methodology to Model the Functional Structure of an Organisation!
  13. (1993). A Review of Alternative Approaches to Traditional Costing Methods. In:
  14. (1994). A Review of Empirical Manufacturing . doi
  15. (1990). A Review of Industrial Costing Systems: L'
  16. (1992). A Review of Petri-Net Applications in Manufacturing! International' doi
  17. (1991). A Revieyv of Activity Based Costing Systems. ' Management Consultpey,
  18. (1950). A Sophisticated Tool that Facilitates Strategic Analysis. ' Planning Revievý July/August 1990,35-39. 232 17T,
  19. (1985). A Stmtegic Approach to Manufacturing Perfonnance. 1 Interfaces.
  20. (1988). A Survey of Queueing Network Packages for the Analysis of Manufacturing Systems.
  21. (1993). A unified classification of manufacturing strategies and design processes! doi
  22. (1990). Accuracy in Qualitative Descriptions of Behaviour. doi
  23. (1992). Achieving Increased Production Efficiency -A Systems Approach! Long Range Plannin&. doi
  24. (1989). Activity Based Costing :A Review With Case Studies. The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants,
  25. (1993). Activity Based Costing: A Methodology for Costing and Profitability! doi
  26. (1990). An Application of Decision Process Modelling to Manufacturing System Design! doi
  27. (1990). An Exploratory Study of the Manufacturing Strategy Process in Practice! doi
  28. (1990). An Integration and Analysis Tool for Engineers! Assembly Automation. doi
  29. (1985). An Overview of Evaluative Models - for Flexible Manufacturing Systems! doi
  30. (1987). An Overview of Verification and Validation of Simulation Models. In: Thesen, doi
  31. (1985). Analytical Tools for Strategic Planning! doi
  32. (1991). Application ofAggregate Industrial Dynamic Techniques to Manufacturing Systems.
  33. (1993). Applied Production and Operations Management. doi
  34. (1978). Archetypes of Strategy Formulation! Management Science. doi
  35. (1989). Assessing Operations Management from a Strategic Perspective! doi
  36. (1987). Breakthrough Manufacturing! Harvard -Business Review.
  37. (1990). Breakthrough to World Class Manufacturing -A Strategy for the Transformation. In:
  38. (1993). Cases in Operations Management. doi
  39. (1990). Cognitive Maps as a Visionary Tool: Strategy Embedded in Issue Management.
  40. (1975). Collected Papers of doi
  41. Comparison of Analysis Techniques for Information Requirement Determination. ' doi
  42. (1988). Competetive Manufacturing: A Practical Approach to the Development of a Manufacturing Strategy. doi
  43. (1985). Competing 71irough Manufacturing'. Harvard Business Review. January -
  44. (1985). Competing Through Manufacturing'. Harvard Business Review. January -
  45. (1985). Competitive Advantage - Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. doi
  46. (1989). Competitive Edge Manufacturing Workshop. Sponsored by the Department of Trade and Industry.
  47. (1980). Competitive Strategy - Techniquesfor Analyzing Industries and Competitors.
  48. (1988). Computer Simulation in Management Science, doi
  49. (1989). Computer Simulation. doi
  50. (1985). Control Ileory Concepts in Production and Inventory Control! doi
  51. (1967). Cost and Management Accounting Volume'l Cost Accounting. doi
  52. (1987). Crafting Strategy'. Harvard Business Review.
  53. (1988). Creating a competitive manufacturing strategy'. Production Engineer. doi
  54. (1987). Creating a Manufacturing Strategy to Suit Your Business'. Long Range Planning, doi
  55. (1987). Credibility Assessment of Simulation Results. In: doi
  56. (1984). Decision Analysis as an Aid to Strategy. doi
  57. (1983). Decision-Aiding Models: Validation, Assessment, and Related Issues for Policy Analysis! doi
  58. (1984). Designing, a Manufacturing Strategy. ' doi
  59. (1993). Determination of Manufacturing Technologies Based on Business Strategies! Computer IntegMted Manufacturing Systems. doi
  60. (1986). Discrete-Event Simulation. doi
  61. (1990). Does Your Company Need a New Cost Systern? 'Journal o Cost Management.
  62. (1987). Economic Interpretation of Dynamic Simulation. In:
  63. (1990). Effective Analysis of Manufacturing Systems Using Appropriate Modeling and Simulation Tools.
  64. (1992). Evaluating and Controlling Investments
  65. (1986). Evaluating the, research of strategy content. doi
  66. (1985). Evolutionary Design of Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems. In: doi
  67. (1987). Evolving the Manufacturing Strategy. Engineering Costs and Production Economics. doi
  68. (1991). Financial Planning as a Strategic Tool! AccounIM,
  69. (1983). Formulating the Mess: Ile Role of Decision Aids doi
  70. (1968). Fundamentals of Operations Research. doi
  71. (1990). Graduate Research. doi
  72. (1990). Guidlines for Successful, Simulation Studies. doi
  73. (1986). How to do Research -A Guidefor Students in the Sciences.
