In this article, we present the findings of stable isotope analysis (carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen) from an analysis of human remains from a burial at the Pipe site (41AN67). The Pipe site is a late 15th-mid-16th century Caddo settlement and cemetery in the Lake Palestine area in the upper Neches River basin in East Texas that was investigated by Buddy Calvin Jones in 1968 and Southern Methodlst University in 1969

Perttula, Timothy K.

Walters, Mark

Wilson, Diane E.

English

SFA ScholarWorks

Index of Texas Archaeology: Open Access Gray Literature from the Lone Star State Volume 2012 Article 15 2012 Stable Isotope Analysis from a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas Diane Wilson Unknown Timothy K. Perttula Mark Walters Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.sfasu.edu/ita  Part of the American Material Culture Commons, Archaeological Anthropology Commons, Environmental Studies Commons, Other American Studies Commons, Other Arts and Humanities Commons, Other History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons, and the United States History Commons Tell us how this article helped you. Repository Citation Wilson, Diane; Perttula, Timothy K.; and Walters, Mark (2012) "Stable Isotope Analysis from a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas," Index of Texas Archaeology: Open Access Gray Literature from the Lone Star State: Vol. 2012 , Article 15. https://doi.org/10.21112/.ita.2012.1.15 ISSN: 2475-9333 Available at: https://scholarworks.sfasu.edu/ita/vol2012/iss1/15 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by SFA ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Index of Texas Archaeology: Open Access Gray Literature from the Lone Star State by an authorized editor of SFA ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact cdsscholarworks@sfasu.edu. Stable Isotope Analysis from a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. This article is available in Index of Texas Archaeology: Open Access Gray Literature from the Lone Star State: https://scholarworks.sfasu.edu/ita/vol2012/iss1/15 Stable Isotope Analysis frotn a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas Diane Wilson, Timothy K. Perttula., and Mark Walters INTRODUCTION In this article, we present the findings of stable isotope analysis (carbon, nitrogen. and oxygen) from an analysis of human remains from a burial at the Pipe site (41AN67). The Pipe site is a late 15"'-mid-16'h century Caddo settlement and cemetery in the Lake Palestine area in the upper Neches River basin in East Texas that was investigated by Buddy Calvin Jones in 1968 and Southern Methodist University in 1969. INFORMATION ON THE PLPE SITE Buddy Jones identitied and investigated the Pipe site (41AN67) in 1968. The site wa~ on a low terrace or lower toc slope on the west side of the Neches River valley, aud a photograph taken by Jones at the time showed the site area in a pasture, with a tree-covered floodplain to the north and east. The Pipe site had a substantial midden deposit as well as a cemetery with 21 burials (Figure l). \ Q- Burial Feature Figure 1. Map of the Pipe site redrawn from a Duddy Jones map on file at the Gregg County Histori<.:al Museum. Journal of Northeast Texas A.rchaeo/ogy, Volume 38,2012 80 Journal of Northeast Texas Archaeology 38 (2012) In 1969, a year after this site had been excavated by Buddy Calvin Jones, Southern Methodist University conducted their own excavations at the Pipe site (which they called the Ferguson site since they were unaware of the Jones excavations) before the construction of Lake Palestine (Anderson et al. 1974: 121-134). Their work was concentrated in a midden deposit near the northeastern extent of the landform (in the same area of the landform depicted in Jones' map, see Figure 1). No Caddo burials were identified during the SMU work, not too surprising given that the cemetery with 21 Caddo burials had been completely excavated