AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,\u27\u27 by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972. Two volumes, 1041 p., published by A. C. Allyn for the Allyn Museum of Entomology, Sarasota, Florida. Distributed exclusively in North America by Entomological Reprint Specialists, P.O. Box 77971, Dockweiler Station, Los Angeles, California 90007. Price: $25.00 U.S. per set

Nielsen, M. C.

English

Valparaiso University

The Great Lakes Entomologist Volume 7 Number 1 -- Spring 1974 Number 1 -- Spring 1974 Article 7 March 1974 "AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,'' by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972 M. C. Nielsen Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle  Part of the Entomology Commons Recommended Citation Nielsen, M. C. 1974. ""AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,'' by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972," The Great Lakes Entomologist, vol 7 (1) Available at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle/vol7/iss1/7 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Biology at ValpoScholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in The Great Lakes Entomologist by an authorized administrator of ValpoScholar. For more information, please contact a ValpoScholar staff member at scholar@valpo.edu. 1974 THE GREAT LAKES ENTOMOLOGIST 25 Drooz, A. T. 1974. The status of Mesoleius tenthredinis and other parasites of the larch sawfly in the eastern United States. Envir. Entomol. 3 (in press). Embree, D. G. and G. R. Underwood. 1972. Establishment in Maine, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick of Olesicampe benefactor (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae), an intro- duced ichneumonid parasite of the larch sawfly, Pristiphora erichsonii (Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae). Can Entomol. 104:89-96. Muldrew, J. A. 1953. The natural immunity of the larch sawfly Pristiphora erichsonii (Htg.) to the introduced parasite Mesoleius tenthredinis Morley, in Manitoba and Saskatchewan. Can. J. Zool. 31:313-332. Turnock, W. J. and J. A. Muldrew. 1971. Pristiphora erichsonii (Htg.), the larch sawfly (Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae). In Biological Control programs against insects and weeds in Canada 1958-1968. Commonw. Inst. Biol. Contr. Tech. Comm. No. 4. Turnock, W. J. 1973. Geographical and historical variability in population patterns and life systems of the larch sawfly. Can. Entomol. 104: 1883-1900. BOOK REVIEW "AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,'' by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972. Two volumes, 1041 p., published by A. C. Allyn for the Allyn Museum of Entomology, Sarasota, Florida. Distributed exclusively in North America by Entomological Reprint Specialists, P.O. Box 77971, Dockweiler Station, Los Angeles, California 90007. Price: $25.00 U.S. per set. This monumental Index is the f i s t  attempt to prepare a bibliography of the immature stages of North American butterflies and moths since Edward's Bibliographical Catalogue o f  the Described Transformations o f  North American Lepidoptera, published in 1889. The compilation includes Edward's work and published data through sometime in 1950 when the manuscript was initiated. Except for an introduction by William D. 1:ield and J .  F. Gates Clarke, both of the National Museum of Natural History, there is no introduction or other prefacing remarks by the author. The Index is divided into two parts: Part I-Insects, and Part 11-Plants, although Volume 1 contents, representing about half the total number of pages, continues into Volume 2. Under Part 1 ,  there are three sections: A-Works Consulted (periodicals, separate works, bibliographies); B-Insect Common Names and C-Macrolepidoptera. Included in the latter section are the names of all species, subspecies and forms, including synonyms, alphabetically listed with cross-references to  the main entry. The nomenclature follows that of McDunnough's 1938 Check List o f  the Lepidoptera o f  Canada and the United States o f  America: Part I ,  Macrolepidoptera. Each main entry is followed with synonyms, forms and subspecies, bibliography of published life history references and list of food plants. This section represents the greatest number of pages in the Index, and is one of the most valuable to  the researcher. Part 11 includes five sections: A-Zoological Hosts; B-Common Names; C-Indefinite Designations; D-Scientific Names; E-Synonyms. It would appear that Section D is most useful as it lists host plants and their "Insect Enemies." The plants are listed alphabetically by genus and species with the common namc, followed with a list of all known macrolepidoptera arranged by family. When the scicntific name of the plant is unknown, it can be located in Section B under the common name. Undoubtedly, this Index will be a valuablc rcference to professional and serious amateur lepidopterists, especially those engaged in life history studies or rearing activities. It will enable anyone to quickly determine whethcr or not life history or  food plant 1Nielsen: "AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTPublished by ValpoScholar, 197426 THE GREAT LAKES ENTOMOLOGIST Vol. 7, No. 1 observations and data are new or have been previously published, prior to 1950. This Index should challenge some researchers to compile additional life histories and food plant data. The food plant lists are useful, too,  in attempting to locate 'missing' species in a particular region and identify unknown larvae from known plants. 