As there is no agreed national list of species of socio-economic and/or cultural value for
Scotland, we developed a set of criteria for selecting species. These include:
• Species prioritised for conservation value
• Species identified as being culturally important
• Species providing important ecosystem services
• Game species
• Species collected for food or medicine
Using these criteria, we selected 26 species for initial assessment. For each species, we
produced a Genetic Scorecard, outlining:
• Relevant genetic conservation issues for the species in question
• The importance of its genetic diversity on an international scale
• An evaluation of the genetic risks facing in situ populations
• A statement of confidence in the assessment
• The degree to which representation in ex situ collections mitigate against genetic
diversity loss.
• An overall ‘traffic light’ score of genetic risks and whether current conservation actions
are effective
Using 2010 as a baseline reference point, the approach assesses contemporary genetic
issues, and likely future issues during a 25-year window from the point of assessment.
For quantification of levels of risk, we adopted the following framework:
• Negligible: No obviously detectable genetic problems occurring or expected over the
next 25 years.
• Moderate: Moderate genetic problems occurring or expected over the next 25 years;
e.g.:
- Moderate loss of populations that are likely to contain unique diversity (e.g.,
resulting in losses of up to 25% of important genetic types / distinct populations);
- Clearly observable fitness problems in up to 25% of populations due to low
genetic variation and subsequent inbreeding depression;
- Marked and clearly observable loss of genetic integrity by hybridisation at up to
25% of populations;
- Severe restrictions on regeneration/recruitment/reproduction in many or most
populations of long-lived species limiting evolutionary change in the immediate
future.
• Serious: Serious genetic problems occurring or expected over the next 25 years; e.g.:
- Severe loss of populations that are likely to contain unique diversity (e.g.,
resulting in losses of > 25% of important genetic types / distinct populations);
- Loss of any highly divergent endemic lineages that are globally unique;
- Strong, clearly observable fitness problems in >25% of populations due to low
genetic variation and subsequent inbreeding depression;
- Marked and clearly observable loss of genetic integrity by hybridisation at >25%
of populations.
The assessment is based on expert opinion, using direct genetic data, where available,
combined with information on species biology, abundance and distribution. Where no direct genetic data are available, the genetic risk assessment is based on species biology,
abundance and distribution