Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Ensuring Sustained Beneficial outcomes for water and sanitation (WATSAN) programmes in the developing world.

By Brian Mathew

Abstract

The two objectives of this thesis are firstly to suggest approaches to achieve sustained beneficial outcomes from WATSAN, and secondly how to ‘scale up’ application of these approaches, so that they impact positively on the lives of the millions of people who live without safe water or adequate sanitation. To discover what these approaches are the literature is examined and practical lessons are drawn from two WATSAN programmes in East and Central Africa. The conclusions are presented in the form of a charter for the sustainable development of WATSAN, with nine clauses suggested to guide project and programme managers around the issues that need to be taken into account in this most important of development sectors. The charter’s clauses walk the reader through various stages of WATSAN development, through participatory project identification, need and demand response, sustainable environmental approaches, structured health education, staffing issues, decentralisation, and the practicalities of policy, allowing work to progress at the speed that communities need to acquire ownership whilst at the same time scaling up programme implementation to make a meaningful impact on the MDGs. The global issues of financing the MDGs are also assessed, and the conclusion is that meeting the MDGs is possible in sustainable manner, but only if there is a massive shift in the resources allocated towards those really in need, and a change in the attitudes of the political power brokers to allow this, promoting quality work, to be implemented by integrated teams, in a process orientated, ethos driven way, with WATSAN set as a keystone of wider human development

Publisher: Cranfield University at Silsoe
Year: 2004
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/921
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1993). 16the Decade’s objectives of ‘water and sanitation for all’, and the increases in coverage “barely kept pace with the growth of the population”
  2. (1996). 1999). Village based consultative inventory. BIRWSSP data.
  3. (1999). 2.1 The sustainability chain (adapted from Carter et al,
  4. (2000). 2.1 Timeline The progression can be put in simple terms into a “timeline” with largely technocratic solutions appearing as far back as the 1930’s (Morgan
  5. (2003). 2.2 Partnership Model (adapted from Caplan
  6. (2004). 2.3 The Carter Paradigm
  7. 233Table 9.1 Estimated human and financial resources required to meet the MDGs 2 by 2015. Staff numbers Costs over 10 years Advisors (capacity building) 5 yrs 3,750 $562,500,000 Integrated team staff (software)
  8. (2004). 3 Kenyan term for communal ‘self help’ or fundraising effort for a good cause (Mwangaza,
  9. (1997). 3.1 Map of north-eastern Tanzania, showing the location of Dodoma and the surrounding Regions.
  10. (2002). 3.3 The increase in safe water coverage, Dodoma Region Tanzania (RWE,
  11. (1991). 3.6 WAMMA today helping to serve more than a million people In
  12. (2002). 3.9 Return visits to schemes,
  13. (2003). 35Box 2.3 The five hypotheses used in the WaterAid looking back report with summarised findings. (Blagborough,
  14. (1999). 362.3.3 Issues of impact and sustainability In
  15. (1999). 39Box 2.3 The “sustainability chain” factors
  16. (1996). 3PHAST stands for Participatory Hygiene and Sanitation Transformation, and it is a further development from SARAR and PROWESS, it emerged as a methodology in
  17. 4.3.17 Is there any difference within villages in the level of this commitment, between men and women? Respondent 1: “Before (the programme)1994, but now it is the same”.
  18. (2001). 422.3.5 Evaluation from Kigezi Diocese water and sanitation
  19. (2001). 49Box 2.7 Water System Classification and Respective Remedial Action Honduras. (Trevett,
  20. 5.1 Map of Zimbabwe (Peart et al, 1997) 5.1.2 Project conception The Bikita Integrated Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Project (BIRWSSP) was conceived as part of the national Integrated Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Programme (IRWSSP).
  21. (2000). 5.4.1 Groundwater and abstraction The ground water in Bikita is held in the regolith, a mantle of fragmented and loose material composed of alluvial deposits and weathered
  22. (1997). 5.5.3 Weaknesses of the ‘three tier’ system • The weakness of the three tier system has been its reliance on a central government department to fund and operate it. By
  23. (2000). 5.9 Productive uses of water In
  24. (2001). 51Box 2.8 Factors that contributed to the TOMS system success (Trevett,
  25. (2003). 54Box 2.9 Summary of the driving forces, challenges and strategies of the four partnership types. (Caplan,
  26. 6.1 Monthly production of individual household members at PWP gardens in Bikita, Zimbabwe Garden Number of members m2 per member Value of monthly production per member
  27. (2000). 64Box 2.10 Capital Assets (Lovell,
  28. (1999). 8 Key The Integrated Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Programme - Zimbabwe B/H borehole Summary of Physical Structures Existing in Districts as at 31 December,
  29. (2004). 9.4 Using the private sector in urban areas Millennium Development Goal 7, as well as tackling access to safe drinking water, targets “significant improvement in the lives of 100 million slum dwellers”
  30. (2002). a flexible process with a learning approach Keep process orientated and promote reflective learning (Brockbank,
  31. (1997). A new approach to working with communities.
