Batek Negritos from the vicinity of Taman Negara National Park in West Malaysia are a hunting and gathering people presently experiencing rapid encroachment by the modern world. Under the authority of the Malaysian government, they are being encouraged to settle and to emulate Malay subsistence farming communities. Unfortunately, this strategy has had a number of adverse effects on the Batek

Faulstich, Paul

Scholarship@Claremont

Claremont CollegesScholarship @ ClaremontPitzer Faculty Publications and Research Pitzer Faculty Scholarship10-1-1985The Taman Negara Batek: A People in TransitionPaul FaulstichPitzer CollegeThis Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Pitzer Faculty Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusionin Pitzer Faculty Publications and Research by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contactscholarship@cuc.claremont.edu.Recommended CitationFaulstich, Paul. The Taman Negara Batek: A People in Transition. Cultural Survival Quarterly, 9(3): 33-35, 1985.Published on Cultural Survival (https://www.culturalsurvival.org)Home > The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition[1] [1]Batek Negritos from the vicinity of Taman Negara National Park in WestMalaysia are a hunting and gathering people presently experiencing rapidencroachment by the modern world. Under the authority of the Malaysiangovernment, they are being encouraged to settle and to emulate Malaysubsistence farming communities. Unfortunately, this strategy has had anumber of adverse effects on the Batek.Traditionally, Batek subsisted primarily on gathered tubers. Fruit, leaves,shoots, fish, and small game such as monkeys contributed to their diet. Morerecently, the addition of cash to their economy has led to a decreasedutilization of wild food sources and an increased dependence on commercialfoods such as rice, sugar, tinned sardines, biscuits and tea. Collected food,however, continues to play an important role, and its availability stronglyaffects the Batek's movements through the jungle.Rivers and streams also play an important role in Batek life. They providewater, fish, a place to bathe and natural territorial boundaries. The Batekprefer to camp in the vicinity of a stream or river. When an individual is askedwhere he or she is from, they usually say that they are from the confluence ofparticular rivers or streams.The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46761 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMAlthough watershed territories are not owned and allegiance to them is notowed, a feeling of homeland is, nonetheless, associated with these culturallyand physically demarcated areas. Each of these tracts is exploited by aclosely-knit residential group. In affairs involving non-Batek, each group, inturn, is represented by a headman. Charisma, extroversion, and a familiaritywith the Malay language are the basic qualifications for the position, butgenerally an individual becomes headman because others are reluctant tointeract with outsiders.Taman Negara, established in 1939, is Malaysia's oldest national park.Situated in the interior of the Malay Peninsula, it contains 1,300 km of primaryjungle. In the late 1960s, tourism to Taman Negara began to increase steadily.This led to the Batek's interest in obtaining work as jungle guides at KualaTahan.Malaysian Government Pressures the Batek to SettleIn 1979, the Malaysian government began to pressure the Batek to relocate ata government-subsidized settlement established at Kuala Atok, just outsidethe park boundaries. Several factors encouraged the government to createthis agricultural community. Their primary concern was the notion that if theBatek were left to continue their semi-nomadic existence, they would comeinto contact with communist terrorists hiding in the jungle and be forced togive them economic and intelligence assistance. During the communist threatof 1948-1960 (the "Emergency"), many aboriginal groups aided thecommunists. The government also hoped, through the sedentization program,to increase the population of Bumiputera, "sons of the soil." This is in line withtheir policy of integrating Aboriginal people into Malay Society.A less immediate but equally important goal of the development project was toencourage the Batek to give up their semi-nomadic existence, perceived bythe authorities as primitive. Another goal was simply to remove the Batek fromTaman Negara, where collecting and selling jungle produce - one of their mainThe Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46762 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMeconomic activities - did not conform to park regulations.The way in which the location of the settlement at Kuala Atok was determinedsheds light on Batek values and how they conflict with those of governmentofficials. When the Bureau of Aboriginal Affairs (Jabatan Hal Ehwal OrangAsli) first approached the Batek with the relocation plan in 1979, the headmanexpressed his strong disapproval. Government authorities suggested that thesettlement be placed on the south bank of the Tembeling River, close to KualaTahan. They felt that this would be a suitable location for the Batek to relocatesince it was outside the park boundaries, but not an unknown region to theBatek. Despite the apparent desirability of the settlement being located closeto Kuala Tahan, the park headquarters, Batek traditions make it inappropriatefor them to live there. To the Batek, the land north of the Tembeling River isancestral land, while the land south of the river is territory for which they haveno affinity. In spite of the headman's strong disapproval, the group was movedto the new site.Relocation at Kuala AtokAt Kuala Atok, ten wooden houses with corrugated tin roofs were constructedfor the Batek. A more substantial house was built for the Malay field officer. Inan initial effort to promote agriculture, the government provided cuttings, tools,and training. Theoretically, the Malay field officer was to encourage cultivationand advise the community.Now, five years since their construction, many of the houses at Kuala Atok arewithout their original sidings. There is no evidence of food crops except fortwo papaya trees, a mango tree, several banana trees, and a few eggplantbushes. According to the park ranger, who is stationed about ¼ mile upriver,when the field officer went away, the Batek generally left the settlement. Evenwhen he was in residence, the Batek were often gone.The government delivers food rations once every six weeks, but shortagesThe Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46763 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMare common. The Batek feel that the settlement is unbearably hot, and thatpeople who stay there