В даній статті досліджено процесуальні аспекти допиту експерта в суді.

(This article is about procedural aspects of the court interrogation of the expert.

Попелюшко, В. О. (V. Popeliushko )

Цифровий архів Острозької академії (Digital Repository of Ostroh Academy)

ililMisicrepcrBo ocsiril i nayru Vrpaiuu #Haqionanrnufi yHinepcnrer <<o4ecrxa rcpr,rAuqna axaAevris>Inauo-OpaHriscrKr,rft QaxylrrerdIPABOBA CI{CTEMA YKPAIHI{:CYTIACH ltrrf4 CT AH TA AKTYAJIbHI IPOEJIEMU>' 3EIpHrrK MATEPIAJTTB Aplroi ncnyrpAiHcbKoiHAyKOBO-npAKTr{qHOi KOHOEPEHTITI(u. Ieaao-epanxiectq24-2| n pasHn 2013 por<y)nr. Inauo-@panxincrx2013 p.\ J?nEEK 67.9 (4 Y"p)n 6 8II 68 flpanona c[creMa Vrpaihn: cyuacHnft craH Ta arrya.nrHi npo6leuu [tercr]:36ipnur rr,rarepianin Apyroi Bceyrpaiucrxoi nalmono-uparmvuoirou$epenqi'i (Inano-@pamiscrr, 24-25 TpaBIUI 2013 pory). - lsauo-@panrincrx: BT.TIaBHHK loninefi O.M.,2013. - 182 c.y s1ipuurc yeiilwtu me3u HayKorux donoeideil yvacuuxie dpyeoiBceyxpaiucuxoi uayxooo-npaxmuquo:i xoufuepen4ii <Ilpaeoea cucrneMa Yxpai'uu:cyvacuuil cmaH ma axmyataui npo6neuu>t, nxa eid6ynacn 24-25 mpaeun 2013 pory eu. Ieauo-(Dpaurciectr<y ua 6asi leauo-tDpanxiecoxoeo Qarynomeny Ha4iouanouozoynieepcumemy <Odecaxa npuduuua axadeuin>.B s6ipuuny s6epetceuo cmunicmurcy, opQozpaQin ma nyHKmyaqin aemopiemes donoeideil.,Qnn cmydeumie, ctyxavie, xypcaumie npuduuuux iucmumymie maQarcyaamemie, uayxoeqie, npaKmwtHux npatlieuuxie ma ecix eaqixaaneuux oci6.O Bci npana arropir ucrepexeso, 201 3@ Haqiona,rurnfi yHirepolrer <OaecuralopHAHqHa axa.qer*,ris>, 201 3i*3MICTCEKIIIfl TEOPIr TA ICTOPIr TEP}KABN I NPABA,AIJIOCOOfi NPABAfanr6a O. MornsH nporl,rnpaBHoi noeeAiHxucy6'eKTiB npaBooxopoHHoi AitrrHocri Yrpainll......... '.. '.. '. .............-.-.-.--.7fo.ronxo B.3na.reHHs 3aKoHoAaBqoi rexnirn y npoqeciQoprvrynanut 3arulrlbHoo6os's3xosnx [paBI'IJI[oBeAiHKIt.. .--.-....1If f ina  I .  Mex i  4 i inpana. . .  . . . . . . . . . . - - - - - . . .13KaSapcrna O.BttxosaHHs IliHHocrefi rpoMa1flHcbKoro cycniJlbcrBay cryAeHrcbroT uoloAi.. ... '. '.16Kona;rr I. flopirnrrnHllfi auani3 peliriesuan'roro ranoriTororiqHoro [iAxoAis Ao szsqegut npo6neMcycninbHo-r lepKoBHllxBiAHocLIH.. .  . . . . . . . ' . . . .19Kopurno JI. CraHoereHus KpI{MiH.rJIbHoisiAnosiAaruHocri 3a eKororirlHi npaBonopy[reHHtB aBcrpi f icbKoMy r lpaBi XD( -  noq. XX cr.  . . . . . . . . . . .  . . . . . - -- .24JIafi uryn .f. OnpnnroAHeHut HopMarI'IBHo-npaBoBpIx aKTiB yHopMorBopqocr i . . . .  . . . . . . . . . . . .28Maranifi O. fli.qcras[ BI,IHHKHeHH.fi i npunuHeunt rpyAoBLIxrrpaBoBiAHocHH 3 cJry)K6oBIItMlI 3a 3aKoHoAaBcrBoM,{pyroi Pevif locnonuro i  ' . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .30Mereuxo C. Bnrus ocHoBoIIoJIoxHItx $aKropin cniromr4Hoirouuenqii llcenao-Aionicir Aepouarira na po3BI'IroK $inocoQcrro-rrpaBoBoi i,qeonorii Cxi4noi Putvlcrxoj ir'auepii.. .... ...... ' - - - -. -. .33cEKIIrfl KOHCTUTWnIfrHOTO, A,TMIHICTPATnBHOTO,oIHAHCOBOTO, MIN(HAPO,q HOrO nyEilIrrHOrO UPABA3invyrc K. flpaoooe craHoBHIIIe npoKyparlpn a npaiHax CH!......36Kucnqx JI. .{erxi acneKrll pealisaqii ra 3axllcryrpaBa ua cao6ogy ra oco6ncry HeAoropKaHHicrr.. '..-.".-41Kona;rr [. Peaniaaui-a npranquny oQiuifiuoro 3'flcyBaHHtsc ixo6crasuHycnpan i ra4r ra in ic rparuBHoMycyAot lnHcrB i  . . . . . . . . . . . ' . - -46I'.rCEKIIIfl TEOPIr TA ICTOPIrFEP}ITABII I IIPABA$,OMOCOOfi NPABAOnez lautda,a d' ru nxni H a qio aatt t n oi axa d ehii,{ep xcaeuoi np uxopdouuo:i anyuc 6 aVxpalinu im. E. XnenbHuqbKozoMOTTIBI{ TIPOTIIIPABHOI IIOBEAIHKI CvE',€KTIBTIPABOOXOPOHHOI AIflJIbHOCTI YKPAIHI,IHa nepexi4nouy Yrani esorloqii yrpaincmoro cycnilrcrra NwnoAanbruoro po3B[rTKy fioro nparosnx coqiaJcHgx Ta ASMqKpaTI,ITIHLIX3acaA Bce 6imur BalKrrHBy ponr nigirpae rocr,rJreHur nporra4ii ropynuii,opranisonanifi sroquHgOCri ra iruuuu Br,rAaM flporr.rnpaBHoi noseAiHrn.gimue rraicqe y IrboMy npoqeci nociAae gano6iranHq ra|IonepeAxeHHs npaBorropyueHb, rri BqHrurroTbcr cy6'emaur,tnpanooxopoHnoi .qir$HOCTi 3 Br,rKopr.rcraHHrM CBoro cnyx6onorocraHoBr,rula, 1qo 3Haqgo cnpoqye ix cKoeHIUI, cnpgse riHigaqiiraHaHocgrb HeIIorpaBHy IIIKoAy cycnilrcrny, 4epxaoi ft orperrlifi oco6i.Tonry AocniAxenn.s Morusaqii ycix npomin npornnparuoinoseAiHrn cneqianrnnx cy6'exdn, y rrocri tKHx Bucqmalorbcninpo6irHuKg npaBooxopoHHux crpyKTyp, e Ba)KrrHBr,rM cKJTaAoBHMenere"rot Qoprr.rynannx Ta yAOcKoHaJIeHHt eQerrunuoro cOqialrsOrouexanisuy ii aano6iraHrul Ta y[epepKeHH.n.Ha croro4ui .qoBeAeHo, Iqo none4iury cy6'erra cnprMoBye- kOMrJreKe-MOTr.rBiB;- qKi-Ee titbKti'He Bui.uiiqdliirb'dlilfH ttAHoro,'d"HaBrraKI,I -,qonoBHlolorb, ni4ct'tlltototl, npHcKoplolorb <popuyranrunporr,rflpaBHoro narraipy i nepepocraHHlo fioro y KoHKperHenpaBonopyrueHHt, lpoflBJltloqu ce6e rr CxlaAosi eJIeMeHTI{ IIiIiCHOicrpyKTypll ll,c.25l.Hafi6irnru mpr6oxe i glricrosHe Bu3HaqeHHq MorI{BynpaBonopy[eHHt rlporronye B.I. Tnuourenro, rKa HaroJlomye, qo nigMOTI{BOM cliA posylrliru ncnxoloriqse {Br{ule, uo AB]fl'l€. co6oronHyrpiururo 6e:nocepegHro [puqr,rHy