Reciprocal Interference Between Ants And Stingless Bees Attending The Honeydew-producing Homopteran Aetalion Reticulatum (homoptera: Aetalionidae)

Abstract

We evaluated the reciprocal effects between foragers of the ants Camponotus crassus and of the stingless bees Trigona hyalinata on aggregations of the honeydew-producing treehopper Aetalion reticulatum. The interactions were observed in Bauhinia variegata (Caesalpiniaceae) and Mangifera indica (Anacardiaceae) trees. We recorded the presence/absence of each attendant species in homopteran aggregations to test if the observed co-occurrence is lower than that expected by chance. An exclusion experiment was performed in which each attendant species was excluded from aggregations in order to test if an attendant species is more likely to occupy aggregations where the other attendant is not present. We also recorded the number of individuals of each attendant species in homopteran aggregations to search for any correlation between homopteran and attendant abundances. Additionally, we performed experiments using termites (Termitidae, Isoptera) as models to verify if the attendant species have the potential to defend A. reticulatum against natural enemies. The co-occurrence of attendant species was lower than that expected by chance. Homopteran aggregations without stingless bees were more visited by ants than those in which T. hyalinata was present, and vice-versa. The abundance of stingless bees was proportional to homopteran abundance, while ants abundance was not correlated to homopteran abundance. Both attendant species attacked the natural enemies models when we glued the termites ca. 1 cm away from homopteran aggregations, but only ants removed termites glued 5-7 cm away from aggregations. We suggest that the effects of non-formicid attendants should be included as another factor influencing the costs and benefits of ant-homopteran interactions, since honeydew availability for ants also depends on the presence and behavior of interspecific attendants.422369380Addicott, J.F., Multispecies aphid ant association - Density dependence and species-specific effects (1979) Canadian Journal of Zoology - Revue Canadienne de Zoologie, 57, pp. 558-569Barrows, E.M., Polistes wasps (Hymenoptera, Vespidae) show interference competition with other insects for Kermes scale insect (Homoptera, Kermesidae) secretions (1979) Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Washington, 81, pp. 570-575Bentley, B.L., Extra-floral nectaries and protection by pugnacious bodyguards (1977) Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 8, pp. 407-427Bentley, B.L., Benson, W.W., The influence of ant foraging patterns on the behavior of herbivores (1988) Advances in Myrmecology, pp. 297-306. , J.C. Trager (ed.). E.J.Brill, New YorkBlank, S., Setter, C., Bruce, P., (2001) Resampling Stats in Excel - Version 2, , Arlington, VA: Resampling Stats, IncBreton, L.M., Addicott, J.F., Does host-plant quality mediate aphid-ant mutualism? (1992) Oikos, 63, pp. 253-259Bristow, C., Differential benefits from ant attendance to two tropical species of homopterans of New York ironweed (1984) Journal of Animal Ecology, 53, pp. 15-726Buckley, R.C., Interactions between ants and membracid bugs decreases growth and seed set of host plant bearing extrafloral nectaries (1983) Oecologia, 58, pp. 132-136Buckley, R.C., Interactions involving plants, Homoptera, and ants (1987) Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 18, pp. 111-138Castro, P.R., Mutualismo entre Trigona spinipes (Fabricius, 1973) e Aetalion reticulatum (L. 1767) em Cajanus indicus Spreng. na presença de Camponotus spp (1975) Ciência & Cultura, 27, pp. 537-539Cortopassi-Laurino, M., Notas sobre associações de Trigona (Oxitrigona) taitara (Apidae, Meliponinae) (1977) Boletim de Zoologia da Universidade de São Paulo, 2, pp. 183-187Dejean, A., Turillazzi, S., Territoriality during trophobiosis between wasps and homopterans (1992) Tropical Zoology, 5, pp. 237-247Del-Claro, K., Oliveira, P.S., Conditional outcomes in a neotropical treehopper-ant association: Temporal and species-specific variation in ant protection and homopteran fecundity (2000) Oecologia, 124, pp. 156-165Figueiredo, R.D.A., Interactions between stingless meliponine bees, honeydew-producing homopterans, ants and figs in a cerrado area (1996) Naturalia, 2, pp. 159-164Flatt, T., Weisser, W.W., The effects of mutualistic ants on aphid life history traits (2000) Ecology, 81, pp. 3522-3529Fowler, H.G., Aethalionidae: Functional equivalents of extrafloral nectaries in Bauhinia (Caesalpinoidea) (1992) Anales de Biologia, 18, pp. 155-159Hubbell, S.P., Johnson, L.K., Comparative foraging behavior of six stingless bee species exploiting a standardized resource (1978) Ecology, 59, pp. 1123-1136Johnson, L.K., Hubbell, S.P., Aggression and competition among stingless bees - Field studies (1974) Ecology, 55, pp. 120-127Krebs, J., Optimal foraging - Theory and experiment (1977) Nature, 268, pp. 583-584Laroca, S., Mutualism between Trigona fuscipennis (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) and Anchistrotus amitteraglobus, an amazonian membracid that suffers mutilation of the pronotum (1997) Acta Biológica Paranaense, 26, pp. 1-18Laroca, S., Sakakibara, A.M., Mutualismo entre Trigona hyalinata branneri (Apidae) e Aconophora flavipes (Membracidae) (1976) Revista Brasileira de Entomologia, 20, pp. 71-72Letourneau, D.K., Choe, J.C., Homopteran attendance by wasps and ants: The stochastic nature of interactions (1987) Psyche, 94, pp. 81-91Messina, F.J., Plant-protection as a consequence of an ant-membracid mutualism - Interactions on goldenrod (Solidago sp) (1981) Ecology, 62, pp. 1433-1440Morales, M.A., Mechanisms and density dependence of benefit in an ant-membracid mutualism (2000) Ecology, 81, pp. 482-489Oliveira, P.S., Silva, A.F., Martins, A.B., Ant foraging on extrafloral nectaries of Qualea grandiflora (Vochysiaceae) in cerrado vegetation: Ants as potential antiherbivore agents (1987) Oecologia, 74, pp. 228-230Roubik, D.W., (1989) Ecology and Natural History of Tropical Bees, , Cambridge Tropical Biology series, New YorkSilva, A.G.A., Gonçalves, C.R., Galvão, D.M., Gonçalves, A.J.L., Silva, M.N., Simoni, L., (1968) Quarto Catálogo dos Insetos que vivem nas Plantas do Brasil: Seus Parasitos e Predadores. Parte II - 1 Tomo. Insetos, Hospedeiros e Inimigos Naturais, , Ministério da Agricultura. Rio de Janeiro, BrasilSokal, R.R., Rohlf, F.J., (1995) Biometry. 3rd Edition, , W.H. Freeman, New YorkSudd, J.H., Sudd, M.E., Seasonal changes in the response of wood-ants (Formica lugubris) to sucrose baits (1983) Ecological Entomology, 10, pp. 89-97Völkl, W., Woodring, J., Fischer, M., Lorenz, M.W., Hoffmann, K.H., Ant-aphid mutualisms: The impact of honeydew production and honeydew sugar composition on ant preferences (1999) Oecologia, 118, pp. 483-491Way, M.J., Mutualism between ants and honeydew-producing Homoptera (1963) Annual Review of Entomology, 8, pp. 307-344Wilson, E.O., (1971) The Insects Societies, , Belknap, Cambridge, Mas