  74. (1985). Implementation of Operations Strategy. In:
  75. (1989). Implementing Manufacturing Strategic Planning'. Planning Review. doi
  76. (1968). Industrial Dynamics - after the first decade. doi
  77. (1958). Industrial Dynamics : A, Major Breakthrough for Decision Makers! doi
  78. (1988). Industrial Dynamics Model Building of a Close-Coupled Production-Distribution System. ' doi
  79. (1961). Industrial Dynamics. doi
  80. (1991). Information in Action: Soft'systems Methodology.
  81. (1991). Integrated InforTnation Modelling for CIM: An Object-Oriented Method for Integrated Enterprise Modelling. In: Doumeingts,
  82. (1957). Introduction to Operations Research, doi
  83. (1990). Introduction to Simulation using Siman, doi
  84. (1985). Introduction' to - Systems Analysis, Modeling and Simulation. In: doi
  85. (1971). Lateral Thinkingfor Management.
  86. (1991). Learning C+t. doi
  87. (1991). Linking simulation to an emulation facility. In:
  88. (1989). Machine Shop Loading -A Planning Board Approach. In:
  89. (1985). Manufacturing - The Formidable Competitive Weapon. doi
  90. (1969). Manufacturing -,, Missing Link in Corporate Strategy'.
  91. Manufacturing Audit in the Process of Strategy Formulation!. doi
  92. (1990). Manufacturing Audit in the Process of Strategy Formulation. doi
  93. (1980). Manufacturing Implications in Determining Corporate, Policy. ' doi
  94. (1978). Manufacturing in the Corporate Strategy. doi
  95. (1989). Manufacturing into the late 1990s a report by PA Consulting Group.
  96. (1985). Manufacturing Strategy - Concepts doi
  97. (1990). Manufacturing Strategy Formulation and Implementation. doi
  98. (1992). Manufacturing Strategy Formulation as a Process. In: Voss, doi
  99. (1990). Manufacturing Strategy-Concept and Practice. In:
  100. (1987). Manufacturing Strategy, Environmental Uncertainty and Performance: A Path Analytical Model'. doi
  101. (1987). Manufacturing Strategy: A Study doi
  102. (1990). Manufacturing Strategy: An Overview of Current Process and Content Models. In: Ettlie, doi
  103. (1984). Manufacturing Strategy: Defining the Missing Link. ' doi
  104. (1989). Manufacturing Strategy: Ile Secret Weapolf.
  105. (1989). Manufacturing Strategy: investing to meet the needs of the market. ' Director.
  106. (1986). Manufacturing Strategy: Its Assessment and Practice% doi
  107. (1991). Mapping and Evolution of Integration in Manufacturing Environments.
  108. (1968). Me Role of Modelling in
  109. (1984). Meeting the competitive edge- Manufacturing strategy for US companies. Dow Jones-Irwin,
  110. (1993). Metamodelling a Just-in-time Kanban System' doi
  111. (1993). Model Type Selection in an Integrated DSS Environment! Decision Sul2RQrt Systems% doi
  112. (1993). Model-based- Scenarios-- - of the ConsMuences of CUacijy Retirements in the Steel Indusiry.
  113. (1990). Modeling and Analysis of a New Product Development in Electronic Sub-Assembly Manufacturing. doi
  114. (1991). Modeling the Manufacturing Process: An Assessment of Three Approaches to Simulation.
  115. (1992). Modem Tools for the Design, Modelling and Evaluation of Flexible Manufacturing Systems!
  116. (1991). Multi-criteria Models for Capacity Analysis and Aggregate Planning in Manufacturing Systems'. doi
  117. (1990). Multi-level Modelling- An Aid to I=roved Manufacturing Performance,
  118. (1991). On Knowing When to Switch from Quantitative to Judgmental Forecasts'. doi
  119. (1993). Operations Management Strategy.
  120. (1989). Operations Strategy: A Literature Review. '
  121. (1980). Practical Research - Planning and Design. doi
  122. (1990). Product Design and Manufacturing Strategy: Strategic Choice of Simultaneous Versus Sequential Engineering for the Introduction of New Products. In:
  123. (1970). Production Systems: -Planning, Analysis, and Control.
  124. (1984). Production/Operations Management -A Key Discipline and Area for Research'. doi
  125. (1992). Rapid Modeling: The Use of Queueing Models' to Support Time-Based Competetive doi
  126. (1990). Research in the Process and, Content of Manufacturing Strategy'. doi
  127. (1984). Restoring Our Competitive Edge: Competing Through Manufacturing. doi
  128. (1987). Rough-Cut Modeling: An Alternative to Simulation. 'CIM Reviewt Winter
  129. (1991). Rule-based Behaviour and Modelling: Specification and Validation of Information Systems Dynamics. ' doi
  130. (1990). Sigma: An Intelligent and Graphical System for Modelling of Assembly Systems.
