THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN REALITY AND FICTION IN ETHNOGRAPHIC AND TRAVEL SOURCES: A CONTRIBUTION TO THE HERMENEUTICS OF THE FOREIGN

Abstract

Članak iz kuta europske etnologije i međunarodnog istraživanja pripovijedanja razmatra nekoliko prosudbi o odnosu stvarnosti i fikcije, ali i o viđenju sebe i slika tuđine u putopisima i etnografskoj literaturi. Primjeri tekstova sežu od antike preko srednjega vijeka u rani novi vijek do baroka i prosvjetiteljstva. Slike tuđine, što može biti prvi rezultat analize, podudarne su u međusobno udaljenim vremenima i prostorima. Stvarnost i fikcija, što je sljedeća spoznaja, ne razlikuju se tako mnogo već se međusobno plodno razmjenjuju. Bitno je i treće stajalište da putopise i etnografske izvore valja shvatiti kao kulturne konstrukte čijem smo stvaranju i mi etnolozi/folkloristi često sami pridonosili i pridonosimo. Slike tuđine imaju, četvrto i posljednje, uvijek i jedan ne manje važan dio u stvaranju slika o nama samima te time i na izgradnju identiteta.The topic of this article is the relationship between reality and fiction but also between pictures of the self and the other in ethnographic and travel literature. The texts used for closer analysis are very consciously taken from a wide range of different sources as well concerning time, space and genre: from Herodotís Historiae to Lukianís Alethes historia, from Brendan\u27s Voyage to Mandeville\u27s Travels, just to mention the most well known examples. The combination of ethnologic and folkloristic approach provides at least four findings: Firstly, pictures of the other are very much alike over time and space. Secondly, differentiation between true and false can not be our first aim. We have to realize that reality and fiction are frequently intertwined, even more that there is a fruitful exchange between both. Thirdly, we have to accept that texts about other cultures or peoples are cultural constructions and that we folklorists and cultural anthropologists are very often workers or at least coworkers in these buildings. This leads to the fourth point: Pictures of the other always play an important role in the creation of identities

    Similar works