a year or more before. No habitation features were documented in the SMU excavations, again not surpris-ing in that the midden was an area of trash deposits and habitation features (i.e., pits and post holes from domestic structures) would be expected to not occur in the midden, but in general proximity to, but outside of, the trash midden itself. SMU's archaeological investigations rarely strayed from the midden (Anderson ct al. 1974:Figure 58). What was recovered at the Pipe/Ferguson site was an abundance of Frankston phase ceramic vessel sherds (n=7964, including Poynor Engraved, Hume Engraved, Maydelle Incised, Bullard Brushed, Killough Pinched, and LaRue Neck Banded) and ceramic pipe sherds (n=43), mussel shell fragments and animal bones, and a modicum of chipped stone tool artifacts. The latter included 16 arrow points and fragments (of the Perdiz type), 13 flake tools and scrapers, and only 297 pieces of lithic debris. There are two radiocarbon dates from the Pipe/Ferguson site (Perttula 1997:Table 1), both obtained from the SMU excavations (Anderson et al. 1974), which is believed to be the same site as the Pipe site investigated by Buddy Calvin Jones. Both dates are on a wood post fragment buried in the midden deposits. These dates, using IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009) to calibrate their conventional ages, have calibrated age ranges at 2 sigma (95% probability) of A.D. 1529-1683 (Tx-1275) and A.D. 1444-1644 (Tx-1276). If these two calibrated age ranges accurately capture the temporal extent of the Caddo occupation, then it would appear that the site was occupied through most of the 16th and 17th century A.D. The mean calibrated age range of these dates is A.D. 1487-1663. A seriation of ceramics from Early to Historic Caddo period sites developed for the upper Neches River/ L'1ke Palestine area, indicates that the Pipe/Ferguson site more likely dates to the middle part of the Frankston phase (Perttula 2011a:Table 2). This group of sites has been estimated to date between ca. A.D. 1480-1560 (Perttula 2011b). As mentioned above, the mean age of the two calibrated radiocarbon dates from the Pipe/ Ferguson site is A.D. 1487-1663. This mean age is in agreement regarding the estimated initial occupation of the site taking place armmd the 1480s, but there is a broad divergence on when the end of the Caddo occupation dates to, either A.D. 1560 from the ceramic seriation data or the A.D. 1660s from the calibrated radiocarbon age ranges. Given the absence of Patton Engraved pottery sherds from the Pipe/Ferguson site (Anderson et al. 1974:Table 40), and an abundance of Poynor Engraved fine ware sherds in the assemblage, it is doubtful that the Caddo occupation here could have lasted as late as ca. A.D. 1650 (the beginning of the heyday of Patton Engraved manufacture and use), but how much earlier than that is unknown. Simply on the basis of the seria-tion results, it is conjectured that the occupation at the Pipe site/Ferguson site ended closer to ca. A.D. 1560 than it did to ca. A.D. 1650. RESUJ..,TS OF THE STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSIS The human remains sampled from the Pipe site were described in a previous study (Wilson 2006). They represented the remains of an adult male described in the Buddy Jones collection as Lot 29, B-11 Skull No 2, suggesting it was part of a multiple burial in the cemetery. Because the individual was represented by only a right femur, dietary reconstruction was not possible at the time of initial analysis. Journal of Northeast Texas Archaeology 38 (2012) Bl This study uses stable isotopes as a means to reconstruct the diet for the individual recovered from the Pipe site in the Buddy Jones collection. A sample of the right femur was sent to the Bone Chemistry Labora-tory, Department of Anthropology, at the University of Florida, Gainesville, where the sample was prepared and processed. Results were provided for b 13C on collagen and