The differential affine velocity estimator (DAVE) developed in Schuck (2006)
for estimating velocities from line-of-sight magnetograms is modified to
directly incorporate horizontal magnetic fields to produce a differential
affine velocity estimator for vector magnetograms (DAVE4VM). The DAVE4VM's
performance is demonstrated on the synthetic data from the anelastic
pseudospectral ANMHD simulations that were used in the recent comparison of
velocity inversion techniques by Welsch (2007). The DAVE4VM predicts roughly
95% of the helicity rate and 75% of the power transmitted through the
simulation slice. Inter-comparison between DAVE4VM and DAVE and further
analysis of the DAVE method demonstrates that line-of-sight tracking methods
capture the shearing motion of magnetic footpoints but are insensitive to flux
emergence -- the velocities determined from line-of-sight methods are more
consistent with horizontal plasma velocities than with flux transport
velocities. These results suggest that previous studies that rely on velocities
determined from line-of-sight methods such as the DAVE or local correlation
tracking may substantially misrepresent the total helicity rates and power
through the photosphere.Comment: 30 pages, 13 figure