research
Spatial Organization and Molecular Correlation of Tumor-Infiltrating Lymphocytes Using Deep Learning on Pathology Images
- Authors
- Mohamed H. Abdel-Rahman
- Adam Abeshouse
- Clement Adebamowo
- Sally N. Adebamowo
- Kathy Agnew
- Keunsoo Ahn
- Jaffer A. Ajani
- Rehan Akbani
- Teniola Akeredolu
- Hikmat Al-Ahmadie
- Monique Albert
- Iakovina Alexopoulou
- Adrian Ally
- Domenico Alvaro
- Matthew L. Anderson
- Chris Andry
- Anna Antenucci
- Pavana Anur
- Elizabeth L. Appelbaum
- Natália D. Aredes
- Joshua Armenia
- Angel Arnaout
- Sylvia L. Asa
- J. Todd Auman
- Marta Aymerich
- Dina Aziz
- Matthew Bailey
- Miruna Balasundaram
- Saianand Balu
- Gene Barnett
- Jill S. Barnholtz-Sloan
- Wendi Barrett
- John Bartlett
- Oliver Bathe
- Rebecca Batiste
- Eric Baudin
- Stephen Baylin
- Karl-Friedrich Becker
- David Beer
- Madhusmita Behera
- Carmen Behrens
- Debra Bell
- Sue Bell
- Michelle Bellair
- Joseph Bennett
- Christopher Benz
- Andrew Berchuck
- Ashton C. Berger
- Alain Bergeron
- Ross Berkowitz
- Brady Bernard
- Rameen Beroukhim
- Felix Beuschlein
- Carlo Bifulco
- Darell Bigner
- Michael Birrer
- Kivanc Birsoy
- Therese Bocklage
- Tom Bodenheimer
- Jolanta Bondaruk
- Moiz S. Bootwalla
- Mitesh Borad
- Jeffrey A. Borgia
- Aaron Bossler
- Natalia Botnariuc
- Alex Boussioutas
- Jay Bowen
- Reanne Bowlby
- Rayleen Bowman
- Carol Bradford
- Maria Consiglia Bragazzi
- Daniel J. Brat
- Anne Breggia
- Cathy Brewer
- Fadi Brimo
- Russell Broaddus
- Denise Brooks
- Bradley M. Broom
- Thomas Broudy
- Alan H. Bryce
- Glenn Bubley
- Raphael Bueno
- Andrew Burnette
- Samantha J. Caesar-Johnson
- Chiara Calatozzolo
- Elias Campo
- Benito Campos
- Irina Caraman
- Vincenzo Cardinale
- Francis Carey
- Thomas Carey
- Carlos Gilberto Carlotti
- Rebecca Carlsen
- Michael Carney
- Guido Carpino
- Peter R. Carroll
- Candace Carter
- Andre L. Carvalho
- Erik Castle
- Patricia D. Castro
- James Catto
- Colleen M. Cebulla
- Mircea Cernat
- John Chabot
- Debyani Chakravarty
- Nyasha Chambwe
- June M. Chan
- Timothy A. Chan
- Vishal Chandan
- Kyle Chang
- Walid K. Chatila
- Inga Chemencedji
- Amy Chen
- Chu Chen
- Feixiong Cheng
- Andrew D. Cherniack
- David Chesla
- Simone Chevalier
- John Cheville
- Juok Cho
- Eric Chuah
- Sudha Chudamani
- Ki Chung
- Carrie Cibulskis
- Adrian Clipca
- Howard Colman
- Leslie Cope
- John A. Copland
- Niall Corcoran
- Matthew G. Cordes
- Tony Costello
- Sandra Cottingham
- Marta Couce
- Kyle Covington
- Daniel Crain
- Daniel Cramer
- Jenette Creaney
- Chad J. Creighton
- Lucia Cuppini
- Erin Curley
- Stefania Cuzzubbo
- Bogdan Czerniak
- Ludmila Danilova
- Amy Davis
- Ino de Bruijn
- Ana C. de Carvalho
- Ronald de Krijger
- Assunta De Rienzo
- Agostino De Rose
- Timothy Defreitas
- Keith Delman
- John A. Demchok
- Laurence Desjardins
- Karen Devine
