Cholakian, Rouben C.

English

ScholarWorks at WMU

The book is generally clearly written, although densely conceived, and the highly compressed arguments require careful unpacking. The author's cogent chapter summaries are a significant help in keeping track of how the multiple strands of her thought contribute to the central project. There is a sustained reading of the history of philosophical ethics, especially phenomenological developments since Hegel, and the analytical/linguistic work of Quine and Davidson. Her negotiations with postmodern foundations center on Levinas, Lacan, Derrida, Deleuze and Guattri. Wyschogrod's bold attempt to construct heroic postrnodern ethics offers much to those studying the ethical and hagiographical strains of medieval narratives of courts and chronicles, religious orders, and pulpit. SHORT NOTICES t Joan Gibson, York University Paterson, Linda M. The World of the Troubadours: Medieval Occitan Society, c.1l00 - c. 1300. Cambridge: University Press, 1993. pp. xii + 367. New and old historicists alike will delight in this treasure trove of information about medieval Occitania, a veritable encyclopedia of the "realities and particularities of medieval Occitan life" (8). The data is gathered in a well-ordered manner, making access easy for the researcher. Under eleven general headings appear sub-headings and, when the need seems reasonable, even further sub-sub-headings of pithy paragraphs. Every chapter provides a useful summary of what comes before. Paterson attacks some of the obvious issues: feudalism, knights and chivalry (10-89), and towns (152-85), other pertinent questions: courts (90-119), peasants (120-50), religion (312-43), and finally, subjects which have only recently demanded the attention of societal historians: medicine (186-219), women (200-79), children (280-311), and the Jewish communities of Occitania (175-82; 192-95). Her style is lucid, her arguments carefully-reasoned and her general attitude cautious: she frequently makes apologetic statements like: "It is not easy to know ... " (115); "And yet this is not the whole picture" (194). She readily acknowledges the complexities of scholarly contradictions: ''Toulouse has been considered alternatively as one of the most brilliant centres of troubadour patronage, or as virtually without significance" (93). She is quick to admit that distance and paucity of documentation should cause scholars to eschew facile and hasty explanations: "Our knowledge of medical teaching and teachers before 1250 is fragmentary" (195). She is aware that text is often context and not infrequently draws upon the troubadour literature as her source, making no excuses for the characteristic circularity of much of the Duby type of social research (63, 88, 100, 183,218, 254). She builds her case on the basis of objective review of materials, and only once argues, as she does concerning Aries' comments on children, in refutation (280-86). No doubt some scholars will point to misrepresentations and bibliographical lacunae. Some will even accuse Paterson of falling prey to the lure of intriguing trivia: "In Montpellier consuls wore a striking but simple costume of red robe and black cap" 23 (168). But most will stand in awe of her learning, and certainly all will have to agree that her hard work will hereafter make their own research that much easier. Rouben C. Cholakian, Hamilton College BIBLIOGRAPHY (CHRIS AFRICA, MFN BIBLICXJRAPHER) t Beer, Frances. Women and Mystical Experience in the Middle Ages. Woodbridge, Suffolk/Rochester, New York: Boydell Press, 1992. Bitel, Lisa M. '''Conceived in Sins, Born in Delights': Stories of Procreation from Early Ireland." Journal of the History of Sexuality 3 (1992): 181-202. Clunies Ross, Margaret. "Women and Power in the Scandinavian Sagas," in Stereotypes of Women in Power: Historical Perspectives and Revisionist Views, edited by Barbara Garlick, Suzanne Dixon, and Pauline Allen, pp. 105-119 (Contributions in Women's Studies, v. 125). New York: Greenwood Press, 1992. Coltheart, Lenore. "The Virago and Machiavelli," in Stereotypes of Women in Power," pp. 141-155. Consent and Coercion to Sex and Marriage in Ancient and Medieval Societies, edited by Angeliki E. Laiou. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library, 1993. Part Two: Byzantium. Angeliki E. Laiou, "Sex, Consent, and Coercion in Byzantium"; Part Three: The Medieval West. Suzanne F. Wemple, "Consent and Dissent to Sexual Intercourse in Germanic Societies from the Fifth to the Tenth Century"; James A. Brundage, "Implied Consent to Intercourse"; John W. Baldwin, "Consent and the Marital Debt: Five Discourses in Northern France around 1200"; Jenny Jochens, "'Meo nakvae i Hennar Sjalfrar': Consent as Signifier in the Old Norseworld. " Donovan, Leslie A. "The Old English Lives of Saints Eugenia and Eufrosina: A Critical Edition," Dissertation, University of Washington, 1993. Dufoumet, Jean, Michel Jezierski, Andre Joris, and Pierre Toubert, editors. Femmes mariages-Iignages Xlle-X/Ve s;ecles: melanges offerts a Georges Duby (Bibliotheque du Moyen Age; 1). Brussels: De Boeck-Wesmael, 1992. This is a collection of 26 contributions on women, the family, marriage, and kinship in medieval history and literature in honor of Georges Duby and inaugurating a new monographic series to complement the journal Moyen Age. Dumbarton Oaks Papers 46 (1992). Homo Byzantinus: Papers in Honor of Alexander Kazhdan, edited by Anthony Cutler and Simon Franklin. Includes Judith Herrin, '" Femina Byzantina': The Council in Trullo on Women"; Patricia Karlin-Hayter, "Further Notes on Byzantine Marriage"; Frances Kianka, "The Letters of Demetrios Kydones to Empress Helena Kantakouzene Palaiologina"; Angeliki E. Laiou, ''Imperial Marriages and Their Critics in the Eleventh Century: The Case of Skylitzes"; Andrzej Poppe, "Once Again Concerning the Baptism of Olga, Archontissa of Rus"'; Alice-Mary Talbot, "Empress Theodora Palaiologina, Wife of Michael VIII." Exemplaria 4 (Spring 1992). Barrie Ruth Straus, "Skirting the Texts: Feminisms' Re-24 

Linda M. Paterson, The World of the Troubadours: Medieval Occitan Society, c. 1100-c. 1300. Cambridge University Press, 1993

https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1458&amp;context=mff

Linda M. Paterson, The World of the Troubadours: Medieval Occitan Society, c. 1100-c. 1300. Cambridge University Press, 1993

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

ScholarWorks at WMU