In this work we study contributions
of mainchain and side chain
atoms to fibrillization of polyalanine peptides using all-atom molecular
dynamics simulations. We show that the total number of hydrogen bonds
in the system does not change significantly during aggregation. This
emerges from a compensatory mechanism where the formation of one interpeptide
hydrogen bond requires rupture of two peptide–water bonds,
leading to the formation of one extra water–water bond. Since
hydrogen bonds are mostly electrostatic in nature, this mechanism
implies that electrostatic energies related to these bonds are not
minimized during fibril formation. Therefore, hydrogen bonds do not
drive fibrillization in all-atom models. Nevertheless, they play an
important role in this process since aggregation without the formation
of interpeptide hydrogen bonds accounts for a prohibitively large
electrostatic penalty (∼9.4 kJ/mol). Our work also highlights
the importance of using accurate models to describe chemical bonds
since Lennard-Jones and electrostatic contributions of different chemical
groups of the protein and solvent are 1 order of magnitude larger
than the overall enthalpy of the system. Thus, small errors in modeling
these interactions can produce large errors in the total enthalpy
of the system