  131. (1989). Simulation for Decision Making (An Introduction). doi
  132. (1991). Simulation Modeling and Analysis, doi
  133. (1988). Simulation ofManufacturing Systems9
  134. (1986). Simulation Software Products for Analysing Manufacturing Systems',
  135. (1990). Simultaneous Cost and Production Analysis of Manufacturing Systems. In: doi
  136. (1983). So What is Strategy? 'Long Range Plamin& doi
  137. (1988). Soft Systems Methodology: An Overview. ' doi
  138. (1993). Spotting The Cost Drivers Brings Value! 'nie
  139. (1993). Standards for Computer-based Enterprise Modelling. In:
  140. (1991). Steps towards total flight simulation,
  141. (1978). Strategic Change: "Logical Incrementalism". ' Sjoan Management Review. Fall 1978,7-21,,, Reagan-Cirincione,
  142. (1990). Strategic Manufacturing Plan? Your Competitiveness Depends On It. '
  143. (1962). Strategy and Structure: Chapters in the History of the American Industrial Enterprise. doi
  144. (1980). Strategy formulation and implementation - tasks of the general manager.
  145. (1978). Strategy Formulation: Analytical Concepts.
  146. (1973). Strategy-Making in Three Modes'. doi
  147. (1973). Strategy: Formulation, Implementation, and Monitoring! doi
  148. (1987). Structured Analysis and Design of Information Systems.
  149. (1986). Structured Analysis and Design Technique.
  150. (1988). Survey Research Methods. doi
  151. (1993). System Dynamics - Background, Methodology, and Applications, Part 2: Applications! CoMuting and Control Engineering Journal. doi
  152. (1990). System Enquiry: A System Dynamics Approach. doi
  153. (1990). Systems Publishing Corporation, doi
  154. (1975). Systems Simulation, doi
  155. (1994). Talk to the City!
  156. (1978). Tattems in Strategy Fonnatiore.
  157. (1987). Teaching and Research Directions in PrOduction/Operations Management: The Manufacturing Sector. ' doi
  158. (1984). Terspec , tives on Strategy: The Real Story Behind Honda's Success! doi
  159. (1993). The ABCs of Costing!
  160. (1987). The Application of Discrete Linear Control Theory to the Analysis and Simulation of Multi-Porduct, MultiLevel Production Control Systems! doi
  161. (1963). The Art of Simulation, doi
  162. (1965). The Art ofResearch -A Guidefor the Graduate.
  163. (1971). The Concept of Corporate Strategy. Dow Jones-Irwin,
  164. (1986). The Design of Competitive Manufacturing Systems'. doi
  165. (1977). The Design of Computer Based Planning and Modeling Systems'. doi
  166. (1990). The Design School: Reconsidering the Basic Pren-dses of Strategic Managemene.
  167. (1990). The Drama Methodology fo ,r Analysing Strategy and its links with
  168. (1990). The Focus, Span and Links in Research on Operations Management Strategy. In: doi
  169. (1989). The LUCAS Manufacturing Systems Engineering Handbook. Institution of Production Engineers,
  170. (1990). The Manufacturing Review. In: doi
  171. (1972). The Modeling Process!
  172. (1992). The Practical Use of Control Theory in Manufacturing Systems Design and Manufacturing Management.
  173. (1990). The Process of Manufacturing Strategy Implementation. In:
  174. (1991). The Process of Manufacturing Strategy: Some Empirical Observations and Conclusions., doi
  175. (1994). The Rise , and Fall of Strategic Planning. doi
  176. (1945). The Role of Models in Science. ' doi
  177. (1991). The Strategy Concept and Process. doi
  178. (1991). The Strategy Process - Concepts, Contexts, Cases.
  179. (1976). The Structure of 'Unstructured" Decision Processes'. Administrative Science Quarterly. doi
  180. (1991). Towards a Unified Theory of Strategic Manufacturing Managemene.
  181. (1994). UK Manufacturing: Facing International Change. Institution of Electrical Engineers,
  182. (1986). Understanding Cash Flow: A Systems Dynamics Analysis. '
  183. (1987). Using Analytical and Simulation Modeling for Early Factory Prototyping. In: doi
  184. (1989). Using Computer Models in Corporate Planning'. doi
  185. (1981). Using Rewards in Implementing Strategy. doi
  186. (1992). Using Simulation to Facilitate Analysis of Manufacturing Strategy.
  187. (1993). Using Whole Business Simulation to Set Operational Policies in an Integrated Manufacturing System. In:
  188. (1992). Vehicle Utilization'at Bay of Plenty Electricity! doi
  189. (1978). What is this thing called Science? doi
  190. (1959). Work Study.
  191. (1991). World Class Manufacturing Versus Strategic Trade Offs. In: doi
  192. (1990). ý Development of Manufacturing Strategy: A Proven Process. doi
  193. (1990). ý', Manufacturing -, Strategy, Manufacturing Strength, Managerial Success, and Economic Outcomes. In: doi
  194. (1984). Yesterday's Accounting Undennines Production. ' Harvard Business Review. July/August 1984,95-101.
  195. (1974). Zen and, the, A, rt - of Motorcycle Maintenance. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.