Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

An exploration of male and female managers' perspectives on the meaning and assessment of commitment: Cases from leading British and Swedish engineering companies

By Val Singh

Abstract

This thesis explores the issue of why female managers’ commitment is so often reported as being less of that of males, despite research evidence that there is no gender difference in levels of commitment. No previous research was found which reported managerial meanings of “commitment”, usually conceptualised with an affective component resulting in loyalty and effort, and a continuance component, the desire to stay in an organisation. Meanings of “commitment” in three major engineering companies were elicited through interviews with 37 engineering managers in the UK and Sweden. The sample included sixteen male/female pairs matched on age, qualifications and job position, from top, middle and junior levels of management. The meanings important to managers were the manifested behaviours of commitment at work. The most common of the 36 elicited meanings were task delivery, putting yourself out, involvement, and quality. Overall, male meanings were more similar to top managers’ meanings than female meanings. Top women’s meanings were similar to those of top men, sharing meanings of being proactive/using initiative, being ready for challenge, being creative/innovative, and being business aware. More women overall gave meanings oriented towards the organisation, particularly good citizen behaviours, which would be less visible to managers, whilst more men overall gave meanings, benefiting themselves as well as the organisation, which were very active and highly visible. Five types of commitment meanings were identified: Virtuous, Volunteer, Virtuoso, Vanguard and Gender-Shared. In a later questionnaire, the sample were asked to rate the importance of their 36 meanings of commitment in terms of their own view and their perceived view of how their organisation would rate them. Through gaps between individual and perceived organisational ratings, tensions were identified and mapped, providing a guide for an indepth analysis of meanings with the greatest tensions, particularly on hours over the norm perceived to be valued more by the organisation, and on getting balance, enjoying work, thinking of oneself as well as the organisation, and being people-concerned. Interviewees at all levels indicated the importance of getting work/nonwork balance, most rejecting the notion of commitment meaning working additional hours. Attitudes to managers seeking maternity/paternity leave were reported. Through the Swedish comparison, a trend was identified that where most male managers take extended paternity leave, the issue which is seen as a woman’s individual problem in the UK becomes an organisational planning issue in Sweden. Thus, perceived lesser commitment is transformed into less unplanned availability for a short period. The process of commitment assessment has also been explored and a number of dimensions drawn out, particularly the tacit nature of the evidence, the subjectivity of assessment, and the manager’s susceptibility to influence. These affect the way in which commitment behaviours are interpreted by the manager, as both males and females use impression management strategies to demonstrate their commitment. The contribution of this thesis is to the commitment field, in identifying managers’ meanings of commitment, and to the women in management field, where evidence is presented of the differences in male and female meanings of commitment, and the importance of visibility of commitment to managers. As women’s meanings are less visible than those of men in this sample, this suggests an explanation of why women’s commitment is still challenged

Publisher: School of Management
Year: 1999
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/1121
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1990). (Ed.) Organizational Climate and Culture, Jossey-Bass,
  2. (1996). (Eds) Data Collection and Analysis, doi
  3. (1985). (Eds) Handbook of Organization Studies, doi
  4. (1989). A Cognitive Learning Perspective on Women Becoming Expert Managers”, doi
  5. (1993). A Different Tack’: An Analysis of British and Swedish Management Styles, Studentlitteratur,
  6. (1994). A dynamic theory of organisational knowledge creation”, doi
  7. (1972). A model of coping with role conflict: the role behaviour of college educated women”, doi
  8. (1985). A Passion for Excellence, doi
  9. (1987). A path analysis of a model of the antecedents and consequences of organizational commitment”, doi
  10. (1989). A political perspective on careers: interests, networks and doi
  11. (1990). A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates and consequences of organizational commitment", doi
  12. (1985). A review and reconceptualization of organizational commitment”, doi
  13. (1998). A study of the leadership styles of female and male managers in ten different nationality banks in Luxembourg, using the Personal Attirbutes Questionnaire”,
