Directional limits on persistent gravitational waves using data from Advanced LIGO's first two observing runs
- Authors
- A,
- A,
- A,
- A,
- A,
- T. A
- B. P Abbott
- R Abbott
- T. D Abbott
- Abhirup and Ghosh,
- S Abraham
- F Acernese
- K Ackley
- C Adams
- R. X Adhikari
- V. B Adya
- C Affeldt
- M Agathos
- K Agatsuma
- N Aggarwal
- O. D Aguiar
- L Aiello
- A Ain
- P Ajith
- G Allen
- A Allocca
- M. A Aloy
- P. A Altin
- A Amato
- A Ananyeva
- S. B Anderson
- W. G Anderson
- Angelova,
- S Antier
- S Appert
- K Arai
- M. C Araya
- Archisman and Ghosh,
- J. S Areeda
- M Arene
- N Arnaud
- Arunava and Mukherjee,
- S Ascenzi
- G Ashton
- S. M Aston
- P Astone
- F Aubin
- P Aufmuth
- K AultONeal
- C Austin
- Avendano,
- B,
- B,
- D. B
- J B. J.
- S Babak
- P Bacon
- F Badaracco
- M. K. M Bader
- S Bae
- P. T Baker
- F Baldaccini
- G Ballardin
- S. W Ballmer
- S Banagiri
- J. C Barayoga
- S. E Barclay
- B. C Barish
- D Barker
- K Barkett
- S Barnum
- F Barone
- B Barr
- L Barsotti
- M Barsuglia
- D Barta
- J Bartlett
- Bartos,
- A Basti
- M Bawaj
- J. C Bayley
- M Bazzan
- B Becsy
- M Bejger
- Belahcene,
- D Beniwal
- B. K Berger
- G Bergmann
- S Bernuzzi
- J. J Bero
- C. P. L Berry
- D Bersanetti
- A Bertolini
- J Betzwieser
- R Bhandare
- J Bidler
- I. A Bilenko
- S. A Bilgili
- G Billingsley
- J Birch
- R Birney
- O Birnholtz
- S Biscans
- S Biscoveanu
- A Bisht
- M Bitossi
- M. A Bizouard
- J. K Blackburn
- C. D Blair
- D. G Blair
- R. M Blair
- S Bloemen
- N Bode
- M Boer
- Y Boetzel
- G Bogaert
- F Bondu
- E Bonilla
- R Bonnand
- P Booker
- B. A Boom
- C. D Booth
- R Bork
- Boschi,
- K Bossie
- Bossilkov,
- Y Bouffanais
- A Bozzi
- C Bradaschia
- P. R Brady
- A Bramley
- M Branchesi
- J. E Brau
- T Briant
- J. H Briggs
- F Brighenti
- A Brillet
- M Brinkmann
- Brisson,
- A. F Brooks
- D. D Brown
- S Brunett
- A Buikema
- T Bulik
- H. J Bulten
- A Buonanno
- D Buskulic
- Bustillo,
- C Buy
- R. L Byer
- C,
- C,
- C,
- C,
- E. C
- J. C
- C-J and Haughian,
- M Cabero
- L Cadonati
- G Cagnoli
- C Cahillane
- J. Caldern and Callister
- E Calloni
- J. B Camp
- W. A Campbell
- M Canepa
- K. C Cannon
- H Cao
- J Cao
- E Capocasa
- F Carbognani
- S Caride
- M. F Carney
- G Carullo
- J. Casanueva and Casentini
- Castro,
- S Caudill
- M Cavaglia
- F Cavalier
- R Cavalieri
- G Cella
- P Cerda-Duran
- G Cerretani
- E Cesarini
- O Chaibi
- K Chakravarti
- S. J Chamberlin
- M Chan
- S Chao
- P Charlton
- E. A Chase
- E Chassande-Mottin
- D Chatterjee
- M Chaturvedi
- B. D Cheeseboro
- H. Y Chen
- X Chen
