A Comparative Analysis of Psychiatric Profile, Depression and Body Dysmorphic Disorder in patients with Amputation and Post Stroke.

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Amputation is defined as the removal of extremities of body part by trauma or by Surgical procedure. Amputees may feel empty, and mutilated. Amputation due to Trauma is a catastrophic injury and causes major disability in most of the cases (Wald 2004)1. Loss of limb is associated with low self-esteem, body image Disturbance, social isolation and also a sense of stigmatization (William et al. 2004). In many conditions amputation is unavoidable. Irrespective of the aetiology, Amputation is considered as a mutilating surgery and it definitely affects the lives Of the patients (De Godoy et al. 2002). Limb amputation is a more commonly Occurring event in the present society. The loss of a limb distorts the individual’s body image leading to the thought of Not being a complete human being. The loss of the functions performed with that Limb renders him helpless for sometime. The amputee not only loses physical Functioning, he also loses hope and future aspirations, his plans and ambitions get Shattered. Thus, he loses not only a limb but also a part of his world and future. Most of them remain anxious and worried about their interpersonal relationship in The social, vocational, familial and marital milieu. Individuals having an overt Mental breakdown will need active psychiatric intervention whereas careful Psychiatric interview is necessary for the ones whose mental symptoms are not so Obvious. Limb loss is a major event that can severely impact the psychological health of the Individual concerned. Studies show that 20-60% of the amputees attending follow Up clinics are assessed to be clinically depressed. Individuals with traumatic Amputation irrespective of the age are likely to suffer from body image problems, But these findings are more common in younger individuals. The psychological Reactions to amputation are clearly diverse ranging from severe disability at one Extreme; and a determination to effectively resume a full and active life at other End. In adults the age at which an individual receives the amputation is an Important factor. Studies by Bradway JK et al (1984)2, Kohl SJ Et al (1984)3, Livneh H (1999)4, on the psycho-social adaptation to amputation has led to a Plethora of clinical and empirical findings. Kingdon D et al 1982 equated Amputation with loss of one’s perception of wholeness, while (Parkes CM 1976)5 With loss of spouse and (Block WE et al (1963)6 with symbolic castration & even Death. The individual’s response to a traumatic event is influenced by personality Traits, pre-morbid psychological state, gender, peri-traumatic dissociation, Prolonged disability of traumatic events, lack of social support and inadequate Coping strategies. Previous studies on amputation mainly focused on demographic Profile, coping skills and outcome; with there being a scarcity of literature on Prevalence of various specific psychiatric disorders in the post-amputation period. Most patients with a limb loss irrespective of whether due to traumatic injury or Surgical procedures go through a series of complex psychological reactions Reported by Cansever et al (2003)8. Most people try to cope with it, those who Don’t succeed develop psychiatric symptoms Frank et al (1984)7. Shukla et Al9 noted that psychological intervention in some form is needed in about 50% of All amputees, and Shukla et al9 reported depression to be the most common Psychological reaction following amputation. The three major problems faced by many amputees are anxiety, depression and Physical disability (Green 2007) Horgan & maclachlan (2004)10 found that anxiety is associated with depression, Low self esteem, poorer quality of life and higher level of general anxiety. Both Anxiety and depression are associated with higher disability as age increases. Body image is the combination of psychosocial adjustment and attitude of the Individual that are related to the function and appearance of one’s own body which Can be influenced by the individual and his environmental factors (Horgan & Maclachlan 2004)10. Each person has an idealized body image, which he uses for Measuring perceptions and concepts of his or her own body (Fishman, 1959)11. From another perspective, Flannery & Faria (1999) body image is viewed as a Dynamic, changing phenomenon occurring in a person and it is formed by the Constantly changing perceptions about his body. According to Newell (1991)13, Attractive people after amputation will receive less reinforcement from others Leading to low self-esteem and reduced positive self-image. Jacobsen et al (1997) Supports this stating i.e. Amputation leads to disfigurement which in turn leads to a Negative body image and greater loss of social acceptance. The relationship Between disability experience and stigma are interwoven and inter-dependent. The Reason for the amputee’s subjective perception of being unfit for the society Probably is that body image provides a sense of ‘’self’ ’and also affects the Persons thinking (Wald 2004)1. According to Kolb (1975)14, changes in body Image may cause series of psychological reactions. The psychiatric aspect of amputation has received scant interest in our country, in Spite of accidental injuries being common (Shukla et al., 1982)9. The commonest Psychiatric disorder seen in amputees is major depression. Randall et al. (1945)15 Have reported an incidence of 61 % in non-battle casualties, while Shukla et al. (1982)9 found depressive neurosis (40%) and psychiatric depression (22%) to be The leading psychiatric disorders in amputees; only 35% of the total sample in the Later study had nil psychiatric disorders. The paucity of literature in this field has Prompted us to study about amputation and its co morbid psychiatric conditions so That proper care & management for the patients can be planned. The present study Was undertaken with the aim of studying the psychiatric problems especially Anxiety, depression and Body Dysmorphic Disorder which may be associated with Disability or changed life circumstances in the immediate post-amputation period. A comparison was made with Stroke patients, as these patients often experience Physical and social handicaps similar to amputees. Depression is the most common mood disorder to follow stroke (Starkstein & Robinson, 1989), with major depression affecting around one quarter to one third Of patients (Hackett16).. Depression hampers functional recovery in a post stroke individual. In Diagnostic And statistical manual (DSM) IV Post Stroke Depression classified under “mood Disorder due to general medical condition (i.e. Stroke)” with the specific depressive Features, major depressive-like episodes, manic features or mixed features. Studies Describe that cerebral ischemia is associated with two types of depressive disorder. Incidence of major and minor depression is 25% and 30% respectively. Prevalence May vary over time with an apparent peak 3months after the stroke and Subsequently decline in prevalence at 1 year. Robinson and colleagues studies Showed a spontaneous remission in the natural course of major depression Occurring post stroke in the first to second year following stroke. However in few Cases depression may become chronic and persist for a longer period. While some propose that post stroke depression is due to stroke affecting the Neural circuits concerned with mood regulation (thereby supporting a primary Biological mechanism), others in the scientific community claim it to be due to the Ensuing psycho-social stressors occurring as a result of stroke. Though an Integrated bio- psycho- social model is warranted, most studies clearly suggest Biological mechanism to have an upper hand in the later post stroke period than in The immediate phase. In the same way Anxiety is also common in post stroke individuals with the Incidence rate being 20%, and it is most common in first three to four months after The stroke. Studies and literatures on post stroke anxiety are very few still remain in its Infancy. Studies have concentrated on socio-demographic variables, cognitive Functions and laterality as examined for post stroke depression. Many studies show That there is correlation between anxiety and right hemisphere lesions and also that Co-morbid post stroke anxiety and depression are associated with left hemisphere Lesions [Astrom, (1996)17]. Many studies have shown the relationship between post Stroke anxiety, age and gender. Women and younger individuals are more Vulnerable to develop post stroke anxiety (Morrison, walter et al 200069), while Another study reports no such relationship (Schultz et al).1

    Similar works