girunr, Bprpaxae oco6ucricnecraBJreHHr cy6',erra Ao Toro, Ha rrlo cnpanaonaHi fioroaii. Morr,IgttnHpaxaroTb HafisaxnHsiuri pucu i slacrusOcri, norpe6u i npalreuH-roco6u 12,c.41. IOptIgu'rua eHufiKnoneAis [sHa'Iae MorHB 3noql'tHy tKycni4ortlleHy c[oHyKy (nparueHHr) .qO :AificHeHHt KoHKpeTHo-BoJIboBI{x^iit qw yrpLIMaHHt eiA HHx (6e:gixlsHicrr), :ytnloaleHl,x rlorpe6aMH,yrloBHoBaxeHoMy opraHi gepxannoi Ytagu, 4epxannifi ycrauooi (opratl4epxanuo'i BJIaAI{, AepxaBHa ycraHoBa' IKI{M 3aKoHoM HaAaHo ilpaBosAificHrosaTH Tpr.rMaHHfl ni4 naprorc oci6), cniauuit cylut :o6os',qsatrHilsa$ircyraru raKy 3atBy a6o npuftnxrn siA oio6u ruc;MoBy 3aqBy ra:,u6"aniuttx IresiAKnaAHe npoBe.4eHHt cyAoBo-Me.quqHoro o6crexesltfloco6n; Aopyquru siAnosiAHol*{y opraHy AocyAoBoro po:cli4ynaHrlrrrpoBecrl,I .qocliaxeHsx Qarria, BI'IKJIaAeHlrx s sassi oco6u; BxlITHnlo6xi,unux gaxoAis Nrfl sa6egneqeHH.s 6egneru oco6pt sriAHo iriaronogancrsoM. Haqsnicrr gaqsr4 aig sarpuuaHolo e Heo6oa'f3xonolo,,,bcxinrxlr clilqnfi cyryfl go6os'ggaHnfi oprani:ynarl'I BHUIeBlIKJIaAeHy'tnepenipxy, rKrrlo soB'i,,,Hift Br{fJUrA 3arpr{MaHoro, craH qu inui siao*{i"nil"ory cyAAi o6craBr4gr Aarorb niAcrasn 4-nr o6rpyurosaHoi ni4o:pHfiopy[reHut BI{Mor 3aKoHoAaBcrsa niA qac 3arpnMaHrul a6o'rpI'IMaHHfl By[oBHoBax(eHoMy opraui gepxaaHoi BJIaAI{' 4epxanHifi ycraHoni'bniaqufi cyAAr go6oe'sgaHr,rfi BXHrr.r neo6xiAul,lx raxogin An,tga6egneqeHHq oco6u, grca nog6asreHa cso6oAH, 3axucHllKOr'4 i siAKIaCrn6ylr-rnnfi pO31.1I-sA, y tKoMy 6epe ytacrr taxa oco6a, ua seo6xiAuuit Ntx'sa6erneqeHHg oco6u 3aXLICHITKOM qac, TKIIIO eoua 6axae 3airrll',ITl',l3axucHuKa a6o tKIIro cri.qqlrfi cygt nupiurNrl, uo o6craBuHlt,BcraHoBJIeHi nil qac rpuuiualsuoro fipoBa.4xeHnf,, BllMaralorb yracri3AXHCHHKA.Cnucor BHKoPHcraHIrx AxePeJr:l. KpurvrinanrHuft npouecyanHrui KoAeKc Yrpalnu / osiqifiHuil tercr. - K. :<f-[eurp yr6oeoi nireparypu)), 2012. * 292 c-2. 3axon Yxpaina <[po cyaoycrpifi i cmryc cyMin> /OQiqiftHlafi sicHrrY-xpplglr, 36ipn45 HopMarHBHo:III4BqP.Hx ?ril!s., Mitttt-tppg:Cg-roc.14uii-Y*rpqiur, :K. , AII <Vrpaincsra rpaBoBa int|opr'aauix>,2010' - 198 c'paxyHoK BH3HaHHI noKa3aHb eKcnepra tK oKpeMofo nu4y.4oxasin (v' Icr. 95 K[IK), ni,{craBn, yIuoBI'r ra npolreAypa orpHMaHHs i 'qocnilkehnssxllx :HaftuJII'I cBoe oKpeMe xpulrinalrue npouecyanbHe yperyrloBanHt B$opui Aonlrry (cr. 356 KnK).Ha cra.qii AocyAoBoro poacni.qyeanun AorIIlTy eKcilepra llenepeg6aveno. Xoqa i n. 2 u. 5 "r. 69 KIIK ft sHa.rr,rrbcr npo fioroo6tn'ssor npn6yrn He JInIue 4o