Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Turbulence modelling of turbulent buoyant jets and compartment fires

By V. E. Sanderson


Turbulent buoyant jets are a major feature in fire hazards. The solution of the Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations through computational fluid dynamic (CFD) techniques allow such flows to be simulated. The use of Reynolds averaging requires an empirical model to close the set of equations, this is known as the turbulence model. This thesis undertakes to investigate linear and nonlinear approaches to turbulence modelling and to apply the knowledge gained to the simulation of compartment fires. The principle contribution of this work is the reanalysis of the standard k- ε turbulence model and the implementation and application of more sophisticated models as applied to thermal plumes. Validation in this work, of the standard k- ε model against the most recent experimental data, counters the established view that the model is inadequate for the simulation of buoyant flows. Examination of previous experimental data suggests that the measurements were not taken in the self-similar region resulting in misleading comparisons with published numerical solutions. This is a significant conclusion that impacts of the general approach taken to modelling turbulence in this field. A number of methods for modelling the Reynolds stresses and the turbulent scalar fluxes have been considered and, in some cases for the first time, are applied to nonisothermal flows. The relative influence of each model has been assessed enabling its performance to be gauged. The results from this have made a valuable contribution to the knowledge in the field and have enabled the acquired experience to be applied to the simulation of compartment fires. The overall conclusion drawn from this thesis is that for the simulation of compartment fires, the most appropriate approach with current computational resources, is still the buoyancy corrected standard k- ε model. However, the turbulence scalar flux should be modelled by the generalised gradient diffusion hypothesis (GGDH) rather than the eddy-diffusivity assumption

Topics: Turbulence modelling, Computational fluid dynamics, Fire plumes
Publisher: School of Mechanical Engineering
Year: 2001
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1994). A comparison of a FLOW3S based fire field model with experimental room fire data, doi
  2. (2001). A comparison of modifed k-ε turbulence models for buoyant plumes, doi
  3. (1993). A comparison of the linear and nonlinear k-ε turbulence models in combustors, doi
  4. A comparison of the use of fire zone and field models for simulating atrium smoke-filling processes, doi
  5. (1984). A critical comparison of a PHOENICS based fire field model with experimental room fire data, doi
  6. (1985). A finite volume method for the prediction of three-dimensional fluid flow in complex ducts, PhD Thesis,
  7. (1991). A half century historical review of the k-ω model. doi
  8. (1999). A low Reynolds number two equation model to predict thermal fields, doi
  9. (1975). A mathematical model for stratified turbulent flows and its application to buoyant jets, doi
  10. (1981). A modified form of the k-e model for predicting wall turbulence, doi
  11. (1997). A modified low-Reynolds-number k-ε models for recirculating flows, doi
  12. (1975). A more general effective-viscosity hypothesis, doi
  13. (1998). A new low-Reynolds-number nonlinear twoequation turbulence model for complex flows, doi
  14. (1995). A nonlinear low-Reynolds-number k-ε model for turbulent separated and reattachment flows - 1. Flow field computations, doi
  15. (1999). A numerical study of atrium fires using derterministic models, doi
  16. (1994). A renormalisation group turbulence model for three-dimensional wall bounded flows,
  17. (1972). A Reynolds stress model of turbulence and its applications to thin shear flows, doi
  18. (1961). A study of the natural convection above a line fire , doi
  19. (1979). A theory for natural convection turbulent boundary layers next to heat vertical surfaces, doi
  20. (1982). A turbulent model for buoyant flows and its application to buoyant jets. (In: Turbulent buoyant jets and plumes), Pergamon, doi
