A recent letter by Xue et al. (PRL v.83, 1235 ('99)) reports a Fermi-Liquid
(FL) angle resolved photoemission (ARPES) lineshape for quasi one-dimensional
Li0.9Mo6O17, contradicting our report (PRL v.82, 2540 ('99)) of a non-FL
lineshape in this material. Xue et al. attributed the difference to the
improved angle resolution. In this comment, we point out that this reasoning is
flawed. Rather, we find that their data have fundamental differences from other
ARPES results and also band theory.Comment: To be published as a PRL Commen