  32. (1988). A planner manager’s guide to the socio-economic issues involved in rural water projects in the Third World. MA Dissertation, Agricultural Extension and Rural Development Centre,
  33. (2000). According to the United Nations in the year 2000 1.1 billion people lacked safe water and 2.4 billion people lacked adequate sanitation (WHO/UNICEF/WSSCC,
  34. (2004). Address to the 12 th session of the Commission on Sustainable Development
  35. (2004). Adopting the approaches revealed in the Carter Paradigm (Carter,
  36. (2002). After a run of seven years it came to an end in
  37. (2004). Ahead of the curve: why the UN needs the Capacity to think; UN reform: why? what? how?. Lecture organised by the Overseas Development Institute,
  38. (1995). Although there were many useful findings in Narayan’s
  39. (2004). An ecological approach to sanitation in Africa, a compilation of Experiences. CD
  40. (1996). and Sanitation As a result of the 1992 drought DFID, then ODA, provided emergency assistance for water supply to the communal areas through the NGO WaterAid. This was followed up in
  41. (1998). Assess the impact of climate change on water resources.” (European Commission,
  42. (2003). Barriers to reflective practice, the changing nature of higher education. doi
  43. (1997). By the 1980s the down turn in the Tanzanian economy was stretching government resources so much that the centralised operation and maintenance of rural water supplies was no longer sustainable (Jarman et al,
  44. (2001). Capacity building and ownership in decentralised project management.
  45. (2003). Caplan’s work with “Plotting Partnerships: Ensuring Accountability and fostering Innovation”
  46. (1998). Civil service reform in Africa: mixed results after ten years.
  47. (2002). Community led improvement of rural drinking water.
  48. (1993). Community management today: the role of communities in the management of improved water supply systems. IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre. The Hague, The Netherlands.
  49. (1987). Community water supply: the hand pump option. The World Bank, doi
  50. (2003). Community water, community management, from system to service in rural areas. doi
  51. (2002). consistent long lasting support……………………… 3.8.9 Attracting new donors…………………………………………... 3.9 Return visits to schemes,
  52. (1998). Continuing Support Evidence from the field (Bagamuhunda & Kimanzi
  53. (2003). Demand response approach in practice: why sustainability remains elusive. WaterAid discussion document for the Water and Poverty Dialogue at the 3 rd World Water Forum Kyoto, Japan. (also available on the WaterAid website, www.wateraid.org).
  54. Department for International Development: maximising impact in the water sector.
  55. (2004). Departmental report
  56. (2000). Design principles for rural water supply and sanitation; community water and sanitation (CWS) strategy for rural areas and small towns. Draft for discussion www.worldbank.org/html/fpd/water/pdf/fn04.pdf accessed 04/08/03
  57. (1991). Designing SARAR materials: a manual for artists. United Nations Development Programme,
  58. (1998). Developing basement aquifers to generate economic benefits: A case study from southeast 248Zimbabwe. doi
  59. (1994). Diwi Consult and Bureau d’Ingenierie pour le Developpement Rural (BIDR)
  60. (2003). Domestic water quantity, service level and health. WHO/SDE/WSH/03.02. World Health Organisation.
  61. (2003). Drawers of Water 2’, the repeat study of water consumption in East Africa 4 shows average water consumption collected from water sources to be 19.6 l/p/d for un-piped sources, this is up from 11l/p/d in the late 1960’s (Thompson et al,
  62. (2003). Drawers of water II: Assessing change in domestic water use in East Africa. doi
  63. (1972). Drawers of water: domestic water use in East Africa. doi
  64. (1999). Ecological sanitation, a compilation of manuals and experience Volume 1. Mvuramanzi Trust. Zimbabwe
  65. (1991). Effects of improved water supply and sanitation on ascariasis, diarrhoea, dracunculiasis, hookworm infection, schistosomiasis, and trachoma. In:
  66. (1997). Eliminating world poverty: A challenge for the 21 st century.