clAY, a fi Ao cliAvoro ra nponypopa iAarH siAno"iai - nia qac Ao[HTy, aJIe B q' 224 K[IK' Hoprrll'I fiKoinpucuueni AorIHTy Ha AocyAoBol''Iy po:cniAysaHni, figerscq JII'Iue flpoaontt csiAKa i norepnirlo.o. foty ini.q gngHam, rqo sa HosI'IM KIIKAonHr eKcrrepra ro*" 6y." sAificHeHnfi JII{uIe B cyAi (cr. 356.KIIK). I ueoireB[AHo, ocrilrrn yN{oBaMI'I ftoro 4onury, tK IIe BITIIJII{Ba€ 13 npHnI'IcrBq. I cr. 365 K[IK, e, rro-rrepule' [poBeAeHHs HI{M y AaHoMyxpuuiuamnor"ry [poBaAXeHHi nia qac AocyAoBoro poscliAynauHxcyaonoi eKcneprl{3l'{ Ta, rlo-Apyfe' nonepeAHe AocliAxeuHt AaHoro HI'IMBncHoBKy B xoAr cyAoBoro po3mqAy.fliAcraeorc NrA BI{KJII{Ky eKcnepra An'fl Aonl'rry B cyAl €neo6xilnicrr pol'nureuHt AaHoro HHM BHcHoBxy (u' I cr' 356 K[IK)' Ueo3Haqae, ufo inuri rrItTaHHq, nos'sgaHi 3 BI4cHoBKoM, 3oKpeMa fi ri, qxicrocyrorbct froro oco6n i Houusreuqii, uarorr s'rconysarncq B cyAiiuuruupr [poqecyanbHltMll r[JIrxaMH, HaIIp[KJIaA, IIIJLfiXOM nO,4aHHt TaAOcniAxesnr riAnonigHr,rx AoKyrueHrin. flpu l{boMy BI'IKJII'IK eKc[Iepra AJUIAoIIHTy glr pos'lcHeHHq BHcHoBKy Moxnusnfi rl'Iile 3a KJIonoraHHf,M"topot, *ptiin-"toro [poBaAXeHHfl, norepniloro a6o sa BnacHoloiHiuiarueorc cyAy ('I. I cr. 356 K[K)'flpoueaypa AorII'ITy eKcnepra.B :yAi 6araro y rloMy BlApl3Hterbct--BiA npoqe5ypl4--'Aonury' n cyai iurullx oci6' " ulo noflcnrcerbcsrHoceoloriqnuuu oco6rHBocrqMH, ffi Jlexarb s ocHosi BI'IcHoBKyeKcnepra, Ta [peAMstoM AonI4Ty. 3no4nrscr BoHa Ao Hacr]mHoro'llepeA Aor[rroM eKcrrepra rolonytouufi BcraHoBJIrue fioro oco6y rarrpuBoAl.{rb Ao npuctru tu*oio :uicry: <<-f, (npienraqe' iM'i' no 6arrrosi)npr"".ulo cywinso Br.{KoHyBaTn o6os',slrH eKcllepra, BI'{KOpI'ICTOByrcqusci cgoi npo<fecifini Mo)KJrr{Bocri>. flicns uboro ronoByrovnfi nonepeAxaeeKcnepra npo xpr{t"tiHanbrry eiAnosiAanrHicrs ga HaAaHHq :agiAol'{oHerrpaBAllBoro BI{cHoBKy 1u' t q' 356 KflK), a raKox ra niqnaony 6esfloBax(Hr,rx IIpHrrHH siA Sr.rroHaHHq [oKnaAeHofo Ha Hboro o6os',l3Xy acyAi, Xrui,t 3BOAHTbCS AO o6on'rtrcy AaBaHHq IIOKa3aHb' Iqo 3Heo6xiaHicrro BHrrJrHBa€ i: npnnnciu n.2,1.5 cr. 69 KIIK ra q- I cr. 385KK YrpaiunIlonepe4xeHHt eKcnepra flpo rcpuuiHansny BlAnoBlAanI'HlcTb 3aHa.IIaHHt :aeiaoil'to HenpaB.{I'lBoro BHclIoBKy' n rofi qac qK ilovy uarexurl-=>.e<-Bacnw lfonarruwxo,d.n.a., npo$., daPexmoP hrcmumYmYnpass in. I. MuturtorcbKoeoH a qio nan wtozo Y uie ePc umemY<OcmPonxs axade*tiiltAOnI{T EKCTIBPTA B CyAIKIIK Vrcpai:Hu 2012 p. :Havno po3lxHpHs o6cqr BHKopItcraHI{tcneuialsHr.rx 3HaHb y xpr.fi,,r iHaru,HoMy npoBaA)I(eHHi. n rouy ' l l ' lcJ]i ' t irl lrr :,'*mr,rii;t'.B, - , a Li. :fa.,i i.,r{$il'riili:i !