- Y Chen
- Cheng,
- H. Y Chia
- A Chincarini
- A Chiummo
- G Cho
- H. S Cho
- M Cho
- N Christensen
- Q Chu
- S Chua
- K. W Chung
- S Chung
- Chunglee and Kim,
- G Ciani
- A. A Ciobanu
- R Ciolfi
- F Cipriano
- A Cirone
- F Clara
- J. A Clark
- P Clearwater
- F Cleva
- C Cocchieri
- E Coccia
- Cohadon,
- R Colgan
- M Colleoni
- C. G Collette
- C Collins
- L. R Cominsky
- M Constancio Jr
- L Conti
- S. J Cooper
- P Corban
- T. R Corbitt
- Cordero-Carrion,
- N Cornish
- A Corsi
- S Cortese
- Costa,
- C. A Costa
- R Cotesta
- M. W Coughlin
- S. B Coughlin
- Coulon,
- P Couvares
- P. B Covas
- E. E Cowan
- D. M Coward
- M. J Cowart
- D. C Coyne
- R Coyne
- J. D. E Creighton
- T. D Creighton
- J Cripe
- M Croquette
- S. G Crowder
- T. J Cullen
- A Cumming
- L Cunningham
- E Cuoco
- D&apos
- D,
- D,
- D,
- D,
- D,
- Wu D. S
- C. F. Da Silva and Datrier
- T Dal Canton
- G Dalya
- S. L Danilishin
- K Danzmann
- A Dasgupta
- Dattilo,
- D Davis
- E. J Daw
- M De Laurentis
- R De Pietri
- R De Rosa
- C De Rossi
- O de Varona
- D DeBra
- M Deenadayalan
- J Degallaix
- W Del Pozzo
- S Deleglise
- L. M DeMarchi
- N Demos
- T Dent
- J Derby
- R DeSalvo
- S Dhurandhar
- L Di Fiore
- M Di Giovanni
- T Di Girolamo
- A Di Lieto
- S Di Pace
- Diaz,
- M. C Diaz
- T Dietrich
- B Ding
- A Dmitriev
- Z Doctor
- F Donovan
- K. L Dooley
- S Doravari
- Dorrington,
- M Drago
- J. C Driggers
- Z Du
- Ducoin,
- Dvorkin,
- S. E
- P. J Easter
- T. B Edo
- M. C Edwards
- A Effler
- P Ehrens
- J Eichholz
- S. S Eikenberry
- M Eisenmann
- R. A Eisenstein
- R. C Essick
- H Estelles
- D Estevez
- Z. B Etienne
- T Etzel
- M Evans
- T. M Evans
- F,
- Fafone,
- S Fairhurst
- X Fan
- S Farinon
- B Farr
- W. M Farr
- E. J Fauchon-Jones
- M Favata
- M Fays
- M Fazio
- C Fee
- J Feicht
- M. M Fejer
- F Feng
- A Fernandez-Galiana
- Ferrante,
- T. A Ferreira
- F Ferrini
- F Fidecaro
- Fiori,
- M Fishbach
- R. P Fisher
- J. M Fishner
- M Fitz-Axen
- R Flaminio
- M Fletcher
- E Flynn
- H Fong
- J. A Font
- P. W. F Forsyth
- Fournier,
- Francisco Hernandez and Heurs,
- F Frasconi
- Z Frei
- A Freise
- Frey,
- R Frey
- V. V Frolov
- P Fulda
- M Fyffe
- G,
- H. A Gabbard
- B. U Gadre
- S. M Gaebel
- J. R Gair
- L Gammaitoni
- M. R Ganija
- S. G Gaonkar
- A Garcia
- C Garcia-Quiros
- F Garufi
- B Gateley
- S Gaudio
- G Gaur
- Gayathri,
- E Genin
- A Gennai
- D George
- J George
- L Gergely
- Germain,
- Ghosh,
- B Giacomazzo
- J. A Giaime
- K. D Giardina
- A Giazotto
- K Gill
- G Giordano
- L Glover
- P Godwin
- E Goetz
- R Goetz
