The Structure of Models of Second-order Set Theories

Abstract

This dissertation is a contribution to the project of second-order set theory, which has seen a revival in recent years. The approach is to understand second-order set theory by studying the structure of models of second-order set theories. The main results are the following, organized by chapter. First, I investigate the poset of $T$-realizations of a fixed countable model of $\mathsf{ZFC}$, where $T$ is a reasonable second-order set theory such as $\mathsf{GBC}$ or $\mathsf{KM}$, showing that it has a rich structure. In particular, every countable partial order embeds into this structure. Moreover, we can arrange so that these embedding preserve the existence/nonexistence of upper bounds, at least for finite partial orders. Second I generalize some constructions of Marek and Mostowski from $\mathsf{KM}$ to weaker theories. They showed that every model of $\mathsf{KM}$ plus the Class Collection schema "unrolls" to a model of $\mathsf{ZFC}^-$ with a largest cardinal. I calculate the theories of the unrolling for a variety of second-order set theories, going as weak as $\mathsf{GBC} + \mathsf{ETR}$. I also show that being $T$-realizable goes down to submodels for a broad selection of second-order set theories $T$. Third, I show that there is a hierarchy of transfinite recursion principles ranging in strength from $\mathsf{GBC}$ to $\mathsf{KM}$. This hierarchy is ordered first by the complexity of the properties allowed in the recursions and second by the allowed heights of the recursions. Fourth, I investigate the question of which second-order set theories have least models. I show that strong theories---such as $\mathsf{KM}$ or $\Pi^1_1\text{-}\mathsf{CA}$---do not have least transitive models while weaker theories---from $\mathsf{GBC}$ to $\mathsf{GBC} + \mathsf{ETR}_\mathrm{Ord}$---do have least transitive models.Comment: This is my PhD dissertatio