The intention of this research project, which was supported within the "Bundesprogramm Ökologischer

Landbau", was to find alternatives for the control of Venturia inaequalis for the organic fruitgrower.

Beside the investigations on reducing the ascospore potential on fallen leaves, experiments

were conducted in laboratory, greenhouses and in orchard to test direct control of scab with different

plant extracts, concentrations and methods of extraction. Extracts from Inula viscosa, Quillaja

saponaria-bark, citrus-species (AGROMIL) and Saponaria officinalis revealed a distinct efficacy

against apple scab in greenhouse studies on apple seedlings. ELOT-VIS, CHITOPLANT, COMCAT,

MOOSEXTRAKT, SILIOPLANT und FZB 24 did not show sufficient efficacy with the application schedule

used for control of scab. Mixtures of Quillaja-saponine and sulphur reduced effectively apple scab

incidence. In an experiment concerning rain stability Citrus-extract and Quillaja-saponine showed a

lower efficacy against scab after a simulated rain of 5 mm. The screening of different supplements

to Citrus-extract as surfactants and adhesives revealed GREEMAX and BIOPLUSS as promising additives.

Both combinations showed an efficacy comparable to copperoxychloride corresponding to

400 g elementary copper per ha

Alt, S.

Hein, B.

Kollar, A.

Pfeiffer, B.

Schulz, C.