'There are, however, some comments that should b e  made concerning the thoroughness and accuracy of the Index. It is unfortunate that the work is not  more current as there has been a wealth of new life history and food plant data published within the past twenty-three years. This shortcoming may be a disappointment t o  some who purchase this Index only to find they must still do  considerable bibliographical research. It is not unusual for an index of this size to be without some errors of commission and omission. The most unaccountable omission is the author's failure to include references to Field's 1938 Studies in Kansas Insects: A Manual o f  the Butterflies and Skippers o f  Kansas; Forbes' 1923 Lepidoptera o f  New York and Neighboring States: Part I ;  Leonard's 1928 Insects of New York; and Macy and Shepard's 1941 Butterflies. Collectively these works include much data on immature stages for many species of Eastern North America. Disappointing, too,  there is no reference made to the Lepidopterists' News, first published in 1947. Some readers may find the relatively small type difficult; others will find annoying the frequent use of asterisks throughout the Index under Part 1 ,  Sections B and C without an appropriate footnote or explanation. It is unfortunate the author did not indicate the source of common names of insects used in Part 1,  Section B. There are many names that are unknown or little used by lepidopterists of today, i.e., "Alderman Butterfly" for Vanessa atalanta (Linnaeus), or "The Joker" for Feralia jocosa (Guente). In checking Ilolland'sMoth Book, we find 7 8  common names listed for the popular Catocala species; yet, this lndex includes only 4 3  of these common names. The lndex does not in- clude other frequently used common names, i.e., Bog Fritillary, Boloria eztnomia (Esper), Bruce's Swallowtail, Papilio brucei Edwards, Iowa Skipper, Atrytone arogos (Boisduval & LeContc), Little Metal-Mark, CalepheZis virginiensis (Guerin), and Mitchell's Satyr, Euptychia mitchellii (French)-to name only a few. One may also question the source of "Pearly-Eyed Grayling" when most references use Pearly Eye, referring to Lethe portlandia (Fabricius). O n  page 5 3  "Umber Moth" should read Umber Skipper for Poanes melane (Edwards). Under Section C, there are several life history headings without published references; however, food plants are listed. One immediately wonders where the author obtained this data; did he personally make this observation or  was the publication reference omitted in error? On page 148, brevicornis and other names on  this page follows brobvningi, an obvious error of alphabetical arrangement. Under juvenalis Abbot & Smith on page 376, it is incorrectly designated as a synonym of brizo (Boisduval). Part I1 contains some information which may prove to be of little value t o  the researcherr There is no indication as to the source of both common and scientific plant names; therefore one must assume they were gleaned from published references cited in Part 1. One could also question the usefulness of Section C, "Indefinite Designations," with numerous insect species listed under such vague headings of "Forest Trees" or "Most Anything." There are a few food plant references that appear erroneous, through no fault of the author. Under Cercis (Redbud), both Incisalia henrici (Grote & Robinson) and I. irus (Godart) are associated with this plant in the larval stage; yet ,  i t  is known that these elfins were confused by early taxonomists and therefore much of their food plant observations were erroneously cited in early publications. Regardless of these errors and omissions, this Index will undoubtedly serve as the main bibliography of macrolepidoptera life histories and food plants for years to come. Certainly the Allyn Museum of Entomology deserves considerable credit for publishing this Index, thereby making this information available to many lepidopterists who otherwise would not have benefitetl. M. C. Nielsen 3415 Overlea Drive Lansing, Michigan 489 17 2The Great Lakes Entomologist, Vol. 7, No. 1 [1974], Art. 7https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle/vol7/iss1/7

AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,\u27\u27 by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972

ValpoScholar

The Great Lakes Entomologist 
Volume 7 
Number 1 -- Spring 1974 Number 1 -- Spring 
1974 
Article 7 
March 1974 
"AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES 
AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE 
CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,'' by Harrison 
Morton Tietz, 1972 
M. C. Nielsen 
Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle 
 Part of the Entomology Commons 
Recommended Citation 
Nielsen, M. C. 1974. ""AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF 
THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,'' by Harrison Morton 
Tietz, 1972," The Great Lakes Entomologist, vol 7 (1) 
Available at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle/vol7/iss1/7 
This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Biology at ValpoScholar. It has 
been accepted for inclusion in The Great Lakes Entomologist by an authorized administrator of ValpoScholar. For 
more information, please contact a ValpoScholar staff member at scholar@valpo.edu. 
1974 THE GREAT LAKES ENTOMOLOGIST 25 
Drooz, A. T. 1974. The status of Mesoleius tenthredinis and other parasites of the larch 
sawfly in the eastern United States. Envir. Entomol. 3 (in press). 
Embree, D. G. and G. R. Underwood. 1972. Establishment in Maine, Nova Scotia, and 
New Brunswick of Olesicampe benefactor (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae), an intro- 
duced ichneumonid parasite of the larch sawfly, Pristiphora erichsonii (Hymenoptera: 
Tenthredinidae). Can Entomol. 104:89-96. 
Muldrew, J. A. 1953. The natural immunity of the larch sawfly Pristiphora erichsonii 
(Htg.) to the introduced parasite Mesoleius tenthredinis Morley, in Manitoba and 
Saskatchewan. Can. J. Zool. 31:313-332. 
Turnock, W. J. and J. A. Muldrew. 1971. Pristiphora erichsonii (Htg.), the larch sawfly 
(Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae). In Biological Control programs against insects and 
weeds in Canada 1958-1968. Commonw. Inst. Biol. Contr. Tech. Comm. No. 4. 
Turnock, W. J. 1973. Geographical and historical variability in population patterns and 
life systems of the larch sawfly. Can. Entomol. 104: 1883-1900. 
BOOK REVIEW 
"AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS 
OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND 
CANADA,'' by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972. Two volumes, 1041 p., published by A. C. 
Allyn for the Allyn Museum of Entomology, Sarasota, Florida. Distributed exclusively in 
North America by Entomological Reprint Specialists, P.O. Box 77971, Dockweiler 
Station, Los Angeles, California 90007. Price: $25.00 U.S. per set. 
This monumental Index is the f i s t  attempt to prepare a bibliography of the immature 
stages of North American butterflies and moths since Edward's Bibliographical Catalogue 
o f  the Described Transformations o f  North American Lepidoptera, published in 1889. 
The compilation includes Edward's work and published data through sometime in 1950 
when the manuscript was initiated. Except for an introduction by William D. 1:ield and J .  
F. Gates Clarke, both of the National Museum of Natural History, there is no 
introduction or other prefacing remarks by the author. 
The Index is divided into two parts: Part I-Insects, and Part 11-Plants, although 
Volume 1 contents, representing about half the total number of pages, continues into 
Volume 2. Under Part 1 ,  there are three sections: A-Works Consulted (periodicals, 
separate works, bibliographies); B-Insect Common Names and C-Macrolepidoptera. 
Included in the latter section are the names of all species, subspecies and forms, including 
synonyms, alphabetically listed with cross-references to  the main entry. The nomenclature 
follows that of McDunnough's 1938 Check List o f  the Lepidoptera o f  Canada and the 
United States o f  America: Part I ,  Macrolepidoptera. Each main entry is followed with 
synonyms, forms and subspecies, bibliography of published life history references and list 
of food plants. This section represents the greatest number of pages in the Index, and is 
one of the most valuable to  the researcher. 
Part 11 includes five sections: A-Zoological Hosts; B-Common Names; C-Indefinite 
Designations; D-Scientific Names; E-Synonyms. It would appear that Section D is most 
useful as it lists host plants and their "Insect Enemies." The plants are listed 
alphabetically by genus and species with the common namc, followed with a list of all 
known macrolepidoptera arranged by family. When the scicntific name of the plant is 
unknown, it can be located in Section B under the common name. 
Undoubtedly, this Index will be a valuablc rcference to professional and serious 
amateur lepidopterists, especially those engaged in life history studies or rearing activities. 
It will enable anyone to quickly determine whethcr or not life history or  food plant 
1