  14. (1962). A Systematic Summary of Symbolic Interaction Theory”,
  15. (1991). Achieving communication goals in superior-subordinate relationships: The multifunctionality of upward maintenance tactics”. doi
  16. (1990). Affective and continuance commitment to the organization: Evaluation of measures and analysis of concurrent and time-lagged relations”. doi
  17. (1995). An examination of the relationship between upward influence tactics and assessments of promotability”, doi
  18. (1993). An HRM role struggling for survival”,
  19. (1991). An Identity Theory Approach to doi
  20. (1998). Assessing psychological contracts: Issues, alternatives and measures”, doi
  21. (1997). Attitudes to women in management: an analysis of West Midlands businesses”, doi
  22. (1980). Balancing Work, Family and Leisure: A Triple Helix Model”,
  23. (1990). Basics of Qualitative Research, Sage: London Sturges,
  24. (1981). Beyond Attribution Theory: Cognitive Processes in Performance Appraisal" doi
  25. (1984). Beyond the contact hypothesis: Theoretical perspectives on desegregation”. doi
  26. (1998). Boundary Control: The Social Ordering of Work and Family Time in a High-tech Corporation”, doi
  27. (1993). Breaking the Mold: Women, Men and Time in the New Corporate World, Free Press, doi
  28. (1992). British engineers in context”. In
  29. (1989). Building Theories from Case Study Research”, doi
  30. (1994). Career and motherhood in engineering: cultural dilemmas and individualistic solutions”, doi
  31. (1978). Career Dynamics: Matching Individual and Organizational Needs, doi
  32. (1989). Career experiences, perceptions of employment practices, and psychological commitment to the organisation”, doi
  33. (1991). Career orientations of MIS Employees: An empirical analysis.” MIS Quarterly, doi
  34. (1999). Careering downwards? Middle managers’ experiences in the downsized organization”, doi
  35. (1994). Case Studies in Organizational Research”.
  36. (1994). Case Study Research: Design and Methods, doi
  37. (1999). Citizenship and impression management: Good soldiers or good actors?”, doi
  38. (1984). Collective climate: Agreement as a basis for defining aggregate climates in organizations”, doi
  39. (1986). Collins English Dictionary, doi
  40. (1984). Coming to a New Awareness of Organizational Culture”, Sloan Management Review, Winter,
  41. (1993). Commitment and employee behavior: comparison of affective commitment and continuance commitment with perceived organisational support”, doi
  42. (1987). Commitment and the Organization: The Organization Man Revisited”, doi
  43. (1983). Concept redundancy on organisational research: the case of work commitment”, doi
  44. (1996). Constructing managers: An exploration of competence, gender and identity”, Unpublished PhD thesis,
  45. (1991). Construing of self and others at work in the early years of corporate careers”, doi
  46. (1958). Cosmopolitans and socials: Towards an analysis of latent social roles. doi
  47. (1999). Creating the “Authentizotic” organization: Corporate transformation and its vicissitudes – A rejoinder”, INSEAD Working Paper 99/02/ENT, doi
  48. (1993). Cross-cultural research on organizational commitment: A review and application of Hofstede’s Value Survey module”, doi
  49. (1993). Cultural constraints in management theories”, doi
  50. (1998). Deconstructing women and leadership”,
  51. (1996). Desperately Seeking Differences: Is Management Style Gendered?", doi
  52. (1998). Determinants of managerial career success: Evidence and explanation of male/female differences”, doi
  53. (1981). Differentiating organizational commitment from expectancy as a motivating force”, doi
  54. (1998). Distorted views through the glass ceiling: The construction of women’s understandings of promotion and senior management positions”, doi
  55. (1999). Diversity and equal opportunities: room for a constructive compromise”, doi
  56. (1994). Do chameleons get ahead? The effects of self-monitoring on managerial careers”, doi
  57. (1998). Doing a Literature Review,
  58. (1986). Early Career Factors that differentiate Technical Management Careers from Technical Professional Careers”, doi
  59. (1998). Editorial: The psychological contract in retrospect and prospect”, doi
  60. (1995). Effects of impression management on performance ratings: A longitudinal study”, doi
  61. (1997). Email dated 8-10-97, QSR-Forum@qsr.latrobe.edu.au REFERENCES (Singh,
  62. (1994). Emergence versus Forcing: Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis, Sociology Press,
  63. (1992). Employee commitment and control",
  64. (1998). Employee involvement and the middle manager: evidence from a survey of organizations”, doi
  65. (1982). Employee-Organization Linkages: The Psychology of Commitment, Absenteeism and Turnover. doi
  66. (1997). Employers and Workers come to Terms”, HRMagazine,
  67. (1998). Empowerment: The Emperor’s new clothes”, doi
  68. (1987). Engineering Careers: Women in a male dominated world”, doi
  69. (1992). Engineering Culture: Control and Commitment in a High-Tech Corporation, doi