#::;lliiu'it'f l i-:,t52 1 5 3AaTlr rroKa3aHHf (q. I cr. 95 KnK), croroAsi MoxHa rrorcHHTH rHM, IIIO[peAMeroM .{onHTy eKcnepra € caMe fioro s[cHoBoK, po3'scHeHHflrroJroxeHb BHcHoBKy, a ne ii AorroBHeHHfl. flpn neo6xiAnocri AorIoBHeHHtBHcrroBKy O69n'q3roso MzUIa 6 npoao4uTgct AoAarKoBa eKCnepTH3a.Touy-ro, 4o peui, peAaKIIit cr. 384 KK Yrcpailrn, tKolo nepeA6aqeHaxpuuiHangra eiAuoeiA:urbHicTb eKcnepra 3a 3aBiAoMO Uenpan4unuftBHCHSBOK, a He IIOKzt3aHHt, 3aKOHOu Yxpainn <<fIpO nneCeHHt 3MiH AOAetKI{x 3aKoHOAaBqI.Ix aKTiB y 3B'q3Ky s npufirurrru KpurvriHaJIbHoIOnpoqecyarlbHoro KoAeKcy yKpaiHu> siA 13.04-2012p.Ilb 465-VI IqoAo"tanigouo HenpaBAI{BI,Ix rloKa3aHb eKcnepra He AorIoBHeHa.,r Y qroruy 3B'q3Ky cJIiA 3BepHytr'I yBary i na rare. Y '1- 7 cr. l0lKrIK, uoprrar.r Koi peuraMeHryroTb BucHoBoK eKcnepTa rK oAHH 3 BHAiBAoKa3iB, Ha BiAMiHy siA sI'IqeHaneAeHI'Ix rpurulciB 'r. I cr. 356 KnK'3Hatrr,rrbcs, ulo KoxHa cropoHa Mae npaBo 3BepHyrHct Ao cyAy 3KJrorrOTaHI[lM IIpO BI{KJII,IK eKC[epTa N6 AOT1,;71Ty 11iA 'IaC CyAOBOIOpo3HItAy He JII{Ue AJUI pO3'tcHeHHt' a fi <wfi AOTIOBHeHH$> ftoroBHCHOBKy. AIe oqeelIAHO, UIO Tyf Mae 3acTocoByBaTHct npurulc'r. I CI'356 KIIK 3 rI,Ix niAcraB, Iqo niu e Hoptylorc cneqialrHolo AlIt AaHoroBr{naAKy, i s rofi xe qac HopMoro, f,Ka )tsfoAxyeTbcf, i e reranrHuunoHf l ITsMBHcHoBKyeKcI IepTaf ,K((AoKJraAHoroouncynpoBeAeHl{xeKcnepTOM AocniAxeHb Ta 3po6neHi sa ix pByJIbTaTaMH BIICHSBKI'I'o6fpyHToBani siAnoni.qi Ha noctaBneHi eKcnepTy 3arll.Irannx...> ('r. Icr. l0l KnK), i g ocHoBHlIM fioro o6os'qgxol\d tK yqacHl{KaKpHMiHaIrbHoro [poBaAxenHr: ((oco6ncro lrpoBecrl{ rIoBHe AocJIiAxeHHf,i Aaru o6fpygToBasufi, ra o6'ermsHgft sqcHosox Ha IIocTaBJIeHi ftoMy3annraHHfl, a B pa3i Heo6xiAHocri - pos'rcHl'IrH fiofo)) (n. I v' 5 cr' 69-,,* --KmQLArorr,ry-toro-qonoBuemls.-MorJllIBe-JlltnexaniAclani-.qo.qarxOruXAocniAxenr i rilrrn y nucbMoBifi $oprvri, flKruo He BBaxaTI'IAonoBHeHHf,M BHcHoBKy si.qnosiAi eKclepTa, tKi fpygTyloTbcr. HanpoBeAeHoMy HI{M eKcIIepTHoMy AocJIiAxeHHi, ale 3 nprBoAy tKltx ftoMyHe cTaBHrl{cf, 3a[HTaHtuI y 3BepHeHHi rlpo npoBeAeHHt eKcneprH3H.Blacne AorrHT eKcrrepra 3AificHro€Tbcr rrrJlffxoM rIocraHoBKI'I fioMy3arII,ITaHb. floqruIaerbct BiH 3 TaK 3BaHoro 11ptMofo AorIHTy, npolreAypagKoro 3BoAI,ITbc' Ao To|o' qo nepllloro eKcIIepTa Aonl{rye cTopoHa' 3'l3BepHeHHtM atcoi sitr rpoBoALIB eKcnepru3y (u.2 cr.356 KIIK).flpegrvrerorvr flprMoro