We have obtained and modeled new NICMOS images of the lens system
MG1131+0456, which show that its lens galaxy is an H=18.6 mag, transparent,
early-type galaxy at a redshift of about z_l = 0.85; it has a major axis
effective radius R_e=0.68+/-0.05 arcsec, projected axis ratio b/a=0.77+/-0.02,
and major axis PA=60+/-2 degrees. The lens is the brightest member of a group
of seven galaxies with similar R-I and I-H colors, and the two closest group
members produce sufficient tidal perturbations to explain the ring morphology.
The host galaxy of the MG1131+0456 source is a z_s > 2 ERO (``extremely red
object'') which is lensed into optical and infrared rings of dramatically
different morphologies. These differences imply a strongly wavelength-dependent
source morphology that could be explained by embedding the host in a larger,
dusty disk. At 1.6 micron (H), the ring is spectacularly luminous, with a total
observed flux of H=17.4 mag and a de-magnified flux of 19.3 mag, corresponding
to a 1-2L_* galaxy at the probable source redshift of z_s > 2. Thus, it is
primarily the stellar emission of the radio source host galaxy that produces
the overall colors of two of the reddest radio lenses, MG1131+0456 and
B~1938+666, aided by the suppression of optical AGN emission by dust in the
source galaxy. The dusty lens hypothesis -- that many massive early-type
galaxies with 0.2 < z_l < 1.0 have large, uniform dust opacities -- is ruled
out.Comment: 27 pages, 8 COLOR figures, submitted to ApJ. Black and white version
available at http://cfa-www.harvard.edu/castle
