This study aims to determine the reasons for the pleading of the guardian adhal/ reluctant to marry his daughter and the judge’s consideration in granting the petition guardian adhal/reluctant. The research method uses empirical juridical legal research that examines its normative and empirical concepts that examine the reality of the existence of the guardian plea adhal and this research is descriptive. Method of data analysis using normative model of qualitative, that is process of discussion which done by processing data obtained by legal norm, doctrine and theory of law exist. Based on the result of the research, it can be concluded that the reason for the submission of the guardian’s petition is mostly not justified by the Islamic Shari’a. The judge’s consideration in the petition of the wali adhal as long as there is no barrier to marriage according to Islamic law and according to applicable law, then the judges panel there is no reason to refuse