- B Goncharov
- J. M. Gonzalez and Gopakumar
- G Gonzlez
- M. L Gorodetsky
- S. E Gossan
- M Gosselin
- R Gouaty
- A Grado
- C Graef
- M Granata
- A Grant
- S Gras
- P Grassia
- C Gray
- R Gray
- G Greco
- A. C Green
- R Green
- E. M Gretarsson
- P Groot
- H Grote
- S Grunewald
- P Gruning
- G. M Guidi
- H. K Gulati
- Y Guo
- A Gupta
- M. K Gupta
- E. K Gustafson
- R Gustafson
- H,
- H-P and Cheong,
- L Haegel
- O Halim
- B. R Hall
- E. D Hall
- E. Z Hamilton
- G Hammond
- M Haney
- Hang and Yu,
- M. M Hanke
- J Hanks
- C Hanna
- O. A Hannuksela
- J Hanson
- Haocun and Yuen,
- T Hardwick
- K Haris
- J Harms
- G. M Harry
- I. W Harry
- Haster,
- F. J Hayes
- J Healy
- A Heidmann
- M. C Heintze
- H Heitmann
- P Hello
- G Hemming
- M Hendry
- I. S Heng
- J Hennig
- A. W Heptonstall
- S Hild
- T Hinderer
- D Hoak
- S Hochheim
- D Hofman
- A. M Holgado
- N. A Holland
- K Holt
- D. E Holz
- P Hopkins
- C Horst
- J Hough
- E. J Howell
- C. G Hoy
- A Hreibi
- Huang-Wei and Pang,
- E. A Huerta
- D Huet
- B Hughey
- M Hulko
- S Husa
- S. H Huttner
- T Huynh-Dinh
- I and Bassiri,
- I and Bell,
- I and Corley,
- I and Davier,
- I and Di Renzo,
- I and Downes,
- I and Dwyer,
- I and Ferreira,
- I and Fiorucci,
- I and Khan,
- I and Kozak,
- I and Malik,
- I and Naticchioni,
- I,
- I,
- B Idzkowski
- A Iess
- C Ingram
- R Inta
- G Intini
- B Irwin
- H. N Isa
- Isac,
- B. R Iyer
- K Izumi
- J,
- J,
- P. J
- J-D and Frasca,
- J-G and Dupej,
- J-M and Isi,
- J-P and Countryman,
- J-P and Zevin,
- J-Y and Vitale,
- Oh J. J
- T Jacqmin
- S. J Jadhav
- K Jani
- N. N Janthalur
- P Jaranowski
- Javed and Rao,
- A. C Jenkins
- J Jiang
- D. S Johnson
- Jones,
- A. W Jones
- R Jones
- R. J. G Jonker
- L Ju
- J Junker
- K,
- K,
- K,
- K,
- C. K
- Li K. J. L
- Ng K. Y
- Kalaghatgi,
- Kalogera,
- S Kandhasamy
- G Kang
- J. B Kanner
- S. J Kapadia
- S Karki
- K. S Karvinen
- R Kashyap
- M Kasprzack
- S Katsanevas
- E Katsavounidis
- W Katzman
- S Kaufer
- K Kawabe
- Keerthana,
- F Kefelian
- D Keitel
- R Kennedy
- J. S Key
- F. Y Khalili
- Khan,
- H Khan
- Z Khan
- E. A Khazanov
- M Khursheed
- N Kijbunchoo
- Kim,
- Kim,
- K Kim
- W Kim
- W. S Kim
- E. J King
- P. J King
- M Kinley-Hanlon
- R Kirchhoff
- J. S Kissel
- L Kleybolte
- J. H Klika
- S Klimenko
- T. D Knowles
- P Koch
- S. M Koehlenbeck
- G Koekoek
- S Koley
- Kondrashov,
- N Koper
- M Korobko
- W. Z Korth
- Kowalska,
- Kringel,
- A Krolak
- G Kuehn
- A Kumar
- P Kumar
- R Kumar
- S Kumar
- L Kuo
- A Kutynia
- S Kwang
- L,
- G. L
- L-W and Weinert,
- H L. E.
