This thesis, entitled “It’s a Big Old Goofy World View: John Prine As a Modern-Day
Mark Twain,” makes the connection between Mark Twain, the nineteenth-century writer and
lecturer, and John Prine, a contemporary songwriter and performer. Like Twain, Prine views the
world with joy and pity: with humor and disdain. While Twain utilizes literary techniques to
advance his impressions, Prine’s musical compositions demonstrate his unique outlook.
In my discussion of Prine’s songs, I will analyze not only lyrics but also musical
characteristics. Lyrically, the songs demonstrate poetic characteristics and narrative devices.
For this reason, I will closely examine the lyrics as one would examine poetry or prose. While
musically the songs are simple, Prine’s choices of accompaniment, instrumentation, dynamics,
and musical genre greatly affect how the lyrics are perceived and are no less important.
Born in 1946 and recording and performing music for more than thirty-four years, Prine’s
observations of the world around him reflect the attitudes and practices of modern American
culture. His views on love, social issues, politics, and religion are presented in a vernacular
language that is made accessible by melodies that are both poignant and memorable.
Because Prine’s song, “It’s a Big Old Goofy World” is a microcosm of his world view, I
have employed the lyrics to this song as a frame for each chapter. The characters which inhabit
this song, and indeed many Prine songs, are described with a unique blend of wit and pathos:
they can make you smile and they can break your heart