Ao[Irry eKcnepra, y fiepury qePry, e nlITaHHt'Anr po3'f,cHeHHf, sKr,rx cTopoHa 3BepTaJracr ao cyAy 3 KJrOrroTaHHtM npofiOrO sr,rKnHI( Ant AOnHry. HnrvIu Mox(ytb 6yru nnraHIUI, IIIO CTOcyrOTbct6yAr-xxoi qacrlrHu BHcHoBKy ra 6yAr,-flKofo iloro acIIeKTy: po3'tcHeHH{BrrKopgcTaHoi cneqia;lrHoi TepMiHolorii ra Qoprr,rynrcraHb, AOcTaTHocTiTa fipr{AarHocri saAaur.rx Arq AocriAXeHHq ruarepialia qx fioro o6'ercrin,o6rpynryeaHHs o6paHoro c[oco6y [poBeAeHHf, eKcIIeprH3I,I roulo. v .I. 3cr. j56 K;IK, 3oKpeMa, cKa3aHo: <Erccnepry Moxytb 6yrn nocrqueHi3anHTaHHt rrloAo HagsHocri B eKcnepTa c[eqiaJIbHI,IX 3HaHb Tarcrali$ixauii g AocripKyBaHr.rx nuraHb (ocnirn, croKy po6oTl4, Ha)rKoBoIocTyneHr Torqo), AOTlrqHnx Ao rrpeAMeTa ftoro ercnepTl{3q; BHKOpLICTaHI1XM9TOAHK Ta TeopeTnqHr,rx po3po6oK; AocTaTHocTi BiAOMOCTefi, Ha ni,qcrasiflKr,rx roTyBaBcr Br{cHoBoK; Ha)troBoro o6fpyHTyBaHHt Ta MeToAiB' 3a.[orroMoforo rKr.rx eKcnepT .qifiluos BrrcHoBKy; 3acrocoBHocri TArrpaBr,IJlbHocri 3acrocyBaHHr npnnqunin ra MeroAiB Ao $arrinrpuuinalsnoro npoBaAxeHHr; innri 3arrr4TaHHt, Iqo cTocyloTbctBr,rcHoBK)D).Cropoua, tKa npoBoAI'ITb nptMl{fi AonI'IT, Nrs' AoBeAeHIUIAocroBip;ocri BrrcHoBKy eKcrepra Mae npaBo HaAaBarI{ ei,{o1,Ioffi, qxicTocyroTbcs 3HaHb, BMiHb, gali$iraUii, ocnirn ra niAroToBKlI eKcnepTa(u. 5 cr. 356 K[IK), a oTx(e it crasuTvr eKcrrepTy 3arLIraHIUI 3 npLIBo,[y quxaiAOuocrefi, a eKcnepr, y cBoro qepry, niA .rac si.qnosi.4efi na qi ra iruli3anr{TaHHt Mae npaBg KopI,ICTyBaTI{Ct cBOiML nuCbMOBITM}l Ta iHIIIHMI'IMarepianaMlr, qKi BHKopIrcToByBaIIHca nig qac eKcneprHoro AocniAXeHrUI(v.6 cr.356 KnK).Ilicns 3aBeprrreHrur np Moro Aonr,rTy eKcnepra nporl,InexHifi cr:opoHiHaAaeTbcr rrpaBo ftoro nepexpecHoro Ao[IITy 3a TaKHMII )|( [paBHJIaMH,TO6TO npaBo AOnIrTy (fiaBxpeCTD fK Ha npeAMeT 3anuTaHb, IIIo cTaBI'IJIHctfiorray npu nprMoMy AonLIri, rar i ycix inulux, aJIe yxe 3 nporlLJIe)KHHxnoeHrlifi, 3 Merqro AHcKpeAr{Taqii rx Br,rcHoBKy eKc[Iepra B IIinoMy, raK iAucKpeAI,ITaIIii cauoro eKc[epra.flpaa4a, B cr. 356 KIIK npaBo rlpornJlexHoi croponn Ha-flepexpecnHfi -AoITHr-eI€nepTa nptMo' He'RepeA6arleHo. I{e nporarlnHa ".--qlrHHoro KIIK VrpaiHu. Bosa Aonaerbct IIIJItxoM 3acrocyBaHHtlplrlHciB 3ACaAr4 3aKOHHOCTi npo Te, rqo KpHMiHZInbHe npoqecyallbHe3aKOHOAaBcrBo Yrpaiun 3acrocoByeTbct 3 ypaxyBaHHsM npaKTI'IKI'Ieaponeftcrrofo cyAy 3 rrpaB nroAHHH (v. 5 cr. 9 KIIK). 3riAuo N rnpaxruxolo erponeficrrorc cyAy 3 npaB IK)AHHH npaBo cropiH Hanepexpecuufi Aonr{r eKcnepra e oAHi€rc is CKJIaAOB}IX npaBa Ha"1pu"i4n""uit cy1onufi po3HUrA, :arpinreuoro B cr. 6 CKIII (at{s..r,pu"t' ()K. E. nporl.