Analiza slučaja i presuda Vrhovnog suda Republike Hrvatsk

Željko Karas

Karas, Željko

Hrčak - Portal of scientific journals of Croatia

!"#!"#$%$&'(")!"'*+!,-&.)$)'+/'(,)!0,(',$%&'()*+,-.(&/0,123.455#6789:;<.;=>=?!Sudska praksa o policijskom postupanju: pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonite12)"!$!,3,-&.)0+(,3,)')+-+*,0-&.)'*0,-.(45)6784)96:;<=>4?)@4A69@7>B7)5B=C76>D87)@4CDEDB=F)4:7B)A95)5;9?4?)A69@>B7)4EB=>B9B=)57)A=)9)84>8;=6>4G)AC9H7B9F)7)A)4IJD;4G)>7)GB=A64)@;4>7C7A87)5;4?7)K9)9>96;7L>B4A6D)rukava jakne) poduzimanje radnje navedenog djelatnika zadiranjem njegove lijeve ;98=)9)9>96;7L>B4A6);987:7)B78>=F);75DC4)4)4A4I>4B)@;=6;7JDF)7)>=)@;=?C=59)4@69M=->D87F)8784)64)DA@;7:>4)J78CB9H9B=)D)A95)@;:4?)A69@>B723'0NF)$)(MOPQRSRP)45)T2)4M9B87)URRT2)?45D>=@2A*3*+2.&B%*C2./*.,3+,/&.+2./(DE2).D.C,)*'.)*.1,(&F&)/C&./(DGH*+&C.+2C,+.1%,A*3H*.%23+)&.C,)&'2.)*.D0A%I*+2./D'+)2.32.)*.,/,H2.1%*DB*(2.3%,JDK.B21,E*,./.&/0%2G&A2+)*'.D/')*%*+&'.+2.1%,+2(2G*+)*./C%&A*+&L.1%*3'*02K.0*.)*.B2D/02A&,.,/D'+)&E*+&C2.&.+2)1%&)*./.A2+)/C*./0%2+*.)2C+*.M3*/+,'.%DC,'./0&/+D,.(&)*A&.%DC2A.)2C+*.&.,1&12,.02.B%+2.+2(&C.+2.02H(*0*M.E&'*.)*.+21&12,./1,%+*.1%*3'*0*.&.1,0A%3&,./D'+)D.,./C%&A2+)D.3%,J*K.2(&.)*.B20&'.),N.&.M(&)*A,'.%DC,'.DN2,.D.)2C+D.&.02C,I*%./.D+D02%+)*./0%2+*.+21&12,.A%*O&FD./.02H(*02'2M.2(&.+&)*.)D.',J2,.&B%2A+,.3,02C+D0&.+&0&.&BA23&0&.)*%.)*.A%*O&F2.H&(2.D'*0+D02.D.&B,(2F&)/C,.1,3%DE)*.)2C+*.&B2.1,3/02A*6.?.,HB&%,'.+2.0,.32.)*.,A2CA&'.3)*(,A2+)*'.,1&12A2,.1,PA%N&+D.%DC2A2.C,)2.+&)*.&B(,G*+2.A2+)/C,'.,12G2+)DK.2(&./A,)&'.1,/0D12+)*'.+&)*.3,N2,.3,./1,%+,J.1%*3'*02.A*O.)*.B2.0,.H&(,.1,0%*H+,.+2C+23+,.1%,A*/0&.3*02()+,.1%*0%2G&A2+)*.)2C+*K.1,/02(,.)*./1,%+,./1232.(&.+)*J,A.1,/0D12C.D.%23+)D.1%*J(*32.&(&.1%*0%2J*6.Q.,A,'.1%&')*%D.',G*./*.1,/02A&0&.&.1&02+)*.)*.(&./1,%+2.A%*O&F2.D,1O*.1%&H2A()*+2.+*B2C,+&0,'.%23+),'./.,HB&%,'.+2.0,.32.)*./2',.+21&12+2.R0,.1&02+)*.)*.,H%2I*+,.D.,A,'.1%&C2BD.C,3.+2%*3+,J.1%&')*%2.,.+2C+23+,).B2C,+&0,).1%*0%2B&S6$%*J(*3.,/,H*.D.3,'2O,)./D3/C,).1%2C/&.+2)E*NO*./*.%2B(&CD)*.,3.1%*0%2J*.,/,H*.1,.%2B&+&.B2LA202.D.1%2A2.1%&A20+,/0&.,/,H*6.T2C,./*.3&)*(,A&.,3)*O*.1,1D0.3G*1,A2./'20%2)D.* '%6./F6.7*()C,.;2%2/K.A&N&.1%*32A2E.+2.U&/,C,).1,(&F&)/C,).NC,(&.VQ$P2.>WK.X2J%*H6!"#Željko Karas: Pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonitePolic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 4, str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dokaze. Kako je potom obavljena pretraga mobilnih aparata na temelju naloga #%,/*C4(-$%&7*6$+*.#%4#7#$($./3,/*+#$.()/3,4#8$%,"*/#$('$<D>$1#.42*$?@@A>$+*)(4#,($%&$./#0*"1234#$'()*+#>$E*#:36$23'4(:$./("3'34*$43+*)(4#,*$/*'42*$./3,/*-3$.()/3,43$%,"*/#$43$#%)12&5&23$:(-&F4(%,$.