- B. D Lackey
- K. H Lai
- T. L Lam
- M Landry
- B. B Lane
- R. N Lang
- J Lange
- B Lantz
- R. K Lanza
- A Lartaux-Vollard
- P. D Lasky
- M Laxen
- A Lazzarini
- C Lazzaro
- H Lck
- P Leaci
- S Leavey
- Y. K Lecoeuche
- C. H Lee
- H. K Lee
- H. M Lee
- H. W Lee
- J Lee
- K Lee
- J Lehmann
- A Lenon
- N Leroy
- N Letendre
- Y Levin
- J Li
- X Li
- LIGO Sci Collaboration and Virgo Collaboration,
- F Lin
- F Linde
- S. D Linker
- T. B Littenberg
- J Liu
- X Liu
- N. A Lockerbie
- L. T London
- A Longo
- M Lorenzini
- Loriette,
- G Losurdo
- J. D Lough
- C. O Lousto
- G Lovelace
- M. E Lower
- D Lumaca
- A. P Lundgren
- R Lynch
- M,
- M,
- M,
- M,
- M,
- M,
- M,
- R. M
- Y Ma
- R Macas
- S Macfoy
- M MacInnis
- D. M Macleod
- A Macquet
- L. Magana and Magee
- F Magana-Sandoval
- E Majorana
- Maksimovic,
- N Man
- Mandic,
- M Manske
- M Mantovani
- F Marchesoni
- F Marion
- S Marka
- Z Marka
- C Markakis
- A. S Markosyan
- A Markowitz
- E Maros
- A Marquina
- S Marsat
- F Martelli
- I. W Martin
- R. M Martin
- Martynov,
- K Mason
- E Massera
- A Masserot
- T. J Massinger
- M Masso-Reid
- S Mastrogiovanni
- A Matas
- F Matichard
- L Matone
- N Mavalvala
- N Mazumder
- J. J McCann
- R McCarthy
- D. E McClelland
- S McCormick
- L McCuller
- S. C McGuire
- J McIver
- D. J McManus
- T McRae
- S. T McWilliams
- D Meacher
- G. D Meadors
- M Mehmet
- A. K Mehta
- J Meidam
- A Melatos
- G Mendell
- R. A Mercer
- L Mereni
- E. L Merilh
- M Merzougui
- S Meshkov
- C Messenger
- C Messick
- R Metzdorff
- P. M Meyers
- H Miao
- C Michel
- H Middleton
- E. E Mikhailov
- L Milano
- A Miller
- A. L Miller
- M Millhouse
- J. C Mills
- M. C Milovich-Goff
- O Minazzoli
- Y Minenkov
- A Mishkin
- C Mishra
- T Mistry
- S Mitra
- V. P Mitrofanov
- G Mitselmakher
- R Mittleman
- G Mo
- D Moffa
- K Mogushi
- S. R. P Mohapatra
- M Montani
- C. J Moore
- D Moraru
- G Moreno
- S Morisaki
- B Mours
- C. M Mow-Lowry
- Mukherjee,
- S Mukherjee
- N Mukund
- A Mullavey
- J Munch
- E. A Muniz
- M Muratore
- P. G Murray
- N,
- N,
- A Nagar
- Nardecchia,
- R. K Nayak
- J Neilson
- G Nelemans
- T. J. N Nelson
- M Nery
- A Neunzert
- S Ng
- P Nguyen
- D Nichols
- S Nissanke
- F Nocera
- C North
- L. K Nuttall
- O&apos
- O&apos
- O&apos
- O&apos
- M Obergaulinger
- J Oberling
- G. H Ogin
- F Ohme
- H Ohta
- M. A Okada
- M Oliver
- P Oppermann
- Richard J Oram
- R. G Ormiston
- L. F Ortega
- S Ossokine
- D. J Ottaway
- H Overmier
- B. J Owen
- P,
- P,
- P,
- T. P
- P-F and Cohen,
- A. E Pace
- G Pagano
- M. A Page
- A Pai
- S. A Pai
- A Pal-Singh
- J. R Palamos
- O Palashov
- Di Palma
- C Palomba
- Pan,
- P. T. H Pang
- C Pankow
- F Pannarale
- B. C Pant
- F Paoletti
- A Paoli
- A Parida
- W Parker
- D Pascucci
- A Pasqualetti
- R Passaquieti
- D Passuello
- M Patil
- B Patricelli
- B. L Pearlstone
- C Pedersen
- M Pedraza
- R Pedurand
- A Pele
- S Penn
- C. J Perez
- A Perreca
- H. P Pfeiffer
- M Phelps
- K. S Phukon
- O. J Piccinni
