Location of Repository

The Spatial Distribution of Physicians in the United States: A Review of the Literature

By J.R. Butler

Abstract

One manifestation of a contemporary concern with equality in the provision of health care services is the growing interest that appears to be developing in the spatial location of medical manpower. There is no evidence that any\ud country has ever achieved, much less sustained, a statistical balance between the spatial distribution of its population and its stock of medical manpower, yet increasingly the judgement appears to be made that imbalances are excessive and should be corrected. Indeed, although some imbalance is inevitable in any country, whatever its methods of organising health care delivery or remunerating physicians, countries with quite small variations in physician-population ratios (PPRs) seem as ready to perceive a distributional problem as those with gross imbalances. Variations of up to ten-fold are not uncommon between the PPRs of urban and rural areas in many countries (WHO, 1976), yet the difference between the average list sizes of primary care physicians in the best and worst areas in England in 1970, when financial incentives to encourage the movement of physicians to under-serviced areas were increased, was only one and a half-fold (Butler, et. al, 1973). There are special historical reasons\ud why the notion of inequality may be defined more rigorously in Britain than in many other countries, but attempts by governmental and other agencies to influence the locational decisions of physicians appear to be widespread (Glaser, 1976). Together with this burgeoning policy interest in the spatial distribution of medical manpower has been a similar growth in the academic study of the nature, causes and possible solutions to the 'problem' of maldistribution, much of it of American origin. This paper is an attempt\ud by an outside observer to summarise the American literature on the theme and to offer some comments on the problems and potentialities of current research

Topics: RA0421
Publisher: Health Services Research Unit
Year: 1977
OAI identifier: oai:kar.kent.ac.uk:24409

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1975). Annals of 'Health manpower: Internal Medicine, numbers, distribution, doi
  2. (1976). area', Medical Care, 7,~, 288-29~ 'Dental manpower in
  3. (1969). Association of American Medical Colleges. discussions at the 79th annual meeting Education.
  4. (1960). Attractins physicians to smaller 3~, 14, ~9-51 World health statistics annual.
  5. (1973). Community-structure constraints on distribution of physicians',
  6. (1975). Community, physicians and inequality, l1assachusetts: • ..
  7. (1973). Determinants of physician office doi
  8. (1969). distance as a factor in accessibility
  9. (1966). Distribution of physicians in the US Bureau of Chicago:
  10. (1973). Do new hospitals attract new doctors?',
  11. (1973). F.:;am;:;~:::· l::oY,-=d;:;o.;;ct..:,o;:,;rs;.;:...;:an=d Kegan Paul - -•
  12. (1942). Location and movement of physicians, 1923-1938: general observations', Public Health Reports, doi
  13. (1965). location trends in the United States', 182-194 'Income opportunities and physician l;estern doi
  14. (1974). Maldistribution of physicians :::J:::o:.::urn::.::::::al=-.::o;:;f....:.:Me=d;:;i.:::c.:::a=l-'E::.d.:::u.:::c:::a::.t:::;~::.·
  15. (1968). Medical education in the United States'.
  16. (1960). medical education program',
  17. (1974). metropolitan areas', doi
  18. (1971). Physician behaviour in Southern Appalachia: some recruitment factors'. doi
  19. (1973). Physician migration from inland to coastal states: antipodal examples of Illinois and California'. doi
  20. (1955). physicians in Upstate New York', doi
  21. (1963). Prentice Hall Medical Care and family security. Englewood Cliffs NJ: •
  22. (1975). rural training programs on physicians doi
  23. (1976). Sharing resources for London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office • -•
  24. (1969). Social, economic and demographic factors affecting physician population in tJpstate
  25. (1963). spatial distribution of physicians in doi
  26. (1971). The city and the region', doi
  27. (1972). The distribution of physicians'. doi
  28. (1941). The emigre Fhysician in America', doi
  29. (1973). The medical economy', Scientific American, ~lilbank

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.