  21. (1996). A two-equation turbulence k-ε model applied to recirculating ventilation flows,
  22. (1994). Achievements & Limitations of modelling and computation of buoyant turbulent flows and heat transfer,
  23. (1993). Advanced combustion science, doi
  24. (1990). Algebraic stress model prediction of a plane vertical plume, doi
  25. (1970). An experimental investigation of natural convection wake above a line heat source, doi
  26. (1980). An experimental investigation of turbulent buoyant plume,
  27. (1995). An introduction to computational fluid dynamics, the finite volume method, Longmann Scientific & Technical,
  28. (1996). An introduction to single point closure, Simulation and Modelling of turbulent flows. Edited by doi
  29. (1997). Application of field model and two-zone model to flashover fire in a full-scale multi-room single level building, doi
  30. (1974). Application of the energy-dissipation model of turbulence to the calculation of flow near a spinning disc, doi
  31. (1994). Assessment of turbulent models for natural convection in enclosures,
  32. (1994). Assessment of turbulent-transport models including non-linear RNG eddy-viscosity formulation and second moment closure for flow over a backwards-facing step, doi
  33. (1973). Buoyancy effects in fluids, doi
  34. (1990). Calculation of turbulent buoyant plumes with Reynolds stress and heat flux transport closure, doi
  35. (1996). Calculation of wall-bounded complex flows and free shear flows, doi
  36. (1997). CFD modelling of combustion and heat transfer in compartment fires, doi
  37. (1999). CFD simulation of a buoyant diffusion flame with a buoyancy modified turbulence model,
  38. (1999). Comments on the role of leakages in the field of modelling of underventilated compartment fires, doi
  39. (1992). Comparing fire models with experimental data,
  40. (1997). Comparing turbulence models for buoyant plume and displacement ventilation simulations, doi
  41. (1995). Comparison of different k-e models for indoor airflow computations, doi
  42. (1994). Comparison of the numerical predictions of horizontal non-isothermal jet in a room with turbulence models-k-e EVM,
  43. (1989). Comparison of turbulence models for the natural convection boundary layer along a heated vertical plate, doi
  44. (1999). Computation of turbulent buoyant flows in enclosures with low-Reynolds-number k-ε models, doi
  45. (1993). Computation of turbulent natural convection in rectangular enclosures with an algebraic flux model, doi
  46. (1993). Computer modelling of compartment fires, doi
  47. (1996). Development and application of a cubic eddyviscosity model of turbulence, doi
  48. (1995). Development and application of a non-linear eddy-viscosity model sensitized to stress and strain invarients,
  49. (1999). Development and validation of an advanced turbulent model for buoyancy driven flows in enclosures, doi
  50. (1996). Diffusion of conserved and reactive scalars behind line sources in homogeneous turbulence, doi
  51. (1986). Doorway flow induced by fire in a compartment, doi
  52. (1942). Equations of turbulence motion of an incompressible fluid, doi
  53. (1990). Evaluation of turbulence models for predicting buoyant flows, doi
  54. (2000). Experimental balances for the second moments for a buoyant plume and their implications on turbulence modelling, doi
  55. (1966). Experimental investigation of laminar free convection flow in air above horizontal wire with constant heat flux, doi
  56. (1994). Experiments on a round turbulent buoyant plume, doi
  57. (1967). Experiments on the buoyant plume above a heated horizontal wire, doi
  58. (1994). Flow and heat transfer in round vertical buoyant jets, doi
  59. (1982). Flow induced by fire in a compartment, doi
  60. (1999). Free boundary conditions for simulating air movement in a big hall induced by a ‘bare cabin’ fire, doi
  61. (1986). Free convection along a heated vertical plate, doi
  62. (1954). Free convection of heat from fine wires,
  63. (1952). Gravitational convection from a boundary source, doi
  64. (1978). Ground effects on pressure fluctuations in the atmospheric boundary layer, doi
  65. (1979). Influence of buoyancy and rotation on equations for the turbulent length scale, 2 nd Symposium on turbulent Shear flows,