  70. (1999). Engineering Workforce Commission
  71. (1997). Engineers in Top Management, Institute for Employment Research Report,
  72. (1997). Equal Opportunities for Women and Men in the European Union, doi
  73. (1995). Equal opportunities, equal survival, not political correctness”, doi
  74. (1998). Examining degree of balance and level of obligation in the employment relationship: a social exchange approach”, doi
  75. (1978). Executive and MBA student views of corporate promotion practices: A structural comparison”, doi
  76. (1998). Exploring the conceptual expansion within the field of organizational behavior, organizational climate and organizational culture”, doi
  77. (2000). forthcoming) “Gendered meanings of commitment from high technology engineering managers doi
  78. (1999). forthcoming) “What does “commitment” really mean? Views of British and Swedish engineering managers”, Personnel Review. doi
  79. (1990). Gender and leadership style: A meta-analysis”, doi
  80. (1989). Gender and power in organizations: A longitudinal perspective”, doi
  81. (1991). Gender and work orientation”, doi
  82. (1993). Gender Differences in Organizational Commitment: Influences of Work Positions and Family Roles”, Work and Occupations, doi
  83. (1995). Gender differences in work values: perpetuating the myth”, doi
  84. (1998). Gender gap in the executive suite: CEOs and female executives report on breaking the glass ceiling”, doi
  85. (1992). Gender segregation in the engineering and science professions: a case of continuity and change", doi
  86. (1997). Gender, equality and the culture of organisational assessment”, doi
  87. (1992). Gendering Organizational Theory”. In Albert J. Mills & Peta Tancred (Eds) Gendering Organizational Theory, doi
  88. (1982). Group versus individual performance: Are N+1 heads better than one?”, doi
  89. (1985). Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, Thousand Oaks, doi
  90. (1995). HESA Data Report: Students in Higher Education Institutions, doi
  91. (1988). Homo Academicus, doi
  92. (1996). HRM and employee involvement in Britain and Sweden: A comparative study”, doi
  93. (1997). Human Resource Management and performance: a review and research agenda” doi
  94. (1998). Identifying organizational subcultures: An empirical approach”, doi
  95. (1982). In a Different Voice, doi
  96. (1988). In another country”. doi
  97. (1996). In search of management development in Europe: from self-fulfilling prophesies to organizational competence” doi
  98. (1998). in the Labour Market: Results from the Spring
  99. (1988). Ingratiatory Behavior in Organizational Settings”, doi
  100. (1998). Intellectual capital = competence x commitment”,
  101. (1993). Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Talk, Text and Interaction, doi
  102. (1991). Interrelationships of work commitment constructs”, doi
  103. (1998). Interviewing Women: A Contradiction in
  104. (1994). Investigating the Glass Ceiling Phenomenon: An Empirical Study of Actual Promotions to Top Management”, doi
  105. (1962). Investment in human capital: A theoretical analysis”, doi
  106. (1998). Is the psychological contract worth taking seriously?”, doi
  107. (1977). Issues in the Study of "Professionals" in Organizations: The Case of Scientists and Engineers", Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, doi
  108. (1998). Jet setters: HR and the bottom line”,
  109. (1982). Job Commitment and the Organizational Woman”, Academy of Management Review, doi
  110. (1992). Jobs, authority and earnings among managers: the continuing importance of sex”, doi
  111. (1996). Key Issues in Women’s Work: Female Heterogeneity and the Polarisation of Women’s Employment, doi
  112. (1995). Leadership and Assessment”. doi
  113. (1984). Learning and developing from managerial experience”, doi
  114. (1984). Loose threads and life fabrics: An extended metaphor about personal, professional and organisational lives”.
  115. (1996). Management and the control of technical labour”, doi
  116. (1991). Management Research: An Introduction. doi
  117. (1995). Managerial perceptions of employee commitment to the organisation", doi
  118. (1993). Managing Human Resources and Industrial Relations, doi
  119. (1996). Managing innovation: controlled chaos”,
  120. (1995). Managing the work-nonwork boundary: An assessment of organisational responses”, doi
  121. (1992). Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus, doi
  122. (1962). Men, Management and Mental Health, doi
  123. (1996). Men, Women and Attitudinal Commitment: The Effects of Workplace Experiences and Socialisation”, doi
  124. (1995). Men’s Perceptions of Women and Management, Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, doi
  125. (1961). Modern Organizations, doi
  126. (1996). Muddle in the middle: organisational restructuring and middle management careers”, doi
  127. (1977). Multiple roles and role strain”, doi
  128. (1985). Naturalistic Inquiry, doi
  129. (1981). Negation, Synthesis and Abomination in Rhetoric.
