Kak's three-stage protocol for quantum key distribution is revisited with
special focus on its hitherto unknown strengths and weaknesses. It is shown
that this protocol can be used for secure direct quantum communication.
Further, the implementability of this protocol in the realistic situation is
analyzed by considering various Markovian noise models. It is found that the
Kak's protocol and its variants in their original form can be implemented only
in a restricted class of noisy channels, where the protocols can be transformed
to corresponding protocols based on logical qubits in decoherence free
subspace. Specifically, it is observed that Kak's protocol can be implemented
in the presence of collective rotation and collective dephasing noise, but
cannot be implemented in its original form in the presence of other types of
noise, like amplitude damping and phase damping noise. Further, the performance
of the protocol in the noisy environment is quantified by computing average
fidelity under various noise models, and subsequently a set of preferred states
for secure communication in noisy environment have also been identified.Comment: Kak's protocol is not suitable for quantum cryptography in presence
of nois