Restoration action effectiveness: employing the concept of net ecosystem improvement

Abstract

The mission statement of the Northwest Straits Initiative includes ‘improving ecosystem health’ of the Strait of Juan de Fuca and Northern Puget Sound by restoring and protecting natural habitats and resources. For the Initiative, and many other programs, defining ‘ecosystem health’ and developing relevant and measureable health metrics is problematic, and yet critical to both assessing program action effectiveness as well as justifying investments. The Initiative is exploring utilizing the concept of net ecosystem improvement (NEI) to summarize results of actions and couch the results in a broader ecosystem perspective. Net improvement is defined as following development; there is an increase in the size and natural functions of an ecosystem or natural components of the ecosystem (Thom et al. 2005. Restoration Ecol. v. 13). Conceptual models are used to summarize knowledge and guide actions to improve the ecosystem. NEI is calculated by estimating the change in function times the change in area over which this change in function occurred including both temporal and spatial aspects. For example, the anchor out zone project managed by the Jefferson County Marine Resources Committee in Port Townsend protects 21.6ha (52 acres) of eelgrass. Without this protection most if not all of the eelgrass would be lost. Using data from other areas, we estimated that 3,998 - 66,077 Dungeness crab (primarily juveniles) and net production by eelgrass of 2,083 metric tons wet wt y-1, are protected. Based on WDNR monitoring (Christiaen et al. 2017), this area of eelgrass protected amounts to 0.5 – 0.8% of the total eelgrass area in the Straits, and 0.5% of the Puget Sound Partnership 2020 eelgrass recovery goal of ~4000ha. Estimating NEI and placing the results in a broader ecosystem perspective is possible for many actions taken by the Initiative’s Marine Resource Committees, and may be appropriate for other programs

    Similar works