  67. (2001). Enhancing human development in the HIPC/PRSP Context, progress in the Africa region during 2000. Africa Region Human Development Working Paper Series. World Bank,
  68. (2003). Environmental science, systems and solutions, 3 rd Ed. Jones &
  69. (2002). Epidemiological fact sheets on HIV/AIDS and sexually transmitted infections doi
  70. (1995). Ethics and accountability in the African civil service.
  71. (2002). Fig 5.5 A selection of risks identified by respondents without prompting with comparison between adults in health club areas (Hca) and the control area (Cont.)
  72. (2003). Financing the millennium development goals for domestic water supply and sanitation, A WaterAid Report.
  73. (2003). Financing water for all. Report of the world panel on financing water infrastructure, chaired by Michael Camdessus. World Water Council / 3 rd World Water Forum / Global Water Partnership.
  74. (2003). Flexibility by design: lessons from multi-sector partnerships in water and sanitation Projects. Building Partners for Development.
  75. (2003). Focus on Africa, a critical need. Network for cost effective technologies in water supply and sanitation.
  76. (1997). Four villages were targeted for the survey in four different wards of Bikita District; two of the villages had no health clubs and acted as the control, and two of the villages were chosen where health clubs were present and had been active since
  77. (2004). From plan to action: water supply and sanitation for the poor in Africa. ODI Briefing Paper,
  78. (2001). From the annual PRSP monitoring reports (URT,2000 and URT,
  79. (2000). Global water supply and sanitation assessment
  80. (1998). Guidance manual on water supply and sanitation programmes.
  81. (2003). Halving the number of people without access to safe water by 2015 – a Malawian perspective. A WaterAid Malawi Country Programme Report
  82. (2004). Handpumps, in depth, technology notes.
  83. (1999). Health clubs - hygiene education in Bikita
  84. (2001). health from better hygiene and sanitation practices • Increased income generating ability • Improved gender relations • Reduced domestic violence • Improvement in attitudes to the Diocese of Kigezi and to their Christian faith. (adapted from Morgan et al,
  85. (1986). History and background of the programme The international non-government organisation (INGO) WaterAid has been active in the Dodoma Region of Tanzania since 1983. Its first local partner was the Anglican Diocese of Central Tanganyka. From
  86. (2003). How WaterAid looked back. doi
  87. (1990). Human development report, concept and measurement of human development. doi
  88. (2003). Human development report, millennium development goals: A compact among nations to end human poverty. United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), doi
  89. (2004). iii) Dignity robbed and pain caused by a lack of adequate and private sanitation, especially for women, leads to poor self-esteem and a feeling of hopelessness, which further locks people into poverty (WSSCC,
  90. (1999). Impact and sustainability of community water supply and sanitation programmes in developing countries. doi
  91. (1998). In the light of experience, water policy and usage in Uganda. doi
  92. (2004). In: Listening, to those working with communities in Africa, Asia and Latin America to achieve the UN goals for water and sanitation.
  93. (1993). Integration of community management within the context of overall planning.”
  94. (1998). Interviewing, the art of science. In: Collecting and interpreting qualitative materials.
  95. (2002). Interviews were carried out with a member of each of the district WAMMA teams in
  96. (1988). Lao (abt.551 – 479BC) 1. When the best leaders work is done the people say “we did it for ourselves” Lao Tzu. Translated by Stephen Mitchell
  97. (1993). Lessons highlighted by Carter et al
  98. (1993). Lessons learned from the UN water decade. doi
  99. (2002). Lessons learned in sanitation promotion
  100. (2001). Looking back: The long term impacts of water and sanitation projects. A WaterAid Report,
  101. (2000). Lovell in his book “Productive Water Points in Dryland Areas” doi
  102. (2003). Making an impact in HIV and AIDS, NGO experiences of scaling up. doi
  103. (2000). Malnutrition as an underlying cause of childhood deaths associated with infectious diseases in developing countries.
  104. (2000). Managing the human animal. Texere Publishing. doi
  105. (1994). Managing water as an economic resource. doi
  106. (2002). Manual for fieldworkers: helping communities to help themselves in sustainable improvements to water supply sanitation and hygiene. Republic of Zambia.
  107. (1925). map W SP using using Wells using extr. using P using pop P WP IFWs UFWs TWs TWs points rivers R spring WARD
  108. (1996). Market production of fruits and vegetables in the peri-urban areas of Dar es Salaam. Urban vegetable promotion project (unpublished).