English

Organic Eprints

1 supported by the BMVEL within the "Bundesprogramm Ökologischer Landbau" 2 BBA Dossenheim, Schwabenheimer Str. 101, D-69 221 Dossenheim/LVWO Weinsberg, Traubenplatz 5, D-74189 Weinsberg 3 BBA Dossenheim, Schwabenheimer Str. 101, D-69 221 Dossenheim Investigations on alternative substances for control of apple scab -  Results from Conidia germinating tests and experiments with plant extracts1 Untersuchungen zum Einsatz alternativer Stoffe zur Regulierung des Apfelschorfes - Ergebnisse aus Konidienkeimtests und Versuchen zu Pflanzenextrakten1 Pfeiffer B.2, Alt S.3, Hein B.2, Schulz C.3, Kollar, A. 3 Abstract The intention of this research project, which was supported within the "Bundesprogramm Ökolo-gischer Landbau", was to find alternatives for the control of Venturia inaequalis for the organic fruit-grower. Beside the investigations on reducing the ascospore potential on fallen leaves, experiments were conducted in laboratory, greenhouses and in orchard to test direct control of scab with differ-ent plant extracts, concentrations and methods of extraction. Extracts from Inula viscosa, Quillaja saponaria-bark,  citrus-species  (AGROMIL)  and  Saponaria  officinalis  revealed  a  distinct  efficacy against  apple  scab  in  greenhouse  studies  on  apple  seedlings.  ELOT-VIS,  CHITOPLANT,  COMCAT, MOOSEXTRAKT, SILIOPLANT und FZB 24 did not show sufficient efficacy with the application schedule used for control of scab. Mixtures of Quillaja-saponine and sulphur reduced effectively apple scab incidence. In an experiment concerning rain stability Citrus-extract and Quillaja-saponine showed a lower efficacy against scab after a simulated rain of 5 mm. The screening of different supplements to Citrus-extract as surfactants and adhesives revealed GREEMAX and BIOPLUSS as promising addi-tives.  Both  combinations showed an efficacy comparable to copperoxychloride corresponding to 400 g elementary copper per ha. Keywords: Apple, organic fruit-growing, Venturia inaequalis, plant extracts, saponins Introduction At the moment organic apple growers in Germany can use the registered preparations based on copper-oxychloride for scab control. The registration will end on December 31st  2004. Products with low copper quantities (copper-octanat CUEVA) are still in the development stage. The aim of this pro-ject was to look for alternatives for scab control. Based on earlier results of Späth (2000), Siegrist (2000) and Pfeiffer (2002) plant extracts were produced from different medicinal plants. Plant ex-tracts which had shown efficacy on Plasmopora viticola were also tested (Cohen, 2002 and Kast 2002). Material and Methods Extracts from medicinal plants normally were produced on two ways: 10 g dried plant material was mixed with 100 ml ethanol (99 %), then it was extracted in a water bath at 60 ° C for 2 hours. The closed jars were cooled down to room temperature and the extracts were filtered. Water extracts were produced like tea from herbs: 100 ml boiling hot water was poured on 10 g dried plant mate-rial, 10 minutes later the extract was filtered. Different types of experiments were used depending on the questions that should be answered.  Conidia were washed from scab infected leaves and a suspension of 10 000 conidia/ml was pro-duced. Different concentrations of plant extracts were added to that suspension. 1 ml of the mixture was filled in sterile Cellstar-Multiplates and incubated at 20 ° C for 24 hours. With the binocular the  germinated conidia were differentiated into three groups: "not germinated", "with a short germinat-Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/  ing tube", "with a long germinating tube". It was classified as "short", if the length of the germinating tube was not longer than twice the conidia itself. The proportions of not germinated conidia of plant extract and control (control = 100 %) were compared and the efficacy according to ABOTT was calculated.  