- Brenda Deyarmin
- Noreen Dhalla
- Renumathy Dhanasekaran
- Varsha Dhankani
- Rajiv Dhir
- Francesco Dimeco
- Li Ding
- Huyen Dinh
- Mikhail Dinkin
- John Dipersio
- Philip Disaia
- Harshavardhan Doddapaneni
- Lawrence A. Donehower
- Serghei Doruc
- Jose Sebastião Dos Santos
- Peter R. Dottino
- Bettina Drake
- Jennifer Drummond
- Paul Drwiega
- Michael Dubina
- Rebecca Duell
- Elizabeth R. Duffy
- John Eckman
- W. Jeffrey Edenfield
- Wil Eijckenboom
- J. Bradley Elder
- Jay Engel
- Jennifer Eschbacher
- Bita Esmaeli
- Kimberley Evason
- Francesco Facciolo
- Cheng Fan
- Huihui Fan
- J. Leigh Fantacone-Campbell
- Michael Farnell
- Carol Farver
- Martin Fassnacht
- Ashley Fehrenbach
- Ina Felau
- Michael Feldman
- Colleen Feltmate
- Martin L. Ferguson
- Gaetano Finocchiaro
- Thomas Flotte
- Kwun M. Fong
- Seth Force
- Ian Forgie
- Scott Frazer
- José H. Fregnani
- Catrina C. Fronick
- Junya Fujimoto
- Jordonna Fulop
- Lucinda A. Fulton
- Robert S. Fulton
- Hani Gabra
- Stacey B. Gabriel
- Joseph Galbraith
- Galen F. Gao
- Jianjiong Gao
- Johanna Gardner
- Julie M. Gastier-Foster
- Eugenio Gaudio
- Nils Gehlenborg
- Mark Gerken
- Jeffrey Gershenwald
- Gad Getz
- Ronald Ghossein
- Nasra Giama
- Richard A. Gibbs
- Sebastien Gilbert
- Ad Gillis
- Anne-Paule Gimenez-Roqueplo
- Eva Giné
- Thomas Giordano
- Nicolas Girard
- Felice Giuliante
- Pat Glenn
- Robert Glenn
- Andrew K. Godwin
- Eryn M. Godwin
- Ana Maria Angulo Gonzalez
- Marc Goodman
- Anuradha Gopalan
- Chandra Goparaju
- Ghenadie Gorincioi
- Ramaswamy Govindan
- Markus Graefen
- Gianluca Grazi
- William E. Grizzle
- Benjamin E. Gross
- Armando López Guillermo
- Charles Guo
- Rajarsi Gupta
- Gavin Ha
- Andrea Haddad
- Curt H. Hagedorn
- Walker Hale
- Yi Han
- Phan Thi Hanh
- Paul Hansen
- Jodi Harr
- Arndt Hartmann
- Lauren Haydu
- D. Neil Hayes
- Nicholas Hayward
- Sharon Heath
- Apurva M. Hegde
- David I. Heiman
- Zachary J. Heins
- Joel Henderson
- Beth Hermes
- Brenda Hernandez
- Christel Herold-Mende
- Peter Hersey
- Julian Hess
- Hanina Hibshoosh
- Joe Hilty
- Toshinori Hinoue
- Thai Ho
- Katherine A. Hoadley
- Robert Holt
- Jeffrey A. Hooke
- Dave Hoon
- Neil Horowitz
- Le Hou
- John Houck
- Christopher Hovens
- Alan P. Hoyle
- Hai Hu
- Jianhong Hu
- Hartwig Huland
- Nguyen Phi Hung
- David Huntsman
- Carolyn M. Hutter
- Mary Iacocca
- Michael Ittmann
- Laura Jacobus
- Valerie Jakrot
- Klaus-Peter Janssen
- Stuart R. Jefferys
- Antonio Jimeno
- Corbin D. Jones
- Steven J. M. Jones
- Zhenlin Ju
- Hartmut Juhl
- Christin Jungk
- Kerstin Junker
- Hojabr Kakavand
- Steven Kalkanis
- Rupa S. Kanchi
- Cyriac Kandoth
- Koo Jeong Kang
- Beth Y. Karlan
- Katayoon Kasaian
- Melpomeni Kasapi
- Alison Kastl
- Electron Kebebew
- Richard Kefford
- Robin K. Kelley
- Rafael Kemp
- Sara Kendall
- Ady Kendler
- Michael Kendrick