too long become sick. The Batek do spend some timeat Kuala Atok, however, since periodic residence is necessary in order to getthe food rations that the government delivers. But once the rations have beenconsumed, the Batek pack up their few personal belongings and move to amore comfortable location, generally within the park boundaries and closer towild foods and wage labor.Kuala Atok Disrupts Batek's LivesThe construction of the Batek's homes at Kuala Atok alone illustrates thegreat difference between Batek patterns of residence, and those devised forthem by the government. A survey of abandoned campsites within the parkindicated that closely situated, inward-facing shelters constitute the preferredBatek residential space. The dwellings at Kuala Atok, however, are in a lineon the top of a bluff overlooking the Tembeling River. While the traditionalBatek camps are sheltered by a thick jungle canopy, the Kuala Atok housesare in a large, unshaded clearing.In October 1984, a large Batek camp was situated at the confluence of theYong and Tembeling Rivers. Numerous Batek felt that this camp was muchcooler and healthier than the Kuala Atok settlement. In addition, several of theBatek men were able to obtain work at a nearby Malay village carrying bagsof cement to the construction site of a school.Until recently one of the Batek's main sources of income was jungle-guiding.Initially, competition for this work was nonexistent. However, as local Malaysobtained experience as trail guides, the Batek found they no longer had amonopoly. A tourist pamphlet published by the national park states that theBatek "now spend most of their time in settlements outside the Park boundaryat...Kuala Atok, where the government has provided land for them to cultivate.They now rarely work as guides...and this work is being taken over by Malayguides from Kuala Tahan." Clearly, the forced move to Kuala Atok has made itThe Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46764 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMeven more difficult for the Batek to obtain guiding jobs.The Batek repeatedly express their dissatisfaction with this state of affairs.Guiding, which pays approximately US$15 per day, is the most lucrativeshort-term work available. The Batek feel that they are being pushed out byMalays whose villages lie adjacent to the park headquarters.The collection and sale of jungle produce, another important economic activityfor the Batek, has also been curtailed in recent years. In accordance with parkregulations, jungle produce such as resin or rattan may not be collected forsale. In spite of the law, the Batek continue to collect plant materials fromwithin Taman Negara and to sell them to local Malays as they have since atleast the 1950s. Park officials are aware that the Batek occasionally engage inthis activity, but because of its infrequency no measures are generally takenagainst them.Wage-labor - not agriculture - is the most desirable economic option for theBatek since it is better suited to their traditional lifestyle. Unlike agriculture,which involves a heavy investment of time and energy before the results maybe enjoyed, wage-labor involves same-day payment with the end of the workperiod in sight.By engaging in temporary wage-labor, Batek men can take advantage ofavailable work while other members of the group exploit wild food resources.The preference for wage-labor over farming indicates that the Batek areunprepared to give up fundamental characteristics of their culture, such asmobility and opportunism.Wage labor, nonetheless, affects the Batek's patterns of social organizationand cultural orientation. For example, contrary to their traditionally flexibledivision of labor, the wage work is open primarily to men. Another example ofthe split between traditional and new ways is vividly apparent in how gatheredand bought foods are distributed: collected foods are shared among allThe Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46765 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMmembers of the group, while packaged foods are consumed by the immediatefamily only.The failure of Kuala Atok as a vital and productive community is testimony tothe drastic changes that would have to be made by the Batek in order toaccommodate an agricultural life. Their hunting and gathering heritage makesthe prospect of permanent and successful settlement largely impossible atthis time.Over the years, the Batek of Taman Negara have been finding solutions to theproblems of encroachment by the modern world. In the interest of maintainingmobility and flexibility, they have become petty entrepreneurs rather thansubsistence farmers. Current governmental policies, however, are makineconomic self-sufficiency harder to achieve. The inclination towardwage-labor suggests that the Batek are changing only as much as they mustin order to maintain important elements of their culture.The removal of the Batek from their traditional homeland, combined with thelack of viable economic alternatives, places them in a tenuous position. Likeindigenous peoples elsewhere, the Batek should be able to enjoy the benefitsof development. They should be allowed to make their own decisionsregarding subsistence strategies, relocation, and integration into the largerMalaysian society. Above all, the Batek should be allowed, if they so desire, tocontinue their hunting and gathering existence within their ancestral territory.Article copyright Cultural Survival, Inc.CSQ Issue: 9.3 (Fall 1985) Nation, Tribe and Ethnic Groups in Africa [2]CSQ Issue: 9.3 (Fall 1985) Nation, Tribe and Ethnic Groups in Africa [2]Author: The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46766 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AMPaul [3]Hashim [4]Susanne; Faulstich [5]Country: Malaysia [6]Issues: Languages and Cultures [7]Source URL (modified on February 2010): https://www.culturalsurvival.org/ourpublications/csq/article/the-taman-negara-batek-a-people-transitionLinks[1] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/ourpublications/csq/article/the-taman-negara-batek-a-people-transition#dexp-carousel[2] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/publications/cultural-survival-quarterly/93-fall-1985-nation-tribe-and-ethnic-groups-africa[3] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/paul[4] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/hashim[5] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/susanne-faulstich[6] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/country/malaysia[7] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/issues/languages-and-culturesThe Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/46767 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM

The Taman Negara Batek: A People in Transition

Keck Graduate Institute

Claremont Colleges
Scholarship @ Claremont
Pitzer Faculty Publications and Research Pitzer Faculty Scholarship
10-1-1985
The Taman Negara Batek: A People in Transition
Paul Faulstich
Pitzer College
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Pitzer Faculty Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion
in Pitzer Faculty Publications and Research by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact
scholarship@cuc.claremont.edu.
Recommended Citation
Faulstich, Paul. The Taman Negara Batek: A People in Transition. Cultural Survival Quarterly, 9(3): 33-35, 1985.
Published on Cultural Survival (https://www.culturalsurvival.org)
Home > The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition
[1] [1]
Batek Negritos from the vicinity of Taman Negara National Park in West
Malaysia are a hunting and gathering people presently experiencing rapid
encroachment by the modern world. Under the authority of the Malaysian
government, they are being encouraged to settle and to emulate Malay
subsistence farming communities. Unfortunately, this strategy has had a
number of adverse effects on the Batek.
Traditionally, Batek subsisted primarily on gathered tubers. Fruit, leaves,
shoots, fish, and small game such as monkeys contributed to their diet. More
recently, the addition of cash to their economy has led to a decreased
utilization of wild food sources and an increased dependence on commercial
foods such as rice, sugar, tinned sardines, biscuits and tea. Collected food,
however, continues to play an important role, and its availability strongly
affects the Batek's movements through the jungle.
Rivers and streams also play an important role in Batek life. They provide
water, fish, a place to bathe and natural territorial boundaries. The Batek
prefer to camp in the vicinity of a stream or river. When an individual is asked
where he or she is from, they usually say that they are from the confluence of
particular rivers or streams.
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
1 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
Although watershed territories are not owned and allegiance to them is not
owed, a feeling of homeland is, nonetheless, associated with these culturally
and physically demarcated areas. Each of these tracts is exploited by a
closely-knit residential group. In affairs involving non-Batek, each group, in
turn, is represented by a headman. Charisma, extroversion, and a familiarity
with the Malay language are the basic qualifications for the position, but
generally an individual becomes headman because others are reluctant to
interact with outsiders.
Taman Negara, established in 1939, is Malaysia's oldest national park.
Situated in the interior of the Malay Peninsula, it contains 1,300 km of primary
jungle. In the late 1960s, tourism to Taman Negara began to increase steadily.
This led to the Batek's interest in obtaining work as jungle guides at Kuala
Tahan.
Malaysian Government Pressures the Batek to Settle
In 1979, the Malaysian government began to pressure the Batek to relocate at
a government-subsidized settlement established at Kuala Atok, just outside
the park boundaries. Several factors encouraged the government to create
this agricultural community. Their primary concern was the notion that if the
Batek were left to continue their semi-nomadic existence, they would come
into contact with communist terrorists hiding in the jungle and be forced to
give them economic and intelligence assistance. During the communist threat
of 1948-1960 (the "Emergency"), many aboriginal groups aided the
communists. The government also hoped, through the sedentization program,
to increase the population of Bumiputera, "sons of the soil." This is in line with
their policy of integrating Aboriginal people into Malay Society.
A less immediate but equally important goal of the development project was to
encourage the Batek to give up their semi-nomadic existence, perceived by
the authorities as primitive. Another goal was simply to remove the Batek from
Taman Negara, where collecting and selling jungle produce - one of their main
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
2 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
economic activities - did not conform to park regulations.
The way in which the location of the settlement at Kuala Atok was determined
sheds light on Batek values and how they conflict with those of government