  130. (1995). New Deals: The Revolution in Management Careers, doi
  131. (1990). New hire perceptions of their own and their employer’s obligations: A study of psychological contracts”, doi
  132. (1998). New organisational forms, processes, jobs and psychological contracts”, in
  133. (1993). New Strategies in Social Research, Polity Press: Oxford Layder, doi
  134. (1980). New work attitude measures of trust, organizational commitment and personal needs non-fulfillment”, doi
  135. (1994). On breaking the glass ceiling: The political seasoning of powerful women executives”, doi
  136. (1983). On the etiology of climates”, doi
  137. (1968). One more time. How do you motivate employees?”, doi
  138. (1983). Organisations as culture-bearing milieux”. In
  139. (1989). Organization career systems and employee doi
  140. (1994). Organizational citizenship behavior: Construct definition, measurement and validation”, doi
  141. (1986). Organizational commitment and psychological attachment: The effects of compliance, identification and internalization on prosocial behavior”, doi
  142. (1987). Organizational commitment: Analysis of antecedents”, doi
  143. (1996). Organizational Commitment: Clarifying the Concept and Simplifying the Existing Construct Typology”, doi
  144. (1990). Organizational culture: A behavioural perspective”,
  145. (1996). Organizing for Innovation”, doi
  146. (1994). Patterns of differential assimilation and acculturation for women in business organizations”, doi
  147. (1991). People and organizational culture: A profile comparison approach to assessing person-organization fit”, doi
  148. (1990). Perceived organizational support and employee diligence, commitment and innovation”, doi
  149. (1997). Perceived organizational support and leadermember exchange: a social exchange perspective”, doi
  150. (1997). Performance management and the psychological contract”, doi
  151. (1989). Personal consequences of employee commitment” doi
  152. (1974). Power: A Radical View, doi
  153. (1998). Preparing people for the future: The next agenda for HRM”, doi
  154. (1999). Proactive personality and career success”, doi
  155. (1993). Profiles of commitment: an empirical test”, doi
  156. (1986). Prosocial organizational behaviors”, doi
  157. (1995). Psychological Contracts in Organizations: Understanding Written and Unwritten Agreements, doi
  158. (1999). Putting the balance back into your career”, Sunday Times,
  159. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, doi
  160. (1993). Qualitative Interviewing”. In doi
  161. (1997). Rationalisation, flexibility and the impact of presenteeism on the working lives of senior managers
  162. (1975). Realist philosophy of science”,
  163. (1989). Reciprocity at Work: The Separate yet Inseparable Possibilities for Individual and Organizational Development”. In doi
  164. (1989). Reclaiming Reality: A Critical Introduction to Contemporary Philosophy, Verso: London Blaikie, doi
  165. (1989). Reluctant Managers: Their Work and Lifestyles, doi
  166. (1989). Rhetoric in bureaucratic careers: managing the meaning of management success.” In: doi
  167. (1997). Riding the Waves of Culture: Understanding Cultural Diversity in Business, Nicholas doi
  168. (1994). Role definitions and organizational citizenship behavior: The importance of the employee’s perspective”, doi
  169. (1996). Second European Charter to Promote Women in Politics and Society, European Commission Report,
  170. (1995). Sensemaking in Organizations, Sage: London Werner, doi
  171. (1983). Sex bias in work settings: The Lack of Fit model”,
  172. (1978). Sex differentiation and the social organisation of science”. In doi
  173. (1992). Sex role stereotyping and requisite management characteristics: A cross cultural look”, doi
  174. (1992). Shattering the Glass Ceiling, doi
  175. (1998). Should we have more family-friendly policies? doi
  176. (1995). Social Theory as Science, Routledge & Kegan Paul, doi
  177. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis, Heinemann, Aldershot Cames, I. doi
  178. (1997). Standards and routes to registration - SARTOR, Part 1, Engineering Council,
  179. (1998). Successful professional women in mid-life: how organisations can more effectively understand and respond to the challenges”, doi
  180. (1998). Taking another look at cross-cultural research: rejoinder to Lachman doi
  181. (1992). That’s Not What I Meant! London: Virago Tannen,
  182. (1961). The Achieving Society, doi
  183. (1990). The consequences of organizational commitment: Methodological investigation”, doi
  184. (1997). The content of the psychological contract”, doi
  185. (1995). The Difficult Relationship between Technology and doi
  186. (1993). The Dimensionality and Stability of Organisational Commitment”, Centre for Economic Performance Discussion
  187. (1989). The dual meaning of managerial careers: organizational and individual levels of analysis”, doi