- Fadlo Khuri
- Adam Kibel
- Jaegil Kim
- Theo Knijnenburg
- Michael Knudson
- Tina Knutson
- Jean-Pierre Kocher
- Bernard Kohl
- Karla Kopp
- Viktoriya Korchina
- Anil Korkut
- Esther Korpershoek
- Robert Korst
- Albert J. Kovatich
- Roger Kramer
- Melanie H. Kucherlapati
- Raju S. Kucherlapati
- Bahavna Kumar
- Ritika Kundra
- Tahsin Kurc
- Leonid Kvecher
- Witold Kycler
- Konnor La
- Louis Lacombe
- Marc Ladanyi
- Phillip H. Lai
- Peter W. Laird
- Charles N. Landen
- Lisa Landrum
- James Lang
- Caroline Larson
- Mathieu Latour
- Kevin Lau
- Michael S. Lawrence
- Alexander J. Lazar
- Alexander J. Lazar
- Xuan Le
- Ronald Lechan
- Darlene Lee
- Jung Il Lee
- Kenneth Lee
- Sandra Lee
- Norman L. Lehman
- Kalle Leinonen
- Kristen M. Leraas
- Douglas A. Levine
- Lora Lewis
- Timothy Ley
- Jun Li
- Wei Li
- Han Liang
- Tara M. Lichtenberg
- Pei Lin
- W. Marston Linehan
- Shiyun Ling
- Eric Lipp
- Michael J. Liptay
- Jia Liu
- Wenbin Liu
- Xiuping Liu
- Yuexin Liu
- Christopher Logothetis
- Pawadee Lohavanichbutr
- Laxmi Lolla
- Georgina Long
- Adhemar Longatto-Filho
- Leendert Looijenga
- Yiling Lu
- James Luketich
- Augustin Luna
- Vladimir Lyadov
- Deqin Ma
- Yussanne Ma
- Rashna Madan
- Dennis T. Maglinte
- Kelly Magliocca
- Shishir Maithel
- David Mallery
- Andrei Malykh
- Randy Mandt
- George Manikhas
- Graham Mann
- Robert Mannel
- Massimo Mannelli
- Elaine R. Mardis
- Armaz Mariamidze
- Odette Mariani
- Mirella Marino
- Jeffrey Marks
- Marco A. Marra
- John A. Martignetti
- Julie Martin
- Luca Mattei
- Michael Mayo
- Shannon Mccall
- Mary Mcgraw
- Ginette Mckercher
- Michael D. Mclellan
- Roger Mclendon
- Christopher Mcpherson
- Sam Meier
- Jonathan Melamed
- Shaowu Meng
- Funda Meric-Bernstam
- Roberta Merola
- Anne-Marie Mes-Masson
- Adam R. Metwalli
- Matthew Meyerson
- Piotr A. Mieczkowski
- Tom Mikkelsen
- Mohammed Milhem
- Christopher A. Miller
- Judy Miller
- Michael Miller
- Gordon B. Mills
- Cyrus Mirsaidi
- Fedor Moiseenko
- Marc Moncrieff
- Kathleen Moore
- Richard A. Moore
- Cesar Moran
- Margaret Morgan
- Scott Morris
- Carl Morrison
- Donna Morton
- Lisle E. Mose
- Catherine Moser
- Katherine Moxley
- Jeffey Moyer
- Andrew J. Mungall
- Karen Mungall
- Sergiu Mura
- Richard J. Mural
- Dawid Murawa
- Michael Muto
- Donna Muzny
- Jerome Myers
- David Nagorney
- Praveen Nair
- Rashi Naresh
- Theresa Naska
- Mark Nelson
- Kwok-Shing Ng
- Phuong Nguyen
- Vu Nguyen
- Moriah G. Nissan
- Michael S. Noble
- Ardene Noss
- Houtan Noushmehr
- Daniel O'Brien
- Brian Patrick O'Neill
- Angelica Ochoa
- Oluwole Olabode
- Jeffrey J. Olson
- Larsson Omberg
- Wolter Oosterhuis
- Quinn T. Ostrom
- Taofeek Owonikoko
- Karel Pacak
- Oxana Paklina
- Jeremy Parfitt
- Joong-Won Park
- Joel S. Parker
- Harvey Pass
- Tushar Patel
- Joseph Paulauskis
- Nathan A. Pennell
- Robert Penny