officials. When the Bureau of Aboriginal Affairs (Jabatan Hal Ehwal Orang
Asli) first approached the Batek with the relocation plan in 1979, the headman
expressed his strong disapproval. Government authorities suggested that the
settlement be placed on the south bank of the Tembeling River, close to Kuala
Tahan. They felt that this would be a suitable location for the Batek to relocate
since it was outside the park boundaries, but not an unknown region to the
Batek. Despite the apparent desirability of the settlement being located close
to Kuala Tahan, the park headquarters, Batek traditions make it inappropriate
for them to live there. To the Batek, the land north of the Tembeling River is
ancestral land, while the land south of the river is territory for which they have
no affinity. In spite of the headman's strong disapproval, the group was moved
to the new site.
Relocation at Kuala Atok
At Kuala Atok, ten wooden houses with corrugated tin roofs were constructed
for the Batek. A more substantial house was built for the Malay field officer. In
an initial effort to promote agriculture, the government provided cuttings, tools,
and training. Theoretically, the Malay field officer was to encourage cultivation
and advise the community.
Now, five years since their construction, many of the houses at Kuala Atok are
without their original sidings. There is no evidence of food crops except for
two papaya trees, a mango tree, several banana trees, and a few eggplant
bushes. According to the park ranger, who is stationed about ¼ mile upriver,
when the field officer went away, the Batek generally left the settlement. Even
when he was in residence, the Batek were often gone.
The government delivers food rations once every six weeks, but shortages
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
3 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
are common. The Batek feel that the settlement is unbearably hot, and that
people who stay there too long become sick. The Batek do spend some time
at Kuala Atok, however, since periodic residence is necessary in order to get
the food rations that the government delivers. But once the rations have been
consumed, the Batek pack up their few personal belongings and move to a
more comfortable location, generally within the park boundaries and closer to
wild foods and wage labor.
Kuala Atok Disrupts Batek's Lives
The construction of the Batek's homes at Kuala Atok alone illustrates the
great difference between Batek patterns of residence, and those devised for
them by the government. A survey of abandoned campsites within the park
indicated that closely situated, inward-facing shelters constitute the preferred
Batek residential space. The dwellings at Kuala Atok, however, are in a line
on the top of a bluff overlooking the Tembeling River. While the traditional
Batek camps are sheltered by a thick jungle canopy, the Kuala Atok houses
are in a large, unshaded clearing.
In October 1984, a large Batek camp was situated at the confluence of the
Yong and Tembeling Rivers. Numerous Batek felt that this camp was much
cooler and healthier than the Kuala Atok settlement. In addition, several of the
Batek men were able to obtain work at a nearby Malay village carrying bags
of cement to the construction site of a school.
Until recently one of the Batek's main sources of income was jungle-guiding.
Initially, competition for this work was nonexistent. However, as local Malays
obtained experience as trail guides, the Batek found they no longer had a
monopoly. A tourist pamphlet published by the national park states that the
Batek "now spend most of their time in settlements outside the Park boundary
at...Kuala Atok, where the government has provided land for them to cultivate.
They now rarely work as guides...and this work is being taken over by Malay
guides from Kuala Tahan." Clearly, the forced move to Kuala Atok has made it
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
4 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
even more difficult for the Batek to obtain guiding jobs.
The Batek repeatedly express their dissatisfaction with this state of affairs.
Guiding, which pays approximately US$15 per day, is the most lucrative
short-term work available. The Batek feel that they are being pushed out by
Malays whose villages lie adjacent to the park headquarters.
The collection and sale of jungle produce, another important economic activity
for the Batek, has also been curtailed in recent years. In accordance with park