apatite, b15N on collagen, and b 1~ on apatite. Carbon stable isotopes are used to examine dietary sourcing. ultimately for plants that utilize different photosynthetic pathways: C3 C4 and CAM. All trees, woody shmbs, herbs,and temperate shade-loving grasses are C3 plants. Prior to the introduction of maize, Caddo food resources were C3 -based. The b13C values of C3 plant resources have an assumed average of -26.5o/oo, while C4 plants average -12.5o/oo (Tieszen 1991 ;Ambrose 1993). CAM (Crassulacean Acid Metabolism) plants are mostly succulents and have b13C values that overlap C3 and C4 plants. They are not discussed in this article due to their lack of dietary contribution to Caddo diets. Nitrogen isotope ratios provide information about the trophic level and protein sources in the diet. Nitrogen isotopes are useful in discerning aquatic versus terrestrial components of the diet. Hmnans in terrestrial-based food webs typically have b 15N values of6-ID%c, whereas consumers of fish may have b15N values that range as high as 15-20o/'oo (DcNiro and Schoeninger 1983; Hard and Katzenberg 2011). Ry convention, stable isotope ratios are expressed in the b notation, in parts per thousand, read as %o, relative to an international standard. For carbon the standard is the marine limestone PDB and for nitrogen it is what we refer to as AIR. Collagen is the main protein in bone and dentin that provides the source for organic carbon. It is less subject to isotopic substitution than apatite, the mineral portion of bone. Controlled diet studies on animals show that bone collagen primarily reflects the protein dietary carbon source while apatite reflects the whole diet (Ambrose and Norr 1993; Tiesl:en and Fagre 1993; Jim et at. 2004). The collagen enriclunent factor is the difference between the dietary and bone signature for carbon and is approximately 5%(1 (van der Merwe and Vogell978; Sullivan and Kmegcr 1981; Lee-Thorpe et al. 1989). Apatite enrichment is assumed to be arow1d 9.5%(1 (Sullivan and Krueger 1981; DeNiro and Schoeninger 1983). Oxygen isotopes are useu for geographic origin determination and are affected by latitude, regional topography, and weather patterns. Delta 180 decreases with distance to the earth's poles anu increases with humidity in the local environment. To date, little use of oxygen isotopes has occurred in the Caddo archaeological region. The results of the stable isotope testing are presented in Table 1. The b 13C collagen result is higher than the mean for Late Caddo period sites in the Neches and Angelina River basins presented in Perttula eta!. (20 ll) and raises the regional mean slightly (Table 2). This indicates a significant contribution of C4 to the protein portion of the diet in the Pipe site male tested. During the Late Caddo period, there is significant variability in D13Ccou"gen values within and between sites. The Pipe site result falls within the standard devia-tion for the region and periou. Table 1. Stable isotope results for Lake Palestine, Lot 29 8-11, SkuU 2 at the Pipe Site (41AN67). Collagen yield Percent CJN 61JC ()15N o[jc ,iBC ()18() collagen collagen o/oo collagen '7w apatite %o apatite- apatite %o collagen 0.048Sg 0.00375 3.2 -13.20 7 .02 -6.35 6.85 -9.50 ~2 Journal of Northeast Texas Archc1eology 38 (20/2) Table 2. Late Caddo period Neches and Angelina River basins stable isotope data . Except data from the Pipe Site, all data from Pea:ttula et al. (2011). Site name Site 613C collagen 613C apatite b ISN collagen o/oo o/oo %o Pipe 41AN67 -13.20 -6.35 7.02 Lang Pasture 41AN38 -15.6 -9.2 9.7 Lang Pasture 41AN3H -18.7 -10.2 -Lang Pasture 41AN3S -19.5 -9.7 -Lindsey Park 4LSM300 -21.8 - -Emma Owens Fam1 41AN2L -13.9 -6.8 6.3 EW Hackney 41CE6 -12.8 -6.7 2.8 EWHacknt:y 41CE6 - -7.4 8.9 JW Blackburn 41CE4 - -7.7 -JW Blackburn 41CE4 -9.7 -7.6 -OL Ellis Farm 41AN54 - -8.1 13.7 OL Ellis Farm 41AN54 - -7.4 12.4 EW Henry Fann 41CE17 -13.3 -12.1 -Fred McKee 41AN32 -12.2 -4.8 10.4 AH Reagor