- M Pichot
- F Piergiovanni
- G Pillant
- L Pinard
- M Pirello
- M Pitkin
- R Poggiani
- D. Y. T Pong
- S Ponrathnam
- P Popolizio
- E. K Porter
- J Powell
- A. K Prajapati
- J Prasad
- K Prasai
- R Prasanna
- G Pratten
- T Prestegard
- S Privitera
- G. A Prodi
- L. G Prokhorov
- M Prrer
- O Puncken
- M Punturo
- P Puppo
- H Qi
- Quetschke,
- E. A Quintero
- R Quitzow-James
- R,
- J. R
- K. R
- Lo R. K. L
- F. J Raab
- H Radkins
- N Radulescu
- P Raffai
- S Raja
- C Rajan
- B Rajbhandari
- M Rakhmanov
- K. E Ramirez
- A Ramos-Buades
- Rana,
- P Rapagnani
- Raymond,
- J Read
- T Regimbau
- L Rei
- S Reid
- D. H Reitze
- W Ren
- F Ricci
- C. J Richardson
- J. W Richardson
- P. M Ricker
- K Riles
- M Rizzo
- N. A Robertson
- R Robie
- F Robinet
- A Rocchi
- L Rolland
- J. G Rollins
- V. J Roma
- M Romanelli
- J. D Romano
- R Romano
- C. L Romel
- J. H Romie
- K Rose
- D Rosinska
- S. G Rosofsky
- M. P Ross
- S Rowan
- A Ruediger
- P Ruggi
- G Rutins
- K Ryan
- S,
- S,
- S,
- S,
- S,
- S,
- S,
- A. S
- Oh S. H
- R S. H.
- S Sachdev
- T Sadecki
- M Sakellariadou
- L Salconi
- M Saleem
- A Samajdar
- L Sammut
- E. J Sanchez
- L. E Sanchez
- N Sanchis-Gual
- Sandberg,
- K. A Santiago
- N Sarin
- B Sassolas
- P. R Saulson
- O Sauter
- R. L Savage
- P Schale
- M Scheel
- J Scheuer
- P Schmidt
- R Schnabel
- A Schoenbeck
- R. M. S Schofield
- E Schreiber
- B. W Schulte
- B. F Schutz
- S. G Schwalbe
- J Scott
- S. M Scott
- E Seidel
- D Sellers
- A. S Sengupta
- N Sennett
- D Sentenac
- Sequino,
- Y Setyawati
- D. A Shaddock
- T Shaffer
- M. S Shahriar
- M. B Shaner
- L Shao
- P Sharma
- P Shawhan
- H Shen
- R Shink
- D. H Shoemaker
- D. M Shoemaker
- Shubhanshu and Tiwari,
- S ShyamSundar
- K Siellez
- M Sieniawska
- D Sigg
- A. D Silva
- L. P Singer
- N Singh
- A Singhal
- A. M Sintes
- S Sitmukhambetov
- Skliris,
- T. J Slaven-Blair
- J. R Smith
- R. J. E Smith
- S Somala
- E. J Son
- B Sorazu
- F Sorrentino
- T Souradeep
- E Sowell
- A. P Spencer
- Srishti and Tiwari,
- Srivastava,
- A. K Srivastava
- C Stachie
- M Standke
- D. A Steer
- M Steinke
- J Steinlechner
- S Steinlechner
- D Steinmeyer
- S. P Stevenson
- D Stocks
- R Stone
- D. J Stops
- K. A Strain
- G Stratta
- S. E Strigin
- A Strunk
- R Sturani
- A. L Stuver
- Sudhir,
- L Sun
- S Sunil
- J Suresh
- P. J Sutton
- B. L Swinkels
- M. J Szczepanczyk
- S. T
- Li T. G. F
- M Tacca
- S. C Tait
- C Talbot
- D Talukder
- D. B Tanner
- M Tapai
- A Taracchini
- J. D Tasson
- R Taylor
- F Thies
- M Thomas
- P Thomas
- S. R Thondapu
- K. A Thorne
- E Thrane
- Tiwari,
- M Tonelli
- Z Tornasi
- A Torres-Forne
- Torrie,
- D Toyra
- F Travasso
- G Traylor
- M. C Tringali
- A Trovato
- L Trozzo
- R Trudeau
- K. W Tsang
- M Tse
- R Tso
- L Tsukada
- D Tsuna
- D Tuyenbayev
- K Ueno
- D Ugolini
- C. S Unnikrishnan
- A. L Urban
- S. A Usman
- V and Avila-Alvarez,
- V and Bose,
- V and Bosveld,
- V and Brockill,
- V and Dave,
- V and Fair,
- V and Fritschel,