  188. (1993). The dynamics of organizational culture”, doi
  189. (1989). The education and training of chartered engineers for the st century”, Fellowship of Engineering,
  190. (1996). The effect of other-oriented values on decision-making: A test of propositions of a theory of Concern for Others in organizations”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, doi
  191. (1994). The effects of gender and leave of absence on attributions for high performance, perceived organizational commitment and allocation of organizational rewards”, doi
  192. (1998). The effects of organisational citizenship behavior on performance judgements: A field study and a laboratory experiment”, doi
  193. (1995). The Essence of Women in Management, London: Prentice-Hall
  194. (1991). The gender relations of assessment”. In
  195. (1984). The Hardy Executive: Health under Stress,
  196. (1989). The internal and external career: A theoretical and crosscultural doi
  197. (1973). The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays, Basic Books Inc,
  198. (1990). The management of information and impressions: when employees behave opportunistically”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, doi
  199. (1983). The meaning of management and the management of meaning”, doi
  200. (1983). The Measurement of Work Performance: Methods, Theory and Applications”,
  201. (1997). The myth of the generic manager: New personal competencies for new management roles”, doi
  202. (1991). The parochial dinosaur: Organisational science in a global context”, doi
  203. (1959). The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, doi
  204. (1995). The relationship paradox: Gender, homophily and the strength of network ties”,
  205. (1998). The rise and fall of organizational commitment”,
  206. (1994). The Rising Tide: A Report on
  207. (1991). The role of scientists and engineers in the process of technological change”, Engineer Today, Manager Tomorrow Conference, Royal Aeronautical Society,
  208. (1986). The Science Question in Feminism, doi
  209. (1978). The Seasons of a Man’s Life, doi
  210. (1980). The structuring of organizational structures.” doi
  211. (1979). The Structuring of Organizations, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: doi
  212. (1993). The Theory and Measurement of Work Commitment,
  213. (1989). The Validity of Idiographic Research Explanations”, doi
  214. (1996). Think manager - think male. A global phenomenon", doi
  215. (1977). Two sides of commitment”, Paper presented at the National Meeting of the Academy of Management REFERENCES (Singh,
  216. (1960). Understanding Organizational Behaviour, doi
  217. (1984). Using computers in qualitative research”, In:
  218. (1995). Verksamhet efter examen. Statistiska Centralbyrån,
  219. (1994). Waiting for fish to grow feet!”.
  220. (1989). What constitutes a theoretical contribution?”, doi
  221. (1997). What HRM means for gender equality”, doi
  222. (1997). What is a processual analysis?”, doi
  223. (1991). What is engineering?”
  224. (1997). When employees feel betrayed: a model of how psychological contract violation occurs”, doi
  225. (1998). Why workers still identify with organizations”, doi
  226. (1985). Win-Win Performance Management Appraisal: A Problem-Solving Approach”, doi
  227. (1994). Women and Career in Engineering: continuity and change in the organisation”, doi
  228. (1997). Women and careers in engineering: management changes in the work organization”, doi
  229. (1988). Women and mentoring: A review and research agenda”, doi
  230. (1983). Women and science”, doi
  231. (1998). Women are still undervalued”, Workforce,
  232. (1989). Women in engineering: A promise unfulfilled”, doi
  233. (1997). Women in international management: an examination of the role of home country selection processes in influencing the number of women in international management positions”, Unpublished PhD thesis,
  234. (1994). Women in management: Current research issues”. In doi
  235. (1995). Women in project management: Entry into a male domain: A discussion on gender and organisational culture, doi
  236. (1991). Women in the engineering and science professions: employers’ policies and practices”,
  237. (1982). Work Alienation: An Integrative Approach. doi
  238. (1995). Work and Commitment among young professionals: A study of male and female dentists”. Human Relations. doi
  239. (1998). Work and Life: The end of the zerosum game”,
  240. (1995). Work and the family”.
  241. (1989). Work commitment among salaried professionals”, doi
  242. (1987). Work commitment and job satisfaction over three career stages”, doi
  243. (1996). Working time and contract flexibility in the EU, Report for the European Commission,
  244. (1987). Working towards a theory of women’s career development”. In

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.