regulations, jungle produce such as resin or rattan may not be collected for
sale. In spite of the law, the Batek continue to collect plant materials from
within Taman Negara and to sell them to local Malays as they have since at
least the 1950s. Park officials are aware that the Batek occasionally engage in
this activity, but because of its infrequency no measures are generally taken
against them.
Wage-labor - not agriculture - is the most desirable economic option for the
Batek since it is better suited to their traditional lifestyle. Unlike agriculture,
which involves a heavy investment of time and energy before the results may
be enjoyed, wage-labor involves same-day payment with the end of the work
period in sight.
By engaging in temporary wage-labor, Batek men can take advantage of
available work while other members of the group exploit wild food resources.
The preference for wage-labor over farming indicates that the Batek are
unprepared to give up fundamental characteristics of their culture, such as
mobility and opportunism.
Wage labor, nonetheless, affects the Batek's patterns of social organization
and cultural orientation. For example, contrary to their traditionally flexible
division of labor, the wage work is open primarily to men. Another example of
the split between traditional and new ways is vividly apparent in how gathered
and bought foods are distributed: collected foods are shared among all
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
5 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
members of the group, while packaged foods are consumed by the immediate
family only.
The failure of Kuala Atok as a vital and productive community is testimony to
the drastic changes that would have to be made by the Batek in order to
accommodate an agricultural life. Their hunting and gathering heritage makes
the prospect of permanent and successful settlement largely impossible at
this time.
Over the years, the Batek of Taman Negara have been finding solutions to the
problems of encroachment by the modern world. In the interest of maintaining
mobility and flexibility, they have become petty entrepreneurs rather than
subsistence farmers. Current governmental policies, however, are makin
economic self-sufficiency harder to achieve. The inclination toward
wage-labor suggests that the Batek are changing only as much as they must
in order to maintain important elements of their culture.
The removal of the Batek from their traditional homeland, combined with the
lack of viable economic alternatives, places them in a tenuous position. Like
indigenous peoples elsewhere, the Batek should be able to enjoy the benefits
of development. They should be allowed to make their own decisions
regarding subsistence strategies, relocation, and integration into the larger
Malaysian society. Above all, the Batek should be allowed, if they so desire, to
continue their hunting and gathering existence within their ancestral territory.
Article copyright Cultural Survival, Inc.
CSQ Issue: 
9.3 (Fall 1985) Nation, Tribe and Ethnic Groups in Africa [2]
CSQ Issue: 
9.3 (Fall 1985) Nation, Tribe and Ethnic Groups in Africa [2]
Author: 
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
6 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM
Paul [3]
Hashim [4]
Susanne; Faulstich [5]
Country: 
Malaysia [6]
Issues: 
Languages and Cultures [7]
Source URL (modified on February 2010): https://www.culturalsurvival.org/ourpublications/csq/article/the-taman-
negara-batek-a-people-transition
Links
[1] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/ourpublications/csq/article/the-taman-negara-batek-a-people-transition#dexp-
carousel
[2] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/publications/cultural-survival-quarterly/93-fall-1985-nation-tribe-and-ethnic-groups-
africa
[3] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/paul
[4] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/hashim
[5] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/author/susanne-faulstich
[6] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/country/malaysia
[7] https://www.culturalsurvival.org/issues/languages-and-cultures
The Taman Negara Batek - A People in Transition https://www.culturalsurvival.org/print/4676
7 of 7 11/9/2016 8:24 AM


English

https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1147&amp;context=pitzer_fac_pub

The Taman Negara Batek: A People in Transition

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Scholarship@Claremont

Keck Graduate Institute