{ @paHuii> siA 2 xosr[fl 2001 p', <<Ealcire-JliAeriese nporu llnrsu) eiA 4 ruc'ronaaa 2008 p. ra iH')'flicrq 3aBeprrreHHr repexpecHoro AorrHl'y eKcrepTy Moxylb 6yrl4[ocTaBneHi 3anUTaHHt noTepnin6M, UI-rBinbHHM no3?rBaqeM, UHBinbHI'tMsiAnoeiAaqeu, i;1 npe.4cTaBHrrKaMH Ta 3aK6HHHMH IIpeAcTaBHHKaMI',I, araKox fonoByrorrHM i cyA.4xull (u.2 cr.356 KInq.v pasi, KonH eKcrrepTa BnKJrr.{KaHo 3a KJro[oTaHHtM norepniloro a6o1 5 51543a BJIacHoto ittiqiarnsolo cyAy, nepruutu fioro AonI'IT Ha [peAMer niAcrasraroro BHKJII,IKy sAiftcHroe, nignoni4Ho, norepnimafi a6o clA' :a HI'IM' Bcr,rJry 3Maransnocri cyAoBoro po3ilItlAy' Ta cropoHa KpHMTH:uIbHororrpoBaAxeHrul, 3a 3aMoBJreHHf,M rxoi ercnepr rIpoBoAItB eKcnepru3y' aflKrrlo eKcrreprl,I3a rlpoBo.4l{nacfl 3a Aop} IeHHxrvr cYAY (u' 2 ct' 332 K[IK)'- Ta cropoHa, tKoro, o6nuuynalrHofo qI'I BHnpaBAyBzrJIbHoro xapaxTepy'BH.rrBHBct BlIcHoBoK "*"rrapiu. floAalrurufi ftoro Aouur sAiftcHloerbcs s3aranbHoMy, BlIIqeHaBeAeHoMy flopflAKy'l V BnnaAKy, KoJII'I cyAy uagaui 4na a6o 6inrure BI'IcHoBKIB' sKlQwepe.rarb oAHH oAHOMY, cYA Mae [paBo rrp]€Haqnru oAnoqauruil"tr";;;;;;; tt'oin"-" "*c,,epti" s"" "'i"yuuHHt 'p".II'IH por6ixtrocri niiHix sucnoBKax, u1o croc)ilorbcfl oAHoro i roro caMoro [peAMera qnrltraHHt AocriAXeHH-s (u.4 cr. 356 K[K)'I{e rax :saHuft flraxosrfr AonI'Ir elccneprin' lloro cyrr rroJlrfae yToMy, ulo ogna i 'ra x o6craer4:na, y HaIIroMy BI'InaAKy oAIaH i rofi xenpeAMer. tlu nHTaHHt' sri niAAanamacr gocligNeuHlo pisHuuu"iarr"ptut", i xxi 6ynu nr'Ipi'reui ttl'lttll't no-pisHortry' 3'lconlnotlclo,unieto oco6oto IlrJLsxoM nocniAosHoi nocraHoBKl{ IIIIM eKcnepraMnnignonigul.rx 3arrr.rTaHb. Ilepronicrr npoBeAeHHs IIIaXoBoro AoIII',ITy, 3HOByx raKH 3 ypaxyBaHuqM 3acar$ luaralrHocri, BI'BHaqae cyA' A-neuraxosnfi AonHT ercneprin t"toxltlEsufi JIHrue nicns ix ocHoBnoro(npxr',roro i nepexpecnoro) ,uonury 3 tlForo x ilpeAMera llu rfiraHrul'duru * nocniaosHiCTb Aonlrry eKcrreprlB Br{3Haqaerbcl oco6oro, sxa ixAonI,ITye, na ii PoscY.uB riHqesoMy perylrrari Merotcl uaxoBoro AonI'ITy 3riAHo 3 3aKoHoMe 3'flcyBaHHt rIpH.II'IH por6ixnocri, cyflepeqHocrefi y BLI:HoBK11 lll:pos6ixHoctefi i cynepeqsocJeri y BI{cHoBKax eKc[€prlB IrlIItxoM lxrrraxoBoro AonI{Ty ycyHyftI He BAacrbcfl, cyl 3a Knor:11".t1Y,^::l:lxpr,tt*liHalHroro [poBaANCeHrIfl , norepniloro qH 3a BJracHoIo lHruraTHBOIOnnpani Aopytrnrll npoBeAeHHt excneprnifi ycrauoni' eKcnepry