Can 3D Camera Imaging Provide Improved Information to Assess and Manage Lymphoedema in Clinical Practice?

Abstract

Background Accurate diagnosis and measurement of limb volume in people with lymphoedema is important in order to provide best information for treatment, management and self-management. Current assessment methods lack detail and accuracy. Three-dimensional camera imaging (3DCI) holds the potential to be cheap, accurate, and provide additional material about limb shape not provided by current methods. However, there is a need to ensure that this assessment method is valid and reliable. Methodology This prospective, observational, longitudinal study utilised a diagnostic test study framework to determine the validity, reliability and accuracy of 3DCI compared to circumferential tape measurement (CTM) and perometry and to explore whether shape is a feasible alternative to measure upper limb lymphoedema. Twenty women with breast cancer-related lymphoedema were recruited. Phase one assessed criterion validity, intra-rater reliability, and accuracy of 3DCI by measuring limb volume of each participant with CTM, perometry and 3DCI four times over six months. Phase two investigated the use of limb shape as a method of lymphoedema assessment using oedema maps and calculations of shape redundancy derived from the 3DCI images in phase one. These data sets were matched against limb volume to determine criterion validity, intra-rater reliability and accuracy. Results 3DCI had high intra-rater correlation (ICC=0.87; p<0.00). Concurrent validity ranged from 0.82 to 0.86 against perometry and CTM, with good sensitivity (91.7% to 100%) and moderate specificity (50% to 66.7%). Limb shape calculation (shape redundancy) had moderate intra-rater correlation (ICC=0.71; p=0.01); but correlated poorly with limb volume (r=0.19 to 0.39). Coloured oedema maps were sensitive to change over time with colours clearly identifying problem areas and fluctuations within the affected limb. Conclusion Our study shows that 3DCI is a reliable, valid and accurate method of limb volume measurement, and that it could provide supportive information in clinical assessment. In addition, limb shape provides insight into localised areas of swelling, which other methods of lymphoedema measurement do not. However, shape redundancy requires further refinement

    Similar works