Nielsen: "AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOST
Published by ValpoScholar, 1974
26 THE GREAT LAKES ENTOMOLOGIST Vol. 7, No. 1 
observations and data are new or have been previously published, prior to 1950. This 
Index should challenge some researchers to compile additional life histories and food 
plant data. The food plant lists are useful, too,  in attempting to locate 'missing' species in 
a particular region and identify unknown larvae from known plants. 
'There are, however, some comments that should b e  made concerning the thoroughness 
and accuracy of the Index. It is unfortunate that the work is not  more current as there 
has been a wealth of new life history and food plant data published within the past 
twenty-three years. This shortcoming may be a disappointment t o  some who purchase 
this Index only to find they must still do  considerable bibliographical research. It is not 
unusual for an index of this size to be without some errors of commission and omission. 
The most unaccountable omission is the author's failure to include references to Field's 
1938 Studies in Kansas Insects: A Manual o f  the Butterflies and Skippers o f  Kansas; 
Forbes' 1923 Lepidoptera o f  New York and Neighboring States: Part I ;  Leonard's 1928 
Insects of New York; and Macy and Shepard's 1941 Butterflies. Collectively these works 
include much data on immature stages for many species of Eastern North America. 
Disappointing, too,  there is no reference made to the Lepidopterists' News, first 
published in 1947. 
Some readers may find the relatively small type difficult; others will find annoying 
the frequent use of asterisks throughout the Index under Part 1 ,  Sections B and C 
without an appropriate footnote or explanation. It is unfortunate the author did not 
indicate the source of common names of insects used in Part 1,  Section B. There are 
many names that are unknown or little used by lepidopterists of today, i.e., "Alderman 
Butterfly" for Vanessa atalanta (Linnaeus), or "The Joker" for Feralia jocosa (Guente). 
In checking Ilolland'sMoth Book, we find 7 8  common names listed for the popular Catocala 
species; yet, this lndex includes only 4 3  of these common names. The lndex does not in- 
clude other frequently used common names, i.e., Bog Fritillary, Boloria eztnomia 
(Esper), Bruce's Swallowtail, Papilio brucei Edwards, Iowa Skipper, Atrytone arogos 
(Boisduval & LeContc), Little Metal-Mark, CalepheZis virginiensis (Guerin), and 
Mitchell's Satyr, Euptychia mitchellii (French)-to name only a few. One may also 
question the source of "Pearly-Eyed Grayling" when most references use Pearly Eye, 
referring to Lethe portlandia (Fabricius). O n  page 5 3  "Umber Moth" should read Umber 
Skipper for Poanes melane (Edwards). 
Under Section C, there are several life history headings without published references; 
however, food plants are listed. One immediately wonders where the author obtained this 
data; did he personally make this observation or  was the publication reference omitted in 
error? On page 148, brevicornis and other names on  this page follows brobvningi, an 
obvious error of alphabetical arrangement. Under juvenalis Abbot & Smith on page 376, 
it is incorrectly designated as a synonym of brizo (Boisduval). 
Part I1 contains some information which may prove to be of little value t o  the 
researcherr There is no indication as to the source of both common and scientific plant 
names; therefore one must assume they were gleaned from published references cited in 
Part 1. One could also question the usefulness of Section C, "Indefinite Designations," 
with numerous insect species listed under such vague headings of "Forest Trees" or 
"Most Anything." There are a few food plant references that appear erroneous, through 
no fault of the author. Under Cercis (Redbud), both Incisalia henrici (Grote & Robinson) 
and I. irus (Godart) are associated with this plant in the larval stage; yet ,  i t  is known that 
these elfins were confused by early taxonomists and therefore much of their food plant 
observations were erroneously cited in early publications. 
Regardless of these errors and omissions, this Index will undoubtedly serve as the 
main bibliography of macrolepidoptera life histories and food plants for years to come. 
Certainly the Allyn Museum of Entomology deserves considerable credit for publishing 
this Index, thereby making this information available to many lepidopterists who 
otherwise would not have benefitetl. 
M. C. Nielsen 
3415 Overlea Drive 
Lansing, Michigan 489 17 
2
The Great Lakes Entomologist, Vol. 7, No. 1 [1974], Art. 7
https://scholar.valpo.edu/tgle/vol7/iss1/7


https://scholar.valpo.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1206&context=tgle

AN INDEX TO THE DESCRIBED LI1:E HISTORIES, EARLY STAGES AND HOSTS OF THE MACROLEPIDOPTERA OF THE CONTINENTAL UNITED STATES AND CANADA,\u27\u27 by Harrison Morton Tietz, 1972

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Valparaiso University

ValpoScholar