The short ranged antiferromagnetism recently seen in UPt_3 is proved
incompatible with two dimensional (2D) order parameter models that take the
antiferromagnetism as a symmetry breaking field. To adjust to the local moment
direction, the order parameter twists over very long length scales as per the
Imry-Ma argument. A variational solution to the Ginzburg-Landau equations is
used to study the nature of the short ranged order. Although there are still
two transitions, the lower one is of first order -- in contradiction to
experiments. It is shown that the latent heat predicted by the 2D models at the
lower transition is too large not to have been seen. A simple periodic model is
numerically studied to show that the lower transition can not be a crossover
either.Comment: To appear in Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter. 9 pages, 2 figure