  109. (2000). Members of a water point user committee on their responsibilities (Mahaka,
  110. (2004). Morgan’s conclusions on the use of ecosan (Morgan
  111. (1990). Most practitioners in water and sanitation are familiar with
  112. (2002). Motoring for Change, WaterAid Tanzania evaluation report (unpublished).
  113. (2003). need to commit adequate resources for long-term support and encouragement. (Adapted from Jolly,
  114. (2005). on the IRC website (www.irc.nl) The ownership and management of productive water point gardens in a time of drought, Zimbabwe This Chapter was published
  115. Ord people to people to % % potential Mar-98 Kitch Lat VIP ratio total latrine coverage coverage No. VIPs Ratio VIPs total latrine to build WARD
  116. (2002). paper on “total sanitation” in India examines an approach to tackling sanitation and hygiene issues.
  117. Paul (2003).Dark star safari. doi
  118. (2002). performance of Bush pumps at PWP gardens The bush pumps that we visited were, apart from one, in good shape and had given long years of service. We found one A type bush pump which had repairs made on it in
  119. (2003). Plotting Partnerships: ensuring accountability and fostering innovation. Practitioner Note Series. Building Partners for Development in Water and Sanitation.
  120. (2002). Poverty reduction and water: Watsan and PRSPs in sub Saharan Africa. Water Policy Brief, No 3.WaterAid.
  121. Poverty reduction strategy paper (PRSP). Government Printer. United Republic of Tanzania (URT), Dar es Salaam.
  122. Poverty reduction strategy paper, progress report 2000/01. Government Printer. United Republic of Tanzania (URT), Dar es Salaam,
  123. (2000). Productive water points in dryland areas, guidelines on integrated planning for rural water supply. doi
  124. (2004). Productive water strategies for poverty reduction
  125. (1990). PROWWESS’ Tools for community participation: a manual for training trainers in participatory techniques.
  126. (2002). Reflective learning in practice. doi
  127. (2002). Regional Water Engineer’s data (unpublished). RWE Office,
  128. (1990). Report on visit to Tanzania,
  129. (2004). Rural water supply in Africa. Building blocks for handpump sustainability. Text draft to be published
  130. (1996). Small scale irrigation using collector wells, pilot project – Zimbabwe, Final ODA Report 95/14. Institute of Hydrology.
  131. (2004). Small scale private sector participation in the rural water supply sector, Draft Inception Report.
  132. (1993). So what were the lessons learned from the Decade? Carter
  133. (2003). Southern African humanitarian crisis response. doi
  134. (1998). Sustainable rural livelihoods: a framework for analysis. Working Paper No.72. Institute of Development Studies,
  135. (2003). Table 2.1 Benefits of rural water supply, raised by local communities (Blagborough,
  136. (2004). Table 2.2 Increases in the cropped weight of various vegetables with the use of fossa alterna compost, mixed with poor top soil at a ratio of 1:1, compared to cropped weight of vegetables planted in poor top soil only (Morgan
  137. Table 6.2 Estimates of production from PWP gardens in Bikita, Zimbabwe…………………………………………………… Table 9.1 Estimated human and financial resources required to meet the MDGs by 2015………………………………………………..
  138. (2002). Taken from “Methodologies in WaterAid Tanzania” (Glockner,
  139. (2002). Taking sustainable rural water supply services to scale. A discussion paper. Bank / Netherlands Water Partnership. Water and Sanitation Programme,
  140. (2000). Tanzania looking back study (Unpublished).
  141. (2002). Ten years experience of WAMMA approach WAMMA report (unpublished).
  142. (2001). the “looking back” report To write of sustained beneficial outcomes from WATSAN it is important to understand what those outcomes may be. The WaterAid “Looking Back” report (WaterAid,
  143. (2000). The Bikita Experience”. Video produced by ZIMMEDIA,
  144. (1995). The blair latrine, A builders manual for the 4 bag model and hand washing tank. Mvuramanzi Trust.
  145. (1997). The break through came in early
  146. (2004). The building blocks model
  147. (2000). The bush pump study (unpublished).
  148. (1998). The bush pump: the national standard handpump of Zimbabwe,
  149. The cause of this poor understanding is according to the WSSCC (2004b) a lack of willingness to learn from past failures and listen to those who have pioneered new approaches.
  150. (1995). The contribution of people’s participation, evidence from 121 rural water supply projects. Environmentally Sustainable Development Occasional Paper Series No.1, The World Bank,
  151. (1995). The contribution of people’s participation, Evidence from 121 rural water supply projects”,
  152. (1999). The demographic transition.
  153. (2000). The development of community water supply systems using deep and shallow well handpumps.