In the greenhouse-experiments 12 seedlings from 'Golden Delicious' (apples from an orchard, where no resistant varieties were grown) per treatment were sprayed in a preventive schedule with a small hand-sprayer. The tip of the youngest fully expanded leaf was removed and the number and the size of the younger susceptible leaves were registered. About 12 hours after the preventive ap-plication the artificial inoculation was done with a suspension of 100 000 conidia/ml. The seedlings were put into plastic bags for 24 hours to maintain a high relative humidity of the air. About 14 days after the inoculation the first symptoms appeared. For each leaf the scab infection was classified from 0 (no symptoms visible) to 4 (big expansion of the symptoms). Since not all lesions can be de-tected by the naked eye all leaves, that were susceptible for scab at the day of inoculation, were removed and the conidia were rinsed out with aqua dest. The titer of conidia was determined with a Kolkwitz-Plancton-cytometer (0,5 ml, Hydro-Bios, Germany) to estimate the reproducibility of fun-gus.  For the testing of rain-stability of extracts from Citrus sp. (AGROMIL) the seedlings were sprayed in the morning of 21.10.2002. Rain (5 and 15 mm) was simulated in the early afternoon, in the morn-ing of October 22nd the plants were inoculated with conidia.   Another type of experiment was chosen to test the efficacy of combinations of plant extracts with surfactants  and  adhesives  for  one  infection  period  under  natural  conditions.  Seedlings  were sprayed preventively. After the treatments had dried, the seedlings were distributed in a randomised pattern under heavily scab infected trees of the variety 'Jonagold' (untreated control of a scab trial in quarter 617 of Heuchlingen, the experimental station of the LVWO Weinsberg). In this way the co-nidia in the rainwater running down from scabbed leaves caused the natural infection. Two or three days later the seedlings were returned into the greenhouse until scab symptoms appeared.  Especially two experiments with AGROMIL (as powder and fluid formulation) were done like this. In July 2003 AGROMIL (powder, 0,25 %) was combined with additives like ADHÄSIT (0,01%), PROFITAL FL. (0,01%), GREEMAX (0,01%) or BIOPLUSS (0,8%). These treatments were compared to untreated control and copperoxychloride (according to 400 g Cu per ha). The plants were treated on July 2nd in the morning and distributed in the orchard in the afternoon. There were two leaf-wetness-periods: 17 hours at 16 to 17 ° C and 86 % relative humidity  of the air (weak to medium infection) and at the next day 16 hours at 14 to 15 ° C and 93 % relative  humidity of the air (medium to severe infection). On July 4th the plants were put back into the greenhouse in the early afternoon. During the exposi-tion in the orchard 11,6 mm rain fell.  In a similar trial AGROMIL (powder, 0,25 %) was compared with AGROMIL + GREEMAX (powder, 0,25 % + GREEMAX 0,01%), AGRO NEU FL. 1(fluid, 0,5%), AGRO NEU FL. 2(fluid, 0,5 %), untreated control, copperoxychloride (according to 400 g Cu per ha) and CUEVA (according to 180 g Cu per ha). The higher concentrations of AGRO NEU FL. 1 and 2 were chosen because of the fluid formulation. The seedlings were treated in the morning of October 2nd, exposed in the orchard on October 3rd in the morning and returned to greenhouse on October 5th in the morning. Two weak infections occurred: 10 hours leaf-wetness at 13 to 14 ° C and 92 % relat ive humidity of the air and 11 hours leaf-wetness at 8 to 9° C and 95 % relative humidity of t he air. During the exposition in the orchard 10,6 mm rain fell. Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/   Results 31 different extracts from medicinal and other native plants (water based or ethanolic extracts), for-mulation agents and plant strengthening preparations were tested in varying concentrations. Nor-mally the extracts were compared at concentrations of 2 %, 4 % and 6 %. Ethanol (99 vol.%) itself had a efficacy between -49 % and 40 %, the average was 10 %. The adhesive preparation GREE-MAX had no inhibiting effect on the germination. Table 1 shows the plant extracts, that in most tests had efficicacy rates of 85 to 100 %. The concentrations of the extracts are listed as volumen % normally.  Table 1: Testing of plant extracts on inhibition of germination of apple scab - Extracts with efficiency rates (WG after ABOTT) 85 to 100 %.  Botanical name, method of extraction / plant strengthening preparation, concentration Part of the plant WG  n* Rhamnus frangula ethan. 2 - 6 %  bark  2 to 100 %  10 Inula viscosa. Aceton 0,4 %, ethan. 2 - 6 % leaves  88 to 100 %  8 Primula veris aqueous 2 - 6 %  roots  - 43 to 100 %  17 Primula veris ethan. 2 - 6 %  roots  18 to 100 %  31 Saponin from Quillaja saponaria aqueous 0,5 - 2 % (w/v) bark  68 to 99 %  10 Saponaria officinalis ethan. 