(4("4(-$(0*"12*42*$,3$/*'423$4*$+*)(4#,$4*5#4>GHIJ6$K$LCMDANO@N$('$D>$%,&'34(-*$?@@D>$-('#43B+@%7%+K)'+0.<%1%+1)0)+7)2+<.-)&6+.+<2&2&+&6+/23:)&6+/02$%?6$%+21%+4)&6:%+*%-60)&%K+3.7+&6+'%<:&.()2+7%+K$)&6+36+0%7):2+2+/06-0%')+23246+23.*$&)(6$)<%+LMN+16;+2+/065:67.+2324%+.+3*)3:.+(:=+BOO=+3-=+B=+)+P=+I@FK9+QRST9+U+@8H"P#V#"+27+P!=+-0%1$&%+P##O=+527)$6=2 KD+$%<2$+.C);6$&%9+7&6:%-$)A)+/2:)A)&6+/02$%,:)+ 3.+<27+2/-.86$)<%+.+786/.+ )+/0)106*6$2+27.'6:)9+.+3<:%7.+)+3+(:=+PBW=+3-=+J=+I@F9+FQX+106;)A.+.+<2&2&+36+$%:%'):%+&67$%+0.<%1)A%+27+<28$2H-6<3-):$25+*%H-60)&%:%9+&67%$+<.C)$&3<)+$28+3+$%'.4:&6$2*+2,-0)A2*+)+&67$6+*6-%:$6+,<%06K9+QRST9+U+@8HB#PWV#P+27+O=+28.&<%+P##W=+527)$6=J+F0)*&60)A69+K1%$&3<)*+/065:672*+27&6;6+.+763$2*+0.<%1.+')*3<6+&%<$6+'%*)&6;6$%+71%+3*2-.:&<%+/%+&6+2/-.86$)<+70%5212:&$2+)3-6+)'0.()2+7&6:%-$)A)*%+/2:)A)&6K9+QRST9+U+@8HOO#V#"+27+PP=+<2:212'%+P##O=+527)$6=!"#Željko Karas: Pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonitePolic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 4, str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te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Željko Karas: Pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonitePolic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 4, str. 539-543$%&'()*&+%&,&-(+./*0-*/&1'%2'(3(/(&4,5*/(&+.&1,3,6%-%&+7.0(5-,&,)(8'(-%&,+,8%&8%9&*4(4:%&1'%2;,)-%&+./-5%&,&1,0*-*2%75.&*&4(9-%-,/&)5%7.<=&(/%'*04,/&+.+2(:.&-%9(4,-*2*;&),4(9(>&4,5*&5%&1,&,+-,:-*/&%7%/%-2*/(&4,'*?2%-&4(,&.9,'&9(&;':(2+4*&/,)%7>&-(4-()-,&1,).9*/(-5%&'()-5%&-(&9(4,-*2&-(0*-&*&1',*9(?7*&),4(9*&.1,'(875*:*&+.&.4,7*4,&1,+2,5*&*9:,'&1,)(2(4(&4,5*&5%&-%,:*+(-&,&-%9(4,-*2,5&'()-5*&2%&+%&9(&2(4:%&+*2.(@*5%&-%&1'*/5%-5.5%&teorija o plodovima otrovne !"#$%. Utemeljenje *9-*/4%&-%,:*+-,3&*9:,'(&A&'(%)%'(%'*+,"-./%+("/*.&'%B&1,+2(:75%-,&5%&5,?&CD#E<&3,)*-%&u odluci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predmetu.T:(4:(&,)7.4(&5%&:'7,&9-(0(5-(&.&.+1,'%)8*&+&)'.3*/&+7.0(5%:*/(&.&4,5*/(&-(G4-()-,&1',:,6%-5%& 1'%2'(3%&-(& 9(4,-*2& -(0*-& -*5%& 8*7,& ,@*5%-5%-,&4(,& 9(4,-*2,>& *(4,&1'%)/%2&-*5%&8*,&1'*8(:75%-&.&-%9(4,-*2,5&1'%2'(9*<&R(4(:&5%&8*,&*&1':*&1'*/5%'&.&,:,/&1'*4(9.&+.)+4%&1'(4+%&,&+7.0(5.&.&4,5%/&5%&1,7*@*5+4*&+7.Q8%-*4>&-(4,-&?2,&,1*1(:(-5%/&'.4(:(&-*5%&/,3(,&),H*&),&1'%)/%2(>&9(+2(,&+&'()-5,/&2%&5%&-(4-()-,&9(2'(Q%-&+.)8%-*&!"#Željko Karas: Pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonitePolic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 4, str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

Sudska praksa o policijskom postupanju: pregled i pretraga osobe; zakonita pretraga nakon nezakonite

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Hrčak - Portal of scientific journals of Croatia