  66. (1952). Investigation of turbulent flow in a two-dimensional channel, NACA-TN2123,
  67. (1988). Investigations of round vertical turbulent buoyant jets, doi
  68. (1968). Iterative solution of implicit approximations of multi-dimensional partial differential equations, doi
  69. (1990). k-ε model simulation of vertical buoyant jets and plumes in atmospheric environments,
  70. (1984). Laminar and turbulent natural convection in an enclosed cavity, doi
  71. (1998). Large eddy simulations of smoke movement, doi
  72. (1985). LDA measurements in plane turbulent jets, doi
  73. (1972). Lectures in mathematical models of turbulence, doi
  74. (1937). Limiting laws of freely rising convection currents,
  75. Mathematical modelling of buoyantinduced smoke flow in enclosures, doi
  76. (1983). Mathematical modelling of natural convection in fire – a state of the art review of the field modelling of the variable density turbulence flow, doi
  77. (1989). Measurements in vertical plane turbulent plumes, doi
  78. (1996). Measurements of the structure of self preserving round buoyant turbulent plumes, doi
  79. (1998). Mixing structure of plane self-preserving buoyant turbulent plumes, doi
  80. (1996). Natural Convection in partitioned twodimensional enclosures at high Raleigh numbers, doi
  81. (1991). Natural-convection flow in a square cavity calculated with low-Reynolds number turbulence models, doi
  82. (1996). New low-Reynoldsnumber k- epsilon model including damping effect due to buoyancy in a stratified flow field, doi
  83. (1991). Nonlinear Reynolds stress model for turbulent shear flows, doi
  84. (1990). Nonlinear Reynolds stress models and the Renormalisation group, doi
  85. (1986). Numerical calculation of three-dimensional turbulent natural convection in a cubical enclosure using a two-equation model for turbulence, doi
  86. (1993). Numerical computation of convective dispersion in turbulence buoyant jets, doi
  87. (1990). Numerical determination of wall functions for the turbulent natural convection boundary layer, doi
  88. (1980). Numerical heat transfer and fluid flow, Hemisphere publishing, doi
  89. (1992). Numerical investigation of turbulent plane and buoyant jets, doi
  90. (1995). Numerical Investigation of Turbulent plumes in both ambient and stratified environments, doi
  91. (1989). Numerical prediction of turbulent plane buoyant jets discharging in a stratified stagnant or flowing ocean, doi
  92. (1987). Numerical prediction of turbulent plane jets and forced plumes by use of k-e model of turbulence, doi
  93. (1993). Numerical simulation of thermal plumes, doi
  94. (1993). Numerical studies on the transient behaviour of a fire plume and ceiling jet, doi
  95. (1989). On computation of buoyancy-driven turbulent flows in rectangular enclosures, doi
  96. (1987). On nonlinear K-l and K-e models of turbulence, doi
  97. (1979). On predictions and unified correlations of vertical buoyant jets, doi
  98. (1976). On the calculation of horizontal, turbulent, free shear flows under gravitational influence, doi
  99. On the effect of the internal friction of fluids on the motion of pendulums, doi
  100. (1974). On transition mechanisms in vertical natural convection flow, doi
  101. (1977). Plane turbulent buoyant jet, part 1, integral properties, doi
  102. (1977). Plane turbulent buoyant jet, part 2, turbulence structure, doi
  103. (1974). Plume rise from large thermal source such as dry cooling towers, doi
  104. (1990). Prediction of Anisotropy of the near-wall turbulence with an anisotropic low-Reynolds-number k-ε turbulence model, doi
  105. (1980). Prediction of channel and boundary layer flows with a low-Reynolds number two equation model of turbulence., doi
  106. (1996). Prediction of room air motion by Reynolds-stress models, doi
  107. (1993). Refined flow modelling and turbulence measurements,
  108. (1986). Renormalisation Group Analysis of turbulence 1. Basic Theory, doi
  109. (1989). Renormalisation group analysis of turbulence, doi
  110. (1997). Renormalization group (RG) in turbulence: Historical and comparative perspective,
  111. (1986). Second moment modelling of turbulent buoyant shear flows with elliptic solvers, Significant questions in buoyancy affected enclosure of cavity flows,