- Alessandro Perin
- Amy H. Perou
- Charles M. Perou
- Gloria Petersen
- Lisa Peterson
- Myron Peto
- Joanna Phillips
- Sarah M. Phillips
- Bui Duc Phu
- Alain Piché
- Alan Pickens
- Todd Pihl
- Robert Pilarski
- Edna M. Mora Pinero
- Peter A. Pinto
- Maria Pirtac
- Bianca Pollo
- Mark Pool
- Sima Porten
- Russel Postier
- Olga Potapova
- James Powers
- Michael Prados
- Mark Prince
- Florencia Que
- Michael Quinn
- Mario Quintero-Aguilo
- Brenda Rabeno
- Karan Rai
- Suresh Ramalingam
- Nilsa C. Ramirez
- Lois Ramondetta
- Arvind Rao
- Arvind U. K. Rao
- Doris M. Rassl
- W. Kimryn Rathmell
- Chandrajit P. Raut
- Daniel Raymond
- Rui M. Reis
- Victor Reuter
- Sheila Reynolds
- Ed Reznik
- David Rice
- William G. Richards
- Robert C. Rintoul
- Michael Rivera
- Jeffrey Roach
- Lewis Roberts
- A. Gordon Robertson
- Bruce Robinson
- Kevin Roggin
- Sergio Roman-Roman
- Howard G. Rosenthal
- Laura Rozek
- Mark A. Rubin
- Michael Ryan
- Fred Saad
- Sara Sadeghi
- Gordon Saksena
- Joel Saltz
- Dimitris Samaras
- Francisco Sanchez-Vega
- Chris Sander
- Ajith Sankarankuty
- Jireh Santibanez
- Xavier Sastre
- Guido Sauter
- Robyn Saw
- Cristovam Scapulatempo-Neto
- Lisa Scarpace
- Dirk Schadendorf
- Jacqueline E. Schein
- Mark Schiffman
- Cathy Schilero
- Thorsten Schlomm
- Heather K. Schmidt
- Laura S. Schmidt
- Lynn Schoenfield
- Nikolaus Schultz
- Steven E. Schumacher
- Richard Scolyer
- Angeles Secord
- Christopher W. Seder
- Harman Sekhon
- Kelly Senecal
- Antonia Sepulveda
- Galiya Setdikova
- Katherine C. Sexton
- Alexey Shabunin
- Kerwin Shannon
- Ashish Sharma
- Alexis Sharp
- Carl Simon Shelley
- Candace Shelton
- Troy Shelton
- Hui Shen
- Robert Sheridan
- Mark Sherman
- Margi Sheth
- Yan Shi
- Juliann Shih
- Kristen Shimmel
- Dong M. Shin
- Eve Shinbrot
- Cassaundra Shipman
- Ilya Shmulevich
- Ilya Shmulevich
- Craig D. Shriver
- Kenneth R. Shroyer
- Gabriel Sica
- Suzanne Sifri
- Rita Sigmund
- Sabina Signoretti
- Henrique C. S. Silveira
- Jeffry Simko
- Ronald Simon
- Janae V. Simons
- Samuel Singer
- Bhuvanesh Singh
- Pankaj Singh
- Rosy Singh
- Payal Sipahimalani
- Tara Skelly
- Andrew E. Sloan
- Julia Slotta-Huspenina
- Robert Smallridge
- Jennifer Smith
- Karen Smith-McCune
- Kathy Smolenski
- Thomas Smyrk
- Heidi J. Sofia
- Matthew G. Soloway
- Stella Somiari
- Anil Sood
- Paul Spellman
- Andrew Spillane
- Irina Stancul
- Melissa Stanton
- Susan M. Staugaitis
- Ruth Steele
- Serghei Stepa
- Marc-Henri Stern
- Christine Stoehr
- Robert Stoehr
- Hans Stoop
- Onathan Stretch
- Joshua M. Stuart
- Tao Su
- S. Onur Sumer
- Qiang Sun
- Yichao Sun
- Patricia Swanson
- Elizabeth Swisher
- Maria Synott
- Angela Tam
- Raina Tamakawa
- Pheroze Tamboli
- Donghui Tan
- Yufang Tang
- Roy Tarnuzzer
- Helge Taubert
- Mikhail Tavobilov
- Barry S. Taylor
- Diana Tcaciuc