a6oeKcnepraM nontopHoi'-eKcneprH3rl (u' I v' 2 cr' 332 KIIK)'_J=>,e<2Bacma Caegeuxo,K. K). rt., do qenm xaQedp u rqtunianitaozonpasa, npoqecy i xpntuiuaticmuxuI e a uo -@p aaxie c u<oz o Q arcyn t m e myH a qio u ant ao a o y ui o ep c u m e my" Od ecaxa rup ud uuua arcad etnin "TIIACTABLI, fIOP.flAOK TA TIPI4nHHEHIIfl TITMqACOBO|OBIIJIYIIEHIIS MAfrHA TIPN AOCYAOBOMY PO3CJIIAYBAHHIATrICrpir'.mufi po3BHroK HayKoBo-rexsiqsoro nporpecy y 20-uycronirT i AaB JIIoAcrBy rr,roxlunicrb BHKopI{craHHt HoBoro'rpaHcnoprrlororaco6y - asroMo6irq. [IIsHAxicm, na4ifiHicrr, riguocHa AeIxeBH3Ha rauo6inrHicrr cIrpHsJII,I ITBI,IAKoMy po3BLIrKy astoMo6imHoi ingycrpii.flporen 3 nof,Boro asrol\,Io6irt nocraila nona npo6leMa, tKa nontraJla yno[epeAxeuni nopyurenr ra poacri4yoauui 3Jto.tlluin, Iuo Bql{Hslorbcfloco6auu, rxi nepyrorr rpaHcnoprHuuu gaco6auu.9uuaro no3r{THBHI,Ix HoBeJI, c[pflMoBaHl{x Ha noKpaIrIeHHteSerrnnnocri porcni4yaauHr rcpnuiHiulbHl,Ix crpaB, 6yno sanpooaA)KeHois upnfiHrrrrM HoBoro KIIKYrcpaihn.OAnar 3acrocyBaHm AetKI,Ix uoprr,r KIIK ropo.eKye 6esriq 3aur{raHby cy6' errin rpuuiHamuoro npoBa"exeHHa, cliAuI'IX, nporypopin, cygAir.Ouixyraru giA sr,rqrx cyAir nu.repnHl,Ix peKoMen,qaqifi ulogo nupirueunxTIlx qI{ ignrux cKJra.u{Hx TILITaHr IoKH luo nepeAqacHo, ocrilrru 4;l.rroqarKy ocransi Malorb sr rarci nocrarH nepeA siArosiAuHMI'I_ cyAgB4l{14opranarr.fl,r, nmiu noeltuHi- 6yrr-onilaUronani, a-sxe niC; Ilboro3anpo[oHoBasi runsxpt ix rupiureunx.HosuM y rpnuinarbHoMy fipoqecyaJlbHoMy 3aKoHogancrai e raKox(rarnfi saxiA sa6egnerteHHt rpnuiHalsHoro npoBaAxeHHfl, tK TI,IMqacoBeBuJryqeHH.rr vraitua, qo raKox BI,IKJII,IKac r{HMiuIo 3arIHTaHb. BianosiAHo .qocr. 167 KIIK VrpaiHH, TLItvrrtacoBHM BHJr) IeHnsI\l r{afiHa e $arruunenos6asreHHr ni4osprcnaHoro MoxulnBocrl nonogiru, KoplrcryBaruct rapo3nopqAx(arlrcr neBHHM fioro uafiHoM Ao nupiurenn-r ilLIraHHt npoaperrrr vraitlaa a6o fioro rIoBepHeHHt.TuNl.racoso Br,uDrrreHHM oxe 6]l'ru uaftuo y uuux4i peuefi,goryueurin, rpourefi ToIIIo, uroAo qKlrx e AocrarHi niAcrasu BBaxarlr, tqoBOHH:l) nigruyrcaHi, BuroroBnet{i. npucroconaui qH auxopr.lcraui rr:aco6u qv 3*apflD,Il BtIr.{HeHHt ttpl.ttrliualluoro flpaBortopylueHHt ra (a6o)157

Допит експерта в суді.

(The court interrogation of expert.)

http://eprints.oa.edu.ua/2663/1/Popeliushko_13022014.PDF

Допит експерта в суді. (The court interrogation of expert.)

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Цифровий архів Острозької академії (Digital Repository of Ostroh Academy)