Cannadine

Carpenter

Douglas

Edkins

Enloe

Etkind

Johnson

KATHARINE M. MILLAR

Kinsella

Mälksoo

Neumann

Rumelili

Turner

Zeigler

AbstractSince the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, over 150 female American military personnel have been killed, over 70 following hostile fire. Given Western society’s long-standing practice of reserving the conduct of collective violence to men, these very public deaths are difficult to encompass within the normative and ideological structures of the contemporary American political system. This study examines the ways in which the public duty to commemorate the heroism of soldiers – and the private desire to accurately remember daughters and wives – poses a significant challenge to coherent discursive representation. In doing so, the study employs hermeneutical interpretation to analyse public representations of female soldiers and their relation to death in US popular culture. These representations are examined via Judith Butler’s concept of grievability – the possibility of receiving recognition as a worthy life within the existing social imaginary. It is argued that female soldiers are grievable as both ‘good soldiers’ and ‘good women’, but not as ‘good female soldiers’. The unified subject position of ‘good female soldier’ is liminal, and thus rendered socially and politically unintelligible. The article concludes with an analysis of the implications of this liminality for collective mourning and the possibility of closure after trauma.</jats:p

Crossref

Review of International Studies

Death does not become her: An examination of the public construction of female American soldiers as liminal figures

Death does not become her: An examination of the public construction of female American soldiers as liminal figures

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Crossref