2 - 6 %  roots  22 to 100 %  6 LEBERMOOSER 0,5 - 2 % (extract from moss)   22 to 100 %  6 AGROMIL (powder, extract from Citrus sp.) 0,25 % - 0,5 % (w/v) fruits  100 %  9 BIOPLUSS 0,4 - 1,2 vol. %  (= 0,64 - 1,92 %, w/v)   100 %  4 Salviathymol 0,2 - 1,2 %  leaves  100 %  9 *n: number of tested concentrations (with replications) in few conidia-germinating-tests  The conidia germinating tests were used for screening different plant extracts and for optimising the method of extraction and the concentrations. For the production of extracts from Primula veris it seemed to be important, to mix the dried roots with cold water and to boil the water slowly. High ef-ficacy under laboratory conditions could be detected, if 10 g dry roots were extracted with 100 ml water and this extracts were used with concentrations between 4 and 6 %. By ethanolic extracts (10 per 100 ml, 99 % ethanol) a concentration of 6 % was necessary for high inhibition of germination of conidia.   In a greenhouse experiment with seedling of 'Golden Delicious' aqueous extracts from Rhamnus frangula,  Sambucus  nigra,  Rheum  officinale,  Polypodium vulgare and Saponaria officinalis were compared to copperoxychloride (500 g Cu/ha) and control. The results (scab lesions on the leaves and production of conidia) are listed in table 2. the lowest conidia production was evaluated in the treatments with Rhamnus frangula and with Saponaria officinalis. In some greenhouse experiments there are differences between data from visual assessment of scab lesions on the leaves and re-sults for the production of conidia, that were shaken from the leaves with water.  Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/   In the last tests in November and December 2002 different plant strengthening preparations like CHITOPLANT,  ELOT-VIS, SILIOPLANT, COMCAT and antagonists based on yeasts or  trichoderma sp. were  tested  in  a  preventive  spraying  schedule.  These  preparations  had  no  inhibiting  effects  on scab.  Table 2: Efficacy of a preventive application of different plant extracts on scab lesions on the leaves and production of conidia of V. inaequalis (greenhouse May 2002) Extract / Preparation   Concentration  Lesions Leaf (1)  Conidia/ml Control    2,07  204.800 Copper 500 g Cu/ha (Oxychlorid)  1,1 %  1,64  185.762 Bark of Rhamnus frangula (aqueous extract)  5 %  1,89  88.458 Tea of flowers of Sambucus nigra  5 %  2,02  408.037 Roots of Rheum officinale (aqueous extract)  5 %  2,76  784.037 Rhizoms of Polypodium vulgare (aqueous extract) 5 %  2,92  425.704 Roots of Saponaria officinalis (aqueous extract)  5 %  1,47  115.380 (1) Lesions divided in classes from 0 to 4  An obvious reduction of scab was visible in a greenhouse-experiment in July 2002 with extracts from Saponaria officinalis (2 % and 6 %), Inula viscosa (1 % and 2 %) and Quillaja-saponin (0,5 % and 1,0 %). Extracts from Inula showed an efficacy of 50 to 74 %, Saponaria 80 to 90 % and Quil-laja-saponin 87 to 94 %. Based on this test sulphur was added in different concentrations to in-crease the effect of Quillaja-saponin. Combinations of 0,75 % Quillaja-saponin with 0,4 or 0,6 % sulphur (according to 2 or 3 kg per ha, sprayed with 500 l/ha) inhibited infections by scab nearly completely. But some questions remained wether the high efficacy was caused by a physical reac-tion of the inoculation suspension or if the applicated droplets did not stay in the same shape on the leaves as in the control.  In the experiments done by Rudolph (2003) AGROMIL, an extract of citrus fruits from Brasil, showed a distinct inhibition of scab in conidia-germinating-test in laboratory as well as in the in greenhouse. In order to proof the rain stability of AGROMIL - being an essential problem in 2002 during an or-chard-experiment with plant extracts - 5 and 15 mm of rainfall were simulated by using a watering device (water sprinkler). The most important results are summarized in table 3.   Table 3: Effect of different amount of simulated rainfall on the infection with V. inaequalis on  seedlings of 'Golden Delicious' after a preventive application of different plant extracts  (greenhouse, October 2002)  Amount of rain simulated  0 mm  5 mm  15 mm  0 mm  5 mm  15 mm   Scab lesions leaves (1)  Production of conidia/ml(2)  Untreated Control  1,94  2,24  2,28  752.000  1.262.000  1.449.000 FUNGURAN (750 g Cu/ha)  0,95  1,84  2,09  224.000  985.000  854.000 AGROMIL (0,25 %)  0,55  1,73  2,13  100.000  688.000  892.000 Quillaja-Saponin (1,0 %)  0,13  1,33  1,9  5.961  325 949  545 651 Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/   (1) Lesions divided in classes from 0 to 4, (2) Conidia per ml; average from 3 replications a 10 Pflanzen, Quillaja-saponin only 4 plants per replication  Without artificial rain AGROMIL showed a clear reduction of scab in comparison to control. With in-creasing amount of rain the effect decreased severely. The same observation was made at Quillaja-saponin, which had the lowest incidence of scab. One reason for that could be that the plants were exposed under the sprinkling device two hours later to have equal conditions at the distribution of the simulated rain, so that probably the preventive treatment dried for a longer time.  