- V and Gemme,
- V and Ghonge,
- V and Kamai,
- V and Kontos,
- V and Krishnendu,
- V and Lormand,
- V and Mangano,
- V and Mansell,
- V and Quinonez,
- V and Razzano,
- V and Sanders,
- V and Sergeev,
- V and Slagmolen,
- V and Staats,
- V and Summerscales,
- V and Toland,
- V,
- V,
- V,
- V,
- V,
- H Vahlbruch
- G Vajente
- G Valdes
- N van Bakel
- M van Beuzekom
- J. F. J van den Brand
- C Van Den Broeck
- L van der Schaaf
- A. A van Veggel
- Heijningen Van
- D. C Vander-Hyde
- M Vardaro
- V Varma
- S Vass
- M Vasuth
- A Vecchio
- G Vedovato
- J Veitch
- P. J Veitch
- K Venkateswara
- G Venugopalan
- D Verkindt
- F Vetrano
- A Vicere
- A. D Viets
- D. J Vine
- Vinet,
- Vivanco,
- T Vo
- H Vocca
- C Vorvick
- S. P Vyatchanin
- A. R Wade
- L. E Wade
- M Wade
- R Walet
- M Walker
- L Wallace
- S Walsh
- G Wang
- H Wang
- J. Z Wang
- W. H Wang
- Y. F Wang
- R. L Ward
- Z. A Warden
- J Warner
- M Was
- J Watchi
- B Weaver
- Wei,
- A. J Weinstein
- R Weiss
- F Wellmann
- L Wen
- E. K Wessel
- P Wessels
- J. W Westhouse
- K Wette
- J. T Whelan
- B. F Whiting
- C Whittle
- D. M Wilken
- D Williams
- A. R Williamson
- J. L Willis
- B Willke
- M. H Wimmer
- W Winkler
- C. C Wipf
- H Wittel
- G Woan
- J Woehler
- J. K Wofford
- J Worden
- J. L Wright
- D. M Wysocki
- L Xiao
- R Xu
- Y-M and Kimball,
- H Yamamoto
- C. C Yancey
- L Yang
- M. J Yap
- M Yazback
- D. W Yeeles
- Yu,
- M Yvert
- T. Z
- A. K Zadrozny
- M Zanolin
- T Zelenova
- Zendri,
- Zertuche,
- J Zhang
- L Zhang
- T Zhang
- C Zhao
- M Zhou
- Z Zhou
- X. J Zhu
- M. E Zucker
- J Zweizig
- Publication date
- 1 January 2019
- Publisher
- 'American Physical Society (APS)'
- Doi
Abstract
We perform an unmodeled search for persistent, directional gravitational wave (GW) sources using data from the first and second observing runs of Advanced LIGO. We do not find evidence for any GW signals. We place limits on the broadband GW flux emitted at 25 Hz from point sources with a power law spectrum at F-alpha,F-Theta < (0.05-25) x 10(-8) erg cm(-2) s(-1) Hz(-1) and the (normalized) energy density spectrum in GWs at 25 Hz from extended sources at Omega(alpha)(Theta) < (0.19-2.89) x 10(-8) sr(-1) where alpha is the spectral index of the energy density spectrum. These represent improvements of 2.5-3x over previous limits. We also consider point sources emitting GWs at a single frequency, targeting the directions of Sco X-1, SN 1987A, and the Galactic center. The best upper limits on the strain amplitude of a potential source in these three directions range from h(0) < (3.6-4.7) x 10(-)(25), 1.5x better than previous limits set with the same analysis method. We also report on a marginally significant outlier at 36.06 Hz. This outlier is not consistent with a persistent gravitational-wave source as its significance diminishes when combining all of the available dataSimilar works
Available Versions
Last time updated on 28/01/2020
Last time updated on 25/10/2022