Fann 41CE15 -14.9 - 10.8 AH Rt:agor Farm 41 CE15 -13.3 -6.7 -Pierce Freeman Farm 41AN34 -14.8 -9.1 13.2 Lang Pasture 41AN38 -19.7 -8.7 -Mean -15.24 -8.03 9.52 Standard deviation 3.43 1.76 3.40 Like b 13C collagen, the 6 l3C apatite value is higher than the mean for the Late Caddo period in the Neches and Angelina River basins , but falls within the standard deviation for the time period. This result indicates that the individual from the Pipe site consumed more C4 dietary resource.s than the average for the region. Using Ambrose et al.'s ( 1997, 2003) formula, C4 contributed an estimated 62% of the dietary resources consumed by the tested individual at the Pipe site. In comparison, the average consumption of C4 for Caddo individuals in the Neches and Angelina River basins from the Late Caddo period is 50%. Nitrogen isotope values from the Pipe site individual were low compared to the mean for the region and time period (see Table 2). The 015N values for the region in the Late Caddo period are highly variable, indicating differences in protein resoun.:es, ranging from primarily beans to fish. The relatively low tro-phic value indic:ated by the 015N value combined with the relatively high 613C collagen and apatite values indicate a higher contribution of maize to the diet of the Pipe site individual than seen in most other Caddo individuals from the region. Journal of Northeast Texas Archaeology 38 ( 2012) 83 CONCLUSIONS In this study stable isotope testing has been used to reconstruct the diet for a Late Caddo period individual from whom only postcranial remains were present. In cases such as this, where teeth are lacking, stable isotope studies provide the only, as well as the mosl direcl, method for determinations of diet. With the use of stable isotope analysis we have been able Lo place the individual from Lhe Pipe sile into a regional context that shows a relatively varied diet, particularly in terms of protein sources. While the individual tested had a reasonably high contribution of maize to his diet, Figure 2 shows that he fits well within a small cluster of other individuals from the Late Caddo Neches and Angelina River basins. This cluster of four consists of adults from different sites: two males, one female, and one of indeterminate sex. Results are wmistent with an intensified maize agricultural diet. -25.00 -20.00 -15.00 -10.00 -5.00 <U ...... ".;l .... ··· ·---------·--··-··-··-·---··-··--·--·-·---------------------~-H-1---l • m ~---------------_,~~.-+---------------~~~ u M ~ -------------------··~----·-··--·----·---··-·-··-····-·-········-·····-8-;{){)········ ~ <U c • ······ ····· ····-···············-- - -----•• -···- · --- -~::::: I Delta 13C collagen Figure 2. C13C ,, plotted against 613C .,_ for the Late Caddo pericxi Neches and Angelina River basins. apaur~ COI.Lilgen 84 Journal of Northeast Texas Archaeolor;y 38 (2012) REFERENCES CITED Ambrose, S. H. 1993 Isotopic Anlaysis of Palt:odiets: Methodological and Interpretive Considerations. In Investigations of Ancient Human Tissue, edited by M. K. Sandford. pp. 59-130. Gordon and Breach Scientitic. Langhorne. Ambrose. S. H., J. Buikstra. and H. W. Krueger 2003 Status and Gender Differences in Diet aL Mound 72, Cahokia, revealed hy Isotopic Analysis of Bone. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 22:217-226. Ambrose, S. H., B. M. Butler. D. B. Hanson, R. L. Hunter-Anderson, and H. W. Krueger 1997 Stable Isotopic Analysi~ of Human Diet in the Marianas Archipelago. Western Pacilic American Journal of Physical Anthropology 104:343-361. Ambrose, S. H. and L. Norr 1993 Isotopic Composition of Dietary Protein and Energy versus Bone Collagen and Apatite: Purified Diet Growth Experiments. In Molecular Archaeology uf Prehistoric Human Bone. edited by J. R. Lambert and G. Grupe, pp. 1-37. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Anderson, K. M., K. Gilmore, 0. F. McCormick Ill, and E. P. Morenon 1974 Arclweological Investigations at Lake Palestine. Texas. Contributions in Anthropology No. 11. Department of Anthropology, Southern Methodist University, Dallas. Del\iro, M . .T. and M. J. Schoeninger 1983 Stable Carbon and Nitrogen Isotope Rarios of Bone Collagen: Variations within Individuals, Between Sexes, and Within Popularions Raised on Monotonous Diet. Journal of Archaenln8ical Science l 0(3): 199-203. Hard, R. J. and M.A. Katzen berg 2011 A Stahle Isotope Study of Hunter-Gatherer-Fisher Diet, Mobility. and Intensification on the Tc.\as Gulf Coastal Plain. American Antiquitv 76(4):709-751. Jim, S., S. H. Ambrose, and R. P. Evershed 2004 Stable Carbon Isotopic Evidence for Different:es in the Dietary Origin of Bone Cholesterol, Collagen and Apatite: Implicalions for their use in Paleodietary Reconstruction. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 68(1):61-72. Lee-Thorp, .T. A., J. C. Sealy, and N.J. van cter Merwe 1989 Stable Carbon Isotope Ratio Differences between Rone Collagen and Bone Apatite. and their Rela tionship to Diet. Journal of Archaeological Science 16(6):585-59<>. Journal of Northeast Texa'i Archaeology 38 (20 12) 85 Perttula, T. K. 1997 A Compendium of Radiocarbon and Oxidizable Carbon Ratio Dates from Archaeological Sites in East Texas, with a Discussion of the Age and Dating of Select Components and Phases. Radiocarbon 39(3 ): 305-341. 20lla The Pipe Site, a Late Caddo Site at Lake Palestine in Anderson County, Texas. Journal of Northeast Texas Archaeology 35:47-80. 20llb The Ceramic Artifacts from the Lang Pastme Site (41AN38) and the Place of the Site within an Upper Neches River Basin Caddo Ceramic Tradition. In Archeological Investigations at the Lang Pasture Site (41 AN38) in the Upper Neches River Basin of East Texas, assembled and edited by T. K. Perttula, D. B. Kelley, and R. A. Ricklis pp. 145-320. Archeological Studies Program Report No. 129. Texas Department of Transportation, Environmental Affairs Division, Austin. Perttula, T. K., D. B. Kelley, and R. A. Ricklis (assemblers and editors) 2011 Archeological Investigations at the Lang Pasture Site (41 AN38) in the Upper Neches River Basin of East Texas. Archeological Studies Program Report No. 129. Texas Department of Transportation, Environmental Affairs Division, Austin. Reimer, P. J., M.G. L. Baillie, E. Bard, A. Bayliss, J. W. Beck, P. G. Blackwell, C. Bronk Ramsey, C. E. Buck, G. S. Burr, R. L. Edwards , M. Friedrich, P.M. Grootes, T. P. Guilderson, I. Hajdas, T. J. Heaton, A. G. Hogg, K . A. Hughen, B. Kromer, F. G. McCormac, S. W. Manning, R. W. Reimer, D. A. Richards, J. R. Southon, S. Talamo, C. S.M. Turney, J. van der Plicht, and C. E. Weyhenmeyer 2009 lnlCal09 and Marine09 Radiocarbon Age Calibration Curves, 0-50,000 cal BP. Radiocarbon 51:1111-1150. Sullivan, C. H. and H. W. Krueger 1981 Carbon Isotope Analysis of Separate Chemical Phases in Modern and Fossil Bone. Nature 292:333-335. Tieszen, L. L. 1991 Natural Variations in the Carbon Isotope Values of Plants: Implications for Archaeology, Ecology and Paleoecology. Journal of Archaeological Science 18:227-248. Tieszen, L. L. and T. Fagre 1993 Carbon Isotopic Variability in Modem and Archaeological Maize. Journal of Archaeological Sci-ence 20:24-40. Vander Merwe, N. J. and J. C. Vogel 197R 13C Content of Human Collagen as a Measurement of Prehistoric Diet in Woodland North America. Nature 276:815-816. Wilson, D. E. 2006 Human Remains in the Collection. In A Study of the Buddy Calvin Jones Collection from Northeast Texa'i Caddo Sites, by T. K. Perttula pp. 110-134. Special Publication No.6 Friends of Northeast Texas Archaeology, Austin and Pittsburg. 

Stable Isotope Analysis from a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas

https://scholarworks.sfasu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2052&amp;context=ita

Stable Isotope Analysis from a Burial at the Pipe Site (41AN67) in Anderson County, Texas

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

SFA ScholarWorks