  154. (1992). The Dublin statement on water and sustainable development International Conference on Water and the Environment (ICWE)
  155. (1992). The Dublin statement on water and sustainable development. doi
  156. (1999). The experience of villagisation: doi
  157. (2004). The experiment with the ecosan ‘arbor loo’ The project experimented with one cement bag options with the “arbor loo” environmental latrine (Morgan,
  158. (1990). The fifth discipline, the art and practice of the learning organisation. doi
  159. (1989). The importance of involving women – a story from Sudan
  160. (1988). The importance of mistakes. Video Lecture.
  161. (1988). The importance of mistakes” according to Cleese
  162. (1990). The international drinking water supply and sanitation decade (IDWSSD) and WATSAN finance The IDWSSD ran from 1981 until
  163. (2000). The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) Set at the Millennium Summit at the United Nations doi
  164. (1959). The motivation to work. (Re-published
  165. (2004). The ongoing study ‘Watsan and PRSPs in sub-Saharan Africa’ by ODI and WaterAid
  166. (2003). The ownership and management of productive water point gardens in a time of drought – Zimbabwe.
  167. (2003). The productive use of domestic water supplies, How water supplies can play a wider role in livelihood improvement and poverty reduction. Conference proceedings: International symposium on water, poverty and productive uses of water at the household level,
  168. (2003). The right to water. World Health Organisation.
  169. (2001). The SANAA technician in operation and maintenance program in Honduras.
  170. (1983). The scale of the world problem. World Water 83, International Water and Sanitation Congress. Institution of Civil Engineers Conference report.
  171. (2002). The Soozhal initiative: a model for achieving total sanitation in low-income rural areas. Fieldwork Report,
  172. (2003). The three issues that resonate from the WaterAid looking back report (Blagborough,
  173. (1969). The Ujaama or “freedom” villages were formed after Independence in 1961, under a process known as villagisation. Between
  174. The village had to have an active water committee with a banked water maintenance fund.
  175. (1990). The WaterAid programme with Maji prior to 1991 was largely technical and doubts arose over several key areas. To address these concerns an internal evaluation in
  176. (2000). The world at six billion.
  177. (2002). The Zimbabwe experience, lessons from a review of 15 years of the Zimbabwe integrated rural water supply and sanitation programme. Water and Sanitation Programme, Africa Region. World Bank,
  178. (1999). Thinking big:
  179. (2001). This is what we had always wanted, report of the 2001 evaluation of the Kigezi Diocese Water and Sanitation Programme (unpublished).
  180. (1959). This study in many ways complements work undertaken by Fredrick Herzberg in the 1950’s in which it was found that the factors that cause job satisfaction are: achievement, recognition, the work itself, responsibility, advancement and growth
  181. (1996). Time Frame The project with support from the Department of International Development started in
  182. (1998). Towards sustainable water resources management, A Strategic Approach.
  183. (1999). Tyrell and Howsam’s
  184. (1990). Tyrrel and Howsam in their 1993 paper “Lessons learned from the UN Water Decade”, quoted figures from the 1990 Human development report (UNDP,
  185. (2004). UN millennium development goals. doi
  186. (1998). United Nations Children’s Fund doi
  187. (1995). Upgraded well manual for field workers, Mvuramanzi Trust.
  188. (1996). Village mapping in Zimbabwe.
  189. (2004). Vision 21, A shared vision for hygiene, sanitation and water supply and a framework for action. Water Supply and Sanitation Collaborative Council,
  190. (2002). WAMMA programme 10 years after: the factors for success -Tanzania.
  191. (1997). WAMMA: Empowerment in practice.
  192. Water Action Plan. A
  193. (2004). Water and poverty, will the dream of sustainable development be realised?.
  194. (2003). Water and sanitation goals, is progress in the pipeline?
  195. (1985). Water supply and sanitation in the health sector in the Asian Region; information needs and programme priorities. WASH Project, for USAID Asia Bureau.
  196. (2005). Water supply, sanitation and hygiene promotion (Chapter 35).
  197. (1987). Water use and health Mueda, doi
  198. (1978). Water, health and development; an interdisciplinary evaluation.
  199. (2002). WaterAid Chairman’s report
  200. (1999). what they are The health club approach revolved around community health clubs formed at village level, where villagers were encouraged to join a structured weekly course of participatory health education classes (Waterkeyn,
  201. (2004). Why plan with people?
  202. (1986). Women and the transport of water. doi
  203. (2002). work from Honduras, Central America
  204. (2001). Work undertaken by Trevett in Central America in

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.