- Pierre Tennstedt
- Nina Thiessen
- George Thomas
- Eric Thompson
- John Thompson
- R. Houston Thompson
- Timothy Thompson
- Richard Thorp
- Vesteinn Thorsson
- Vésteinn Thorsson
- Nguyen Viet Tien
- Henri Timmers
- Daniela Tirapelli
- Arthur Tischler
- Michael Torbenson
- Patricia Troncoso
- Anne Tsao
- Kane Tse
- Kelinda Tucker
- Bernard Têtu
- Andreas Unterberg
- Walter Urba
- Federico Valdivieso
- John Van Arnam
- Nguyen Van Bang
- David J. Van Den Berg
- Kim E. van Kessel
- Erwin G. Van Meir
- Brian Van Tine
- Scott Vandenberg
- Umadevi Veluvolu
- Ales Vicha
- Daniel O. Vidal
- Cathy D. Vocke
- Doug Voet
- Andreas von Deimling
- Olga Voronina
- Sven Wach
- Paul Wakely
- Jens Waldmann
- Joan Walker
- Yunhu Wan
- Jing Wang
- Jioajiao Wang
- Linghua Wang
- Min Wang
- Timothy Wang
- Zhining Wang
- Ronald Warnick
- John N. Weinstein
- Daniel J. Weisenberger
- Nicolas Wentzensen
- Peter Westervelt
- David A. Wheeler
- Matthew D. Wilkerson
- Felicia Williams
- James Wilmott
- Richard K. Wilson
- Lisa Wise
- Ignacio Wistuba
- Maciej Wiznerowicz
- Gregory Wolf
- Yingli Wolinsky
- Christopher K. Wong
- Tina Wong
- Robert Worrell
- Ye Wu
- Bernd Wullich
- Liu Xi
- Hannah Yang
- Ian Yang
- Ju Dong Yang
- Liming Yang
- Christina Yau
- Peggy Yena
- Leigh Anne Zach
- Howard Zaren
- Tomas Zelinka
- Jean C. Zenklusen
- Hailei Zhang
- Hongxin Zhang
- Hongzheng Zhang
- Jiashan (Julia) Zhang
- Jiexin Zhang
- Lizhi Zhang
- Wei Zhang
- Fengmei Zhao
- Tianhao Zhao
- Wanding Zhou
- Erik Zmuda
- Rosemary Zuna
- Ellen C. Zwarthoff
- Publication date
- 1 January 2018
- Publisher
- 'Elsevier BV'
- Doi
Abstract
Beyond sample curation and basic pathologic characterization, the digitized H&E-stained images of TCGA samples remain underutilized. To highlight this resource, we present mappings of tumorinfiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) based on H&E images from 13 TCGA tumor types. These TIL maps are derived through computational staining using a convolutional neural network trained to classify patches of images. Affinity propagation revealed local spatial structure in TIL patterns and correlation with overall survival. TIL map structural patterns were grouped using standard histopathological parameters. These patterns are enriched in particular T cell subpopulations derived from molecular measures. TIL densities and spatial structure were differentially enriched among tumor types, immune subtypes, and tumor molecular subtypes, implying that spatial infiltrate state could reflect particular tumor cell aberration states. Obtaining spatial lymphocytic patterns linked to the rich genomic characterization of TCGA samples demonstrates one use for the TCGA image archives with insights into the tumor-immune microenvironmentSimilar works
Available Versions
Last time updated on 06/05/2018