Based on this experiment in 2003 the main intention in the trials was to find combination either of AGROMIL with surfactants or adhesives either of Quillaja-saponin with adhesives. Meanwhile two fluid formulations of AGROMIL were available. Figure 1 shows the effect of combination of AGROMIL with different adhesives (see Material and methods).  0200.000400.000600.000800.000Con Cu  AG AG+AD AG+PF AG+GR AG+BPLConidia/ml Figure 1: Efficacy of combinations of AGROMIL with different adhesives on natural infections with  V. inaequalis (AG = AGROMIL powder, AD=ADHÄSIT, PF=PROFITAL FLÜSSIG, GR=GREEMAX, BPL= BIOPLUSS).  The  adhesives  ADHÄSIT  and  PROFITAL  FLÜSSIG  did  not  enhance  the  scab  reduction  effect  of AGROMIL.  The  addition  of  GREEMAX  or  BIOPLUSS  did  not  show  increased  effect  of  AGROMIL,  the amount of rain during the deposition in orchard was about 11 mm, which fell regularly.   In October 2003 both fluid formulations were compared with AGROMIL powder and with AGROMIL (powder)+GREEMAX.  During  that  natural  infection  period  the  addition  of  GREEMAX  was  advanta-geous, the production of conidia was about 10 % lower than with AGROMIL alone. Both fluid formula-tions were not as effective as AGROMIL powder. Discussion: The initial results of this research project, that ended on December 31st 2003, show that there is a promising potential in some plant extracts like AGROMIL, Inula viscosa or Quillaja-saponin for the use against apple scab. The step from greenhouse into practice in the orchards is always lengthy, espe-cially because there are only few adhesives or formulations that can be applied in organic fruit-growing. GREEMAX and BIOPLUSS are encouraging preparations for enhancing the effect of extracts and should be tested in the next season in orchards. Before that the question of residues of conven-tional plant protection agents in the extracts has to be answered. Furthermore the extraction has to be optimised to lower the costs for the extracts.  Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/   Literature Cited Cohen, Y., Baider, A., Ben-Daniel B., Ben-Daniel Y.(2002): Fungicidal preparations from Inula vis-cose. In: FÖKO (Hrsg.): Proceedings 10th International Conference on Cultivation Technique and Phytopathological Problems in Organic Fruit-Growing and Viticulture, 152-156. Kast, W. (2002) Wirkung von Pflanzenextrakten in Labor- und Freilandversuchen gegen Rebenper-onospora. In: FÖKO (Hrsg.): Proceedings 10th International Conference on Cultivation Tech-nique and Phytopathological Problems in Organic Fruit-Growing and Viticulture, 157-162. Pfeiffer, B. (2002): Greenhouse experiments on control of Venturia inaequalis – First results. In: FÖKO (Hrsg.): 10th International Conference on Cultivation Technique and Phytopathological Problems in Organic Fruit-Growing and Viticulture – 4th to 7th February 2002, Weinsberg. Proceedings 81-85. Rudolph, K. (2003): Bekämpfung des Apfelschorfs im ökologischen Obstbau - Prüfung von Alterna-tiven zur Kupferanwendung. Diplomarbeit FH Osnabrück. Siegrist, J.; Mayer, A.; Walz, A.; Retzbach, A.(2000): Gurke/Pseudoperonospora cubensis, ein Modellsystem zur Entwicklung biologischer Bekämpfungsstrategien sowie zur Untersuchung pflanzlicher Abwehrreaktionen In 52. Dt. Pflanzenschutztagung, 9.-12.Oktober 2000, Freis-ing-Weihenstephan, Mitteilungen der BBA Heft 376, S. 410-411. Späth, S. (2000): Versuche an Apfelsämlingen zur Regulierung von Apfelschorf Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) Aderhold im Ökologischen Landbau. Diplomarbeit FH Nürtingen. Archived at http://orgprints.org/14452/

Investigations on alternative substances for control of apple scab - Results from Conidia germinating tests and experiments with plant extracts

Abstract

Similar works

Full text

Available Versions

Organic Eprints