The regulatory subunit of human DNA primase has a C-terminal domain (p58C) that contains a [4Fe4S] cluster and binds DNA. Previous electrochemical analysis of a p58C construct revealed that its affinity for DNA is sensitive to the redox state of the [4Fe4S] cluster. Concerns about the validity of this conclusion have been raised, based in part on differences in X-ray crystal structures of the p58C_(272-464) construct used for that study and that of a N-terminally shifted p58C_(266-456) construct and consequently, an assumption that p58C_(272-464) has abnormal physical and functional properties. To address this controversy, a new p58C_(266-464) construct containing all residues was crystallized under the conditions previously used for crystallizing p58C_(272-464), and the solution structures of both constructs were assessed using circular dichroism and NMR spectroscopy. In the new crystal structure, p58C_(266-464) exhibits the same elements of secondary structure near the DNA binding site as observed in the crystal structure of p58C_(272-464). Moreover, in solution, circular dichroism and ^(15)N,^1H-heteronuclear single quantum coherence (HSQC) NMR spectra show there are no significant differences in the distribution of secondary structures or in the tertiary structure or the two constructs. To validate that the two constructs have the same functional properties, binding of a primed DNA template was measured using a fluorescence-based DNA binding assay, and the affinities for this substrate were the same (3.4 ± 0.5 μM and 2.7 ± 0.3 μM, respectively). The electrochemical properties of p58C_(266-464) were also measured and this p58C construct was able to engage in redox switching on DNA with the same efficiency as p58C_(272-464). Together, these results show that although p58C can be stabilized in different conformations in the crystalline state, in solution there is effectively no difference in the structure and functional properties of p58C constructs of different lengths