  112. (1990). Second-order correction of the k-e model to account for non-isotropic effect due to buoyancy, doi
  113. (1999). Simulation of oil tank fire,
  114. (1999). SOFIE (Simulation of Fires in Enclosures) Version 3.0, Cranfield University, School of Mechanical Enginnering,
  115. (1993). Some further exploration of turbulence models for buoyancy driven flows, Turbulent Shear Flows 8, doi
  116. (1984). Statistical analysis of the deviation of the Reynolds stress from its eddy-viscosity representation, doi
  117. (1994). Structure of round, fully-developed, buoyant plumes, doi
  118. (1994). Structure of the turbulent temperature field of a two-dimensional fire plume,
  119. (1983). Study of vertical plane jets and plumes, doi
  120. (1989). Swaying motion in thermal plumes above a horizontal line heat source, doi
  121. (1986). The axisymmetric buoyant jet – numerical solution for a semi-empirical theory, doi
  122. (1973). The calculation of low-Reynolds number phenomena with a two-equation model of turbulence, doi
  123. (1994). The challenge of fire modelling, doi
  124. (1999). The development and application of group solvers
  125. (1978). The effect of buoyancy on the turbulence structure of vertical round jets, doi
  126. (1999). The effect of vent size on a compartment fire: numerical simulations and validation,
  127. (1974). The numerical computation of turbulence flow, doi
  128. (1972). The prediction of free turbulent boundary layers by use of a two-equation model of turbulence,
  129. (1972). The prediction of laminarisatioin with a two-equation model of turbulence, doi
  130. (1984). The prediction of turbulence jets and plumes by use of the k-W model of turbulence, doi
  131. (1992). The renormalisation group, the ε expansion and derivation of the turbulence models, doi
  132. (1976). The structure of turbulent diffusion in an axisymmetrical thermal plume,
  133. The turbulent buoyant plume in a stratified environment, doi
  134. Théorie de l’Écoulement Tourbillant, Mem. Présentés par Divers Savants Acad.
  135. (1995). Three-dimensional and heat-loss effects on turbulent flow in nominally two-dimensional cavity, doi
  136. (1970). Transport equations in turbulence, doi
  137. (1968). Transport of turbulence energy rate, doi
  138. (1977). Turbulence measurements in an axisymmetric buoyant plume, doi
  139. (1994). Turbulence modelling for CFD, DCW Industries, doi
  140. (1993). Turbulence models and their application in hydraulics: a state of the art review,
  141. (1985). Turbulence models for near-wall an low Reynolds number flows: a review, doi
  142. (1986). Turbulent buoyant air flow in a tall rectangular cavity,
  143. (1992). Turbulent flow past a backward-facing step - a critical evaluation of 2-equation model, doi
  144. Turbulent gravitational convection from maintained and instantaneous sources, doi
  145. Turbulent jets and plumes, doi
  146. (1995). Turbulent penetrative and recirculating flow in a compartment fire, doi
  147. (1941). Turbulente Ausbreitung eines Stromes erhitzter Luft, doi
  148. (1994). Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence model for engineering applications, doi
  149. (1978). Two-equation thermodynamical model for turbulent buoyant flows. Part 1: theory, doi
  150. (1989). Two-equation thermodynamical model for turbulent buoyant flows. Part 2: numerical experiments, doi
  151. (1925). Uber die ausgebildete Turbulenz, doi
  152. (1945). Uber ein neues Formelsystem fur die ausgebildete Turbulenz, doi
  153. Use of computational fluid dynamics for simulating enclosure fires, doi
  154. (1999). Using CFD and Mathematical optimisation to investigate air pollution due to stacks, doi
  155. (1997). Variable density effects in axisymmetric isothermal turbulent jets: a comparison between a first- and second-order turbulence model, doi
  156. (1995). Velocity statistics of round fully developed buoyant turbulent plumes, doi
  157. (1995). Velocity/mixture fraction statistics of round, self preserving buoyant turbulent plumes, doi
  158. (1980). Vertical turbulent buoyant jets: a review of experimental data, Pergamon,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.