"Published online: 03 Apr. 2013"The paper is concerned with the comparative analysis of interactive devices. It compares two devices by checking a battery of template properties that are designed to explore important interface characteristics. The two devices are designed to support similar tasks in a clinical setting but differ in a number of respects as a result of judgements based on a range of considerations including software. Variations between designs are often relatively subtle and do not always become evident through even relatively thorough user testing. Notwithstanding their subtlety these differences may be important to the safety or usability of the device. The illustrated approach uses formal techniques to provide the analysis. This means that similar analysis can be applied systematically.This project was partly funded by the CHI+MED project: Multidisciplinary Computer Human Interaction Research for the design and safe use of interactive medical devices (UK EPSRC Grant EP/G059063/1). Patrick Oladimeji of Swansea University provided help with the Alaris pump and Chris Vincent of UCL provided access to the B. Braun simulation. We are grateful to reviewers for helpful comments
